science fraud is common place

Humans have developed language, sign language, written text, symbolism and other ways to communicate using the tools available. Computers like the telegraph, telephone and smoke signals are tools used to communicate.

Animals also use tools to solve problems. Does that mean they have a developed knowledge of the scientific method or like humans, improvised.

How does any of that answer Belz's question? I don't think anyone here has ever claimed that the scientific method is the only way problems are solved, tools invented, or progress made (just the most consistently reliable); improvisation and inspiration certainly have their moments. The question was whether, in the specific example of computers, you're aware of the role of science in their development; or do you think computers were just made up by someone as they went along with no idea of what they were aiming for or how the thing would work? ("I'll just connect this here thingamajig to that there doohickey and press me a button, let's see what happens- oh, looka here, I got me a computer!")

Please try to avoid simplistic all-or-nothing thinking if you decide to try to actually answer the question, ok?

(And speaking of unanswered questions- how's that test for god by the scientific method coming along? Have you made creationism a science yet?)
 
Humans have developed language, sign language, written text, symbolism and other ways to communicate using the tools available. Computers like the telegraph, telephone and smoke signals are tools used to communicate.

Animals also use tools to solve problems. Does that mean they have a developed knowledge of the scientific method or like humans, improvised.

And if we found computers or telephones lying on the ground and just used them in the way a crow uses a stick you might have a point but computers, telephones etc are the product of systematic research and development with each new iteration building on scientific knowledge gained from prior work. Again you choose a false or inaccurate definition for a word and then demand that everyone else conform to your choice; it isn't going to happen.
 
JiT humans make our tools we do not just pick them up at random from the ground like a stick, if telephones grew on trees your point might be valid, they do not they had to be invented and made.
 
Possible explanation why science fraud is common place.

1. Scientists have a poor understanding of science even though they might be qualified in their field.

2. They are generally ignorant of the history of their fields, let alone anyone else's,

3. Same ideas being tried repeatedly, and getting the same results while expecting a different result.

4. Left to the researcher to make their own conclusions about their own research.

5. The problem when a few people are responsible for determining the veracity of all research.

6. Science is politics as practiced by the scientific community.

Just because someone has a good science background doesn't mean that their understanding of science is good. Most scientists I've met have an extremely good understanding of their chosen field, but a very, very poor understanding of science itself. They are generally ignorant of the history of their fields, let alone anyone else's, for example. This results in ideas being tried repeatedly, and getting the same results.

There have always been attempts to formally designate and differentiate between theories with varying degrees of support. They all fail for the simple reason that each researcher is obliged to come to their own conclusions about this issue. This is one of the foundational concepts of science: each researcher is independent and obliged to follow the data, resulting in the increase in knowledge along all fronts and the ability to self-correct. Establishing a formal system to designate well-supported theories vs. unsupported vs. disproven undermines this, since someone has to do the designating. Even if we say "Everyone can do it", in practice you'd still end up with a small handful of people making these determinations. That's not science; that's politics.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9761076&postcount=10
 
Possible explanation why science fraud is common place.
1. Scientists have a poor understanding of science even though they might be qualified in their field.

2. They are generally ignorant of the history of their fields, let alone anyone else's,

3. Same ideas being tried repeatedly, and getting the same results while expecting a different result.

4. Left to the researcher to make their own conclusions about their own research.

5. The problem when a few people are responsible for determining the veracity of all research.

6. Science is politics as practiced by the scientific community.


http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9761076&postcount=10

You've tried and spectacularly failed to show that this is the case. The remainder moot but also very very silly. A scientist stole your girl, right?
 
Possible explanation why science fraud is common place.

1. Scientists have a poor understanding of science even though they might be qualified in their field.

2. They are generally ignorant of the history of their fields, let alone anyone else's,

3. Same ideas being tried repeatedly, and getting the same results while expecting a different result.

4. Left to the researcher to make their own conclusions about their own research.

5. The problem when a few people are responsible for determining the veracity of all research.

6. Science is politics as practiced by the scientific community.
[/url]

You just described yourself with most of those 'reasons'.
 
Originally Posted by justintime View Post
Possible explanation why science fraud is common place.

1. Scientists have a poor understanding of science even though they might be qualified in their field.

2. They are generally ignorant of the history of their fields, let alone anyone else's,

3. Same ideas being tried repeatedly, and getting the same results while expecting a different result.

4. Left to the researcher to make their own conclusions about their own research.

5. The problem when a few people are responsible for determining the veracity of all research.

6. Science is politics as practiced by the scientific communi

You just described yourself with most of those 'reasons'.

Actually that was taken straight out of Dinwar's post. The link was even provided. Read it this time.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9761076&postcount=10
 
Last edited:
Humans have developed language, sign language, written text, symbolism and other ways to communicate using the tools available. Computers like the telegraph, telephone and smoke signals are tools used to communicate.

Animals also use tools to solve problems. Does that mean they have a developed knowledge of the scientific method or like humans, improvised.

That has absolutely no relation with the post you were replying to.

You said science had no practical application. The fact that you are typing this on a computer, on the internet, proves you wrong.
 
You have just supported my position science has no practical application.
I have done no such thing. I've demonstrated that courtrooms are not the final arbitor of truth. If you can't wrap your head around that, that's your problem.

Actually that was taken straight out of Dinwar's post.
You misunderstood that statement (it was not intended as a bullet-list like you presented, for one thing). I was specifically talking about how a particular scheme for evaluating theories fails. It had nothing to do with fraud, and you know it. You HAVE NOT DEMONSTRATED THAT SCIENTIFIC FRAUD IS COMMON, and therefore cannot rationally speculate about the causes.

Stop acting like I support your idiocy. I've opposed you at every turn, and stooping to cherry-picking and misrepresenting my statements is profoundly dishonest, even for you. While it's a right of passage for people in my field, it's obnoxious, dishonest, and discourtious.

If you're going to engage in cherry-picking, I recommend you pick someone who can't respond to you. Distorting my statements is only going to make you look like a fool when I correct the egregious and unconscionable errors.

Belz... said:
What part of that don't you understand ?
The part where someone disagrees with him, apparently.

JayUtah said:
Except for the part where you ignore everything I've said over the past 36 hours.
That's not bad for him. He's ignored most of what I've said for a few weeks, except a few cherry-picked quotes he demonstrably doesn't understand. Frankly, I prefer him ignoring me.
 
Humans have developed language, sign language, written text, symbolism and other ways to communicate using the tools available.

Irrelevant reference to methods of convenience.

Computers like the telegraph, telephone and smoke signals are tools used to communicate.

No. Computers and other engineered devices are not methods of convenience or happenstance occurrences. Engineering and science are not merely reactive improvisation.

Animals also use tools to solve problems. Does that mean they have a developed knowledge of the scientific method or like humans, improvised.

Irrelevant analogy, because you have conflated happenstance tool use with engineering.

The computer you are using, the cars and other vehicles on the road, and the buildings you live and work in are applications of science. They are not merely sticks that happened into existence and were pressed into service. The principles by which they operate can be explicitly connected to overt endeavors that used the scientific process to arrive at the conclusions that drove those modern inventions.
 
Clearly, since he is trying to argue that the products of science merely happened into existence with no systemetized effort to produce them. Obviously in his worldview scientists and engineers do not actually do what they claim to do, so he has to explain the miracles of the modern world by some other means -- apparently here, some sort of magical natural process independent of human endeavor.

The engineer he quoted, Henry Petroski, argues that this is the genesis of engineering, but not how it is practiced today. The trial-and-error methods preceded what we generally refer to as the Rational Period of engineering, arising largely in the Enlightenment and continuing up through today, but also being rooted deeply in the work of Newton and his colleagues. The rational practice of engineering, as distinct from trial-and-error methods, are strongly based on classical science and is responsible for nearly all of the conveniences of the modern world.

Trial-and-error methods, cargo-cult methods, and propositional methods are still practiced by humans in subsistence cultures and other third-world cultures. The distinction between rational engineering and trial-and-error or improvisational engineering is precisely what defines the quality of life in each of these cultures, because rational engineering is capable of so much more.

From my reading, trial and error played a role in technological solutions found by Edison and Thomas Midgley, Jr's labs.
 
From my reading, trial and error played a role in technological solutions found by Edison and Thomas Midgley, Jr's labs.

It plays a role in all of science and engineering--we're constantly learning new things and testing the limits of our capacity, and failure is data. We don't throw out data merely because we discovered it unexpectedly (and it's fairly disrespectful to the people who die in engineering disasters to ignore the data from those disasters).

"Trial and error" suggests a scattershot technique--throw enough crap against a wall and some of it is bound to stick. Given justintime's posting history, I've little doubt that was his intent. In contrast, engineering and science use past knowledge to make the best judgments about how to move forward, and when failures do happen scientists and engineers examine them to determine why and how to fix them. When a theory fails, scientists pour over the data to try to figure out why. When a design fails, engineers pour over the data to try to figure out why. The next theory or design takes those into account--so at the very least, any failure will be a NEW failure. This is not trial-and-error; this is a systematic examination of events to determine their root causes, and application of that knowledge to revisions to the system.
 
That has absolutely no relation with the post you were replying to.

You said science had no practical application. The fact that you are typing this on a computer, on the internet, proves you wrong.

A computer is not science. It is a tool. A tool I am using to communicate. Drums, smoke signals, carrier pigeons have been used to send messages. Typing a message is not science. It is converting thoughts and ideas into language developed for communication.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom