science fraud is common place

Actually, I believe he's saying the complete opposite- that "uneducated" is the proper metric by which to judge science and evidence, and the ideal to which everyone should aspire.

This is probably closer.

The premise that juries reject scientific evidence is arguable. The juries in my experience have generally taken their duties seriously and genuinely want to know if any scientific findings bear on the question they're supposed to decide. They would rather base their verdict on something external and rational such as science rather than be accountable for their own determinations of credibility.

That said, juries are often suspicious of scientific findings presented in court, not because they distrust science or consider it "dung" to any degree of flinging, but because they realize that in the context of a courtroom each side will attempt to spin scientific conclusions one way or another. Hence if there is any jury distrust, it is generally directed at the lawyers and not at the the expert scientific witnesses or the science itself. Often juries are asked to decide which interpretation of some given scientific conclusion is most credible, which can be interpreted as asking them to "reject" some particular bit of expert testimony in a scientific context.

Juries do not universally or typically reject scientific findings presented as evidence. However, anti-science advocates generally have two reasons for rejecting science broadly.

In the first case they simply don't understand it. "Science" to them represents a body of knowledge they are not conversant with, and competence in which equates in their worldview to credibility they themselves do not enjoy. Hence they lash out at those who are competent and do indeed deserve credibility for it, generally taking the form of portraying science and scientists as rife with fraud. Since the line of reasoning is motivated by the notion of undeserved credibility, the accusation generally pushes well over the line into affirmative malfeasance.

In the second case there is some competing philosophy, typically religion. Science is portrayed as the enemy of faith, and necessarily malefacent. Because the faith-based conclusion is propositionally, axiomatically true in the believer's mind, any competing philosophy must know (or strongly suspect) itself to be in the wrong, and therefore conspire to hide exculpatory truths.
 
I find the idea of judging the merits of science by juries to be laughable, frankly. In some cases, such as my work, there's justification for it, but courtrooms are not places for scientific debate, nor were trials designed to establish scientific facts. The proper venue for scientific debate and discourse is publication (presentations--meaning talks and lectures--can be useful, but referencing them is a nightmare). Juries, being composed of non-experts, are generally not qualified to comment on scientific issues. They simply don't know enough. This is no insult to them--I'm not qualified to comment on numerous scientific issues either; I'm qualified to comment on my areas of expertise, but you start talking E&M and I'm out of my depth. Expecting non-experts who have not had time to do the requisite research to be the final arbitor of scientific truth is nonsense. Criticizing science for not being drafted in a way they can understand is equally nonsensical--scientific publications are not, outside of a limited area (ie, people like me), are not drafted for that audience. The audience of scientific papers is other scientists in that field--peopel to whom the jargon is second nature. It's no fault of an author if someone the paper was never intended for can't understand it.

The proper judge of quality of scientific writing is other scientists. There's no way around that. Any attempt to use jury trials as an analogue are doomed from the start, because they are two fundamentally different (I am tempted to say opposed) systems.
 
any falsifiablility goes out the window when magical thinking- "god can do anything"- can be proposed as an answer.

Hence why any supernatural explanation -- however "scientifically" denominated -- is immediately a non-starter.

In a simplistic sense, anything to which you can apply a scientific method is then by definition "science," in the circular sense that "science" is any pursuit of knowledge governed by a certain broadly defined procedure.

There is no such thing as the scientific method, although concepts such as empiricism and falsifiability apply to all such methods. What I mean is that there is a family of methods that share certain common, broadly-drawn traits deriving from the philosophy and epistemology of hypothetico-deductive methods. Each particular science creates specific methods in its field that follow those broad principles, but then in turn address the peculiarities of the field.

Materials science, one of the cornerstones of engineering, is ruthlessly and rigorously scientific to any degree of rigor you'd choose to establish. Paleontology (dunno why that one came to mind) uses different methods than materials science, but generally follows the same logical and philosophical tenets. The methods differ because paleontology, for example, is limited to specimens on hand; it cannot generally rely on empiricism that requires newly-minted observations. Paleontologists cannot simply generate new skeletons in order to test a new hypothesis. In that respect these sciences often accept conclusions that are likely to be true based on what observations and analysis can be made, but cannot often rise to the same level of confidence as sciences that can generate their own empirical observations at will. This leaves conclusions open to healthy and productive debate, an exemplifies that notion that any scientific finding is forever tentative (cf. Popper).

Conversely astronomy employs still different methods. While it can generate new observations ad hoc to test new hypotheses, it is still limited in the methods it can use because the things it studies, while present and vital (as opposed to dinosaurs, which are visible to us only via their remnants), are still a long way off and often require very expensive tools to study.

The OP is following the common amphibolistic tactic of conflating different denotations of the word "science," hoping to undermine the rigor of some sciences by noting the different practical limits of others. By strict etymology "science" means simply the pursuit of knowledge. The scientific method required in some sciences is simply the evolving understanding of how each field of study must be conducted in order to avoid known paths of error.

In rigorous sciences such as medical research, for example, we learned the importance of the placebo effect and double-blind empirical research. These don't apply to all sciences. They don't affect whether a paleontologist can discover a correlation between isotope ratios in fossils and some characteristic of the organism's former life. They don't affect whether a computer scientist can create functional closure in a complex system. They don't affect whether an astronomer can correlate radiometric observations to theoretical predictions for transit periods. But they do affect whether medicines can be proven scientifically to affect disease, and they embody mistakes once made by earlier medical scientists.

In short, the complaint that all scientific pursuits must share the same fine-grained behavior in order to be a "true" science is a desperate ploy. No scientist ever believed this or taught it. It is, however, the common straw-man characterization foisted by people anxious to disregard science as a whole.
 
The proper judge of quality of scientific writing is other scientists. There's no way around that. Any attempt to use jury trials as an analogue are doomed from the start, because they are two fundamentally different (I am tempted to say opposed) systems.

I agree. The parties are compelled by expedience to present their case briefly, and the juries identically compelled to render a verdict in finite time. An answer must be forthcoming, even it if is the wrong answer. We rely upon charitable (but unscientific) presumptions to resolve an insurmountable inductive leap in favor of the jeopardized party, but science has no such need nor sees any such value. Science is perfectly happy tip-toeing its way toward the truth, adjusting and readjusting its conclusions as necessary and with great care. The law is about getting as close as possible to the truth within a limited time; science is about taking as long as is needed to understand the truth fully.
 
This is probably closer.

The premise that juries reject scientific evidence is arguable. The juries in my experience have generally taken their duties seriously and genuinely want to know if any scientific findings bear on the question they're supposed to decide. They would rather base their verdict on something external and rational such as science rather than be accountable for their own determinations of credibility.

That said, juries are often suspicious of scientific findings presented in court, not because they distrust science or consider it "dung" to any degree of flinging, but because they realize that in the context of a courtroom each side will attempt to spin scientific conclusions one way or another. Hence if there is any jury distrust, it is generally directed at the lawyers and not at the the expert scientific witnesses or the science itself. Often juries are asked to decide which interpretation of some given scientific conclusion is most credible, which can be interpreted as asking them to "reject" some particular bit of expert testimony in a scientific context.

Juries do not universally or typically reject scientific findings presented as evidence. However, anti-science advocates generally have two reasons for rejecting science broadly.

In the first case they simply don't understand it. "Science" to them represents a body of knowledge they are not conversant with, and competence in which equates in their worldview to credibility they themselves do not enjoy. Hence they lash out at those who are competent and do indeed deserve credibility for it, generally taking the form of portraying science and scientists as rife with fraud. Since the line of reasoning is motivated by the notion of undeserved credibility, the accusation generally pushes well over the line into affirmative malfeasance.

In the second case there is some competing philosophy, typically religion. Science is portrayed as the enemy of faith, and necessarily malefacent. Because the faith-based conclusion is propositionally, axiomatically true in the believer's mind, any competing philosophy must know (or strongly suspect) itself to be in the wrong, and therefore conspire to hide exculpatory truths.
So, in the first case, the reason is personal envy; and, in the second, ideological jealousy.
 
JayUtah said:
Paleontology (dunno why that one came to mind) uses different methods than materials science, but generally follows the same logical and philosophical tenets. The methods differ because paleontology, for example, is limited to specimens on hand; it cannot generally rely on empiricism that requires newly-minted observations. Paleontologists cannot simply generate new skeletons in order to test a new hypothesis. In that respect these sciences often accept conclusions that are likely to be true based on what observations and analysis can be made, but cannot often rise to the same level of confidence as sciences that can generate their own empirical observations at will. This leaves conclusions open to healthy and productive debate, an exemplifies that notion that any scientific finding is forever tentative (cf. Popper).
One benefit of paleontology is that no one's life depends on our results. That means that the field can be used to test various methodologies and concepts. For example, I recently read a paper testing the use of null hypotheses in research, which found that people were under-estimating the role chance played in certain events due to the nature of randomness and their analysis. The specifics get a bit technical, but the end result is the identification of a new random model, something with implications outside of paleontology.

Basically, paleontology is a safe field in which to test various methodologies. You can test various ways to analyze data, to assess theories, etc., and not worry about anyone getting hurt. And since paleontology has the worst datasets in science, if the methods work here they work anywhere.

Less off-topic, your point is well-stated: there is no singular scientific method that all scientists apply consistently and constantly. We each develop our own methodologies. A physicist can reasonably expect to construct an experiment where only one or two variables change at a time. An astronomer takes what he can get, and a sociologist can only run experiments in a limited fashion. The key unifying features of science are peer review and the absolute rule that nothing is admissible to the conversation without evidence supporting it. There's also an informal rule that before anyone will listen to you, you have to demonstrate that you know what you're talking about. Obtaining a Ph.D. is one way to do this, but ametures can become world-recognized authorities.
 
Revisiting: How Many Scientists Fabricate and Falsify Research? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Survey Data
Everyone here knows about the problems with surveys.
What people may not realize is that the most of surveys do not ask whether scientists committed fraud, i.e. have published papers that contain fraudulent data :eye-poppi.
Self-report questions included in review, and responses (DOC)

Some questions ask about "reporting". There is one explicit "Was there X in the target publication" question.

P.S. The scientists surveyed were:
* biomedical trainees
* postdoctoral research fellows
* academic economists
* newly appointed consultants
* Australian medical specialists
* "mid-career scientists"
* authors of pharmaceutical clinical trials
 
I find the idea of judging the merits of science by juries to be laughable, frankly. In some cases, such as my work, there's justification for it, but courtrooms are not places for scientific debate, nor were trials designed to establish scientific facts. The proper venue for scientific debate and discourse is publication (presentations--meaning talks and lectures--can be useful, but referencing them is a nightmare). Juries, being composed of non-experts, are generally not qualified to comment on scientific issues. They simply don't know enough. This is no insult to them--I'm not qualified to comment on numerous scientific issues either; I'm qualified to comment on my areas of expertise, but you start talking E&M and I'm out of my depth. Expecting non-experts who have not had time to do the requisite research to be the final arbitor of scientific truth is nonsense. Criticizing science for not being drafted in a way they can understand is equally nonsensical--scientific publications are not, outside of a limited area (ie, people like me), are not drafted for that audience. The audience of scientific papers is other scientists in that field--peopel to whom the jargon is second nature. It's no fault of an author if someone the paper was never intended for can't understand it.

The proper judge of quality of scientific writing is other scientists. There's no way around that. Any attempt to use jury trials as an analogue are doomed from the start, because they are two fundamentally different (I am tempted to say opposed) systems.

You have just supported my position science has no practical application. You cannot use science in the legal process because expert witnesses contradict each other raising questions about the very science they submit as evidence. You cannot discuss science over a dinner conversation. That would be permeating the air with esoteric high flung dung. You cannot trust peer-reviewed publications because many are predatory and 65% of studied papers are fraudulent. You cannot trust science to be self correcting because it does nothing of that sort. The peer review process is flawed and 2% of scientists admit to fraud and a good 14% admit they know of someone guilty of fraud going undetected.

Against this backdrop not only is science fraud common place. It is getting worse and the reported criminal activity has increased 10 folds. How this culture of deceit passes off as scientific methodology is a travesty?
 
You have just supported my position science has no practical application.

And with this single absurd statement you demonstrate your utter ignorance on the subject of science. But please do tell us what system for the acquisition of knowledge you prefer to the scientific method? Decoding the bible? Studying Tarot Cards? Phoning a Psychic hotline?
 
You have just supported my position science has no practical application. You cannot use science in the legal process because expert witnesses contradict each other raising questions about the very science they submit as evidence. You cannot discuss science over a dinner conversation. That would be permeating the air with esoteric high flung dung. You cannot trust peer-reviewed publications because many are predatory and 65% of studied papers are fraudulent. You cannot trust science to be self correcting because it does nothing of that sort. The peer review process is flawed and 2% of scientists admit to fraud and a good 14% admit they know of someone guilty of fraud going undetected.

Against this backdrop not only is science fraud common place. It is getting worse and the reported criminal activity has increased 10 folds. How this culture of deceit passes off as scientific methodology is a travesty?
That's funny, I was just at a 4 day conference where the science done by the Office of Naval Research, and the Office of Naval Research, was on full display, including the practical applications thereof.

Say, you don't happen to have a GPS, do you? Use a microwave?

ETA: by the way, how widespread is this fraud really? Does a fraction of a percent mean widespread?
 
Last edited:
That's funny, I was just at a 4 day conference where the science done by the Office of Naval Research, and the Office of Naval Research, was on full display, including the practical applications thereof.

Say, you don't happen to have a GPS, do you? Use a microwave?

ETA: by the way, how widespread is this fraud really? Does a fraction of a percent mean widespread?

And speaking of microwaves:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cavity_magnetron#History

From laboratory research to the military to the kitchen; almost as if science gives rise to real world applications...
 
The peer review process is flawed and 2% of scientists admit to fraud and a good 14% admit they know of someone guilty of fraud going undetected.

It is getting worse and the reported criminal activity has increased 10 folds. How this culture of deceit passes off as scientific methodology is a travesty?
Sorry but that is a bit of a rant without any substance, justintime.
Everyone knows that the peer review process is flawed.
Everyone (but you!) knows that it works well and that peer review is not the only process that detects scientific fraud (attempts to replicate results should be the major detection of fraud).

How Many Scientists Fabricate and Falsify Research? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Survey Data concludes that 2% of the sampled scientists committed misconduct (not fraud). 14% admit they know of someone guilty of misconduct that may or may not have gone undetected (not a question in the surveys).

There is no "reported criminal activity" listed in this thread. Scientific fraud is not legal fraud.

Thinking that a 10-fold increase in detected fraud to 0.001% is a travesty is a travesty. The increase in detection could be from better detection of more fraud (or both).

The loaded "culture of deceit" is a good conspiracy theory phrase, justintime. A pity that it is based on what looks like ignorance about the scientific culture where fraud is seen as a major crime.
 
Last edited:
You have just supported my position science has no practical application.
Therefore the internet and computers do not exist. You are not really here. Nor am I.

Or are you using some odd definition of science where only those things which you can understand or use may be considered "scientific", while that which you cannot figure out must be magic?
 
You are aware that you're using a computer based partly on quantum mechanics, among other science fields, right ?

Humans have developed language, sign language, written text, symbolism and other ways to communicate using the tools available. Computers like the telegraph, telephone and smoke signals are tools used to communicate.

Animals also use tools to solve problems. Does that mean they have a developed knowledge of the scientific method or like humans, improvised.
 
Humans have developed language, sign language, written text, symbolism and other ways to communicate using the tools available. Computers like the telegraph, telephone and smoke signals are tools used to communicate.

Animals also use tools to solve problems. Does that mean they have a developed knowledge of the scientific method or like humans, improvised.

I don't know if you're aware of this but the computer has more functions than just communication, and viewing porn.

Really.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom