Reality Check
Penultimate Amazing
Surely a 10 fold increase in the detection of scientific fraud in biomedical and life sciences papers would be a cause for joy, justintimeSurely a 10 fold increase in scientific fraud would be a cause for alarm.
Seriously though you do know that Misconduct accounts for the majority of retracted scientific publications is not about the occurrence of scientific fraud, justintime. It is about the presence of fraud in retracted papers (which are also retracted because of other reasons, e.g. honest errors). The relationship to occurrence is uncertain as Dinwar points out.
Tenfold increase in scientific research papers retracted for fraud
In addition, the long-term trend for misconduct was on the up: in 1976 there were only three retractions for misconduct out of 309,800 papers (0.00097%) whereas there were 83 retractions for misconduct out of 867,700 papers at a recent peak in 2007 (0.0096%).
Citing a source that states that scientific fraud is s tiny percentage does not support an assertion that scientific fraud is "commonplace".
Last edited:
