Maartenn100 said:
They just publish the paper, without having done the experiments themselves and checking the data.
Do you have any idea how stupid such a requirment would be? It would require constructing another Large Hadron Collider for no better purpose than re-running tests, for example. In historical sciences it's even worse--often the data cannot be reproduced in a manner that people like you would find acceptable (reproduce the discovery of a specific fossil, for example!). Reproducibility in those fields is slightly different, and consists of being able to reproduce the general findings, such as ecological trends.
Also, NO editor has time to waste reproducing perfectly good experiments. They're all professional scientists themselves, after all, with their own research.
So, peerreview is not really a good test.
No one ever said it was. What peer review does is ensure that most of the journal articles published are worth discussing. It has nothing to do with whether the paper is right or not.
Your misunderstanding of how science works does not disprove the efficacy of science.
justintime said:
People reject science because science is overrated. The scientific community are made up of short sighted people barely able to cope with the immediate problems and have little use for long term goals that are less sensational.
So to be clear: You are saying that my research is worthless, that I'm short-sighted, that I'm incapable of coping with immediate problems, and tha tI have little use for long term goals. What, precisely, do you base this off of? I would like specific citations, please.
Their disdain for the general public and an inability to articulate their discipline garbled in esoteric mambo jumbo provides them the protection under the disguise of science.
There is nothing even remotely close to true in this statement. Our "esoteric mambo jumbo" is actually very precise jargon that anyone can learn, if they put in a bit of effort. The fact that most don't have any desire to do so in no way demonstrates that the concepts are incomprehensible. My wife and I have a lot of fun with doctors that try to talk over our heads; both of us have a background in anatomy and physiology (though neither of us is in a medical field), so we can generally figure out what the doctors are talking about. The looks of surprise on the doctors' faces are priceless, and with only one exception the doctors have become much more open and ready to discuss the issues with us.
And we generally don't have disdain for the general public. It varries from scientist to scientist, but many see themselves as working for the good of that general public. I'm ambivalent towards the general public; I honestly don't care about such a nebulous and ill-defined concept. As for non-scientist individuals, I tend to like most people.
Finally, we can ALL articulate our discipline. But again, some effort is required on the part of the listener. And we may get sick of trying to explain the same things over and over to incompetents who wish to have all the benefits of science without any of the costs and who wish to be taken seriously in scientific discussions without bothering to do any research into the topic and who can't even be troubled to learn the basic terminology.
Again, please provide specific citations of my activities that support your point. I am a scientist, therefore you are accusing ME of these things. I think that if you're going to make such accusations, you should be able to back them up.
What corporation would want to be sued for the incompetence of scientists hired to deliver the evidence?
None want to. That said, my company has staked a small part of its reputation on my findings a number of times. They have internal checks and ballances, but in the end they're willing to let me choices that are worth hundreds of thousands of dollars, based on my interpretations of scientific evidence. Oh, and each time it happens there are two or three regulatory bodies (minimum--it can be a LOT more) looking over my work, ready to sue us. You may want to get the facts before you go too far. Some corporations do encourage fraud, but it's hardly universal.