science fraud is common place

The problem is, that when you do not repeat the experiment, you can be biased.
And it's a selffulfilling process:

First you accept a paper A because it seems reasonable.
Then you accept paper B because it is in line with the data of paper A.
But you do not accept paper C because it is 'outrageous' (not at all in line with the data of paper A and paper B)

In all these cases you haven't checked the data at all by repeating the described experiments. You just use previous accepted manuscripts about the same subject to judge the next manuscripts with it. But you didn't check any of the data, presented by any of these manuscripts.

This is how scientific publication works. I learned something new today.
No- you've misconstrued what I have written.

Whether or not paper A, B or C seems reasonable is not simply based on whether it is in line with previous papers that I've read, because I was also doing my own experiments at the same time. If a paper says that a solution was made by dissolving sodium sulphate in toluene, I know that this is wrong, because I've worked with this stuff long enough to know that sodium sulphate does not dissolve in toluene. I don't have to specifically duplicate that experiment- I have enough experience to know that it won't work. And if another paper claims to have dissolved sodium sulphate in chloroxylene...well, I've never worked with chloroxylene, but I have worked with enough similar compounds to know that it's not going to happen.
 
Ok, Dinwar, I don't say that the peerreview is not good. I only say that there is the possibility for being biased. That's very human.
I hope you can live with this notion, that there is 'subjectivity' involved.

I don't think you know enough to support this position.

I'll ask again:What, in your opinion, is meant by the word "experiment"?
 
Because they don't check the evidence or presented data at all. They don't check the scientific validity of the paper at all. So, what do they actually review?

Referees are there to do readability and consistency checks. Other scientists are there to do reproducibility checks.

If you're actually trying to understand what science results are believable and which are not, do not get these two things mixed up.

If you're trying to make a generic pro-crackpot, anti-science rant, and don't care if it means anything---sure, mix up whatever you want.

Did someone tell you that every refereed paper is true? Did someone tell you that science is in trouble if a bunch of untrue results and up in refereed papers? This is nonsense. That is like saying that engineering will collapse if someone files a patent on a nonworking idea. Both of these things (wrong results in papers, nonworking patents) happen all the time and it's fine.

Scientists are not stupid. We are smart enough to do complicated and subtle things in the lab. We are also smart enough to read published papers whose data/analysis/interpretation/importance/reproducibility is not instantly obvious.
 
As a professional scientist, I can assure you that this is not true.

It's amazing how many people think that scientists are secretive, faceless and soulless folk locked up in underground government bases, plotting the end of the world and the domination of the sheeple, as if they could never encounter any of them or, indeed, become one through hard work and studying.
 
Most of what occurs in the practice of science goes on behind closed doors, beyond the prying eye of the public.
...semi-religious rant snipped...
Staring with an irrelevant fact is not good, Maartenn100!
A lot of what happens in life goes on behind closed doors, beyond the prying eye of the public.
I am currently behind closed doors, beyond the prying eye of the public :eye-poppi.

The reality is that what as much as possible in science is made public.
 
By the way: I discovered that peerreviewers don't check the data with experiments...
By the way, Maartenn100, every one knows that this is not the job of peer reviewers!

Peer review of a paper is a good test that the science as presented in the paper is as correct as humanly possible.
 
People reject science because science is overrated. The scientific community are made up of short sighted people barely able to cope with the immediate problems and have little use for long term goals that are less sensational.

Really. Do you understand what basic research is?

I must say that most of the attacks I see come from the right, from creationist silliness, leading even to the point where basic mathematics like the Nash Equilibrium is ignored, control system theory is denied, etc, and those who cite it, even here, are routinely defamed by people who don't like what mathematics and science teach.
 
Last edited:
But what criteria do peerreviewers use to in order to check the claimed data, the experimental conditions etc?
They do not check the claimed data.
They do not check the experimental conditions.
They do check that the data presented to them in the paper is
* internally consistent,
* clearly presented,
* correctly analyzed,
* in their experience would be produced from the experiment as described,
* etc.

Editors decide to publish a paper in a journal when the peer reviews say that the paper contains no obvious mistakes.
 
These scientific journals publish these papers without checking the evidence for the claims.
:notm Maartenn100
We can say what everyone knows.
No scientific journal would be idiotic enough to try to reproduce the data in very paper that is submitted to them.
Every scientific journal "checks" the evidence for the claims as presented in the papers.

So, we, the public, ask ourselves: what do these peers review?
The reputation of the institute?
The reputation of the authors?
So we, the public, ask ourselves: where do these rather ignorant questions come from, Maartenn100 :jaw-dropp!
Peer reviewers do not review the reputation of the institute :eek:
Peer reviewers do not review the reputation of the authors :eek:
Peer reviewers review the scientific validity of the papers that are presented to them by evaluating them according to their expertise in the field.
 
How do they check the outcome of an experiment (the data) without doing the experiment at all? I don't get it.
...some musing based on ignorance snipped...
That would be because you are still ignorant about what the job of a peer reviewer is, Maartenn100.
Here is a good explanation: The 4 Jobs of a Referee in Peer Review
1.) To verify that the introductory section(s) adequately sets up, explains, and places their work into its appropriate historical and scientific context.
...
2.) What are the methods used to obtain and analyze the data presented in this paper? Are they sound? Are there questions about their validity?
...
3.) Results: are they clear? Has anything been omitted (or included) that shouldn’t have been? Is all the data that needs to be there actually there? And does it contain and show all the information that it was designed to?
...
4.) Can the conclusions reached be justified based on both the combined, pre-existing breadth of knowledge of the field and the work done in this paper?
 
The OP and this thread are absurd. There is no human endeavor -- other the sciences -- where the accuracy of findings are more zealously scrutinized. Mathematical equations are checked again and again for accuracy. Experimental results are tested again and again to search for deviations and to find greater degrees of accuracy. Theories are debated ad nauseam until better ones emerge. It might take a little time, but ultimately the best answers currently available are found.
Are there occasional dishonest activities? Does greed occasionally rear its ugly head? That is quite irrelevant -- of course; scientists are humans.
 
Last edited:
The problem is, that when you do not repeat the experiment, you can be biased. ...
Once again, Maartenn100: That is nothing to do with what a peer reviewer does.
The 4 Jobs of a Referee in Peer Review

You are confused with another step in the scientific review process. The next step is the review of the published paper by other workers in the field. That can produce criticism of the paper as letters to the editor or experiments that contradict the results. The step after (or as well as) this step is to reproduce the experiment.

ETA: You should also realize that not all papers are written about experiments or even science!
Many mathematical papers do what you say is wrong to do - they start with clearly stated assumptions and thus take the risk that they will be shown to be false later.
 
Last edited:
It's amazing how many people think that scientists are secretive, faceless and soulless folk locked up in underground government bases, plotting the end of the world and the domination of the sheeple, as if they could never encounter any of them or, indeed, become one through hard work and studying.

That's why I like to point out that I'm a scientist. People are perfectly comfortable with accusing scientists of various things--for precisely the same reason we don't care when stormtroopers get shot. They're nameless, faceless people behind white lab-coats. Put a name and a face on them (so to speak), and suddenly those attacks become less acceptable. It's one thing to say "Scientists are evil and in cahoots with the big corporations!" It's much harder to picture Dinwar, a random forum denizen, of being that.

The other thing it demonstrates is that scientists aren't some special breed. My grandfather was a truck driver and machinist, and my other grandfather was a civil engineer. The only reason I can use ten-dollar words in casual conversation is that I've put the time into learning them. I'm crass, I'm rude, I'm overly emotional at times, I make stupid mistakes--I'm just a regular person. It proves that the idea that common people can't understand science is complete bunk. If someone like me can do it, anyone can.
 
ETA: You should also realize that not all papers are written about experiments or even science!
Many mathematical papers do what you say is wrong to do - they start with clearly stated assumptions and thus take the risk that they will be shown to be false later.

To clarify something, since Maartenn100 doesn't want to answer my question: The reason I asked about the definition of "experiment" is that many historical sciences utilize natural experiments that cannot be replicated. As I said up-thread, you can't replicate a supernova--yet observing one can provide powerful insight into many mechanisms foundational to our existence. You also can't cause an extinction more than once--once something is extinct, it's been permanent thus far. Sometimes it's hiking over a hillside--the drafting of geologic maps is a powerful demonstration of the scientific method. I once observed a natural experiment by driving over a mountain pass, which allowed me to observe the rainshadow effect in action (one of the more moving experiences of my life). These are experiments, just as much as anything a physicist or chemist does--but in an uncontrolled environment, and often occurring or being discovered at unpredictable times (other times, the very existence of the thing is the experiment). Replication often consists of either replicating patterns in different systems (for example, looking at ammonites as well as dinosaurs approaching the impact horizon) or testing implications of a particular event (the search for gravitational lenses springs to mind). No serious researcher would deny that these are valid tools of scientific inquiry, but they are vastly different from the concept of "experiment" you learned in grade school.

I believe that Maartenn100 uses the term "science" to mean "physics, plus maybe a bit of chemistry"--the way many people think of science. The reality is far different and much, much cooler.
 
Quote:
Because they don't check the evidence at all.

Dinwar wrote: This is, simply put, a lie. I've already addressed that point, and to continue to act as though I haven't merely furthers the degradation of your reputation here.

justintime: So you're willing to make accusations about me without actually bothering to provide any examples of my work that justify your accusations. Nice. Glad to know you've done your homework before committing what can be termed slander.

Dinwar, you are confusing quotes from Maartenn100 and attributing it to me. I did not say they don't check the evidence at all. You should not mix quotes from different members in the same post. I think Maartenn100 is more than a match for you and you are ill equipped to manage a war on two fronts.

Maartenn100 wrote: Because they don't check the evidence or presented data at all. They don't check the scientific validity of the paper at all. So, what do they actually review?

I have responded to your request for citation on the three major points I raised. You will find them in my post #29 which you have not responded to.

1. Scientists are poor communicators. They hide behind scientific jargon so as to avoid being questioned by the general public. They mask their inability to articulate their discipline and indulge in garbled esoteric mambo jumbo to protect themselves under the disguise of science.

2. The scientific community are made up of short sighted people barely able to cope with the immediate problems and have little use for long term goals that are less sensational.

3. There is excessive fraud among the scientific community a disservice to the Corporations and Institutions that fund their research. Gross incompetence and dangerously inept unreliable research bordering on criminal negligence has raised doubts and suspicion on what was once a noble profession.
 
justintime said:
Dinwar, you are confusing quotes from Maartenn100 and attributing it to me.
No, I haven't. If anything, someone couuld potentially think that I was saying that I said what I was calling a lie, but I thought it was pretty clear.

You should not mix quotes from different members in the same post.
You're one of the few people who've complained about my posting style in the past few years. So I'd say I'm good.

I think Maartenn100 is more than a match for you and you are ill equipped to manage a war on two fronts.
Maartenn100 has demonstrated a hopeless ignorance of the topic at hand and an unwillingness to learn the actual information, along with an inability to acurately re-state what he has been told. There's no war to fight with him. You're not much better--your main tactic in this post is to ignore everything I've said and re-state mere opinions about an activity you clearly know nothing of as if they were data!!

I have responded to your request for citation on the three major points I raised. You will find them in my post #29 which you have not responded to.
You've misunderstood what I said. My demand is that you present evidence that I have committed those crimes. You want to attack "scientists", and I don't want to let you hide behind such nonsense. When you say "scientists", you're talking about ME--and a host of others here on this forum. You are saying I do this. And it's perfectly acceptable for me to demand you provide evidence for these accusations, or appologize for the libel.

1. Scientists are poor communicators.
Some are, some aren't. I've communicated complex ideas to grade schoolers, and i've met scientists that couldn't explain an acid/base reaction to a fellow chemist. We're HUMAN; we're variable.

The rest of this point is unsupported nonsense that does not follow at all from the opening premise. As I have said, there's nothing esoteric or even particularly difficult about scientific jargon. We use it because it's very precise, and such precision is necessary in what we do. The difference between a mandibular fossa and a mandibular fenestra may be obscure and esoteric to you, but to an anatomist they are very precise terms that provide a great deal of meaning--and both would best be described as "a hole in the jaw" in the vernacular, which is imprecise and has no taxonomic or physiological value. Species names are similar--the common names merely confuse the issue, and scientists have developed a way to very precisely talk about individual groups due to the need to be able to do so in multiple fields. If you find scientific jargon difficult to comprehend, it is because you have not put the effort into learning it. NO scientist I've met has EVER advocated obscurity; in fact, they advocate clarity and easy of comprehension. The issue is that we're dealing with things English wasn't built to handle, so we've been sort of making up the terms as we go along for the past few hundred years (which is, before you say anything, not the least different from any other field).

If you're too lazy to bother to learn the jargon of the field, you don't get to criticize it for being hard to understand. The problem isn't with the scientists. It's with you, pure and simple.

Also, being a scientist I demand you substantiate your claim that I'm a poor communicator when it comes to scientific ideas. I can often fail to explain other ideas, but when it comes to my areas of expertise I seem to be doing pretty well.

2. The scientific community are made up of short sighted people barely able to cope with the immediate problems and have little use for long term goals that are less sensational.
Again, I deamnd you show that I'm short-sighted and barely able to cope with immediate problems. This sounds like nothing mroe than "They don't do the research I want them to in the way I want them to", a common thread among anti-science groups. This interpretation is further supported by your previous ravings concerning unintended consequences.

3. There is excessive fraud among the scientific community a disservice to the Corporations and Institutions that fund their research.
There is no evidence--in your links or elsewhere--that the highlighted part is true. Is there fraud? Sure. Even some high-profile cases. But as I've demonstrated, you have no idea, outside a few soundbites worth of data, what the history of science is like in regards to fraud (Owen's case for example was rather high-profile, to use gross understatement), and therefore are incapable of evaluating whether it's gone up or down, much less what the impacts would be. Furthermore, you have ignored my first-hand experience in precisely the field you say is degraded.

But I'll let you dig your own grave: Please provide a precise level of fraud that is acceptable and not "excessive". 0% is impossible; again, scientists are not some alien breed, we are human beings. No fraud is ideal, but an unreasonable demand (until you remove fraud from some other field, completely and without exception, don't expect if from science). At what point does fraud become acceptable? And--perhaps more importantly--how do arive at that number?
 
1. Scientists are poor communicators. They hide behind scientific jargon so as to avoid being questioned by the general public. They mask their inability to articulate their discipline and indulge in garbled esoteric mambo jumbo to protect themselves under the disguise of science.

2. The scientific community are made up of short sighted people barely able to cope with the immediate problems and have little use for long term goals that are less sensational.

3. There is excessive fraud among the scientific community a disservice to the Corporations and Institutions that fund their research. Gross incompetence and dangerously inept unreliable research bordering on criminal negligence has raised doubts and suspicion on what was once a noble profession.

:big:

Good joke
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom