These passions have been well communicated to this non scientist by scientists like David Attenborough, Carl Sagan, Richard Feynman, Richard Dawkins, Brian Cox and Jim Al-Khalili.
Add Steven J. Gould, Niles Eldredge, Robert Bakker, and Peter Ward from my field.
MCH said:
1) Peer review *is* frequently given, by scientists, as the reason teh ign'ant public should believe teh science.
It certainly is A reason. Peer review ensures that the papers have at least been looked at by someone knowledgeable about the field, as opposed to opinion pieces and the crap websites thus far presented as evidence against peer review. The thing is, peer review is not an excuse to stop thinking, which is basically what justintime and Maartenn100 are presenting as the only thing they'll accept. Reviewers screw up, and it's up to every individual to make their own determinations about the quality of the paper.
2) There is little or no scrutiny.
Horse apples. We may not invite the public to view the day-to-day operations (though you'd be surprised at how often this does happen), but there IS scrutiny. In-depth and constant. What you fail to understand is that the people doing the scrutinizing
are people knowledgeable about the field. John Q. Public isn't going to be able to identify good lab practices from bad--the number of students I've had to yell at for doing mind-numbingly stupid stuff (like pouring hydrocloric acid on themselves or eating in a chemistry lab) demonstrates that.
My alma matre purchased a mass spectrometer about a year after I graduated. I was around for the initial phases of the purchase, and was involved a bit because frankly I was the only one who knew how to use the machine it was replacing. The company came in and inspected our set-up. Then they issued a series of required upgrades and modifications. If we wanted the machine, we had to do those modifications/upgrades (which is why it took more than a year). The company simply would not have sold us the equipment otherwise. And that's just one story I could tell about my work being picked over by outsiders.
3) Because there is little or no scrutiny, we are left with a lot of vague handwaving about fraud.
False premise. But even if it weren't, there's not "vague handwaving about fraud". Numbers have been provided in this thread, and references specifically analyzing fraud in science. Scientific fraud isn't something we deal with in a vague manner; the punishment is quite specific and precise. The person's career is, with VERY few exceptions, completely destroyed.
4) Replication only works when there's replication.
Okay, hot shot: exactly how do we replicate Peter Ward's work on ammonite biostratigraphy of the Sacramento Valley? How do we replicate observations of a supernova? How do we replicate the discovery of the mass graves from the Battle of Wisby?
You are assuming that experiments are what you learned in high school: controled, conducted in a lab, and under conditions that can be precisely replicated. Unfortunately for your argument, this is not the case for many sciences. Our experiments are what are called "natural experiments"--things in nature that we use to support/refute our hypotheses. Exact replication of these natural experiments is frequently impossible; you simply cannot blow up a star a second time. What we do in these cases is to work out the implications of these natural experiments, and seek out additional proof of those implications. For example, one implication of the Alvarez Hypothesis was that organisms should go extinct suddenly at the K/Pg boundary. Peter Ward was among the hundreds or more paleontologists who worked on that problem (it was the biggest question in paleontology in the 1990s). He didn't replicate what Alvarez et al. did; instead, he found a beach cliff in France (hey, if you've got to do field work, pick some place nice!) where ammonites had been found and carefully sampled the sediment up through the boundary. It wasn't even similar to what the Alvarez team did--the Alvarez team was a physicist and I believe a sedimentologist, among others--but it certainly was replication.
justintime said:
Then goes around rationalizing, justifying and trying to convince like minded people (peers) to accept the research with the understanding should it be proven wrong even after it was accepted (peer-reviewed), it can always be retracted under the mutually agreed Oooops factor!!!! That is science for the layman.
If that's your view of science, no wonder your opinions are so screwed up. What you've presented is not even close to what real science is like. For example, most papers that are proven wrong aren't retracted. Unlike your cartoon view of science, real researchers don't accept papers as gosple truth. Scientific publication can be thouoght of as a conversation, one with rules and gate keepers but a conversation none the less. An individual paper is akin to a single post on a forum; it may be interesting, but by itself tells you nothing. Only by looking at the context--by understanding all the papers around it, that it is responding to, expanding upon, refuting, and address--can one understand the paper fully. And if the paper is wrong, that's fine; it may be wrong in a useful way. There's a Quaternary sedimetologist, Jay Quade, that started a debate about lake/spring deposits in the Mojave (as part of the Yucca Mountain mess; a lot of it is publically available, so feel free to check my arguments for yourself). When one researcher says "That's a lake" and another says "That's a spring", only one can be right (well....given the parameters, only one could). That means that at least one paper is wrong. Neither have been retracted. Now, after spending a few years looking at these deposits I'm convinced they are spring deposits, for a number of reasons; but that required me to read the rebuttals to Quade's work and get my hands dirty looking at the sediment. And this is not unusual; this is what scientists do. Check out the Geological Society of America's annual meeting's field trips to see dozens of examples of exactly this sort of thing.