science fraud is common place

It doesn't matter where your hypothesis comes from - Kekule 'dreamt' the shape of the benzene molecule - it's the disciplined approach to testing that hypothesis that distinguishes science from other efforts towards knowing the world.

Yes.

As opposed to, for example, mysticism, which starts with an uneducated guess and puts it through the process:
1. Claim guess was a revelation from the great beyond.
2. Start church in downtown LA
3. Throw baseless accusations at any who point out the flaws in your idea
4. Hope you hang on long enough to leverage that 12-episode self-help DVD deal.

:D
 
These passions have been well communicated to this non scientist by scientists like David Attenborough, Carl Sagan, Richard Feynman, Richard Dawkins, Brian Cox and Jim Al-Khalili.

Add Steven J. Gould, Niles Eldredge, Robert Bakker, and Peter Ward from my field.

MCH said:
1) Peer review *is* frequently given, by scientists, as the reason teh ign'ant public should believe teh science.
It certainly is A reason. Peer review ensures that the papers have at least been looked at by someone knowledgeable about the field, as opposed to opinion pieces and the crap websites thus far presented as evidence against peer review. The thing is, peer review is not an excuse to stop thinking, which is basically what justintime and Maartenn100 are presenting as the only thing they'll accept. Reviewers screw up, and it's up to every individual to make their own determinations about the quality of the paper.

2) There is little or no scrutiny.
Horse apples. We may not invite the public to view the day-to-day operations (though you'd be surprised at how often this does happen), but there IS scrutiny. In-depth and constant. What you fail to understand is that the people doing the scrutinizing are people knowledgeable about the field. John Q. Public isn't going to be able to identify good lab practices from bad--the number of students I've had to yell at for doing mind-numbingly stupid stuff (like pouring hydrocloric acid on themselves or eating in a chemistry lab) demonstrates that.

My alma matre purchased a mass spectrometer about a year after I graduated. I was around for the initial phases of the purchase, and was involved a bit because frankly I was the only one who knew how to use the machine it was replacing. The company came in and inspected our set-up. Then they issued a series of required upgrades and modifications. If we wanted the machine, we had to do those modifications/upgrades (which is why it took more than a year). The company simply would not have sold us the equipment otherwise. And that's just one story I could tell about my work being picked over by outsiders.

3) Because there is little or no scrutiny, we are left with a lot of vague handwaving about fraud.
False premise. But even if it weren't, there's not "vague handwaving about fraud". Numbers have been provided in this thread, and references specifically analyzing fraud in science. Scientific fraud isn't something we deal with in a vague manner; the punishment is quite specific and precise. The person's career is, with VERY few exceptions, completely destroyed.

4) Replication only works when there's replication.
Okay, hot shot: exactly how do we replicate Peter Ward's work on ammonite biostratigraphy of the Sacramento Valley? How do we replicate observations of a supernova? How do we replicate the discovery of the mass graves from the Battle of Wisby?

You are assuming that experiments are what you learned in high school: controled, conducted in a lab, and under conditions that can be precisely replicated. Unfortunately for your argument, this is not the case for many sciences. Our experiments are what are called "natural experiments"--things in nature that we use to support/refute our hypotheses. Exact replication of these natural experiments is frequently impossible; you simply cannot blow up a star a second time. What we do in these cases is to work out the implications of these natural experiments, and seek out additional proof of those implications. For example, one implication of the Alvarez Hypothesis was that organisms should go extinct suddenly at the K/Pg boundary. Peter Ward was among the hundreds or more paleontologists who worked on that problem (it was the biggest question in paleontology in the 1990s). He didn't replicate what Alvarez et al. did; instead, he found a beach cliff in France (hey, if you've got to do field work, pick some place nice!) where ammonites had been found and carefully sampled the sediment up through the boundary. It wasn't even similar to what the Alvarez team did--the Alvarez team was a physicist and I believe a sedimentologist, among others--but it certainly was replication.

justintime said:
Then goes around rationalizing, justifying and trying to convince like minded people (peers) to accept the research with the understanding should it be proven wrong even after it was accepted (peer-reviewed), it can always be retracted under the mutually agreed Oooops factor!!!! That is science for the layman.
If that's your view of science, no wonder your opinions are so screwed up. What you've presented is not even close to what real science is like. For example, most papers that are proven wrong aren't retracted. Unlike your cartoon view of science, real researchers don't accept papers as gosple truth. Scientific publication can be thouoght of as a conversation, one with rules and gate keepers but a conversation none the less. An individual paper is akin to a single post on a forum; it may be interesting, but by itself tells you nothing. Only by looking at the context--by understanding all the papers around it, that it is responding to, expanding upon, refuting, and address--can one understand the paper fully. And if the paper is wrong, that's fine; it may be wrong in a useful way. There's a Quaternary sedimetologist, Jay Quade, that started a debate about lake/spring deposits in the Mojave (as part of the Yucca Mountain mess; a lot of it is publically available, so feel free to check my arguments for yourself). When one researcher says "That's a lake" and another says "That's a spring", only one can be right (well....given the parameters, only one could). That means that at least one paper is wrong. Neither have been retracted. Now, after spending a few years looking at these deposits I'm convinced they are spring deposits, for a number of reasons; but that required me to read the rebuttals to Quade's work and get my hands dirty looking at the sediment. And this is not unusual; this is what scientists do. Check out the Geological Society of America's annual meeting's field trips to see dozens of examples of exactly this sort of thing.
 
Just to add to Dinwar's points:

The primary purpose of peer review isn't to show that a certain research paper presents the One True Result(TM). The purpose of peer review is to make sur ethat the paper contains enough information and detail to show that:
1. There was research done
2. The research adds something to science (i.e.-it isn't a copy of things already done, but somehow adds to the field: either qa new idea, a new confirmation of an old idea, or something similar)
3. There is enough information for others to understand what was done, how it was done, why it was done, where it was done, and to do it themselves if they want and have the resources available.

Basically, the purpose of peer review is to make sure there is enough information about the research for a meaningful conversation and discussion of the research among experts, and enough information that others can check their work.

And to add to this, regard what Dinwar said about many papers not being retracted for being wrong. That leaves the arguments and counterarguments "in the record", so to speak. So if new evidence comes along later (to borrow and shamelessly mutilate his example, say there was evidence found of numerous fossil riverbeds leading to the supposed spring, but none leading away), then the arguments are still there in the publications to be reviewed.

I would imagine that if wrong papers were retracted, the same people would be posting threads about how science hides it mistakes.
 
Last edited:
Hellbound said:
And to add to this, regard what Dinwar said about many papers not being retracted for being wrong. That leaves the arguments and counterarguments "in the record", so to speak. So if new evidence comes along later (to borrow and shamelessly mutilate his example, say there was evidence found of numerous fossil riverbeds leading to the supposed spring, but none leading away), then the arguments are still there in the publications to be reviewed.
Very true!

Another thing to consider: A paper may not be all right or all wrong. Most papers are very information dense, and it may be that some of the information is correct while other information in the paper isn't. Future studies may demonstrate that some of the interpretations are flawed--for example, papers written pre-Quade about lake stratigraphy in the Mojave it frequently include some "lakes" that turned out to be springs. That part is wrong. The startigraphy and interpretation of the actual lakes may be very, very good, however. To retract the entire paper for a screw-up no one noticed for two generations would be completley insane; it would strip the record of some of the best references for some incredibly important geological and hydrolic features in the Mojave!

Science isn't all-or-nothing. Science throws ideas against reality until they shatter, then picks up any pieces that look useful to build new ideas. We can--and are encouraged to--acept bits and pieces from papers while rejecting others.
 
As for the claim that if you submit a paper for peer-review that someone can steal your idea. Yes, that is a theoretical possibility, though by that point in time it's very difficult as you have a time stamped document showing you already HAD that idea and shared it first.
This far more often happens when you have a friendly chat with a scientist from a rival lab on a conference and you accidentally mention a bit too much.

The objection that papers rejected by one journal are then published later in other journals is again an indication that the objector knows little about scientific communication. Everyone wants fame. And the more read a journal is, the bigger your fame. But journals that are read more also want the bigger discoveries. It is quite normal to try for the best journal you think you can get, then after they reject to search for another to publish your ideas.
It's like a journalist trying to sell a story to CNN, only to get rejected and sell his story to a local news agency. Does that makes the story untrue?
 
Science isn't all-or-nothing. Science throws ideas against reality until they shatter, then picks up any pieces that look useful to build new ideas. We can--and are encouraged to--acept bits and pieces from papers while rejecting others.

What you are saying is science isn't wholesome. It is the broken shattered pieces that are left after bumping against reality. That is the same as saying scientists throw everything and anything against the wall and see what sticks. Shouldn't scientists then redefine what the scientific method it? It certainly is even less sophisticated than the methods the general public use to arrive at the facts. :jaw-dropp
 
justintime said:
What you are saying is science isn't wholesome.
This is like saying "The speed of sound doesn't feel like sour". It appears, superficially, to resemble English, but makes no actual sense.

It is the broken shattered pieces that are left after bumping against reality.
No. THEORIES shatter against reality. Science is the process of constructing the theories, shattering them, and sorting through the pieces. It's a metaphore.

That is the same as saying scientists throw everything and anything against the wall and see what sticks. Shouldn't scientists then redefine what the scientific method it?
This has no similarity to what I said.

I was specifically speaking about the fact that papers do not need to be accepted or rejected wholesale. Individual parts of the papers can be accepted or rejected without accepting or rejecting the rest. THAT is the "sorting through the shattered pieces" bit--we look through papers to find useful and true data and ideas. We then use those--along with our own observations--to create new ideas. This was said specifically to address the idea of falsehoods entering into the literature, and to refute the moronic idea that falsehoods should cause us to reject or retract papers wholesale. Please read what I say in context, and actually pay attention to what I say rather than reconstructing it to fit with your delusions.
 
Originally Posted by justintime
Then goes around rationalizing, justifying and trying to convince like minded people (peers) to accept the research with the understanding should it be proven wrong even after it was accepted (peer-reviewed), it can always be retracted under the mutually agreed Oooops factor!!!! That is science for the layman.

Dinwar wrote: If that's your view of science, no wonder your opinions are so screwed up. What you've presented is not even close to what real science is like. For example, most papers that are proven wrong aren't retracted. Unlike your cartoon view of science, real researchers don't accept papers as gosple truth. Scientific publication can be thouoght of as a conversation, one with rules and gate keepers but a conversation none the less. An individual paper is akin to a single post on a forum; it may be interesting, but by itself tells you nothing. Only by looking at the context--by understanding all the papers around it, that it is responding to, expanding upon, refuting, and address--can one understand the paper fully. And if the paper is wrong, that's fine; it may be wrong in a useful way. There's a Quaternary sedimetologist, Jay Quade, that started a debate about lake/spring deposits in the Mojave (as part of the Yucca Mountain mess; a lot of it is publically available, so feel free to check my arguments for yourself). When one researcher says "That's a lake" and another says "That's a spring", only one can be right (well....given the parameters, only one could). That means that at least one paper is wrong. Neither have been retracted. Now, after spending a few years looking at these deposits I'm convinced they are spring deposits, for a number of reasons; but that required me to read the rebuttals to Quade's work and get my hands dirty looking at the sediment. And this is not unusual; this is what scientists do. Check out the Geological Society of America's annual meeting's field trips to see dozens of examples of exactly this sort of thing.

Since the general public are left out of the review process scientists should be held to a higher standard because they are reviewed by their peers. But it appears that process is flawed, unsophisticated and compromised. Criminal charges should be laid when scientists commit fraud with no exceptions.

(February 2012) Scientists and engineers make up only about 5 percent of the U.S. labor force

When it is reported there is a 10 fold increase in scientific research frauds when only 2.5% of the working force (split between S and E) are scientists.That is an alarming increase in fraud in the small scientific community. Does that suggest criminal minds are drawn to science?
 
When it is reported there is a 10 fold increase in scientific research frauds
Except this isn't what was reported. This has been explained repeatedly.

when only 2.5% of the working force (split between S and E) are scientists.That is an alarming increase in fraud in the small scientific community. Does that suggest criminal minds are drawn to science?
It suggests nothing of the sort. Learn to understand statistics before trying to use them in an argument.
 
justintime said:
Since the general public are left out of the review process scientists should be held to a higher standard because they are reviewed by their peers.
Which is precisely what happens. What you fail utterly to understand--willfully at this point--is that there are TWO review processes, with drastically different intentions. Both have been thoroughly explained to you.

But it appears that process is flawed, unsophisticated and compromised.
You keep asserting this without providing the slightest shred of evidence to support it. This appears to be an article of faith with you--not based on evidence, and impervious to any data or argument.

Criminal charges should be laid when scientists commit fraud with no exceptions.
I shudder to think what would happen if someone as ignorant of the scientific process as you were the one to make such determinations.

When it is reported there is a 10 fold increase in scientific research frauds when only 2.5% of the working force (split between S and E) are scientists.
That ten-fold increase, given the data you provided, still amounts to less than 1 percent of 1 percent of all the papers publisheed (ignoring the remarkable number of errors you committed in your presentation of that information). It remains statistically insignificant, and hardly cause for any alarm.

Does that suggest criminal minds are drawn to science?
You've completely abandoned any pretense at rational evaluation at this point. When less than 1 percent of 1 percent of the work done is fraudulent, you can't exactly accuse the field of attracting frauds.
 
You've completely abandoned any pretense at rational evaluation at this point. When less than 1 percent of 1 percent of the work done is fraudulent, you can't exactly accuse the field of attracting frauds.

Just to add to this, I'd be willing to bet that ANY other field one would care to investigate would have an incidence of fraud at a MUCH higher level than the fraction of a percent that's been reported here.

In fact, I'd be willing to go even farther and state that the incidence of fraud in science is at least one standard deviation lower than the average for all fields, and more likely two or three.

So, unless one can show evidence that fraud in science is somehow more than the norm, or greater than other fields, or something similar, then comments like "science attracts criminal minds" are nothing but irresponsible and unsupported assertions, that reveal more about the nature of the positer than they do about the state of science.

ETA: And I can garuantee you that EVERY field that stands itself in opposition to science: homeopathy, mysticism, religion, and so on, have a much, much, MUCH higher incidence of fraud...by several orders of magnitude.
 
Last edited:
Justintime Quote:
Does that suggest criminal minds are drawn to science?

Dinwar wrote: You've completely abandoned any pretense at rational evaluation at this point. When less than 1 percent of 1 percent of the work done is fraudulent, you can't exactly accuse the field of attracting frauds.

That is the percentage that got caught. What about those that escaped discovery such as the tons of paleontologist mentioned in the link I provided and those from other disciplines yet to be mentioned? Unless criminal charges are laid and scientists who commit fraud are treated as ordinary criminals, this trend will continue to grow.

Every discipline has accountability. Scientific research are exempt from such accountability because they are at best 'educated guesses'. And even after they are accepted and then proven wrong they can still be retracted under the mutually agreed Oooops factor!!!! without any incrimination. This career only promotes more fraud and is attractive to the criminal minded elements in society.

Paleontology Fraud & Hoaxes Wiki
http://paleontologyfraudhoaxes.wikia.com/wiki/Paleontology_Fraud_&_Hoaxes_Wiki
 
What you are saying is science isn't wholesome. It is the broken shattered pieces that are left after bumping against reality. That is the same as saying scientists throw everything and anything against the wall and see what sticks. Shouldn't scientists then redefine what the scientific method it? It certainly is even less sophisticated than the methods the general public use to arrive at the facts. :jaw-dropp

Is language your first language? Nothing that has been posted here, outside of your screed, supports your claim.

Your misstatements about how science actually works provide no information about science, at all--but so provide a wealth of information about your lack of understanding.

Seriously: in which area(s) of science does your expertise lie?
 
justintime said:
What about those that escaped discovery such as the tons of paleontologist mentioned in the link I provided and those from other disciplines yet to be mentioned?
The link you provided was so obviously and horrifyingly biased that you'd have more chance of finding accurate information in a bowl of Alphabet Soup. The mere act of considering it a valid source destroyes any shred of credibility a person has, by demonstrating their incompetance at vetting sources. As for those frauds that do happen, in order to be discussed they must first be identified. This quite neatly removes them from supporting the point you wish to make--which, to remind you of your own argument, is that unreported frauds represent a larger portion of the research than we admit.

Unless criminal charges are laid and scientists who commit fraud are treated as ordinary criminals, this trend will continue to grow.
You've yet to demonstrate that there is a trend. An insignificant number of frauds occurred. That's all the data can say.

Scientific research are exempt from such accountability because they are at best 'educated guesses'.
Actually, no. Scientific research is put through the most rigorous analysis of any field that I'm aware of, and held to standards that would be considered insane among any other field. People long dead continue to have their work analyzed and scrutinized and picked over. Let's be clear here: There is NO other field that analyzes itself with even half the rigor of science. Your continued willful refusal to acknowledge how science is actually conducted--despite being corrected by numerous practicing scientists in numerous fields--is neither evidence nor honest.

And science isn't "at best 'educated guesses'". Science has rules. Hypotheses can be educated guesses, but the actual papers require substantiating evidence.

even after they are accepted and then proven wrong they can still be retracted under the mutually agreed Oooops factor!!!! without any incrimination.
I have demonstrated that this exact statement is complete humbug already. To re-state it as if it were true is nothing short of dishonest.

This career only promotes more fraud and is attractive to the criminal minded elements in society.
Funny how the data don't show that. But then, this isn't about truth or falsehood, is it? It's about you attacking science.
 
Since the general public are left out of the review process scientists should be held to a higher standard because they are reviewed by their peers. But it appears that process is flawed, unsophisticated and compromised. Criminal charges should be laid when scientists commit fraud with no exceptions.

The general public are, of course, welcome to put in the work to become qualified to be part of the review process.

When it is reported there is a 10 fold increase in scientific research frauds when only 2.5% of the working force (split between S and E) are scientists.That is an alarming increase in fraud in the small scientific community. Does that suggest criminal minds are drawn to science?

I have slogged through enough of your threads to realize that it is fruitless to anticipate that you might, in fact, respond to actual information presented in a thread. Naetheless, it is important to point out that your construct that there is a "10-fold increase in scientific research frauds", is a dishonest and inaccurate construction. How many papers were withdrawn for demonstrated fraud during the last year that records have been completed? Not percentage, not X-fold increase; how many actual papers (out of all peer-reviewed science papers published in all peer-reviewed journals) were withdrawn do to demonstrated fraud? Produce that number.

In addition, do consider explaining in which area of science your expertise lies.
 
That is the percentage that got caught. What about those that escaped discovery such as the tons of paleontologist mentioned in the link I provided and those from other disciplines yet to be mentioned?

All these paleontologists committed fraud, and were *never* caught? Nobody *ever* found out about them? Who collected the data for the website, then?

Unless criminal charges are laid and scientists who commit fraud are treated as ordinary criminals, this trend will continue to grow.
People who are caught committing scientific fraud *do* get caught and punished.

Guido Zadel, for example, in the 1990s, published a paper with a surprising result. Since this result would have significant implications for other scientists' work, a number of research groups tried to do something similar. It couldn't be replicated, and Zadel's PhD was revoked.
Every discipline has accountability. Scientific research are exempt from such accountability because they are at best 'educated guesses'.

********. If I come up with a hypothesis which later turns out to be wrong...oh well, I was wrong. If I fake some data to support my hypothesis, then either a) other researchers who have an interest in the kid of work I'm doing will try to apply my results, and find that it simply doesn't work, or b) my work will be so inconsequential that nobody will ever check it. If the former, I get caught. If the latter, it's not important enough to justify your cries for jail time.
 
Here is a sample of scientific high flung dung (esoteric mambo jumbo) which a layman can shrink down to one or two sentences.

Saltatory Processes and Altricial to Precocial Forms in the Ontogeny of Fishes

Abstract

SYNOPSIS. Development is not a gradual but a saltatory process. A combination of qualitative changes in form and function—thresholds—creates boundaries between a succession of quantitative intervals—steps. Thresholds can be modified by an altered time of appearance of structures and functions (heterochrony), especially during early ontogeny, to form an operational basis for the prolongation of juvenile characters and adaptability into later ontogeny. Whereas such prolongation enables juvenilization in phylogeny, analogous principles may operate on a much shorter time scale to produce the r-selection-like altricial and the K-selection-like precocial trends in ontogeny. The inherited capacity to adjust constantly to the environment (heterochrony) selects for structural, biochemical and behavioral improvements. The tendency is toward the precocial but the way back to altricial forms is left open. The heterochronous adaptations in early ontogeny can “reverse” the vulnerable specialization, should the environment become less stable and/or the community less competitive. Juvenilization, capable of turning gerontomorphosis into paedomorphosis in evolution, and heterochronous shifts of character anlagen, capable of turning a precocial trend into an altricial trend in ontogeny are both part of the same biological process which operates during early ontogeny.
 
Slowvehicle said:
The general public are, of course, welcome to put in the work to become qualified to be part of the review process.
Many are. In paleontology in particular ametures can become quite important to the scientific process, both as formal reviewers and as researchers (that second, informal review process I keep mentioning).

Madalch said:
All these paleontologists committed fraud, and were *never* caught? Nobody *ever* found out about them? Who collected the data for the website, then?
What I've always found amusiing is that the people objecting to science have never found, to my knowledge, a single case of fraud. Every fraud they trot out as proof of science's failure was discovered by scientists.

What they actually prove is that the process works. Not fast, certainly--perhaps not even in the researcher's lifetime. But eventually the false data is found out and the crime laid bare. And ONLY science appears capable of doing so. Otherwise, people like justintime would be able to point to examples of their own discoveries of frauds.
 
Here is a sample of scientific high flung dung (esoteric mambo jumbo) which a layman can shrink down to one or two sentences.
Okay, then- shrink it down to one or two sentences and we'll see if you've understood it correctly.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom