science fraud is common place

Fact is that sometimes very good submitted manuscripts were first rejected by some high profile journals and, later on, these manuscripts were accepted by another journal.

That tells us enough about the 'objectivity' of the peerreview process.
 
Last edited:
Akri, do you really think that a scientist is going to admit here on a forum that he doesn't like the current peerreview process?
So if they agree with you it would mean you're right, and if they disagree with you it STILL means you're right. That's certainly handy.

[quot]He or she is not going to risk his or her reputation or careerchanches.[/quote]
They've criticized peer review on this forum before without showing any fear of damaging their reputations or career chances. And, funny enough, what you're accusing them of doing (hiding their true thoughts in order to save face) WOULD ruin their reputations and career chances.

But the fact is: you ask your competitor in the same field to judge you... Objective method? No, not at all.
The fact is that scientists do not view one another as competitors the way companies do.
 
The fact is that scientists do not view one another as competitors the way companies do.

Not true. Application-oriented research often leads to products, and products have competitors. A former research partner and I had one journal article that took 2 1/2 years to get published because the only qualified reviewers at the beginning were our competitors, had inferior products, and were jerks.
 
Why are you thinking that people like Justintime are 'against science' or 'against scientists' when they give some arguments 'contra'? Isn't this how discussions suppose to be.
I'm not 'against science' or 'against scientists'.
No one is against a fair method of trying to be neutral and trying to be objective.

In theory, this is a beautiful sentiment.

But, imagine that you are a scientist in a very competitive environement. And you send your work to a journal and peers must decide wether it's good or not...

It's like asking another company (your competitor) to evaluate your product.

It is possible that you do not realize that you seem to be arguing the other end of the spectrum from Justintime's claim that enormous amounts (0.00096%!) of fraudulent papers are being improperly included in peer-reviewed journals due to the ignorance, or collusion, of the reviewers. Were the scenario you describe an accurate characterization, it would result in a large number of valuable papers being improperly excluded from peer-reviewed journals due to the incompetence, or perfidy, of the reviewers. It is a testament to the process that neither of the two scenarios can be demonstrated to be at all common.

That's asking for problems with 'objectivity' or problems with 'getting neutral, unbiased reviews'.

We are not the only people saying this.
I read some articles from scientists and their experiences with peerreview. They worked hard on it, send it to a journal and another group of scientists took their data and published it in their study.

Were you able to document this, entire careers would be destroyed. Plagiarism is as close to an unforgiveable vile and cowardly act as exists in science.

You seem to have this attitude of 'black against white'. Or you are defending what's been called 'science' these days or you are against science.

this is a discussionforum. So everyone may post arguments and counterarguments. This is not about 'people against science or pro science'. This is just a free discussion with free arguments.

And everyone likes a 'neutral' and 'objective' evaluation. (science).
No one is against that.

This is not consonant with the accusation you made earlier in this post.

But 'reputation of the author' or 'title' or 'being scientist' are no objective criteria for the evaluation of a paper. Not at all. It's always about the content: are the premisses true and is the logic valid.

And when someone did years of study and hard work, he or she wants to have a fair change. And that's not always the case with the current peerreview method.

I encourage you to demonstrate specific occurrences, or admit to promulgating your own fantasy.
 
Last edited:
The 0.0096% was in 2007 from a low of (0.00097%) in 1976. But as of 2012 "(PNAS), found that more than two-thirds of the biomedical and life sciences papers that have been retracted from the scientific record are due to misconduct by researchers, rather than error."
It only takes a small percentage of fraud to create havoc. Take the example of thalidomide babies.Andrew Wakefield's MMR vaccine papers, the tobacco industry.

Justintime, you are dishonestly equivocating. You are cleverly trying to imply that 2/3 of ALL "biomedical and life science papers" are fraudulent. The reality is, of the vanishingly small percentage of "biomedical and life science papers" that are, in fact, withdrawn, 2/3 of them (2/3 of that vanishingly small percentage, which was...what...again?) are withdrawn due to fraud. To the intelligent, impartial observer, that resembles a system policing itself. Not the hecatomb purge you try to imply.

On another note, I have politely asked this question of you several times. I'm sure you must have simply overlooked it, so I will ask again, "mate":

In what area of science does your expertise lie?
 
Fact is that sometimes very good submitted manuscripts were first rejected by some high profile journals and, later on, these manuscripts were accepted by another journal.

That tells us enough about the 'objectivity' of the peerreview process.

I encourage you to provide support for this calumny, or withdraw it.
 
It's like asking another company (your competitor) to evaluate your product.

You mean like what happens to me about once a month? I have both reviewed reports for other companies and had my reports reviewed by them. It's called subcontracting out your review process.

Also, Slowvehicle has hit the nail on the head. Fraud=ended carrier. Few people risk it--as the numbers show.
 
Akri, do you really think that a scientist is going to admit here on a forum that he doesn't like the current peerreview process? He or she is not going to risk his or her reputation or careerchanches.
se.

I have done so, openly, both here and at conferences. My career is doing fine, thanks. Thing is, I know the difference between REAL objections and made-up nonsense.
 
Originally Posted by Maartenn100 View Post
You seem to have this attitude of 'black against white'. Or you are defending what's been called 'science' these days or you are against science.

this is a discussionforum. So everyone may post arguments and counterarguments. This is not about 'people against science or pro science'. This is just a free discussion with free arguments.

This is a SCIENCE FORUM where EVIDENCE based arguments are expected....and you sir have failed miserably at providing any.

It is not a "free discussion with free arguments"it is a science forum.
...if you participate in a science forum like this your opinion is worthless without verifiable backup.
You have provided none despite numerous requests.
 
Not true. Application-oriented research often leads to products, and products have competitors. A former research partner and I had one journal article that took 2 1/2 years to get published because the only qualified reviewers at the beginning were our competitors, had inferior products, and were jerks.
Good point; I should have said that it is not always the case that scientists view one another as competition where peer-review is concerned.
 
But it's true. My research supervisor locked me up in this dungeon and told me not to come out until I can fudge enough data to prove that Black Holes actually have marshmallow cores.
Mmmmm. Gravitationally collapsed marshmallow.... :D

Why are you thinking that people like Justintime are 'against science' or 'against scientists' when they give some arguments 'contra'?
That would be experience of his postings here. He doesn't like science as it contradicts his beliefs.

I'm not 'against science' or 'against scientists'.
No one is against a fair method of trying to be neutral and trying to be objective.
:rolleyes: Even when science demonstrates (again) that you're views are rubbish?

But, imagine that you are a scientist in a very competitive environement. And you send your work to a journal and peers must decide wether it's good or not...

It's like asking another company (your competitor) to evaluate your product.

That's asking for problems with 'objectivity' or problems with 'getting neutral, unbiased reviews'.
No.

this is a discussionforum. So everyone may post arguments and counterarguments. This is not about 'people against science or pro science'. This is just a free discussion with free arguments.
And when your arguments are unsupported crap you can expect to have this pointed out.

But 'reputation of the author' or 'title' or 'being scientist' are no objective criteria for the evaluation of a paper. Not at all. It's always about the content: are the premisses true and is the logic valid.
Correct. Hence peer review.
 
Actually, it's the other way around. most of us are passionate people who feel more deeply about things than non-scientists can imagine.

These passions have been well communicated to this non scientist by scientists like David Attenborough, Carl Sagan, Richard Feynman, Richard Dawkins, Brian Cox and Jim Al-Khalili.

For a large archive of scientists effectively communicating their work, passion and career path to non scientists, take a look here:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b015sqc7/profiles/jim-al-khalili

or here:
http://www.abc.net.au/radionational/programs/scienceshow/
 
Last edited:
It seems as if this subject is already too polarised to be worth discussing. But to pick up on a few points:

1) Peer review *is* frequently given, by scientists, as the reason teh ign'ant public should believe teh science. Just google 'rigorous peer review'. So let's not be surprised when some of the public go 'but it's not rigorous' and so start to treat public announcements by researchers (whether scientific or not) with some skepticism.

2) There is little or no scrutiny. Academic institutions do *not* routinely let the public watch experiments for some very sensible reasons, the internal review processes are not public and the outputs are usually pay-walled to even other academic disciplines. Academic research is routinely neither 'heavily regulated' nor 'zealously scrutinised'. If anyone feels they work in a minority disciplines that is, I'd be very interested in what they feel is 'heavy regulation' or 'zealous scrutiny'. As an example: when a paper is submitted for journal review, is there an independent check that the data in it corresponds to actual measurements made? What other industry not only allows that gap but seems to feel it's perfectly normal?!? And even resists closing it?

3) Because there is little or no scrutiny, we are left with a lot of vague handwaving about fraud. Lack of evidence is not evidence of lack. We don't know if there's fraud because we have no sensible way of detecting it - particularly the minor, passing, ignorable fraud of losing a few inconvenient data points, or dropping a half-completed experiment, or only checking for errors in unexpected results, or all those other little only slightly dishonest things that, who knows, maybe somebody here 'knows someone' who might have done something a bit like that? eh? eh?

4) Replication only works when there's replication. And how long does that take? When are the conclusions 'settled'? What levels of confidence can you apply and when (say, after the initial publication?) What happens when replication doesn't happen, because of expense, or funding, or because it's not very publishable - or it's not possible?

There's a reason why medicine moved from 'expert-based' treatments to 'evidence-based' treatments (although obviously that's not a clean transfer!). Efforts are being made across the board in many fields of human activity to reduce established bias, perverse incentives (publication bias anyone?), the effects of pride, the effects of social identity, and so on and so on.

Without *demonstrated* corrections to all these ordinary human failings (the sort that we get from blinded medical trials, for example - and even there we have some major problems), we really can't trust very much in the outputs of academic research. If we make the completely uncalled for claim that academic researchers are as honest as most people, then we can expect most of them to be a little dishonest much of the time (see eg Dan Ariely's research... if you can trust it...).

The effort in research should be on demonstrating trustability (ie, that the research really is scientific), not requiring evidence of fraud and assuming everything is fine without it.

Update: Pointing at things we now know well doesn't demonstrate that 'science works' - it just shows that academic research sometimes produces science.
 
Last edited:
Justintime, thank you for the data.

Intresting to read about the peerreview filtering process:

"The Sokal affair was a hoax by Alan Sokal (a physicist) perpetrated on the postmodern cultural studies journal Social Text (published by Duke University). In 1996, he submitted a paper of nonsense camouflaged in jargon to see if the journal would “publish an article liberally salted with nonsense if (a) it sounded good and (b) it flattered the editors’ ideological preconceptions.”

and

Another recent example of this same situation is the 2005 Rooter Paper; this was a paper randomly generated by a computer which was submitted – and consequently approved as legitimate – to a scientific conference.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bogdanov_Affair
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SCIgen
The Sokal affair says exactly nothing about the peer review process of science journals since Social Text was NOT peer-reviewed and is not a science journal.
 
Akri, do you really think that a scientist is going to admit here on a forum that he doesn't like the current peerreview process? He or she is not going to risk his or her reputation or careerchanches.
But the fact is: you ask your competitor in the same field to judge you... Objective method? No, not at all.

And do you really think that there are a lot of scientists who want to do a study on science fraud in current 'theories'? They don't want to lose their titles. The university doesn't want to lose it's reputation. The truth is less important in such a case.

Actually, most of the scientists on this board have already shared their concerns about problems in the peer review process, including ideas to make it better.

And the information we do have about scientific fraud has been found by *gasp* scientists.

Do you really think that your uninformed assertions, sans and contra evidence, are persuasive?
 
Any profession that starts out with a guess(hypothesis) on critical research and puts it to the standard process (scientific method):
1. Can this be true?
2. Will others believe it?
3. Do I believe it?
4. Can others repeat the results?
Then goes around rationalizing, justifying and trying to convince like minded people (peers) to accept the research with the understanding should it be proven wrong even after it was accepted (peer-reviewed), it can always be retracted under the mutually agreed Oooops factor!!!! That is science for the layman.

Only point 4 is a sticky one. 4. Can others repeat the results? According to scientists asking points 1,2,3 repeatedly meets the tests. :jaw-dropp
 
Any profession that starts out with a guess(hypothesis) on critical research and puts it to the standard process (scientific method):
1. Can this be true?
2. Will others believe it?
3. Do I believe it?
4. Can others repeat the results?
Then goes around rationalizing, justifying and trying to convince like minded people (peers) to accept the research with the understanding should it be proven wrong even after it was accepted (peer-reviewed), it can always be retracted under the mutually agreed Oooops factor!!!! That is science for the layman.

Only point 4 is a sticky one. 4. Can others repeat the results? According to scientists asking points 1,2,3 repeatedly meets the tests. :jaw-dropp

I wonder if you would be so kind as to substantiate this baseless assertion?

Further, since you have shown yourself intentionally ignorant of how science is actually Dne, might you be so kind as to identify the specific area of science within which your expertise lies?
 
I wonder if you would be so kind as to substantiate this baseless assertion?

Further, since you have shown yourself intentionally ignorant of how science is actually Dne, might you be so kind as to identify the specific area of science within which your expertise lies?

What is a Scientific Hypothesis? | Definition of Hypothesis
Many describe it as an “educated guess,”
http://www.livescience.com/21490-what-is-a-scientific-hypothesis-definition-of-hypothesis.html

That is what I said.

"Any profession that starts out with a guess(hypothesis) on critical research and puts it to the standard process (scientific method)..........."
 
What is a Scientific Hypothesis? | Definition of Hypothesis
Many describe it as an “educated guess,”
http://www.livescience.com/21490-what-is-a-scientific-hypothesis-definition-of-hypothesis.html

That is what I said.

"Any profession that starts out with a guess(hypothesis) on critical research and puts it to the standard process (scientific method)..........."

Which equivocation does not, of course, address the issue, or answer the question I have politely asked, that you have been ignoring.

You have been called on equivocating vocabulary before, many times. As you should be aware, the way "many" describe the term, "hypothesis", is not the way scientists correctly define it (in the same way that "many" misuse, for instance, the term, "theory").

In which area of science does your expertise lie, that that is not patent to you?
 
What is a Scientific Hypothesis? | Definition of Hypothesis
Many describe it as an “educated guess,”
http://www.livescience.com/21490-what-is-a-scientific-hypothesis-definition-of-hypothesis.html

That is what I said.

"Any profession that starts out with a guess(hypothesis) on critical research and puts it to the standard process (scientific method)..........."

It doesn't matter where your hypothesis comes from - Kekule 'dreamt' the shape of the benzene molecule - it's the disciplined approach to testing that hypothesis that distinguishes science from other efforts towards knowing the world.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom