science fraud is common place

That is what happens when you have a scientist interested in religion. By applying the scientific method he turns it into Christian science or creation science. They all satisfy the scientific method because scientific method is a process and when applied to anything the process validates the premise.

Then why don't the other sciences you've denigrated (social, political, behavioral- for that matter, engineering) qualify as science? You're not "No True Scotsman"-ing here, are you? Drawing a circle of exclusion by a definition deliberately chosen to (you think) keep your "science" in and others out?

And let's look at your definition of "scientific method":
The steps of the scientific method are to:

1) Ask a Question
2) Do Background Research
3) Construct a Hypothesis
4) Test Your Hypothesis by Doing an Experiment
5) Analyze Your Data and Draw a Conclusion
6) Communicate Your Results

(I've numbered your steps for easy referral)
This isn't too bad, but it's a little cartoonish, because you've left out one very important part of the method- any hypothesis you advance to answer your step 1 must be testable by falsification of it; scientific propositions aren't proven true, they can only be proven false. Since "God," by definition, is omnipotent, there's no way to falsify "goddidit" as a hypothesis; any falsifiablility goes out the window when magical thinking- "god can do anything"- can be proposed as an answer.

So there go your steps 3 and 4 of the method. What creation "science" actually does is to short-circuit the actual scientific method- you've removed the load (of testability) the circuit must bear to remain a viable one, and tripped the breaker; you now have a useless bunch of dead wire. Congratulations.

If you think this is wrong, please feel free to tell me specifically how you would test for god.
 
Just to remove all avenues of escape: my research has been called into court (for the record, I was not; my report served as evidence). I'm a paleontologist, just about as ivory-tower as you can get. This is not unusual, either. If justintime were right, most of my colleagues would be in jail for purgery. justintime has to explain how fraud can survive when federal prosecutors are involved.

It's fairly uncommon for a learned treatise to stand alone as evidence in court, which means the other party may have stipulated to its conclusions. Normally a learned treatise considered as evidence must have an expert witness to testify to it in court. That doesn't have to be its author, but if the author is available it's best to have him testify if the conclusions of the paper will be questioned.

Science in the hands of lawyers is as problematic as the law in the hands of a scientist. But the end result is exactly the point you're trying to make: there is no one more motivated to find any error (real or imaginary) in a learned treatise than someone trying to undermine it in court.
 
JayUtah said:
It's fairly uncommon for a learned treatise to stand alone as evidence in court...
True, but it's not uncommon for environmental compliance documents to stand as evidence in court. Basically what happens is some group gets upset about a construction project and feels that the easiest avenue of attack is the environmental compliance. Then the entire Environmental Impact Statement and all supporting documentation are called into court as evidence of compliance.

Normally a learned treatise considered as evidence must have an expert witness to testify to it in court. That doesn't have to be its author, but if the author is available it's best to have him testify if the conclusions of the paper will be questioned.
I'm not quite high enough up the company food chain for them to trust me in court yet. We have senior technical advisors who take on that responsibility (as well as many other tasks). I'm not 30 yet, so it's hardly surprising that I'm not in that position--normally you need a few decades to get to the point where my company trusts you in court. Since the STAs also serve as internal review for all technical documents, they're already pretty familiar with the content.

Fortunately that hasn't happened yet while I've worked for my company. The lawyers pour through the documents looking for complaince issues, but so far they've been unable to find fault in my work. Which is surprising--I've made a few interpretations that are not universally accepted. All perfectly within the realm of paleontological analysis, and all very well supported, but still, going against that many people you'd think someone would have asked me why by now.

Science in the hands of lawyers is as problematic as the law in the hands of a scientist.
Dear gods in Hell yes!!! I've had no end of headaches from lawyers trying to read my work. "Can you simplify the term 'facies'?" "Do we need to use the technical terms for these rock units?" "Why do you include discussions of outdated names for rock units?" And that's before the other lawyers get ahold of it--my company makes each report that goes out the doors go through a legal review. I understand why, though--their job is to think like their opponents, and find all the flaws they can. They just don't know enough about the job to know what IS a flaw.
 
It's fairly uncommon for a learned treatise to stand alone as evidence in court, which means the other party may have stipulated to its conclusions. Normally a learned treatise considered as evidence must have an expert witness to testify to it in court. That doesn't have to be its author, but if the author is available it's best to have him testify if the conclusions of the paper will be questioned.

Science in the hands of lawyers is as problematic as the law in the hands of a scientist. But the end result is exactly the point you're trying to make: there is no one more motivated to find any error (real or imaginary) in a learned treatise than someone trying to undermine it in court.

Most juries appear to reject scientific evidence because of it esoteric high flung dung. What gets even more ridiculous is having experts challenge each others science. Most scientific evidence/testimony are even unable to overcome a reasonable doubt. No wonder science fraud is common place.
 
Then the entire Environmental Impact Statement and all supporting documentation are called into court as evidence of compliance.

Oh, that makes sense then. I can see how it could stand like that under rules of evidence.

...normally you need a few decades to get to the point where my company trusts you in court.

Testifying in court is an art.

I understand why, though--their job is to think like their opponents, and find all the flaws they can.

And the most reliable science goes through peer review.
 
Most juries appear to reject scientific evidence because of it esoteric high flung dung. What gets even more ridiculous is having experts challenge each others science. Most scientific evidence/testimony are even unable to overcome a reasonable doubt.

Really? How many actual trials have you actually participated in where expert testimony was prevalent? I want an actual number.

No wonder science fraud is common place.

It isn't, and you've ignored every single refutation of this ridiculous assertion that I've given you, as well as those given by others. Simply repeating your nonsense doesn't suddenly make it true.
 
Most juries appear to reject scientific evidence because of it esoteric high flung dung.

So what you're saying is that most people are uneducated and we should solve the problem by funneling more money through public education, specifically science and critical thinking ? I agree.
 
Most juries appear to reject scientific evidence because of it esoteric high flung dung. What gets even more ridiculous is having experts challenge each others science. Most scientific evidence/testimony are even unable to overcome a reasonable doubt. No wonder science fraud is common place.

How do you know what most juries accept and reject? Is it on the infamous page 78?

I've given expert testimony in court a few times. I didn't notice any blanket rejection of scientific evidence.
 
And peer review is flawed.

It has its weaknesses, but it's the best thing we've got.

Most juries appear to reject scientific evidence because of it esoteric high flung dung.
Back to this nonsense, I see. Typical troll behavior--wait a few days until everyone forgot that this argument was demolished, and present it as if it's never been criticized.
 

Indeed, no one has claimed the peer-review process is foolproof. However the rate of error in peer-reviewed publications remains vastly lower than in non-refereed or popular publications.

However this popular article makes exactly the same error you continue to make, which is to simply infer that fraud must be widespread because the review process does not catch all errors. Where the actual rate of fraud is studied and reliably measured, it falls far short of your inferred rate.

Do you ever plan on getting around my main point of refutation? Or can I safely assume that you have no answer for it?
 
Hmmmm cartoonish claims with no basis in fact, taunting, repeating failed claims.... ah a troll. I'll leave this to those who like to shred same.
 
Most juries appear to reject scientific evidence because of it esoteric high flung dung.
How do you know that? You've already proven that you don't understand scientific terminology, so how do you know if it's "high flung dung" or not? You don't know what any of it says, so how can you evaluate it?
 
How do you know that? You've already proven that you don't understand scientific terminology, so how do you know if it's "high flung dung" or not? You don't know what any of it says, so how can you evaluate it?

OP doesn't understand the law, scientific terminology, or methodology, so his arguments end up being a lot of handwaving and FUD.

Here's what happens in the law. A party in a case files its list of expected expert witnesses, among them let's say the noted (fictional) engineer Otto Kaufflinger. They provide the obligatory paragraph describing what he'll be testifying to.

The other party in the case calls me up and says, "Hey, Jay, I need you to research such-and-such a paper by Otto Kaufflinger and tell me everything you can about what might be wrong with it." I immediately log the call, because should I be called to testify as an expert witness, everything I do from the moment of retention is discoverable. Now eventually a jury might not understand everything in the paper. But I will, and if it's "high flung dung," I'll know it. And it would conceivably be my job to explain, in layman's terms, just how and why.

Further, either I or counsel will have pulled every testimony transcript from every trial in which Kaufflinger has been deposed or examined and have acquainted ourselves with the strengths and weaknesses of his testimony on a related point. We'll be well armed with knowledge of how this witness can be used by favorable counsel to mislead a jury.

And I'll be well motivated to do a good job, because the law firm that calls me is paying me for my expertise. If I screw up, or if I miss something important that loses them the case, I won't be hired again.

Now that's not science, which is to say, it's not how scientific inquiry works. That's how legal inquiry works. But bad science can stand up to neither. And fraudulent science is necessarily bad science.
 
So what you're saying is that most people are uneducated and we should solve the problem by funneling more money through public education, specifically science and critical thinking ? I agree.

Actually, I believe he's saying the complete opposite- that "uneducated" is the proper metric by which to judge science and evidence, and the ideal to which everyone should aspire.

I did like the "high flung dung" thing, though- I think I had some of that at the Chinese restaurant my wife and I went to last night.
 
justintime? Come up with any ideas yet on how specifically your creation "science" can use the scientific method (even as loosely defined by you) to test for god? Slamming actual science won't do it- any science is a fabric, and you can't make your fabric whole just with the holes you think you're poking in someone else's.
 
Actually, I believe he's saying the complete opposite- that "uneducated" is the proper metric by which to judge science and evidence, and the ideal to which everyone should aspire.

I did like the "high flung dung" thing, though- I think I had some of that at the Chinese restaurant my wife and I went to last night.

I think High Flung Dung is related to Wuan Huang Loo.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom