science fraud is common place

Most definitely he did. Henry Petroski is one of the most widely quoted author-engineers in the English speaking world. He has written numerous books, the subject of one is exactly how engineering is applied science. The OP has gotten Petroski's career work exactly 100% wrong.

Characteristic of the OP's MO, here, in other threads, and elsewhere.
 
Yet your same well-known engineer/author, Henry Petroski, writes extensively elsewhere on how engineering is science. Do not cherry-pick the literature of my profession. Petroski is here distinguishing between pure science and the directed science underlying engineering. He is not saying that engineering is unscientific. Further, you are completely side-stepping my point -- you simply cannot fool engineers who rely on your science to do actual things.

In his seminal book To Engineer is Human, Petroski draws explicit parallels between the scientific method and the process of engineering design.

Ask a Question. My clients present me with problems. Every solution I contemplate is a question asked, in exactly the same sort of method as a scientist asks questions about the behavior of the physical world. "Will a steel truss framework provide sufficient support?" "Does the resonance of this material in these dimensions satisfy the vibration requirement of that spacecraft?" "Will axial rotation dominate this design?"

Do Background Research. Every design project begins with surveys of the state of the art, and of new research.

Construct a Hypothesis. Petroski argues that an engineering design is precisely a scientific hypothesis. It is a statement designed to be tested and either validated or falsified by empirical analysis -- namely building it.

Test Your Hypothesis by Doing an Experiment. Most of our designs are tested on a small scale to validate the hypotheses in the design. The ultimate empiricism is the full-scale construction of the design. Petroski spends practically a whole chapter on this, so go read it.

Analyze Your Data and Draw a Conclusion. Design analysis is about two-thirds of what engineers do, and the backbone of my personal economy. I specialize in computational tools for engineering design analysis. The conclusions we draw are precisely whether the design candidate is suitable in all respects, just as a scientists uses his experimental data to determine whether his hypothesis has truly predicted the outcome as observed in the physical world. If you think this isn't what engineers do, you don't know a thing about engineering.

Communicate Your Results. The ultimate communication of our work is the objects we produce. Many of them, such as large civil engineering structures, cannot be hidden. Formally, we communicate significant findings in publications such the Engineering News Record.

You don't know what you're talking about. But by all means continue to express your vast ignorance of the profession I've practiced successfully for 25 years. Oh, and explain to me how allegedly fraudulent science is caught by the people who depend on it to work in order to do anything that they do.
Science has lost its meaning. Today we have social sciences, political science, behavioral science, computer science. Even mathematics is considered a science which it is not. There is a science to everything as in method. Science included natural science as in biology, zoology and chemistry. Today adding the word science to any study gives it the appearance of credibility.
 
Science has lost its meaning. Today we have social sciences, political science, behavioral science, computer science. Even mathematics is considered a science which it is not. There is a science to everything as in method. Science included natural science as in biology, zoology and chemistry. Today adding the word science to any study gives it the appearance of credibility.

You are correct, like Christian science, for example. Lame attempt to garner credibility. Or creation science, even lamer.
 
Science has lost its meaning. Today we have social sciences, political science, behavioral science, computer science. Even mathematics is considered a science which it is not. There is a science to everything as in method. Science included natural science as in biology, zoology and chemistry. Today adding the word science to any study gives it the appearance of credibility.


Which again has no connection to the topic at hand, are you going to offer up anything to support your currently extremely flimsy hypothesis?
 
You are correct, like Christian science, for example. Lame attempt to garner credibility. Or creation science, even lamer.

That is what happens when you have a scientist interested in religion. By applying the scientific method he turns it into Christian science or creation science. They all satisfy the scientific method because scientific method is a process and when applied to anything the process validates the premise.
 
That is what happens when you have a scientist interested in religion. By applying the scientific method he turns it into Christian science or creation science. They all satisfy the scientific method because scientific method is a process and when applied to anything the process validates the premise.

Creation science has no evidence, no method and no rigour. All it has is a conclusion, already arrived at before the process begins. That's not science; it's a lie.

0.005% is a small number, by the way. It's the REAL number of frauds.
 
No, YOU have lost your argument.

Science fraud is incredibly rare.

Just when science fraud is gaining public attention in the US. Europe does not even have an oversight body to combat science fraud. This would double the number of reported cases of science fraud if statistics of scientific fraud were available for Europe.

In the United States, the Office of Research Integrity and the National Science Foundation both impose legal sanctions for scientific fraud in publicly funded research. The European Commission has no equivalent measures in place. Strict regulations and policy procedures to combat misconduct (see, for example, go.nature.com/a1znzb) are needed before Europe's…

http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v480/n7376/full/480181c.html

I will rework my numbers to reflect this inclusion of Europe's contribution to science fraud.

Incidentally on retractions due to fraud, China ranked fourth, behind America, Germany and Japan.
http://www.economist.com/news/china...earch-leading-academic-fraud-looks-good-paper

I will also rework my numbers to include China's contribution to science fraud after I get numbers for Germany and Japan. :jaw-dropp
 
Just when science fraud is gaining public attention in the US. Europe does not even have an oversight body to combat science fraud. This would double the number of reported cases of science fraud if statistics of scientific fraud were available for Europe.



http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v480/n7376/full/480181c.html

I will rework my numbers to reflect this inclusion of Europe's contribution to science fraud.

Incidentally on retractions due to fraud, China ranked fourth, behind America, Germany and Japan.
http://www.economist.com/news/china...earch-leading-academic-fraud-looks-good-paper

I will also rework my numbers to include China's contribution to science fraud after I get numbers for Germany and Japan. :jaw-dropp

You'd have to work the numbers first to actually re-work them. So far, the only one that approves of your math is you.
 
That is what happens when you have a scientist interested in religion. By applying the scientific method he turns it into Christian science or creation science. They all satisfy the scientific method because scientific method is a process and when applied to anything the process validates the premise.

Nonsense; certain religious types have used the word science to try and lend a false impression of rigour and logic to their ideas. Even a cursory inspection of creation science reveals that they have rejected the scientific method and again all you have revealed here is you are as ignorant of how the scientific method works as they are.
 
Science has...

You quoted my post but you didn't address a single point I made in it.

Your source, Henry Petroski, is on widely-published record disagreeing vehemently with the notion you've wrongly attributed to him. You have no rebuttal to this.

I've asked you now three times to explain how science can be as fraudulent as you say, yet still allow practitioners who rely upon it -- and indeed bear legal liability for their efforts -- to get the right answer.

Please address those points forthwith.
 
You'd have to work the numbers first to actually re-work them. So far, the only one that approves of your math is you.

I submit that anyone who thinks you can have 7000% fraud rates has demonstrated that their interpretations of any numbers can be safely ignored.

JayUtah said:
Please address those points forthwith.
I wouldn't hold my breath if I were you...

justintime said:
By applying the scientific method he turns it into Christian science or creation science. They all satisfy the scientific method because scientific method is a process and when applied to anything the process validates the premise.
This is funny. Know what happens when you actually apply the scientific method to modern Creationism? You discard Creationism as false. If you continue believing in Creationism, you've failed to apply the scientific method.
 
By applying the scientific method he turns it into Christian science or creation science.

No. Neither Christian Science nor creation science applies the scientific method. They all assume their desired conclusion as the null and rely upon arguments from silence and straw-man arguments to give the illusion that competing hypotheses have been falsified.

They all satisfy the scientific method because scientific method is a process and when applied to anything the process validates the premise.

I described in detail how design engineering fits the scientific method in all its particulars. Your only attempt to rebut that was to gesticulate wildly at other pursuits you deemed unworthy of the title "science." But here, by your own argument, you confirm that design engineering is indeed a valid applied science.

Now that that's been cleared up, please explain how such applied sciences, with legally accountable "conclusions," can survive in a world as rife with scientific fraud as you say it is. You have constantly and assiduously evaded this important real-world check on your results.
 
Now that that's been cleared up, please explain how such applied sciences, with legally accountable "conclusions," can survive in a world as rife with scientific fraud as you say it is. You have constantly and assiduously evaded this important real-world check on your results.

Just to remove all avenues of escape: my research has been called into court (for the record, I was not; my report served as evidence). I'm a paleontologist, just about as ivory-tower as you can get. This is not unusual, either. If justintime were right, most of my colleagues would be in jail for purgery. justintime has to explain how fraud can survive when federal prosecutors are involved.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom