science fraud is common place

Sorry you don't get to derail the thread that easily; if you cannot answer your critics then just have the courage to say so and don't attempt such pathetic sidetracking. All you've managed to demonstrate to to date in this thread is you don't understand statistics and you suck at maths.

Agreed, although I'd say - to borrow a phrase from the esteemed Terry Pratchett - I would call his understanding of math abysmal, but that would leave no adequate word to describe his understanding of statistics.
 
Lets revist the math.

The study found 2% of scientists admit to fraud. It was also reported elsewhere scientists publish under several different names to avoid detection or to enhance their chances of getting publicity. Let us give it a number say 5 different publishers or publications.
2% x5 = 10% of publications are fraudulent.

Now for every 1 major fraud 100 go undetected.
10% x 100 = OMG 1000% of science is fraudulent.

But the survey found 14% of scientists admitted to knowing someone a peer/collegue committing fraud.

Rework the math.

14% x 5 = 70%

Now for every 1 major fraud 100 go undetected.
70% x 100 = OMG 7,000% of science is fraudulent.

Of course 0.005% is not many. But 7,000% is.
I decided to have my brother take a look at this, as he is a math major. He disagrees with your conclusion:

Claim: If 7,000% of science is fraudulent, then for any given scientist, that scientist is not fraudulent.

Proof:
Let U be the universe of 'science' composed of elements called 'scientists.' Assume 7,000% of science is fradulent. Then 7,000% of U is fradulent, meaning that 100% of 'scientists' s in U must be 700% fraudulent. Let us define 100% fraudulency to be compltely fraudulent. A scientist of 100% fraudulency would then be fraudulent, but a scientist of 700% fraudulency implies a mathematical impossibility: that s is over 100% of a property. We will take the relationship 'If s is 100% fraudulent, then s not fraudulent' to be false. Our statement, however, would then would be that 'If s is 700% fraudulent, then s is not fradulent'. Based on the principles of implication, the statement is vacuously true since there is no situation in which s can be 700% of anything. Since it is impossible to provide a counterexample of any sort (since there is no such thing as a 700% fraudulent scientist), our statement that 'if s is 700% fraudulent, then s is not fraudulent' must be correct. Thus, every s in U is not fraudlent.

Quod erat demonstrandum.

Thus, your claim that science is 7,000% percent fraudulent has proven that 100% of scientists are not fraudulent. Which in and of itself is a contradiction with the claim that .005% of scientists are fraudulent, meaning that the claim that 7,000% of scientists are fraudlent is therefore wrong.

Quod erat demonstrandum.
 
It was always thought science was self correcting and therefore un-corruptable.
Wrong, justintime: Science is actually self correcting and therefore the chances of fraud being undetected are small. Peer-review catches the obvious frauds. Continuing review captures the more subtle frauds. The lack of replication captures totally concealed fraud.
 
Wait, how does that work ?
7000/100=700, assuming 100 scientists.

So, about as well as justintime's math :D

ETA: Actually, you could say that each scientist is 7000% fraudulent and the proof would still hold.
 
Last edited:
Well, I'm an engineer. That means I'm a scientist who is legally accountable for the strength of his reasoning, most of which is based at some point upon academic science.

The problem with the "widespread fraud" argument in science is that, at a certain point, the science has to correlate with observable reality or else it is discarded. Engineering and other practical applications of science is where that rubber meets that road. And literally, if the science of, say, friction were wrong, then it would be discarded. Because I have a fiduciary responsibility for correctness, I have no patience or tolerance for science that is inaccurate for any reason, including fraud. And I honestly don't see any appreciable percentage of fraud in science.
 
I split a bunch of posts discussing forum management issues to AAH. If you want to discuss forum management issues, feel free to start a thread in the appropriate sub-forum.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LashL
 
Well, I'm an engineer. That means I'm a scientist who is legally accountable for the strength of his reasoning, most of which is based at some point upon academic science.

The problem with the "widespread fraud" argument in science is that, at a certain point, the science has to correlate with observable reality or else it is discarded. Engineering and other practical applications of science is where that rubber meets that road. And literally, if the science of, say, friction were wrong, then it would be discarded. Because I have a fiduciary responsibility for correctness, I have no patience or tolerance for science that is inaccurate for any reason, including fraud. And I honestly don't see any appreciable percentage of fraud in science.
.
Yeah, our bolts can't break in use! Otherwise, we'd get our pants sued off!
:)
 
Well, I'm an engineer. That means I'm a scientist who is legally accountable for the strength of his reasoning, most of which is based at some point upon academic science.

The problem with the "widespread fraud" argument in science is that, at a certain point, the science has to correlate with observable reality or else it is discarded. Engineering and other practical applications of science is where that rubber meets that road. And literally, if the science of, say, friction were wrong, then it would be discarded. Because I have a fiduciary responsibility for correctness, I have no patience or tolerance for science that is inaccurate for any reason, including fraud. And I honestly don't see any appreciable percentage of fraud in science.

Engineering Is Not Science
http://spectrum.ieee.org/at-work/tech-careers/engineering-is-not-science

In fact there is some rivalry between the professions.

Engineers tired of being outshined by scientists
http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/tech/science/columnist/vergano/2010-02-26-engineers_N.htm

But according to many here mechanics are scientists because they follow the scientific method such as:

The steps of the scientific method are to:

Ask a Question
Do Background Research
Construct a Hypothesis
Test Your Hypothesis by Doing an Experiment
Analyze Your Data and Draw a Conclusion
Communicate Your Results
 
Engineering isn't science? I'd like to see it get along without science, and vice versa.

I think you took the wrong message away from that article. Mind you it is a poorly titled article.

As for scientists allegedly 'outshining' the engineers, well, the Eloi seemed to outshine the Morlocks, but who was keeping the Eloi alive?
 
The steps of the scientific method are to:

Ask a Question
Do Background Research
Construct a Hypothesis
Test Your Hypothesis by Doing an Experiment
Analyze Your Data and Draw a Conclusion
Communicate Your Results

Whereas your method is:

Make up your own ideas about a topic (in this case, fraud in science)
Ignore all contrary evidence
Babble endlessly about your idea
 
Engineering Is Not Science
http://spectrum.ieee.org/at-work/tech-careers/engineering-is-not-science

In fact there is some rivalry between the professions.

Engineers tired of being outshined by scientists
http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/tech/science/columnist/vergano/2010-02-26-engineers_N.htm

But according to many here mechanics are scientists because they follow the scientific method such as:

The steps of the scientific method are to:

Ask a Question
Do Background Research
Construct a Hypothesis
Test Your Hypothesis by Doing an Experiment
Analyze Your Data and Draw a Conclusion
Communicate Your Results
.
Look at that video of the Boeing structural test on that wing.
The prediction of the failure event was based on the intimate knowledge of the strengths of the various materials used to assemble the wing.. the outer skins, the spars, the fasteners, all of these had to have been tested and their good qualities selected to produce that wing with that failure at that point!
Science all the way, no hand-waving or soothing the structure into behaving as desired.
The process from the initial question as to how to construct the wing and the result of the process fits ALL of the criteria posted.
 
good grief how did you arrive at the idea that Engineering is not science nor science based???

This University seems to think it is:

http://www.eng.ox.ac.uk/

These people seem to think it is too

http://www.esm.psu.edu/about/whatisesci/

You should read the description of Engineering Science.

"Engineering Science is a multidisciplinary honors program that emphasizes enhanced understanding and integrated application of engineering, scientific, and mathematical principles. "

That is not your traditional Engineering graduate program. It is designed to be a multidisciplinary program which is clearly stated.
 

Yet your same well-known engineer/author, Henry Petroski, writes extensively elsewhere on how engineering is science. Do not cherry-pick the literature of my profession. Petroski is here distinguishing between pure science and the directed science underlying engineering. He is not saying that engineering is unscientific. Further, you are completely side-stepping my point -- you simply cannot fool engineers who rely on your science to do actual things.

In his seminal book To Engineer is Human, Petroski draws explicit parallels between the scientific method and the process of engineering design.

Ask a Question. My clients present me with problems. Every solution I contemplate is a question asked, in exactly the same sort of method as a scientist asks questions about the behavior of the physical world. "Will a steel truss framework provide sufficient support?" "Does the resonance of this material in these dimensions satisfy the vibration requirement of that spacecraft?" "Will axial rotation dominate this design?"

Do Background Research. Every design project begins with surveys of the state of the art, and of new research.

Construct a Hypothesis. Petroski argues that an engineering design is precisely a scientific hypothesis. It is a statement designed to be tested and either validated or falsified by empirical analysis -- namely building it.

Test Your Hypothesis by Doing an Experiment. Most of our designs are tested on a small scale to validate the hypotheses in the design. The ultimate empiricism is the full-scale construction of the design. Petroski spends practically a whole chapter on this, so go read it.

Analyze Your Data and Draw a Conclusion. Design analysis is about two-thirds of what engineers do, and the backbone of my personal economy. I specialize in computational tools for engineering design analysis. The conclusions we draw are precisely whether the design candidate is suitable in all respects, just as a scientists uses his experimental data to determine whether his hypothesis has truly predicted the outcome as observed in the physical world. If you think this isn't what engineers do, you don't know a thing about engineering.

Communicate Your Results. The ultimate communication of our work is the objects we produce. Many of them, such as large civil engineering structures, cannot be hidden. Formally, we communicate significant findings in publications such the Engineering News Record.

You don't know what you're talking about. But by all means continue to express your vast ignorance of the profession I've practiced successfully for 25 years. Oh, and explain to me how allegedly fraudulent science is caught by the people who depend on it to work in order to do anything that they do.
 
You should read the description of Engineering Science.

Engineering Science is not engineering. Please don't just frantically Google for stuff and think it will impress those of us who practice a licensed profession and, in some cases, have also taught it academically.

You've latched onto one largely irrelevant sentence of my post and are off to the races trying to frantically undermine it as a distraction. You haven't actually addressed the point of my post. If science is fraudulent it will get answers that disagree with the behavior of the natural world. Please explain how any profession that relies upon the correctness of science can possibly tolerate a field that is as rampant with error as you infer it must be.
 
I think you took the wrong message away from that article.

Most definitely he did. Henry Petroski is one of the most widely quoted author-engineers in the English speaking world. He has written numerous books, the subject of one is exactly how engineering is applied science. The OP has gotten Petroski's career work exactly 100% wrong.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom