science fraud is common place

I just said in my example. If 65% of 2000 teachers charged with altering tests scores were found guilty, it would be considered a disaster.
Try reading the entire sentence. I said it would depend on the total number of teachers charged with that task. The task being "altering test scores". 2000 is not the entire number of retracted papers, so for the analogy to be fair it can't be the entire number of teachers altering test scores either. In both cases you need to know the total number in order to have any idea of perspective.

On top of this, if the scientific method attracts fraud and if peer review is so bad at removing fraud, why were 65% of those papers removed specifically because of fraud? How were the frauds caught if science is so terrible at catching fraud?
 
Read the title of the OP.
Science fraud is common place.


Unfortunately, rational discussion of the issue has been impeded by your innumeracy and unwillingness to admit when you're wrong.
 
65% of 2000 studied papers were found fraudulent. That is not a tiny percentage or the article would have said so.
2000 retracted papers out of a total of 25 million papers is a tiny percentage. Thus my 0.0096% is a tiny percentage justintime post on 19th December 2013.
The authors of the paper would not think that there would be people ignorant enough not to know this. So the paper does not have the actual tiny percentages - you have to look at figure 1B.
The authors of the Guardian article though do make this explicit :D.

And you have it wrong - 25 million papers were studied (the contents of the PubMed database). The 2047 retracted papers were just studied more closely.
 
Last edited:
65% of 2000 studied papers were found fraudulent. That is not a tiny percentage or the article would have said so.
That's like reading an article that says "65% of hunters arrested in Jasper National Park were arrested for poaching", and declaring "65% of hunters are poachers! That's a huge number!" Hunters who aren't poaching don't get themselves arrested in a national park where hunting is illegal.
 
2000 retracted papers out of a total of 25 million papers is a tiny percentage. Thus my 0.0096% is a tiny percentage justintime post on 19th December 2013.
The authors of the paper would not think that there would be people ignorant enough not to know this. So the paper does not have the actual tiny percentages - you have to look at figure 1B.
The authors of the Guardian article though do make this explicit :D.

And you have it wrong - 25 million papers were studied (the contents of the PubMed database). The 2047 retracted papers were just studied more closely.

There are millions of scientific papers published. Most of them do not touch on the devastating power of nuclear weapons or nuclear leaks. Millions more do not have much to say about climate change. The public have a better sense of what is important to them and science fraud is at the top of the list. It can affect what they eat, breathe and the quality of life in general(health, wealth and happiness).

As you stated the more closely scientific research papers are studied the higher the percent of fraud will be uncovered. No one has the resources to study every paper published. But the high percentage of fraud in the ones studied is indicative of scientific fraud and how common science fraud has become.
 
Last edited:
As you stated the more closely scientific research papers are studied the higher the percent of fraud will be uncovered. No one has the resources to study every paper published. But the high percentage of fraud in the ones studied is indicative of scientific fraud and how common science fraud has become.

No. Just no.

Complete and utter failure to understand.

The 2000 papers they studied were only the ones that had already been caught by existing processes and retracted.

They were not a random sampling of all scientific papers, they were a check of ONLY the 2047 papers that had ALREADY been retracted from the journals for various reasons.

Of those 2047, 65% were for misconduct (45% for actual fraud).

You are completely misunderstanding the statistics provided.
 
But the high percentage of fraud in the ones studied is indicative of scientific fraud and how common science fraud has become.

No it isn't, because the ones studied were not random samplings, but were retracted papers.
 
To use your court analogy:

What this study did was like doing a study of people convicted of felonies. And then finding that 65% of the people convicted of felonies, were convicted for assault.

This does not mean that 65% of the people who went to court had committed assault (it specifically excludes those that were found not guilty).

You're trying to say that because 65% of court convictions are for assault, that 65% of the people who went into court at all are guilty of assault.

As many times as this has been explained, and in as many ways, I can only think you're trying to perpetrate fraud of your own.

It's simple enough that a 6 year old can understand it. Perhaps you can find one to teach you?
 
The public have a better sense of what is important to them and science fraud is at the top of the list. It can affect what they eat, breathe and the quality of life in general(health, wealth and happiness).
You realize that everyone disagreeing with you in this thread is part of "the public", right? You do not speak for us.
 
To use your court analogy:

What this study did was like doing a study of people convicted of felonies. And then finding that 65% of the people convicted of felonies, were convicted for assault.

This does not mean that 65% of the people who went to court had committed assault (it specifically excludes those that were found not guilty).

You're trying to say that because 65% of court convictions are for assault, that 65% of the people who went into court at all are guilty of assault.

As many times as this has been explained, and in as many ways, I can only think you're trying to perpetrate fraud of your own.

It's simple enough that a 6 year old can understand it. Perhaps you can find one to teach you?

Here is a better example.

The tobacco company is charged with misleading the public. After the preliminary investigations 2000 are officially charge for being directly involved in the coverup. The final verdict, out of the 2000 charged 65% are convicted or 1300 out of the 2000. This high number/percentage would be considered a disaster in any company/profession/institution. The 100s of thousands of people working for the tobacco industry are not material to the case. It is the fraud/coverup/misleading the public with unscientific facts that was seen as criminal activity. The same applies to the scientific research body. Only the cases of fraud are material evidence needed to expose fraud in the scientific community and 65% of 2000 papers studies were found fraudulent. :jaw-dropp
 
Here is a better example.
It's actually a far worse example, as I shall demonstrate.

The tobacco company is charged with misleading the public. After the preliminary investigations 2000 are officially charge for being directly involved in the coverup. The final verdict, out of the 2000 charged 65% are convicted or 1300 out of the 2000. This high number/percentage would be considered a disaster in any company/profession/institution. The 100s of thousands of people working for the tobacco industry are not material to the case. It is the fraud/coverup/misleading the public with unscientific facts that was seen as criminal activity. The same applies to the scientific research body. Only the cases of fraud are material evidence needed to expose fraud in the scientific community and 65% of 2000 papers studies were found fraudulent. :jaw-dropp
The hilighted bit is not analogous to the scientific papers, because the 2000 papers in question were retracted. That's the scientific equivalent of being found guilty. So an appropriate analogy would be if 2000 companies/people were found guilty of something, and 65% of those were specifically guilty of fraud.
 
Here is a better example.

The tobacco company is charged with misleading the public. After the preliminary investigations 2000 are officially charge for being directly involved in the coverup. The final verdict, out of the 2000 charged 65% are convicted or 1300 out of the 2000. This high number/percentage would be considered a disaster in any company/profession/institution. The 100s of thousands of people working for the tobacco industry are not material to the case. It is the fraud/coverup/misleading the public with unscientific facts that was seen as criminal activity. The same applies to the scientific research body. Only the cases of fraud are material evidence needed to expose fraud in the scientific community and 65% of 2000 papers studies were found fraudulent. :jaw-dropp

At this point, justintime, it's clear to me that you are deliberately ignoring everything we're saying about the difference between 65% of retracted papers and 65% of all papers. So I'm done here until and unless you figure this stuff out.
 
The tobacco company is charged with misleading the public. After the preliminary investigations 2000 are officially charge for being directly involved in the coverup. The final verdict, out of the 2000 charged 65% are convicted or 1300 out of the 2000. This high number/percentage would be considered a disaster in any company/profession/institution. The 100s of thousands of people working for the tobacco industry are not material to the case.

This is dishonest for the reasons Akri mentioned, but there is another reason as well. If 0.009% of the people committed fraud, it would be a tremendous victory for any field except science. Do you honestly think that only 0.009% of mechanics are guilty of fraud? 0.009% of bankers? Of carpenters? It's not disasterous to those industries, despite much higher rates of fraud!

And as for the conviction rate, anything less than 100% means one of two things: either people were falsely accused, or people were aquitted when they were guilty. Either one is far worse than convicting guilty people.

Basically what you're saying is that if most of the people accused of a crime are guilty, it's a disaster for the company, regardless of how many people worked for the company. In reality, the disaster is the accusations against innocent people, and the guilty who walk free.
 
It's actually a far worse example, as I shall demonstrate.


The hilighted bit is not analogous to the scientific papers, because the 2000 papers in question were retracted. That's the scientific equivalent of being found guilty. So an appropriate analogy would be if 2000 companies/people were found guilty of something, and 65% of those were specifically guilty of fraud.

The 2000 papers retracted found 65% of them fraudulent the balance had different levels of infractions. But that is typical in any court proceedings. Many are charge and the final convictions are much smaller. But 65% of 2000 papers studies found fraudulent is no small number by any stretch of the imagination.
 
justintime said:
The 2000 papers retracted found 65% of them fraudulent the balance had different levels of infractions.
Inability to accept basic facts? Check.

Ignores all arguments against him? Check.

Gramar going downhill? Check.

The evidence of trolling is mounting.

But that is typical in any court proceedings.
Irrelevant. What's relevant to this conversation is the fact that all fraud in that study amounts to less than 1% of 1% of published works--to say that fraud is rampant is a flat-out lie.

But 65% of 2000 papers studies found fraudulent is no small number by any stretch of the imagination.
Compared to 25 MILLION published papers in that venue during that time, yeah, it is. It's less than 1% of 1%, in fact.
 
This is dishonest for the reasons Akri mentioned, but there is another reason as well. If 0.009% of the people committed fraud, it would be a tremendous victory for any field except science. Do you honestly think that only 0.009% of mechanics are guilty of fraud? 0.009% of bankers? Of carpenters? It's not disasterous to those industries, despite much higher rates of fraud!

And as for the conviction rate, anything less than 100% means one of two things: either people were falsely accused, or people were aquitted when they were guilty. Either one is far worse than convicting guilty people.

Basically what you're saying is that if most of the people accused of a crime are guilty, it's a disaster for the company, regardless of how many people worked for the company. In reality, the disaster is the accusations against innocent people, and the guilty who walk free.

The tobacco company was levied a multi-billion dollar fine not because 100s of thousands of employees were innocent but because a few mislead the public. The same is with the scientific community. No one is looking at the innocent millions of valid research published but only the fraudulent ones are being investigated. And of the ones studied a high percentage is found fraudulent which is what is fueling further investigation into the oversight process.
 
justintime said:
The tobacco company was levied a multi-billion dollar fine not because 100s of thousands of employees were innocent but because a few mislead the public.
Evidence?

The same is with the scientific community.
Not quite. The issue with tobacco companies is that specific people misled the public in specific ways, and the company higher-ups were in on it. The people actually convicted of fraud were a small percentage of the people involved, and the entire business model was geared towards maintaining it. In contrast, there is no scientific business model, nor is there any administration telling us what to do. Each researcher is on his or her own, and each functions as an independent unit. Therefore the actions of others--even a majority of others--in no way reflect upon the individual researchers. The actions of <1% of 1% certainly do not.

No one is looking at the innocent millions of valid research published but only the fraudulent ones are being investigated.
Actually, YOU are obsessed with the 65% number. The ACTUAL question is whether scientific fraud is commonplace. To answer the REAL question requires us to examine ALL publications, not just retractions. You have dishonestly and intentionally shifted the frame of this discussion because you got trounced in the actual discussion. Now you're running into trouble because people aren't falling for this fraudulant tactic.

65% can mean as little as 13 people. You are saying that we can call fraud commonplace if 13 people commit it--regardless of the actual number of people in the system in question. This is dishonest and moronic. This is akin to calling all humans rapists because hey, a lot of people accused of rape are found guilty! :boggled:

And of the ones studied a high percentage is found fraudulent which is what is fueling further investigation into the oversight process.
None of that is true. Of the RETRACTED studies a pretty good chunck (>40%) were found to involve fraud. However, since there really aren't any good reasons to retract a scientific paper, I'd say that percentage is remarkably LOW. I'd expect the majority of retractions to be due to fraud. That's one of the major reasons for having a retraction system in place to begin with, after all.
 
There are millions of scientific papers published. ...
Yes there are, justintime - in fact it is probably 100's of millions.
Your reply has nothing do with my 2000 retracted papers out of a total of 25 million papers is a tiny percentage post, justintime.

ETA: Your reply is wrong - there is nothing in that post about "the more closely scientific research papers are studied the higher the percent of fraud will be uncovered".
We do not know what will happen to the ~0.001% of all papers that are fraudulent figure if that study is extended to more papers in other fields. It will drop dramatically if we looked at pure math papers (not much chance of fraud there since there is no data to manipulate!). There is the possibility that "harder" sciences such as physics or chemistry might have less fraud than the biomedical area. The best guess is that the ~0.001% figure will not change much.
Unless you mean the trivial fact that misconduct in papers are more likely to be found the more that they are studied. This is obvious. What is not obvious is what that would do to the percentage . It may even double it to a whopping 0.002% :jaw-dropp!
 
Last edited:
Yes there are, justintime - in fact it is probably 100's of millions.
Your reply has nothing do with my 2000 retracted papers out of a total of 25 million papers is a tiny percentage post, justintime.

ETA: Your reply is wrong - there is nothing in that post about "the more closely scientific research papers are studied the higher the percent of fraud will be uncovered".
We do not know what will happen to the ~0.001% of all papers that are fraudulent figure if that study is extended to more papers in other fields. It will drop dramatically if we looked at pure math papers (not much chance of fraud there since there is no data to manipulate!). There is the possibility that "harder" sciences such as physics or chemistry might have less fraud than the biomedical area. The best guess is that the ~0.001% figure will not change much.
Unless you mean the trivial fact that misconduct in papers are more likely to be found the more that they are studied. This is obvious. What is not obvious is what that would do to the percentage . It may even double it to a whopping 0.002% :jaw-dropp!

Every statistic points to an increase in science fraud. I will stick with the peer-review survey 2% of scientists admit to fraud, some 12% know of someone committing fraud and many many more go undetected. These numbers are higher in some countries and expected to get worse.

In defense of science most of the research have very little affect on the general public or are of any practical value. When the funding for fraudulent scientific research shrinks we might see a change in attitudes in the scientific community.
 
Yes there are, justintime - in fact it is probably 100's of millions.
Your reply has nothing do with my 2000 retracted papers out of a total of 25 million papers is a tiny percentage post, justintime.

ETA: Your reply is wrong - there is nothing in that post about "the more closely scientific research papers are studied the higher the percent of fraud will be uncovered".
We do not know what will happen to the ~0.001% of all papers that are fraudulent figure if that study is extended to more papers in other fields. It will drop dramatically if we looked at pure math papers (not much chance of fraud there since there is no data to manipulate!). There is the possibility that "harder" sciences such as physics or chemistry might have less fraud than the biomedical area. The best guess is that the ~0.001% figure will not change much.
Unless you mean the trivial fact that misconduct in papers are more likely to be found the more that they are studied. This is obvious. What is not obvious is what that would do to the percentage . It may even double it to a whopping 0.002% :jaw-dropp!

This is unfortunately typical of the kind of scurrilous claims justintime makes but fails to support. He counts on people not having the ability to understand what he claims, what his links support, and the diff between the two.

He knows that many if not most of us are wise to his game, but can't help living under a bridge, if you get my drift.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom