science fraud is common place

65% of the 2000 studied papers were found to be fraudulent. I did not say the scientists were convicted or jailed. I said "If 65% of violators were convicted in any profession, it would be considered a disaster."

eg. If 65% of 2000 teachers charged with altering tests scores were found guilty, it would be considered a disaster.

I'll explain it again. You are so desperate to find reasons to hate scientists that you assume that all 2000 papers were "violators". The whole point is that 65% of them were violators. The other 35% were papers withdrawn for entirely different reasons - we discovered we made a mistake, or we realized an alternative explanation for the results we found, or whatever. Retracting a paper is done for many reasons; don't equate them all with "altering test scores"!
 
Originally Posted by Daylightstar View Post




The issue here is the peer-review process is flawed, corrupt and scientific fraud is increasing exponentially. .


How do you know? You don't even know what the discipline of science is. Unlike what you previously stated, it's not predictability.
 
Originally Posted by justintime View Post
65% of the 2000 studied papers were found to be fraudulent. I did not say the scientists were convicted or jailed. I said "If 65% of violators were convicted in any profession, it would be considered a disaster."

eg. If 65% of 2000 teachers charged with altering tests scores were found guilty, it would be considered a disaster.

That would depend on how many total teachers had been charged with the task, and on whether it was reasonable to assume that the 65% figure would hold true across the board. In this case the assumption is not reasonable, as has been explained previously.

I just said in my example. If 65% of 2000 teachers charged with altering tests scores were found guilty, it would be considered a disaster.
 
Originally Posted by Daylightstar View Post




The issue here is the peer-review process is flawed, corrupt and scientific fraud is increasing exponentially. Even the research integrity oversight commissions are complacent/complicit in this science fraud which the public is discovering is quite common.

If we had to retroactively bring charges I am sure a lot of the past fraudulent science practices would also be exposed.

I notice you don't really answer my question:

Originally Posted by justintime View Post
... science fraud defenders ... convicted ...

It is a failure of the scientific method, peer-review or Office of Research Integrity? Science attracts the criminally inclined because the chances of getting away with fraud is higher than those forced to retract and the actual frequencies of misconduct are higher, but go willfully undetected.
Hilite by Daylightstar
How about all the crackpots who try to force their unsubstantiated idea onto other people, misquoting or misassigning data, falsely stating that supporting data exists, refusing to provide substance, general misconduct, refusing to engage in any sort of peer review process, refusing to correct when detected, etc etc ....

Would you call that criminally inclined?

Or is that the group you actually refer to? I'm asking because it sort of sounds plausible ....



What should be done about these crackpots, justintime, bring charges against them?
 
Last edited:
65% of the 2000 studied papers were found to be fraudulent. I did not say the scientists were convicted or jailed.

You did up-thread. And this argument demonstrats the depths of your dishonesty. You expect us to ignore the fact that this is 65% of less than 1% of 1% of the papers published in one particular field.

This is like saying that because 65% of teachers in one school that engaged in grade inflation did it because the student was the child of an administrator, therefore 65% of all teachers are frauds. It makes no sense, is unsupported by the data, and at this point is dishonest enough to call fraud in its own right.
 
Originally Posted by justintime View Post
65% of the 2000 studied papers were found to be fraudulent. I did not say the scientists were convicted or jailed. I said "If 65% of violators were convicted in any profession, it would be considered a disaster."

eg. If 65% of 2000 teachers charged with altering tests scores were found guilty, it would be considered a disaster.

I'll explain it again. You are so desperate to find reasons to hate scientists that you assume that all 2000 papers were "violators". The whole point is that 65% of them were violators. The other 35% were papers withdrawn for entirely different reasons - we discovered we made a mistake, or we realized an alternative explanation for the results we found, or whatever. Retracting a paper is done for many reasons; don't equate them all with "altering test scores"!

Read the post again. If 65% of violators are charged in any profession and I gave an example of teachers. That is a very high percent which is more than the percent not charged.

Another example. If the courts had a 65% success rate in convictions the jails would be packed.
 
If 65% of violators are charged in any profession and I gave an example of teachers. That is a very high percent which is more than the percent not charged.

There's no way to know this. 65% could mean 13 people--hardly a horrific breakdown of a profession that includes a few hundred thousand folks.

Percentages are not absolute numbers, and cannot be treated as such the way you are trying to use them.
 
... If 65% of 2000 teachers charged with altering tests scores were found guilty, ...
Actually, I have to agree with this, because it would indicate that 35% of those teachers are falsly accused. That's an outrageously high rate of baseless accusations.

It depends: see the brackets

... If (65% of 2000 teachers) charged with altering tests scores were found guilty, ...
or:
... If 65% (of 2000 teachers charged) with altering tests scores were found guilty, ...

justintime doesn't like to be unambiguous.
 
Last edited:
Another bragging point for science fraud defenders (only 65% of retracted papers are found to be fraudulent). If 65% of violators were convicted in any profession, it would be considered a disaster.
Sorry, justintime, but that statement is a bragging point for the failure of basic logic.
"65% of retracted papers being fraudulent" does not mean that 65% of all papers are fraudulent papers.

Maybe you still need to comprehend the basic fact pointed out in my 0.0096% is a tiny percentage justintime post on 19th December 2013.

You may have forgotten everything so here is the article again:
Misconduct accounts for the majority of retracted scientific publications
The authors looked at about 25 million PubMed records.
The authors did a "comprehensive search of the PubMed database in May 2012"which "identified 2,047 retracted articles".
Simple math will tell you, justintime, that the % of retracted articles is about 0.008%.

65% of the retracted papers were retracted because of misconduct (not fraud).
67.4% of retractions were attributable to misconduct, including fraud or suspected fraud (43.4%), duplicate publication (14.2%), and plagiarism (9.8%).
43.4% of the retracted papers were retracted because of fraud or suspected fraud.

Thus the % of fraudulent retracted papers in the data (every paper in PubMed) is 0.004% not 65% :jaw-dropp!

ETA: To make it clearer - the 65% figure refers to retracted papers where 100% of the violators were "convicted"!
 
Last edited:
Read the post again. If 65% of violators are charged in any profession and I gave an example of teachers. That is a very high percent which is more than the percent not charged.

Another example. If the courts had a 65% success rate in convictions the jails would be packed.

You're making very little sense. Just look at how everybody in this thread thought you were saying something different when you called it a disaster - some thought you were saying it was too high, others thought you were saying it was too low! You play so fast and loose with the numbers that we have no idea what you're trying to say anymore!

Let's go back to basics. We have 2000 papers here that were retracted for one reason or another. To what do you compare this? To the number of people who "violated"? Violated what? If they violated something, wouldn't you want a 100% conviction rate? Why is a lower conviction rate considered a good thing?

And again, we're not picking 2000 papers at random. We're picking 2000 papers that were retracted. These are papers that are known to have some flaw in them! Of course the percent of those with deliberate flaws is going to be high!

I'll note that Israeli courts have something like a 97% conviction rate. This is because the Israeli police and prosecutors are so inept they never bring anything to court unless they're completely sure, and will desperately grab at any chance for a plea bargain.

--------

Anyway, nothing here changes the fact that the vast, vast majority of science is not part of those 2000 retracted papers. Most of science is not fraudulent, and it is ridiculous for you to claim that it is, given that you are currently reading the words I'm typing through computers that depend on that very science to work properly, and wouldn't work at all if you were right.
 
The issue here is the peer-review process is flawed, corrupt and scientific fraud is increasing exponentially.
No, justintime, the issues here are
1. Everyone knows that the peer-review process is flawed. We also know that it is the best system that we have, it works and is being continuously improved.

2. You have an unsupported, vague assertion that the peer-review process is "corrupt".

3. You have an unsupported assertion that scientific fraud is increasing exponentially (which has a specific meaning in science).
The trend in figure 1B does not look linear. It may or may not be exponential.

4. You are ignoring the simple fact that detected scientific fraud is a tiny fraction of all papers.
Tenfold increase in scientific research papers retracted for fraud
In addition, the long-term trend for misconduct was on the up: in 1976 there were only three retractions for misconduct out of 309,800 papers (0.00097%) whereas there were 83 retractions for misconduct out of 867,700 papers at a recent peak in 2007 (0.0096%).
Misconduct includes duplicate publication and plagiarism as well as fraud or suspected fraud.
 
Sorry, justintime, but that statement is a bragging point for the failure of basic logic.
"65% of retracted papers being fraudulent" does not mean that 65% of all papers are fraudulent papers.

Maybe you still need to comprehend the basic fact pointed out in my 0.0096% is a tiny percentage justintime post on 19th December 2013.

You may have forgotten everything so here is the article again:
Misconduct accounts for the majority of retracted scientific publications
The authors looked at about 25 million PubMed records.
The authors did a "comprehensive search of the PubMed database in May 2012"which "identified 2,047 retracted articles".
Simple math will tell you, justintime, that the % of retracted articles is about 0.008%.

65% of the retracted papers were retracted because of misconduct (not fraud).

43.4% of the retracted papers were retracted because of fraud or suspected fraud.

Thus the % of fraudulent retracted papers in the data (every paper in PubMed) is 0.004% not 65% :jaw-dropp!

The issue here is scientific fraud and the article looked at 2047 retracted papers and found fraud. It might have been the increasing high number of retractions in recent years that propelled the study, shockingly science fraud was found to be very common. 65% of the studied papers were found fraudulent.

Attention is brought to the science fraud in research papers and not to the number of research papers published over time because fraud is very disturbing in science especially when science is thought to be self-correcting. Public perception has changed and scientists are no longer held in high esteem. Even the US congress calls science 'quackery'.

There are millions of research articles published and most are of little interest to the general public. But the ones retracted have caught the imagination of the public because the general public is fascinated with criminal elements and now they can appreciate criminal scientists and science albeit for the wrong reasons.
 
If 65% of 2000 teachers charged with altering tests scores were found guilty, it would be considered a disaster.
That example has nothing to do with the paper, justintime. The 2047 papers were retracted. Thus 100% of the authors were "found guilty" of various "charges" with 43.4% of fraud or suspected fraud.

Using your language, justintime:
A retracted paper is the court of the peer-review process (which does not stop at publication) determining that that authors are guilty.
The court of the peer-review process charges every author of every paper with misconduct (including fraud). The PubMed data shows that this courts finds a tiny percentage of authors guilty.
 
That example has nothing to do with the paper, justintime. The 2047 papers were retracted. Thus 100% of the authors were "found guilty" of various "charges" with 43.4% of fraud or suspected fraud.

Using your language, justintime:
A retracted paper is the court of the peer-review process (which does not stop at publication) determining that that authors are guilty.
The court of the peer-review process charges every author of every paper with misconduct (including fraud). The PubMed data shows that this courts finds a tiny percentage of authors guilty.

65% of 2000 studied papers were found fraudulent. That is not a tiny percentage or the article would have said so.
 
The issue here is scientific fraud and the article looked at 2047 retracted papers and found fraud.
...snipped the usual irrelevant stuff...
We all can read and know this - you do not have to repeat the obvious, justintime :).
We have been guilty though of accepting your incorrect statement that "65% of the studied papers were found fraudulent". The actual figure is 43.4% of the retracted papers.

The fact remains that 0.0096% is a tiny percentage justintime posted 19th December 2013.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom