science fraud is common place

65% of 2000 studied papers were found fraudulent. That is not a tiny percentage or the article would have said so.

They were looking at why articles were retracted. There are many potential reasons other than fraud for a retraction. It turns out that fraud is the most common. This does not tell us anything about the prevalence of fraud, only that there are more retractions for fraud than for the other reasons. The results of this study are only applicable to papers that have been retracted.
 
They were looking at why articles were retracted. There are many potential reasons other than fraud for a retraction. It turns out that fraud is the most common. This does not tell us anything about the prevalence of fraud, only that there are more retractions for fraud than for the other reasons. The results of this study are only applicable to papers that have been retracted.

That is why I provided a study that arrives at numbers we can apply.
How Many Scientists Fabricate and Falsify Research? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Survey Data
http://www.plosone.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pone.0005738

A pooled weighted average of 1.97% (N = 7, 95%CI: 0.86–4.45) of scientists admitted to have fabricated, falsified or modified data or results at least once –a serious form of misconduct by any standard– and up to 33.7% admitted other questionable research practices. In surveys asking about the behaviour of colleagues, admission rates were 14.12% (N = 12, 95% CI: 9.91–19.72) for falsification, and up to 72% for other questionable research practices.
 
The 2000 papers retracted found 65% of them fraudulent the balance had different levels of infractions. But that is typical in any court proceedings. Many are charge and the final convictions are much smaller. But 65% of 2000 papers studies found fraudulent is no small number by any stretch of the imagination.
The hilighted part is still making the same error as before. The 2000 papers were all retracted. That's equivalent to being found guilty. To use the court analogy those 2000 were not merely tried, they were convicted. And of those 2000 who were convicted, 1300 had been convicted of a specific crime (fraud, in this case).

You're not looking at a sampling of the entire population. You're also not looking at a sampling of the population that was brought to court. You're looking at a sampling of the population that was brought to court and found guilty. That is where your 2000 figure comes from.
 
The hilighted part is still making the same error as before. The 2000 papers were all retracted. That's equivalent to being found guilty. To use the court analogy those 2000 were not merely tried, they were convicted. And of those 2000 who were convicted, 1300 had been convicted of a specific crime (fraud, in this case).

You're not looking at a sampling of the entire population. You're also not looking at a sampling of the population that was brought to court. You're looking at a sampling of the population that was brought to court and found guilty. That is where your 2000 figure comes from.

Whatever analogy you want to use is fine so long at it arrives at the same numbers. 65% of the 2000 studies were found fraudulent.
 
Justintime, your main complaint seems to be that most fraud doesn't get caught by peer review (unlike those 1300 papers you brought up). How, in your opinion, would we be able to tell if peer review were to catch the majority of frauds? Bear in mind that we can never be certain that all frauds have been caught due to the very nature of the beast. So are there any conditions where you would say "yes, science is doing a good job of catching the liars within its ranks"?
 
Whatever analogy you want to use is fine so long at it arrives at the same numbers. 65% of the 2000 studies were found fraudulent.
Arriving at the same numbers isn't good enough. The context for those numbers also needs to be analagous. That was my whole point. Your analogy showed a flawed understanding of the numbers (and the same goes for just about everything else you've said about them).

Why do you think people keep emphasizing that those 2000 studies were retracted? We're not doing it to annoy you. We're doing it because that fact is important, and it completely changes the meaning of that statistic.

ETA: As Dinwar said earlier, there aren't that many reasons to retract a scientific paper aside from fraud. Why, then, should we be concerned that a lot of retracted papers were retracted due to fraud? Papers that aren't fraudulent have little reason to be retracted, so most of those would not be included in any study of retracted papers.
 
Last edited:
Whatever analogy you want to use is fine so long at it arrives at the same numbers. 65% of the 2000 studies were found fraudulent.

Like I said before, this is the equivalent of saying that because some percent of people in prison are guilty of rape, rape is rampant in the USA and we should treat everyone we meet as a rapist.

It's stupid. There's no other word for it. You are willfully and intentionally ignoring the facts of the situation and willfully and intentionally avoiding learning anything about it.
 
Like I said before, this is the equivalent of saying that because some percent of people in prison are guilty of rape, rape is rampant in the USA and we should treat everyone we meet as a rapist.

It's stupid. There's no other word for it. You are willfully and intentionally ignoring the facts of the situation and willfully and intentionally avoiding learning anything about it.

If justintime were to do a formal study and formally published a paper with the same content as can be seen from him here, it would be fraud.
 
I'd just like to add that plagiarism, while a problem of scientific integrity, is not itself something that affects the conclusions. If I were to, say, copy Einstein's GR paper and present it as my own, modern astrophysics would not be affected in the slightest. It's not good, but from the POV of the general public, it shouldn't really affect their confidence in the findings.
 
Yes 'perhaps' is speculative because the number could be much higher.

If pigs had wings, perhaps they could fly, which means they may be able to go into space, and I suspect they could even travel through time. There is also speculation that they can punch through to other realities and, I guess, alter the laws of physics and, perchance, create new universes.
 
And therefore you find it reasonable to conclude that 200% of science is fraudulent. Gotcha.

And maybe up to 2000% have lesser violations that go undetected.

At this point I suspect that each and every word in every science paper ever published or even planned is a fraud in and of itself.

**** science !
 
Try to figure this out. Engineers and scientists make up less than 5% of the work force.

If you separate engineers from scientists. You can say scientists make up 2.5% of the work force. Why does such a small group of people have so much to say about everything? That is why they publish millions of theories to suck up all the research funding to justify their existence.

Now that it has come to light not only do scientists waste research funding on useless studies, they are also engaging in fraud. You cannot top fraudulent useless research. At the very least scientists should show some integrity in their work.

So what does it say about skeptics who are defending such fraudulent practices in the scientific community?

The scientific method and peer-review are processes introduced to make science self-correcting with some oversight. When 2% of scientists admit to fraud and of the 2000 papers studied 65% turn out to be fraudulent. The scientific community must be promoting a culture of deceit.

We don't see 2% of the scientists who admit to committing fraud charged with criminal behavior nor is action taken against reports that scientists claim they know of another 14% of scientists involved in fraud but go undetected.

There are several books written about the culture of deceit withing the scientific community. In 'Betrayers of the truth' Broad and Wade speculate for every major fraud committed by scientists a 100 goes undetected.

If 65% of studied papers turn out fraudulent what would the number of undetected fraudulent papers amount to? 65% x 100 = too many.
 
I'd just like to add that plagiarism, while a problem of scientific integrity, is not itself something that affects the conclusions.

It's often not even that--plagiarism is a bit of a loose term, and often acts that are technically plagiarism are really good-faith efforts to give credit where credit is due.

http://www.uwgb.edu/dutchs/PSEUDOSC/PlagShame.HTM

Here's a brief discussion of the topic from a scientist's perspective.

Belz... said:
At this point I suspect that each and every word in every science paper ever published or even planned is a fraud in and of itself.
Sadly, justimtime is one of those people who are impossible to parody. He argued in another thread that the entirety of paleontolgoy--the whole bloody science--was fraudulant.

I call this the South Park Test: If merely quoting someone's position is sufficient to mock it, that position is likely untennable.
 
If 65% of studied papers turn out fraudulent what would the number of undetected fraudulent papers amount to? 65% x 100 = too many.

Yet again you are dishonestly attempting to argue that since 65% of RETRACTED papers contained fraud, 65% of PUBLISHED papers should be assumed to be fraudulant. This is profoundly dishonest at this point in the discussion--even the 65% number is nothing more than a lie.
 
Isn't it ironic that in your rant against a claimed magnitude of fraud in science, you yourself display conduct which, if formalized, could constitute fraud ....

Could that be the real meaning of your statement that:
... Science attracts the criminally inclined ...
...... justintime?

E.T.A.: What the heart thinks, the mouth speaks?
 
Last edited:
It is not a contradiction. A small percentage of fraud is caught by the oversight bodies like the Research Integrity Office. But many more go undetected

How would you know it goes undetected ? How would you know there is much more fraud that gets caught ? Aside from "perhaps", that is ?

Science attracts the criminally inclined

What ? Do you have any evidence for this vile accusation ?

If 65% of 2000 teachers charged with altering tests scores were found guilty, it would be considered a disaster.

Yeah but that's not what we're talking about here. I find it hard to believe that you still don't understand this after it's been pointed out to you.

Attention is brought to the science fraud in research papers and not to the number of research papers published over time because fraud is very disturbing in science especially when science is thought to be self-correcting.

It IS self-correcting. That's why they were retracted.

65% of 2000 studied papers were found fraudulent. That is not a tiny percentage or the article would have said so.

Let's quote Reality Check again:

Reality Check said:
Thus the % of fraudulent retracted papers in the data (every paper in PubMed) is 0.004% not 65%

The 2000 papers were checked BECAUSE they had something wrong with them. The other millions of papers did NOT. 65% is meaningless because it tells you NOTHING about the papers outside of those 2000 who were KNOWN to have problems.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom