science fraud is common place

Here is a better example.

The tobacco company is charged with misleading the public. After the preliminary investigations 2000 are officially charge for being directly involved in the coverup. The final verdict, out of the 2000 charged 65% are convicted or 1300 out of the 2000. This high number/percentage would be considered a disaster in any company/profession/institution.

Why ? There are 25 million workers, and only 1300 were convicted for fraud. That's rather low.

The 2000 papers retracted found 65% of them fraudulent the balance had different levels of infractions. But that is typical in any court proceedings. Many are charge and the final convictions are much smaller. But 65% of 2000 papers studies found fraudulent is no small number by any stretch of the imagination.

It is when compared to 25 million.

65% of the 2000 studies were found fraudulent.

Out of 25 million.

If 65% of studied papers turn out fraudulent what would the number of undetected fraudulent papers amount to? 65% x 100 = too many.

25 million.
 
Try to figure this out. Engineers and scientists make up less than 5% of the work force.

If you separate engineers from scientists. You can say scientists make up 2.5% of the work force.
Only if there are equal numbers of scientists and engineers.

Why does such a small group of people have so much to say about everything?
Because it's their job.

Now that it has come to light not only do scientists waste research funding on useless studies, they are also engaging in fraud.
Compositional fallacy. Or, as it's called in Straight and Crooked Thinking, the "All and Some" fallacy. Some scientists engage in fraud (and you don't even know how many that is--you don't even have a rough estimate); however you're stating it as though all scientists are engaging in fraud.

Your statement is fraudulent.

You cannot top fraudulent useless research. At the very least scientists should show some integrity in their work.
See above. Pretending that the existence of frauds means no scientist shows integrity is an act of fraud on your part.

So what does it say about skeptics who are defending such fraudulent practices in the scientific community?
No one here has done , making this another fraudulent claim on your part.

When 2% of scientists admit to fraud
Unless every single scientist in the world was polled, this is an inaccurate (one might even say fraudulent) characterization of the data.

and of the 2000 papers studied 65% turn out to be fraudulent. The scientific community must be promoting a culture of deceit.
That's an idiotic conclusion to draw. The scientific community decided those papers needed to be retracted--that's the exact opposite of promoting a culture of deceit. Seeing as this has been pointed out to you previously I can only conclude that this is more fraud on your part.

We don't see 2% of the scientists who admit to committing fraud charged with criminal behavior nor is action taken against reports that scientists claim they know of another 14% of scientists involved in fraud but go undetected.
Given your general understanding of the topic I don't believe that you'd be aware of such events happening, so your lack of knowledge of them means nothing.

There are several books written about the culture of deceit withing the scientific community.
There are also several books written about a land ruled by a talking lion.

In 'Betrayers of the truth' Broad and Wade speculate for every major fraud committed by scientists a 100 goes undetected.
And everyone except you is actually paying attention to what those words mean, particularly the one in yellow.

If 65% of studied papers turn out fraudulent what would the number of undetected fraudulent papers amount to? 65% x 100 = too many.
See, you're ignoring what that Broad and Wade quote actually says. You want to pretend that it says there are 100 undetected frauds for every detected one, but that isn't what it says. So this is even more fraud.

Your argument is built on fraud. Speck, plank; pot, kettle; glass house, stones.
 
Perhaps a conspiracy enthousiast, one which will latch onto anything?

My bet is psuedo-science.

Most likely someone who "overturned" relativity and/or quantum mechanics in their own mind, then got their theory ripped to shreds by real scientists. In the process, discovering that real science takes work and knowledge, math and logic, and many other things that they hadn't applied (the mantra "why not use common sense" is often heard in ths type).

So now, the alternative is to tear science down, so then he can say see, here's my theory that they rejected, look how much smarter I am!

Either that, or a homeopath.
 
With:
It is called critical thinking or scientific skepticism.....literally.

justintime probably purports to apply critical thinking to his purported skepticism of science.
Critical thinking it certainly isn't. It appears more like fraudulent thinking.
 
My bet is psuedo-science.

Most likely someone who "overturned" relativity and/or quantum mechanics in their own mind, then got their theory ripped to shreds by real scientists. In the process, discovering that real science takes work and knowledge, math and logic, and many other things that they hadn't applied (the mantra "why not use common sense" is often heard in ths type).

So now, the alternative is to tear science down, so then he can say see, here's my theory that they rejected, look how much smarter I am!

Either that, or a homeopath.

I reiterate: Denialism. JiT is the poster child.

From the rationalwiki page:
Diethelm and McKee have identified five characteristics of denialists:[9]
The identification of perceived conspiracies. This includes belief of corrupted peer review and inversionism (i.e., attributing some of one's own characteristics and motivations to others).[10]
The use of fake experts (often with the smearing of real experts).
Selecting or cherry picking sources: picking the weakest papers or only ones that are contrary. Particularly worrisome is looking at only a single study, especially in medicine, as one study rarely conclusively proves something.[11] Others note that this includes anecdotal evidence[2] and quote mining.[12]
Demanding impossible standards for research.
Use of fallacy, including misrepresentation and false analogy.[13] Informally, this can include a witch's brew of half-truths and sob stories.[14] and/or spin to try to force the public to ignore an important issue.

Skeptics also ask questions, but a big difference between skeptics and denialists is that skeptics listen to answers and regard evidence as paramount. Denialists tend to see the piles of evidence against their claim, and see a conspiracy theory to perpetuate a hoax. But skeptics accept good evidence. Skeptics have a lot of respect for science, and denialists are usually out to undermine scientists working in the field where they have an agenda. Denialists will wear the costume of scientific thinking, but they usually show a piss-poor understanding how ... the accumulation of studies and data work. (For instance, they promote the idea that if one study can be found to be flawed, this brings down the whole theory, as if the other hundreds of studies don’t count.)
 

Belz arrived at 25 million.

Given such high numbers, the authors of 'Betrayers of truth' Broad and Wade should not have called it a speculation. They should have labeled it a prediction.

I wonder if most of the retracted fraudulent peer-reviewed papers end up in the public domain because they are worthless and therefore made available for free. That might explain why the general public are so misinformed....they have been citing fraudulent discredited scientific papers freely available on the internet especially on skeptic forums where providing citations is the rule.
 
justintime said:
Belz arrived at 25 million.
Lie. 25 million is the number of published papers in the venue in that study you keep referencing. Of that 25 millino, 2,000 or so were retracted. Of those 2,000 or so, 45% or so were retracted due to fraud.

If you can't tell the difference between a percentage and an absolute value, you have no business talking about science. Go back to the fourth grade.

I wonder if most of the retracted fraudulent peer-reviewed papers end up in the public domain because they are worthless and therefore made available for free.
No. Any peer-reviewed paper remains property of hte journal that published it. This caused some trouble with Academia.edu a short while ago. Retraction doesn't impact that at all; it merely means that the paper is recognized as being inadmissable to scientific discourse and should not be cited.

It would be kinda fun to find out how often retracted papers are cited post-retraction (ie, exclude citations that occur prior to retraction, since until it's retracted it's fair game). But that in no way strengthens JiT's position; it's merely a curiosity of mine piqued by the thread.

I'd like to point out to any lurkers still on the fence about JiT's dishonesty that JiT is now attempting to get us to accept that papers merely being in the public domain as evidence that they are fraudulent. And in fact he's going further--he's trying to sneek in the idea that papers publicly available are by definition fraudulant. That means that every publication from, say Paleontologia Electronica (a reputable paleontology journal that's open to the public and offers papers for free) is, by JiT's "logic", defined as fraudulant--regardless of the quality of the paper, and regardless of the existence of any proof of fraud in the paper. There is no way to make that mistake honestly.
 
25,000,000%!

Help me sort this out. I like your math.

65% of 2000 papers studied were found fraudulent. But for every major fraud exposed a 100 goes undetected. So the percent of fraud actually occurring you calculated was 6,500%

According to Belz 25million papers were published. Applying your math what would 6,500% of 25 million be? I get such an outrageous number it has to be a prediction that Broad and Wade were making. Those fraudulent papers have yet to be published and even a 10 fold increase in fraud will take more than a decade to meet that number.

Now according to another study 2% of scientists admit to fraud. But when scientists are asked about their colleagues the admission number jumped to 14% suspected of committing fraud. Applying your math for every fraud a 100 goes undetected. What percent of scientist are actually committing fraud.

jt512 offered his math. OMG! 200% of science is fraudulent!

Shouldn't it be 14% x 100 OMG! 1,400% of science is fraudulent! :jaw-dropp
 
Last edited:
65% of 2000 papers studied were found fraudulent. But for every major fraud exposed a 100 goes undetected. So the percent of fraud actually occurring you calculated was 6,500%
No, for every fraud exposed someone speculated that a 100 might go undetected. Continuing to state this figure as a fact is nothing short of fraud at this point.

And you do realize that the 6500% was a joke, right? Because that's an impossible percentage? Tell me you at least know that much about percentages.

According to Belz 25million papers were published. Applying your math what would 6,500% of 25 million be?
Nothing, because you can't have 6500%.

I get such an outrageous number it has to be a prediction that Broad and Wade were making.
How is it a prediction? You've just restated their speculation, but in longer form. You haven't shown that there are that many frauds. You've just shown (or tried to show, using terrible math) how many frauds there would be if their speculation were correct.

Now according to another study 2% of scientists admit to fraud.
Did every scientist participate in the study? No? Then at best 2% of those who participated admitted to fraud. So what percentage of scientists participated in the study?

But when scientists are asked about their colleagues the admission number jumped to 14% suspected of committing fraud.
This has the same problems as the previous statement, plus the problem of "suspected" not equating to guilt. You can wrongly suspect someone of fraud.

Applying your math for every fraud a 100 goes undetected.
No, that's YOUR math. Temporalillusion applied YOUR math to get that result, in order to show how stupid your argument is (because you cannpt have 6500%).

What percent of scientist are actually committing fraud.
I seem to recall asking you this. I don't recall getting an answer.

jt512 offered his math. OMG! 200% of science is fraudulent!

Shouldn't it be 14% x 100 OMG! 1,400% of science is fraudulent! :jaw-dropp
No. Learn math.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom