science fraud is common place

The red and blue bits contradict each other. How can we know what the frequencies of undetected misconduct are?

It is not a contradiction. A small percentage of fraud is caught by the oversight bodies like the Research Integrity Office. But many more go undetected because of the flawed peer-review process and scientists turning a blind eye to defend their profession from embarrassment.
 
Oh, I read it. However, I understand the issues with such surveys, unlike you. They're little more than anecdotes.

And I note that you continue to ignore the fact that your 1 in 100 or 1 in 10 numbers or the like are pure fiction; that other data contradicts your arguments; and that a rigorous methodology has been proposed to determine rates of undetected fraud. You want to play make-believe, not actually engage in a serious discussion.

I also note that you continue to ignore phrases like "...it is likely...", which prove that the statements following are nothing but fantasy with no rigorous data to support them. After all, if the author had the data, why not provide it? Answer: Because they don't have the data to support it.

You should check my source before you dismiss the survey. http://www.plosone.org/static/information

"PLOS ONE (eISSN-1932-6203) is an international, peer-reviewed, open-access, online publication. PLOS ONE welcomes reports on primary research from any scientific discipline. It provides:

Open-access—freely accessible online, authors retain copyright
Fast publication times
Peer review by expert, practicing researchers
Post-publication tools to indicate quality and impact
Community-based dialogue on articles
Worldwide media coverage

PLOS ONE is published by PLOS, a nonprofit organization. "
 
You should check my source before you dismiss the survey. http://www.plosone.org/static/information

"PLOS ONE (eISSN-1932-6203) is an international, peer-reviewed, open-access, online publication. PLOS ONE welcomes reports on primary research from any scientific discipline. It provides:

Open-access—freely accessible online, authors retain copyright
Fast publication times
Peer review by expert, practicing researchers
Post-publication tools to indicate quality and impact
Community-based dialogue on articles
Worldwide media coverage

PLOS ONE is published by PLOS, a nonprofit organization. "

The problem from my perspective, having looked at the cited article, isn't with the article, it is with your mangled interpretation of what the authors of the article are actually saying within the contextual focus of their study, its parameters, and the data collected.

by analogy:

They are talking about a batch lemons that were examined from one particular orchard, and you are trying to claim that this isn't just as bad as they have found, but that it is 100x worse and doesn't just apply to all lemons, but that it applies to all fruit in general and is probably much worse than even you imagine.
 
The problem from my perspective, having looked at the cited article, isn't with the article, it is with your mangled interpretation of what the authors of the article are actually saying [...]

Others have observed the same. It appears to be deliberate, and based on the hope that anyone who reads the links will understand it even less well than himself.
 
It is not a contradiction. A small percentage of fraud is caught by the oversight bodies like the Research Integrity Office. But many more go undetected because of the flawed peer-review process and scientists turning a blind eye to defend their profession from embarrassment.
How can you know that it's MANY more when you don't know the number of undetected frauds? It could be a thousand more, or it could be only 100. We haven't detected them, so we don't know if there are many or a few (there are methods to get a better estimate, as Dinwar has said, but nobody has done so).
 
Read the article again. It is exactly as I quoted it.
Read the article linked to from that article, justintime:
Fraud Breeds Retractions
An analysis of retractions dating back to 1977 shows that most papers are retracted due to misconduct.

Scientific misconduct contributes to more retractions than previously realized, according to a new analysis published today (October 1) in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Using retractions indexed in Pubmed, researchers found that fabrication, falsification, and duplication led to more retractions than error or plagiarism.
It is exactly as the basic English states - a study of retracted papers that shows that 65% of retracted papers were retracted due to misconduct.
How many retracted papers were studied ? 2000
What percentage were retracted? 100%
What percentage were retracted due to "poor ethical judgment"? 65%

Thus: more than 65 percent of the 2,000 or so retracted papers studied were retracted because of poor ethical judgment.
 
Read the article linked to from that article, justintime:
Fraud Breeds Retractions

It is exactly as the basic English states - a study of retracted papers that shows that 65% of retracted papers were retracted due to misconduct.
How many retracted papers were studied ? 2000
What percentage were retracted? 100%
What percentage were retracted due to "poor ethical judgment"? 65%

Thus: more than 65 percent of the 2,000 or so retracted papers studied were retracted because of poor ethical judgment.


Justintime has continually demonstrated he either purposefully or ignorantly doesn't understand basic English and mathematics.
 
Justintime has continually demonstrated he either purposefully or ignorantly doesn't understand basic English and mathematics.

Another bragging point for science fraud defenders (only 65% of retracted papers are found to be fraudulent). If 65% of violators were convicted in any profession, it would be considered a disaster.

It is a failure of the scientific method, peer-review or Office of Research Integrity? Science attracts the criminally inclined because the chances of getting away with fraud is higher than those forced to retract and the actual frequencies of misconduct are higher, but go willfully undetected.
 
... science fraud defenders ... convicted ...

It is a failure of the scientific method, peer-review or Office of Research Integrity? Science attracts the criminally inclined because the chances of getting away with fraud is higher than those forced to retract and the actual frequencies of misconduct are higher, but go willfully undetected.
Hilite by Daylightstar
How about all the crackpots who try to force their unsubstantiated idea onto other people, misquoting or misassigning data, falsely stating that supporting data exists, refusing to provide substance, general misconduct, refusing to engage in any sort of peer review process, refusing to correct when detected, etc etc ....

Would you call that criminally inclined?

Or is that the group you actually refer to? I'm asking because it sort of sounds plausible ....
 
Another bragging point for science fraud defenders (only 65% of retracted papers are found to be fraudulent). If 65% of violators were convicted in any profession, it would be considered a disaster.
Except that 65% of retracted papers aren't fraudulent. 65% of the 2000 retracted papers sampled were fraudulent. What % of all retracted papers is that 2000?

It is a failure of the scientific method, peer-review or Office of Research Integrity?
It's a failure on your part to understand the statistics.
 
You should check my source before you dismiss the survey.

Not really. The issues with surveys are sufficient by themselves to warrant dismissing them. First and foremost, they aren't measuring fraud--they're measuring rates of PERCIEVED fraud, which is a different matter all together. Surveys of this kind rapidly go downhill from there.

Another bragging point for science fraud defenders (only 65% of retracted papers are found to be fraudulent). If 65% of violators were convicted in any profession, it would be considered a disaster.
You continue to spread proven lies. It's 65% of less than 1% of 1% of papers--ie, 65% of RETRACTED papers. There's a big of a difference there. About three orders of magniguted difference, in fact.

When you place yourself in custody and put yourself on trial for the frauds you have committed in this thread you get to talk about punishing frauds. Until then, you're just ranting in an attempt to take over science.

Science attracts the criminally inclined because the chances of getting away with fraud is higher than those forced to retract and the actual frequencies of misconduct are higher, but go willfully undetected.
You quite noteably avoid any attempt to get you to actually DEMONSTRATE that science attracts frauds. This is nothing but a mere assertion on your part, in contradiction to the data thus provided. Please see your local police office and turn yourself in--you have committed fraud, and must be punished by your logic!
 
Originally Posted by justintime View Post
You should check my source before you dismiss the survey.

Dinwar wrote: Not really. The issues with surveys are sufficient by themselves to warrant dismissing them. First and foremost, they aren't measuring fraud--they're measuring rates of PERCIEVED fraud, which is a different matter all together. Surveys of this kind rapidly go downhill from there.
You clearly did not read the article. It is stated under Methods:

Only quantitative survey data assessing how many researchers have committed or observed colleagues committing scientific misconduct in the past were included in this review. Surveys asking only opinions or perceptions about the frequency of misconduct were not included.
 
You clearly did not read the article. It is stated under Methods:

The quotes you've provided are sufficient. I simply disagree with your interpretation. The reason is that if someone doesn't consider what they did to be fraud, they wouldn't report it as such--and humans are very inconsistent in applying such evaluations, meaning that what I wouldn't consider a fraud for me I might consider a fraud if you were to do it. Even if the researches asked "Did you ever do X? Did you ever see a colleague do X?" we're dealing with perception--the surveyer's perception, to be exact.

I note that you prefer a survey, the most dubious of data-gathering techniques, over actual studies of fraud in the literature. I'm guessing that this is because even you have realized that the evidence from the literature (such as it is) demolishes your arguments, and you're now struggling to find some other justification for this a priori conclusion. Regardless, this clearly IS an a priori conclusion--one you reached prior to starting your research, and your research is merely an attempt to find support for it, rather than an attempt to find the truth. This is fraud. Please head to your local police office and turn yourself in--or stop talking about prosecution.
 
Another bragging point for science fraud defenders (only 65% of retracted papers are found to be fraudulent). If 65% of violators were convicted in any profession, it would be considered a disaster.

You don't understand the meaning of that statistic. Not all retracted papers are violations. 65% of retracted papers are found to be fraudulent, which means 35% of retracted papers were retracted for some other reason (plagiarism, the honest discovery after-the-fact of a mistake, etc.). The 35% of non-fraudulent retracted papers are people who did nothing deliberately wrong. The 65% is not a conviction rate!
 
So, justintime,

... science fraud defenders ... convicted ...

It is a failure of the scientific method, peer-review or Office of Research Integrity? Science attracts the criminally inclined because the chances of getting away with fraud is higher than those forced to retract and the actual frequencies of misconduct are higher, but go willfully undetected.
Hilite by Daylightstar
How about all the crackpots who try to force their unsubstantiated idea onto other people, misquoting or misassigning data, falsely stating that supporting data exists, refusing to provide substance, general misconduct, refusing to engage in any sort of peer review process, refusing to correct when detected, etc etc ....

Would you call that criminally inclined?

Or is that the group you actually refer to? I'm asking because it sort of sounds plausible ....


....... how about it?
 
Originally Posted by justintime View Post
Another bragging point for science fraud defenders (only 65% of retracted papers are found to be fraudulent). If 65% of violators were convicted in any profession, it would be considered a disaster.

You don't understand the meaning of that statistic. Not all retracted papers are violations. 65% of retracted papers are found to be fraudulent, which means 35% of retracted papers were retracted for some other reason (plagiarism, the honest discovery after-the-fact of a mistake, etc.). The 35% of non-fraudulent retracted papers are people who did nothing deliberately wrong. The 65% is not a conviction rate!

65% of the 2000 studied papers were found to be fraudulent. I did not say the scientists were convicted or jailed. I said "If 65% of violators were convicted in any profession, it would be considered a disaster."

eg. If 65% of 2000 teachers charged with altering tests scores were found guilty, it would be considered a disaster.
 
65% of the 2000 studied papers were found to be fraudulent. I did not say the scientists were convicted or jailed. I said "If 65% of violators were convicted in any profession, it would be considered a disaster."

eg. If 65% of 2000 teachers charged with altering tests scores were found guilty, it would be considered a disaster.
That would depend on how many total teachers had been charged with the task, and on whether it was reasonable to assume that the 65% figure would hold true across the board. In this case the assumption is not reasonable, as has been explained previously.
 
Originally Posted by Daylightstar View Post
Originally Posted by justintime View Post
... science fraud defenders ... convicted ...

It is a failure of the scientific method, peer-review or Office of Research Integrity? Science attracts the criminally inclined because the chances of getting away with fraud is higher than those forced to retract and the actual frequencies of misconduct are higher, but go willfully undetected.
Hilite by Daylightstar

Originally Posted by Daylightstar View Post
How about all the crackpots who try to force their unsubstantiated idea onto other people, misquoting or misassigning data, falsely stating that supporting data exists, refusing to provide substance, general misconduct, refusing to engage in any sort of peer review process, refusing to correct when detected, etc etc ....

Would you call that criminally inclined?

Or is that the group you actually refer to? I'm asking because it sort of sounds plausible ....

....... how about it?

The issue here is the peer-review process is flawed, corrupt and scientific fraud is increasing exponentially. Even the research integrity oversight commissions are complacent/complicit in this science fraud which the public is discovering is quite common.

If we had to retroactively bring charges I am sure a lot of the past fraudulent science practices would also be exposed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom