Yerushalmi
Scholar
- Joined
- Jan 2, 2014
- Messages
- 104
Where did you address my point??
"In Betrayers of the Truth, Broad and Wade speculate that for every major of case of fraud that comes to light, perhaps 100 go undetected, and that for each major case, another 1000 lesser violations are committed." (url removed from quote because it won't let me post it)
SO if only 1% of science fraud gets exposed how many can we extrapolate goes undetected....you do the math.
I can't believe that this hasn't yet been commented upon.
"For every major case of fraud that comes to light, perhaps 100 go undetected." Therefore, yes, 1% of science fraud gets exposed. That's a tautology. If only 1 in 100 cases of science fraud are noticed, then 1% are noticed.
So I'll do the math, like you asked. If 1% of science fraud gets exposed, 99% of science fraud goes undetected. Fine. That's a tautology.
Now, what percent of science is science fraud? The category of "science" appears nowhere in this analysis. You can draw absolutely no conclusions about it! All you're saying is how much science fraud is detected - but the percent of science that is fraud can be anywhere from 100% to 0.000000000000(...)000000000000000001%!
