science fraud is common place

The brightest minds are recruited by financial institution and engineering conglomerates where there are tangible results and rewards for the individual careers. Only third and fourth tier candidates apply for science.
"Apply for science"? :confused:
 
Only a very small percentage of science that is taught has any real practical value. The rest is all esoteric high flung dung and some are even retractable......imagine that!!!!

You really do have absolutely no idea what you're talking about.
 
I don't think it's the people, but the system, wich makes them corrupt.
The hard competition, the need for publication in journals every month, the reputation of the university, the money, coming from companies or politicians with their own intrests, they want to keep their title, keep their job, keep their reputation, make careers etc.

Knowledge must only be 'because of wanting to know'. And that's it. No conflict with other intrests: just the enterprise of science, because of the beauty of this interprise.
No pressure, no deadlines, no conlfict of intrests only: silent thinking and studying and testing, and maybe, when we are lucky: discovering something new. But that's about 'having luck'.


Diederick Stapel, a scientist, said it: the system in universities is not good for scientists: the pressure is too high and people make mistakes: they invent data, to make it look nice for publication. They don't like critical thinkers (against current scientific hypothesis)
That's not good for society and not good at all for science.

The big problem is: scientists are sometimes only long goal driven. And it's the only goal they have. So they don't want to hear: it's wrong. Mr. Stapel states that this is a problem.
In my town school teachers and university professors discovered the profitability of real estate and more and more of them invested their money in rental property, usually registered on the wife or children's name. So here is now this prof who demands the assistance of T.A.s, because he is too busy managing the apartment building he just bought.
 
The objective/goal is to expose science for what it is not and and to see through it without rose-colored glasses for what it is.

Let us focus on this. What do you want to expose science as? What is it you want us to agree that science is?
 
So, the top 10 science hoaxes. I was sort of expecting these to be modern examples of fraud, perpetrated by scientists - and fooling other scientists. Some of them aren't very modern. Few of them involve scientists.

1. An amateur archaeologist fooled a paleontologist 100 years ago. The hoax was discovered by scientists 60 years ago.
2. From 1999, so this one is at least recent. A magazine was fooled (by a farmer cementing bits of fossil together), and scientists demonstrated that the 'discovery' was a fake. By February 2000, the magazine had begun an investigation and in 2002 there were papers published that identified the true origin of parts of the fossil.
3. El Chupacabra. Wait, what? How is this a science hoax?
4. Someone apparently convinced 18th century doctors they'd given birth to rabbits. I'm not sure that the credulity of quacks in the 1700s has much relevance to modern science.
5. Barnum's mermaid. A 19th century showman attracted customers by means of a hoax. Not really "science fraud" is it?
6. The fake chess-playing machine from the 18th century, The Turk. More a magician's trick than a science fraud, imho.
7. 1990s. A cameraman pretended to have footage of an alien autopsy and Fox decided to broadcast some of the faked footage. Again - how is this "science fraud"?
8. 1995. A comedy show successfully trolls an MP. Science fraud? Er, no. Satire from comedians and gullibility from politicians.
9. Someone fooled the media into thinking there was a study that predicted blondes would 'become extinct'. 2002-2006
10. 1956. "...actually a satire of everyday American life" Not a hoax. Satire. There is a difference.

Thus, we have an exposure of justintime's empty claims, which are devoid of logic and promulgated in ignorance.
What is his real agenda?
The success of Darwinism was accompanied by a decline in scientific integrity."
The Descent of Man was all the excuse the scientific community needed to cloud the boundaries between true science and deception.

Conflicts Between Darwin and Paleontology
http://www.veritas-ucsb.org/library/.../stasis/2.html
So, it appears we are dealing with just another garden variety believer in creationism, a field which is as patently dishonest as any human endeavor.

As for Maartenn, the tread, "Maartenn100 theories of physics." tells us all we need to know about his version of crackpottery.
Bottom line: None of those people participating here and arguing that "science fraud is common place (sic)" have enough knowledge and understanding of the subject to have an opinion worth discussing.
 
Thus, we have an exposure of justintime's empty claims, which are devoid of logic and promulgated in ignorance.
What is his real agenda?

So, it appears we are dealing with just another garden variety believer in creationism, a field which is as patently dishonest as any human endeavor.

As for Maartenn, the tread, "Maartenn100 theories of physics." tells us all we need to know about his version of crackpottery.
Bottom line: None of those people participating here and arguing that "science fraud is common place (sic)" have enough knowledge and understanding of the subject to have an opinion worth discussing.

Top 10 Modern Scientific Hoaxes.
http://listosaur.com/science-a-technology/top-10-modern-scientific-hoaxes.html

25 Greatest Scientific Hoaxes In History
http://list25.com/25-greatest-scientific-hoaxes-in-history/

Careless science now threatens our very survival as a species
http://www.naturalnews.com/035837_science_survival_human_race.html

Time for skeptics to take their head out of the sand and stop defending fraudulent science and the threat it poses to the survival of the human race. There was a time when science attracted the brightest and best minds. But today it attracts third and fourth tier candidates. As the saying goes. Garbage in garbage out.
 
People are aware that they only have to convince themselves that science doesn't work to believe in Woo right? They don't have to convince everyone else.
 
Originally Posted by Perpetual Student
OK, I give up! If an auto mechanic is a scientist, then science fraud is commonplace.
Hah! That is funny. And so true.
Originally Posted by Perpetual Student
Are you totally humorless?
That does seem to be a shortcoming of many.

I thought the mechanic thing was brilliant. I can think of a dozen more scenarios where it it's science involved, and fraud involved, then it's scientific fraud.

:)
 
Top 10 Modern Scientific Hoaxes.
http://listosaur.com/science-a-technology/top-10-modern-scientific-hoaxes.html

25 Greatest Scientific Hoaxes In History
http://list25.com/25-greatest-scientific-hoaxes-in-history/

Careless science now threatens our very survival as a species
http://www.naturalnews.com/035837_science_survival_human_race.html

Time for skeptics to take their head out of the sand and stop defending fraudulent science and the threat it poses to the survival of the human race. There was a time when science attracted the brightest and best minds. But today it attracts third and fourth tier candidates. As the saying goes. Garbage in garbage out.
The links you have provided have already been exposed as nonsense. Do you have any statistical data supporting this baseless claim?
Considering fraud, my own view (based on many years of observation) is that science is the least contaminated human endeavor. The quest for truth and confirmation is public and a relentless worldwide activity. Mistakes and/or dishonesty are inevitably and rather quickly corrected. It has been already pointed out that when mistakes are found, they are found by other scientists.
Repeating the same silly links has no traction. You have been exposed!
 
The links you have provided have already been exposed as nonsense. Do you have any statistical data supporting this baseless claim?
Considering fraud, my own view (based on many years of observation) is that science is the least contaminated human endeavor. The quest for truth and confirmation is public and a relentless worldwide activity. Mistakes and/or dishonesty are inevitably and rather quickly corrected. It has been already pointed out that when mistakes are found, they are found by other scientists.
Repeating the same silly links has no traction. You have been exposed!

The links prove scientists have both perpetrated and were victims of fraud in the past. But modern scientists are mainly perpetrators of fraud and are much more sophisticated in concealing them.

It has already been pointed out the majority of scientific retractions were not because of errors but were fraudulent.

The scientific community have not hit the bottom yet and it is quite obvious they see that as room left for more mischief.

How is it possible that a process/method the scientific method which skeptics rely on as amateurs to ascertain the truth and facts is failing the very scientific community that adopted it as the basis for their discipline? Without the ability to discern the truth science is nothing but repetitious ignorance/dung piled on more ignorance/dung. Anyone wishing to repeat the process will be successful as a scientists if the goal is to end up with a pile of dung.
 
How is it possible that a process/method the scientific method which skeptics rely on as amateurs to ascertain the truth and facts is failing the very scientific community that adopted it as the basis for their discipline?


How is it possible that the results of a failing method work so well that, for example, you are able to post on the internet?
 
Top 10 Modern Scientific Hoaxes.
http://listosaur.com/science-a-technology/top-10-modern-scientific-hoaxes.html

25 Greatest Scientific Hoaxes In History
http://list25.com/25-greatest-scientific-hoaxes-in-history/

Careless science now threatens our very survival as a species
http://www.naturalnews.com/035837_science_survival_human_race.html

Time for skeptics to take their head out of the sand and stop defending fraudulent science and the threat it poses to the survival of the human race. There was a time when science attracted the brightest and best minds. But today it attracts third and fourth tier candidates. As the saying goes. Garbage in garbage out.

I'm just a lurker in this thread but I have to say there should be a ban against citing top ten lists written by $0.03 a word SEO writers for entertainment purposes.
 
How is it possible that a process/method the scientific method which skeptics rely on as amateurs to ascertain the truth and facts is failing the very scientific community that adopted it as the basis for their discipline?

Since the scientific method is not failing, your question is in and of itself either mistaken or dishonest.
 
justintime said:
The links prove scientists have both perpetrated and were victims of fraud in the past. But modern scientists are mainly perpetrators of fraud and are much more sophisticated in concealing them.
In other words, you expect us to believe that because someone, somewhere, did something in the past, all scientists currently are guilty of an undefined fraud.

I re-itterate my earlier challange: Prove that my works are fraudulant. Provide specific works and specific cases where I have presented false data as true, or true data as false, or withheld necessary information.

It has already been pointed out the majority of scientific retractions were not because of errors but were fraudulent.
There are several things you insist on ignoring.

1) Total retractions amount to less than 1% of 1% of the papers in that study; and
2) That only accounts for a single field of science.

The scientific community have not hit the bottom yet and it is quite obvious they see that as room left for more mischief.
Well, since 99.999% of papers in that study were honest and did not contain errors, I'd say that technically this is true. However, it's pretty much the opposite of your claim. We're doing damn well at reducing fraud, though there's still some room for improvement. I defy you to find any field with less fraud.

How is it possible that a process/method the scientific method which skeptics rely on as amateurs to ascertain the truth and facts is failing the very scientific community that adopted it as the basis for their discipline? Without the ability to discern the truth science is nothing but repetitious ignorance/dung piled on more ignorance/dung. Anyone wishing to repeat the process will be successful as a scientists if the goal is to end up with a pile of dung.
Never mind the demonstrable effects of science in our culture--because justintime can't be bothered to learn the technical terms, it's obviously false! :rolleyes:

This has nothing to do with science. This entire thread is nothing but a petulant, childish rant by a few forum members that amounts to "I want to be treated as better than scientists, but those big fat meanies say I have to actually put forth some effort to do so!"
 
In other words, you expect us to believe that because someone, somewhere, did something in the past, all scientists currently are guilty of an undefined fraud.

I re-itterate my earlier challange: Prove that my works are fraudulant. Provide specific works and specific cases where I have presented false data as true, or true data as false, or withheld necessary information.

There are several things you insist on ignoring.

1) Total retractions amount to less than 1% of 1% of the papers in that study; and
2) That only accounts for a single field of science.

Well, since 99.999% of papers in that study were honest and did not contain errors, I'd say that technically this is true. However, it's pretty much the opposite of your claim. We're doing damn well at reducing fraud, though there's still some room for improvement. I defy you to find any field with less fraud.

Never mind the demonstrable effects of science in our culture--because justintime can't be bothered to learn the technical terms, it's obviously false! :rolleyes:

This has nothing to do with science. This entire thread is nothing but a petulant, childish rant by a few forum members that amounts to "I want to be treated as better than scientists, but those big fat meanies say I have to actually put forth some effort to do so!"

It's not just this thread, unfortunately, it is a pretty constant theme in all the threads where pseudoscience is offered as counterpoint to mainstream scientific understandings.
 
Here is a link to the top 10 science hoaxes. You will also find top 10 science mistakes and top 10 science feuds.
Top 10 Science Hoaxes
http://science.discovery.com/strange-science/10-science-hoaxes.htm
/QUOTE]

Let's be fair, though.

How about the "top 10 hoaxes by non-scientists." or the "top 10 frauds by non-scientists" (let's include bankers and Internet gurus and real estate gurus and all that, too.) So how do you think scientists compare (in terms of fraud) to Infomercial proponents? Or bankers? Or Congresscritters? Or lawyers? Or mechanics?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom