Belz...
Fiend God
Funny how you've yet to present a single example of a fraud committed in science that wasn't discovered by non-scientists.
I think you made a typo, there. You meant to say "by scientists" or "was discovered", I think.
Funny how you've yet to present a single example of a fraud committed in science that wasn't discovered by non-scientists.
That assumes that it is "science" that is "getting stuff wrong". Isn't fraud a completely different thing than scientific error? And fraud by definition means the intent is to fool people, bget ahead, it is done for a reason. It is not the same as a mistake, an error, or doing science poorly.
I think you made a typo, there. You meant to say "by scientists" or "was discovered", I think.
Scientific fraud occurs when a scientist knowingly gives false information as their professional opinion (this is light-years away from a mere opinion, by the way--publications and the like are examples of giving professional opinions).r-j said:If you define something as "doing science", or say somebody is "using science", and they are engaged in a fraud, is that "scientific fraud"? It's not a flippant question.
Scientific fraud occurs when a scientist knowingly gives false information as their professional opinion
You're right--what I meant to say is that all valid examples of fraud in this thread were discovered by scientists. (We can dismiss anything said by Creation.com or the like, for obvious reasons.) No example of a case fo fraud discovered by a non-scientist has been presented.
Does anyone else agree with this?
Does anyone else agree with this?
I agree with it, but would also add "or withholds true, relevent information" between "information" and "as"![]()
I agree with it, but would also add "or withholds true, relevent information" between "information" and "as"![]()
A very good addition. Thank you for bringing it up!![]()
You're right--what I meant to say is that all valid examples of fraud in this thread were discovered by scientists. (We can dismiss anything said by Creation.com or the like, for obvious reasons.) No example of a case fo fraud discovered by a non-scientist has been presented.
Hopefully that clears things up. The baby kept me up last night.![]()
Scientific fraud occurs when a scientist knowingly gives false information as their professional opinion (this is light-years away from a mere opinion, by the way--publications and the like are examples of giving professional opinions).
The difference between a mechanic and a scientist is that the mechanic is working with a well-known, man-made system that we know pretty much everything about, in an attempt to bring it back to a pre-defined optimum state. If the mechanic is building a new motor, or is attempting to define the optimum state, or something like that, they're acting as a scientist; however, the person who diagnosed and fixed the leaky coolant tank on my wife's car was quite clearly merely following pre-established protocols. That's not to deminish what they do; I'm merely saying that it's different from what scientists do. The fact that one can describe what they do as following the scientific method is only evidence that the mechanic is rational--they are basing their assessment of the situation on knowledge gained from observing the system.
If you wish to call a mechanic a scientist because they adjust their opinions based on reality, you'd need to classify anyone who dates another person as a scientist. A relationship is a constant re-adjustment of one's understanding of the other person based on what one learns about them. And anyone who breaks up with someone is CERTAINLY a scientist--after all, they've drastically altered their interpretation of the other person! I think it's obvious that not all rational people are scientists.
Scientists, in my opinion, are those who specifically seek to gather new information about the universe using some version of the scientific method, which necessarily includes presenting their findings for evaluation by other scientists. A person can quite obviously act as a scientist sometimes, and not at other times. Any fraud committed outside of the times when a person is acting as a scientist is irrelevant to this topic. For example, if I cheat on my taxes (I don't, but it illustrates my point) that doesn't count as scientific fraud, despite the fact that my company classifys me as a scientist.
Considering the fact that this is true, I do not consider this a criticism, but rather an argument in favor of my definition.Trakar said:While I agree with most of what you say here, specifically with regard to scientific fraud, your limitations of what is and is not science means that 99.9% of the dedicated scientific careers of professional research scientists is not involved with doing science.
Writing grants isn't science, not by any stretch of the imagination. Writing papers is presenting one's profesional opinion, and would qualify as doing science. Number/data crunching qualifies as writing papers. The routine procedures would be included, or not, depending on what they are. I used to work with a graphite furnace atomic absorption spectrometer, and the graphite furnace itself needed replaced regularly. Not a hard process, but one that was required for the analysis. The analysis itself is science; the replacement of the furnace, yeah, I'd be willing to include it. When we tore the machine apart to see if we could repair it? Not so much; that was us functioning as mechanics, not as scientists.It is mostly about filing for grants, writing papers, number/data crunching and performing routine procedures over and over again where the results are predictable and largely known before the procedure is ever initiated.
Science certainly is more than the insant of insight. Reading the background data, compiling the data, running tests, etc. all are included. It's the PROCESS of learning new information about the universe, not the instant of gaining such knowledge.Personally, I consider all of these processes to be just as much a part of "science" as the insightful instant when they discover a novel substance, process or connection.
I fully agree. When working with fraud, I've found it best to have VERY specific definitions that cover every eventuality. Otherwise you have some idiot claiming that a cover-up isn't fraud, because "...no one actually said anything that wasn't true!" Too many people try to follow the letter of a law or definition, without regard for the intent.Hellbound said:Well, technically, if it's true and relevent, not presenting it would be presenting false information...but I thought it should be explicitly spelled out.
Now we are advancing. Anyone else want to add anything?
"Scientific fraud occurs when a scientist knowingly gives false information or withholds true, relevant information, as their professional opinion"
I've been saying that for a week now.annnnoid said:I suppose a useful metric for the issue might reference the ratio of papers retracted / exposed as fraudulent to papers not so affected.
Some examples were given up-thread. They were of individual fields, but none the less, such studies do in fact exist. As I stated previously, by themselves they are not definitive; however, we can use them to estimate fraud rates, including undetected frauds, at least to the point where we can hypothesize whether fraud is commonplace or not. This can be done using standard sampling techniques, treating each such study as a particular sample.It's doubtful that any such study has ever occurred
We also have a method for exposing science when it it a product of fraud.
We call it science.
You are accepting a dictionary definition over that given by actual practitioners of the field. I could probably think of a less rational approach to this problem, but it would take some effort.justintime said:The method for exposing science when it is a product of fraud is not science. Science is by definition...
We have explained, patiently and thoroughly, that you are mistaken about the peer-review process. Fraud is discovered during the informal review, meaning by the scientists who read and use the publications. Peer-review is not, according to a reviewer in this thread, intended to detect all frauds. To continue this line of argument is, in itself, fraudulant.Scientific fraud is often exposed during the peer-review process
Fraud is often committed by senior members of the scientific body which makes detection harder.
...Writing grants isn't science, not by any stretch of the imagination...
Then you are wrong. There's no other way to put it. The stuff you attribute to grant writing is included because the agencies granting the grants wish to ensure that they are paying for actual science; those steps would generally be required of any rigorous research program, and attributing them to grant-writing is an inversion of causality.Trakar said:I don't know that I agree with this