science fraud is common place

So you've got the top ten science hoaxes....out of how many? What's the total number of known hoaxes? Giving us a "top ten" list is useless. I mean, it could be the top 10 out of 11, in which case there's really nothing to be concerned about. If it's the top 10 out of 2 billion then that's a different story altogether.
Some of them aren't even science hoaxes, so justintime hasn't even got to 10 yet, never mind 11.
 
The scientific community would beg to differ with your assessment of the problem so would the general public.

Justintime, under no circumstances whatsoever do you have permission or license to speak for any scientific community.
 
Last edited:
I think it's telling that the same lie is told over and over.

At some point, one must question the motives and ethics of someone who repeats a claim, without providing even scant evidence for the assertions, and in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary.
 
I think it's telling that the same lie is told over and over.

At some point, one must question the motives and ethics of someone who repeats a claim, without providing even scant evidence for the assertions, and in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary.

Just look at the member's posting history. It's been a long time since he made his motives obvious as well as his utter lack of ethics and his dishonesty in engaging in actual debate.
 
Just look at the member's posting history. It's been a long time since he made his motives obvious as well as his utter lack of ethics and his dishonesty in engaging in actual debate.

Although, I have to say these threads make me giggle.

I still can't understand how the longest threads, and the most arguments, end up posted to a thread where one side's argument is, basically, variations of "Is too!".

There's usually gems hidden in the rubble, though...we often get those well-written, and informative posts by knowledgeable members every 25 pages or so.

ETA: Thinking about it, I think I can undertsand. It's frustrtating because people want to debate the point, but the opposition simply doesn't engage. It's like going to a boxing match where your opponent just runs around the ring and never lets you get close. They may never get a hit in, but you get damn tired of chasing them :)
 
Last edited:
The problem is, that when you do not repeat the experiment, you can be biased.
And it's a selffulfilling process:

First you accept a paper A because it seems reasonable.
Then you accept paper B because it is in line with the data of paper A.
But you do not accept paper C because it is 'outrageous' (not at all in line with the data of paper A and paper B)

In all these cases you haven't checked the data at all by repeating the described experiments. You just use previous accepted manuscripts about the same subject to judge the next manuscripts with it. But you didn't check any of the data, presented by any of these manuscripts.

This is how scientific publication works. I learned something new today.

You are raising so many questions about the integrity of science/scientists, one has to ask why skeptics failed to recognize the deception but instead blindly embrace the scientific method.

Science fraud will continue regardless of public disclosures. The scientific method helps scientists to systematical project misinformation by masking fraudulent research in esoteric high flung dung. The only way to expose the fraud is to wait for one of their own to surface from this cesspool of deception and incriminate the rest.
 
justintime said:
You are raising so many questions about the integrity of science/scientists, one has to ask why skeptics failed to recognize the deception but instead blindly embrace the scientific method.
The issues is that Maartenn100 grossly misrepresents the scientific method, both in terms of the theory and in terms of the practice. This has been extensively explained in this thread.

The scientific method helps scientists to systematical project misinformation by masking fraudulent research in esoteric high flung dung.
As has been explained to you, the exact opposite is true. The scientific method ensures that fraud will eventually be discovered; the efficacy of this method is demonstrated by your continued inability to present a single case of scientific fraud uncovered by non-scientists.

Your continued use of "high flung dung" to describe technical jargon is dishonest, particularly given the fact that you have a demonstrated inability to comprehend what's written. Essentially, you can't understand the jargon so there's no way you can possibly understand whether it's useful or not.
 
As has been explained to you, the exact opposite is true. The scientific method ensures that fraud will eventually be discovered; the efficacy of this method is demonstrated by your continued inability to present a single case of scientific fraud uncovered by non-scientists.

There are no independent panels or third party data verification process in place to investigate scientific fraud. The general public are not part of the peer-review process and have no say in where research funding is allocated. This might explain why scientific fraud have escaped public scrutiny. But the public have legal recourse when they are victims of scientific fraud.

It is the press/media and public awareness of how common science fraud is that will change the current situation and empower the non-scientific population to bring criminal charges. The public should show less veneration for a profession that does not deserve to be trusted and subject it to the maximum verification/scrutiny for the safety of all.
 
...
It is the press/media and public awareness of how common science fraud is that will change the current situation and empower the non-scientific population to bring criminal charges. The public should show less veneration for a profession that does not deserve to be trusted and subject it to the maximum verification/scrutiny for the safety of all.

So, you're saying that the opinion of the non-scientific population enables this same non-scientific population to bring criminal charges against ... the profession of science?

That's not going to happen :D
 
There are no independent panels or third party data verification process in place to investigate scientific fraud. The general public are not part of the peer-review process and have no say in where research funding is allocated. This might explain why scientific fraud have escaped public scrutiny. But the public have legal recourse when they are victims of scientific fraud.
It is the press/media and public awareness of how common science fraud is that will change the current situation and empower the non-scientific population to bring criminal charges. The public should show less veneration for a profession that does not deserve to be trusted and subject it to the maximum verification/scrutiny for the safety of all.
Can you come up with an argument that's not the same low-flung dung you spouted earlier?
 
There are no independent panels or third party data verification process in place to investigate scientific fraud...

You really don't have a clue as to how science functions, do you?

Every scientist in your field (and many from other fields) will attempt to replicate your work and check to see if the results you got are verifiable. Those that don't manage to replicate your work and results will write papers about their findings. Science is an exhaustive competition against other scientists, it isn't a fraternal brotherhood of back-patters.
 
Your continued use of "high flung dung" to describe technical jargon is dishonest, particularly given the fact that you have a demonstrated inability to comprehend what's written. Essentially, you can't understand the jargon so there's no way you can possibly understand whether it's useful or not.

The technical language of the various branches of science that are being dishonestly referred to as "high flung dung" are accessible to anyone willing to take the time and make the effort to understand the language and the concepts involved. There is no secret society with a hidden language available only to the initiates of some cult. There is no mysterious cipher. It's a language available for all to learn on the internet, in all the universities, bookstores, libraries, etc. -- all over the world. However, it does take a great deal of time and effort.
One of the wonderful aspects of science is that it is universal, available to all (who live in developed parts of the world) and -- with the advent of the internet -- astonishingly accessible to anyone willing to make the effort.
For example, I spend my retirement years studying mathematics and theoretical physics with lecturers at MIT, Stanford, The Indian Institute of Technology, The University of Michigan, etc. -- all at no cost! Science is open for all to learn. It is virtually impossible for fraud (as is being claimed here) to gain any traction.
Those who claim fraud is "common place" (sic) simply do not understand the subject they are criticizing. They have not made the effort to learn the language and the concepts and consequently live in some delusional proxy for reality.
 
Last edited:
Okay so let's run this through here.

When "Science" (which I still need the point out isn't a single "thing" other then a method) makes a mistake there's a process in place, namely science, to find it and correct it.

When Woo makes a mistake... what happens exactly? What finds out? What fixes it? What corrects it?

Again I get it. You want your Woo and science just will not let you have it. I feel for you. But I'm sorry your problem is really with reality for not having your Woo in it rather then science for pointing it out.
 
There are no independent panels or third party data verification process in place to investigate scientific fraud. The general public are not part of the peer-review process and have no say in where research funding is allocated. This might explain why scientific fraud have escaped public scrutiny. But the public have legal recourse when they are victims of scientific fraud.

Lolwut?

http://ori.hhs.gov/

The NIH will come in and inspect your lab notebooks and all your research records if they suspect fraud. If they determine misconduct has occurred you lose your federal funding. Good luck getting funding from any other source as well once your reputation has been tainted. Universities and research institutes also conduct their own internal investigations.

Peer review is utilized by journals to assess whether something is worthy of publication. Why would the general public be involved with it (a system that is not even designed to stop fraud)?

The public allocates research funding as much as they do any other government spending...by electing representatives that make a budget.

You are incredibly uninformed about how scientific research is funded, conducted, and published... and yet you act as if you are an expert on the topic. I find that amusing.
 
Last edited:
You really don't have a clue as to how science functions, do you?

Every scientist in your field (and many from other fields) will attempt to replicate your work and check to see if the results you got are verifiable. Those that don't manage to replicate your work and results will write papers about their findings. Science is an exhaustive competition against other scientists, it isn't a fraternal brotherhood of back-patters.

Didnt the claim for cold fusion go thru the scientific verification process you are talking about, a number of years ago?
 
Didnt the claim for cold fusion go thru the scientific verification process you are talking about, a number of years ago?

No, not really. This is only a Wiki overview but it goes into great detail of Pons and Fleischmann's publication history. They did announce their results to the world prior to publication in a peer reviewed journal.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cold_fusion

Also don't confuse two different processes. There is a difference between editors determining criteria for publication and attempts by colleagues to replicate the published results. It didn't take long to find out that Pons and Fleischmann's results were irreproducible.

Despite the nonsense of Justintime, this is another example of how scientific fraud (or in the case of Pons and Fleischmann, self delusion) is eventually uncovered by the scientific process.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bad_Science:_The_Short_Life_and_Weird_Times_of_Cold_Fusion
 
Last edited:
Lolwut?

http://ori.hhs.gov/

The NIH will come in and inspect your lab notebooks and all your research records if they suspect fraud. If they determine misconduct has occurred you lose your federal funding. Good luck getting funding from any other source as well once your reputation has been tainted. Universities and research institutes also conduct their own internal investigations.

Peer review is utilized by journals to assess whether something is worthy of publication. Why would the general public be involved with it (a system that is not even designed to stop fraud)?

The public allocates research funding as much as they do any other government spending...by electing representatives that make a budget.

You are incredibly uninformed about how scientific research is funded, conducted, and published... and yet you act as if you are an expert on the topic. I find that amusing.
You missed the point completely. My post was in response to Dinwar's point repeated below.


Originally Posted by Dinwar View Post
As has been explained to you, the exact opposite is true. The scientific method ensures that fraud will eventually be discovered; the efficacy of this method is demonstrated by your continued inability to present a single case of scientific fraud uncovered by non-scientists.

My response points to the current oversight bodies (ORI) made up of members of the scientific community and the exclusion of the general public in the peer-review process as well as allocation of research funding. In short the current system is failing because it is managed by people of science who are willing to turn a blind eye when members of their profession commit fraud. That explains why so few fraud cases are exposed and why the majority of scientific fraud goes undetected/unchallenged.

Statistics were provided that proved scientists are just as criminally inclined as the general population and even fail to meet the high standards they set for themselves. That change is needed and the public should not be lulled into any sense of false security believing science is self correcting or the scientific community is above criminal intent.

I wrote what I believe will change the current lopsided review and investigative process.

"It is the press/media and public awareness of how common science fraud is that will change the current situation and empower the non-scientific population to bring criminal charges. The public should show less veneration for a profession that does not deserve to be trusted and subject it to the maximum verification/scrutiny for the safety of all. "

Here is a quote from NIH and Research Misconduct Dr. Sally Rockey is NIH's Deputy Director for Extramural Research. (Note the amount of trust placed on the integrity of the researcher....scientific naivety I presume).

Research integrity is the reason why we have many of the regulations, guidelines, and policies in place that safeguard our research, but, ultimately, you, the researcher, are responsible for conducting your research in a responsible, ethical manner. This shared responsibility we have with you enables us to maintain the public trust and have confidence in the research record and results.
 
...
Here is a quote from NIH and Research Misconduct Dr. Sally Rockey is NIH's Deputy Director for Extramural Research. (Note the amount of trust placed on the integrity of the researcher....scientific naivety I presume).

Note the lack of reference by justintime to external review and investigation into allegations of Research Misconduct.

:rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom