science fraud is common place

Here is a link to the top 10 science hoaxes. You will also find top 10 science mistakes and top 10 science feuds.
Top 10 Science Hoaxes
http://science.discovery.com/strange-science/10-science-hoaxes.htm
/QUOTE]

Let's be fair, though.

How about the "top 10 hoaxes by non-scientists." or the "top 10 frauds by non-scientists" (let's include bankers and Internet gurus and real estate gurus and all that, too.) So how do you think scientists compare (in terms of fraud) to Infomercial proponents? Or bankers? Or Congresscritters? Or lawyers? Or mechanics?

I have stated it and even the links have stated that scientists are both perpetrators and victims of scientific fraud.

"Nobody's perfect, even scientists get duped (or try to dupe others). Here we've gathered the top 10 science hoaxes of all time."
http://science.discovery.com/strange-science/10-science-hoaxes.htm

Science is based on trust (read post # 490), science is self-correcting (read post # 490), scientific fraud is more likely to be committed by scientists in higher positions (read post# 482).
Maybe it is time to lump science/scientists with financial institutions and other commercial enterprises. The scientific method is just as unreliable as other methods to forecast, predict and analyze data and prone to the same corrupt practices found in the other institutions.

Less than 5% of the workforce are made up of engineers and scientists. If you separate scientists from engineers and further separate scientists from science fiction writers and further separate scientists from scientist who commit scientific fraud, you will get a very small fraction of scientists who actually do any honest, practical research.

Is it any surprise why the public accept how common science fraud is when they compare it to the few, rare useful science research they encounter in their daily lives?
__________________
 
So you've got the top ten science hoaxes....out of how many? What's the total number of known hoaxes? Giving us a "top ten" list is useless. I mean, it could be the top 10 out of 11, in which case there's really nothing to be concerned about. If it's the top 10 out of 2 billion then that's a different story altogether.
 
So you've got the top ten science hoaxes....out of how many? What's the total number of known hoaxes? Giving us a "top ten" list is useless. I mean, it could be the top 10 out of 11, in which case there's really nothing to be concerned about. If it's the top 10 out of 2 billion then that's a different story altogether.

Less than 5% of the workforce is made up of engineers and scientists. If you separate scientists from engineers and further separate scientists from science fiction writers and further separate scientists from scientist who commit scientific fraud, you will get an even smaller fraction of scientists who actually do any honest, practical research.

It is not only how much fraud is concealed or revealed in science. You also have to consider the very small percentage of scientists actually doing any practical, useful research.
 
Actually right now it IS just about how much fraud has been revealed. Until you can give us that number we've got no reason to think there's an issue worth considering.
 
Less than 5% of the workforce is made up of engineers and scientists. If you separate scientists from engineers and further separate scientists from science fiction writers and further separate scientists from scientist who commit scientific fraud, you will get an even smaller fraction of scientists who actually do any honest, practical research.

It is not only how much fraud is concealed or revealed in science. You also have to consider the very small percentage of scientists actually doing any practical, useful research.

So theoretical research is a no-no then? What an odd little perspective you have on science and scientists. How cute.

BTW, you need to read up on Venn diagrams.
 
It is not only how much fraud is concealed or revealed in science. You also have to consider the very small percentage of scientists actually doing any practical, useful research.

Also, car repair shops. Car repair is rife with fraud.

www.askmen.com/top_10/cars/top-10-mechanic-scams.html‎

If you subtract the 93% of car shops that are fraudulent, and the 79% of car shops that only service foreign cars, there is virtually no way to get an American car fixed any more. I don't know why anyone bothers. These car repair shops just sit there and don't repair cars. That's OK because cars never worked anyway.

And: sports? Total fraud from one end to the other.

www.realclearsports.com/lists/top_10_frauds_in_sports_history‎

There has not been a non-fixed pro sports game in North America since 1982, and that one is doubtful. Most athletes are throwing most of their games, and the remaining tiny fraction isn't actually any good. I watched a football game once and saw a missed field goal, that's how bad things are. The mainstream idea of "training" for "performance" is a complete fake, but because "successful" athletes have all this training mambi-jibbo. Roger Bannister runs this unquestionable fake 4-minute mile and everyone forgets that running isn't actually a sport. Nobody runs any more. Prove me wrong.
 
Actually right now it IS just about how much fraud has been revealed. Until you can give us that number we've got no reason to think there's an issue worth considering.

The scientific community would beg to differ with your assessment of the problem so would the general public.

What is the true costs of scientific fraud?

A case of research misconduct rarely results in only one single cost; in most cases, misconduct creates a ‘ripple effect’ of damages that touch a number of individuals and organizations. Some of the most common types of damages that a case of misconduct can produce include:
• Individual costs
• Brand costs
• Capital costs
• Human costs
 
The scientific community would beg to differ with your assessment of the problem so would the general public.

No, not unless you are defining both "the scientific community" and "the general public" to mean yourself exclusively.
 
The method for exposing science when it is a product of fraud is not science.

Of course it is. Through additional experiments and validations you will invalidate the fraud's results.

Science is by definition
1. knowledge about or study of the natural world based on facts learned through experiments and observation

2. a particular area of scientific study (such as biology, physics, or chemistry) : a particular branch of science.

Yes, precisely. That's why it works to expose falsehoods.

It might help to reduce fraud and quackery in science. But where can you find honest senior scientists when they are the perpetrat0ors of the fraud? In short the process was doomed to fail and the general public are finally catching up with just how common science fraud is.

Assuming all this is true, what do you propose to solve this problem ?
 
The objective/goal is to expose science for what it is not and and to see through it without rose-colored glasses for what it is.
[...]

I'm ready any time you are.

But please, actually READ your sources before you cite them.

You're welcome. :)
 
What that proves is scientists are rather inept at detecting fraud and only manage to expose a few or that scientists protect their profession by downplaying how common science fraud is in the scientific community.

Slow down. Aren't you assuming your conclusion, here ? You're saying that although scientists are the ones exposing the frauds and pretty much no one else, they are, in your opinion, not exposing more than a fraction of all frauds and therefore are inept at detecting fraud despite the fact that they are the only ones to successfully do it ?

That's so twisted it probably forms an infinite loop.
 
There are several studies that exposes the "The Myth of the Self-Correcting Nature of Science."
[SNIP!]

Let's see you present some -- with references and ISBNs.

This ought to be a hoot. Page 78 is already a meme thanks to justintime.

:)
 
Also, car repair shops. Car repair is rife with fraud.

www.askmen.com/top_10/cars/top-10-mechanic-scams.html‎

If you subtract the 93% of car shops that are fraudulent, and the 79% of car shops that only service foreign cars, there is virtually no way to get an American car fixed any more. I don't know why anyone bothers. These car repair shops just sit there and don't repair cars. That's OK because cars never worked anyway.

And: sports? Total fraud from one end to the other.

www.realclearsports.com/lists/top_10_frauds_in_sports_history‎

There has not been a non-fixed pro sports game in North America since 1982, and that one is doubtful. Most athletes are throwing most of their games, and the remaining tiny fraction isn't actually any good. I watched a football game once and saw a missed field goal, that's how bad things are. The mainstream idea of "training" for "performance" is a complete fake, but because "successful" athletes have all this training mambi-jibbo. Roger Bannister runs this unquestionable fake 4-minute mile and everyone forgets that running isn't actually a sport. Nobody runs any more. Prove me wrong.

Brilliant, sir.
 
It is not only how much fraud is concealed or revealed in science. You also have to consider the very small percentage of scientists actually doing any practical, useful research.

Ah. So anything justintime doesn't see as practical or useful is also fraud. Never mind the fact that it's true, honestly presented, and independently verified--because some random schmuck on the net doesn't see a use for it, so it's fraud.

Sorry, but it doesn't work that way. We've defined "scientific fraud" in this thread. Please stick to it, or refute it. Honest research that you see no practical value to IS NOT, IN ANY SENSE fraud.

This also demonstrates why you should be excluded from any discussion on how to fix science, should it need fixing. Basic research--that which has no obvious practical value, but merely explores the universe--provides the broad knowledge base necessary to advance any of the practical fields. Without it, those fields stagnate and eventually die. At best, you end up with Warhammer 40k; at worst, Easter Island.
 
The links prove scientists have both perpetrated and were victims of fraud in the past. But modern scientists are mainly perpetrators of fraud and are much more sophisticated in concealing them.

It has already been pointed out the majority of scientific retractions were not because of errors but were fraudulent.

No, it has not.

The scientific community have not hit the bottom yet and it is quite obvious they see that as room left for more mischief.

Thank goodness we have you to plumb the bottoms like a septic-tank drainer.


How is it possible that a process/method the scientific method which skeptics rely on as amateurs to ascertain the truth and facts is failing the very scientific community that adopted it as the basis for their discipline?

It's not done so.


Without the ability to discern the truth science is nothing but repetitious ignorance/dung piled on more ignorance/dung. Anyone wishing to repeat the process will be successful as a scientists if the goal is to end up with a pile of dung.

Yet science is the most profitable process that humanity has ever come-up with for discovering the laws of the universe.

If you have a better plan, let's see it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom