science fraud is common place

Actually, I have to apologize--I dropped the context of the discussion. You are right, fraud in a grant proposal would in fact constitute scientific fraud. Grant proposals are not science as such, but they are examples of scientists giving professional opinions, and therefore including false information or excluding relevant true information would constitute scientific fraud.

To clarify my position regarding grant-writing: I do not think that grant-writing should be included in a definition of science as such. It's not a necessary component of science, but rather a component due to our culture. It can be included in a description, but not a definition, of science. It seems like a subtle distinction, but considering we're dealing with pedantic jerks in this thread I think it's important to be precise here.
 
The difference between a mechanic and a scientist is that the mechanic is working with a well-known, man-made system that we know pretty much everything about, in an attempt to bring it back to a pre-defined optimum state.


On the other hand, the difference between a mechanic and a quantum mechanic is that the quantum mechanic can get his car into the garage without opening the door.
 
You are accepting a dictionary definition over that given by actual practitioners of the field. I could probably think of a less rational approach to this problem, but it would take some effort.

We have explained, patiently and thoroughly, that you are mistaken about the peer-review process. Fraud is discovered during the informal review, meaning by the scientists who read and use the publications. Peer-review is not, according to a reviewer in this thread, intended to detect all frauds. To continue this line of argument is, in itself, fraudulant.

Here is a link to the top 10 science hoaxes. You will also find top 10 science mistakes and top 10 science feuds.
Top 10 Science Hoaxes
http://science.discovery.com/strange-science/10-science-hoaxes.htm

Top 10 Science Mistakes
http://science.discovery.com/strange-science/10-science-mistakes.htm

Top 10 Science Feuds
http://science.discovery.com/strange-science/10-science-fueds.htm

Here is another kicker. With all the controversy in scientific research fraud and peer-review retractions. Science programs in the US are seeing a decline in foreign enrollment.
Fewer Foreigners Eye U.S. Graduate Science Programs.
http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB10001424127887323916304578405060631410012

It must be hard on the foreign students to spend so many years learning science only to spend years later unraveling all the fraud and hoaxes they were taught. Science is what we would call a zero sum game. Only a very small percentage of science that is taught has any real practical value. The rest is all esoteric high flung dung and some are even retractable......imagine that!!!!:jaw-dropp
 
Now we are advancing. Anyone else want to add anything?
"Scientific fraud occurs when a scientist knowingly gives false information or withholds true, relevant information, as their professional opinion"


I disagree with the notion of publishing a scientific paper as giving a professional opinion.

I would say that scientific fraud occurs when a scientist knowingly presents false information as true in a scientific publication.
 
Last edited:
justintime said:
Here is a link to the top 10 science hoaxes. You will also find top 10 science mistakes and top 10 science feuds.
And who discovered these hoaxes? It was scientists, wasn't it?

Thank you for proving my point.

It must be hard on the foreign students to spend so many years learning science only to spend years later unraveling all the fraud and hoaxes they were taught.
Not really. Most students who get very far in science realize that they need to make up their own minds about the quality of research. Unlike you, who apparently wishes to be able to take everything scientists say as fact, and who treats any error as proof that we should discard the whole structure.

jt512 said:
I disagree with the notion of publishing a scientific paper as giving a professional opinion.
Why? As I said, a professional opinion is very different from a mere opinion. It is, ideally, the considered conclusion reached after careful examination of the available data, and (this being science) often after running specific tests.
 
Then you are wrong. There's no other way to put it. The stuff you attribute to grant writing is included because the agencies granting the grants wish to ensure that they are paying for actual science; those steps would generally be required of any rigorous research program, and attributing them to grant-writing is an inversion of causality.

The journal write-ups are, as I have stated, expressions of professional opinion, which is quite different from writing a grant. As such, they count as part of science.

And you don't think grant writing includes expressions of professional opinion?

So do you consider most in-house corporate research to be "science?"
 
And you don't think grant writing includes expressions of professional opinion?

So do you consider most in-house corporate research to be "science?"

Please see the comment I made immediately after the one you quoted.
 
Why? As I said, a professional opinion is very different from a mere opinion. It is, ideally, the considered conclusion reached after careful examination of the available data, and (this being science) often after running specific tests.

Please see the comment I made immediately after the one you quoted.

Presumably you mean the one above?

If so, my questions stand.

You don't think grant writing includes expressions of professional opinion?

Do you consider most in-house corporate research to be "science?"
 
Trakar said:
Presumably you mean the one above?
No. I meant this one:

Dinwar said:
Actually, I have to apologize--I dropped the context of the discussion. You are right, fraud in a grant proposal would in fact constitute scientific fraud. Grant proposals are not science as such, but they are examples of scientists giving professional opinions, and therefore including false information or excluding relevant true information would constitute scientific fraud.

To clarify my position regarding grant-writing: I do not think that grant-writing should be included in a definition of science as such. It's not a necessary component of science, but rather a component due to our culture. It can be included in a description, but not a definition, of science. It seems like a subtle distinction, but considering we're dealing with pedantic jerks in this thread I think it's important to be precise here.
 
And who discovered these hoaxes? It was scientists, wasn't it?

Thank you for proving my point.

What that proves is scientists are rather inept at detecting fraud and only manage to expose a few or that scientists protect their profession by downplaying how common science fraud is in the scientific community.

It also points to why the role of the press and the public in exposing scientific and medical fraud in becoming increasingly critical in the interest of public safety and to reign in scientific fraud. It was naive to believe science is self-correcting, now that the evidence to the contrary is shedding light on just how common science fraud is.
 
Originally Posted by Dinwar
Actually, I have to apologize--I dropped the context of the discussion. You are right, fraud in a grant proposal would in fact constitute scientific fraud. Grant proposals are not science as such, but they are examples of scientists giving professional opinions, and therefore including false information or excluding relevant true information would constitute scientific fraud.

To clarify my position regarding grant-writing: I do not think that grant-writing should be included in a definition of science as such. It's not a necessary component of science, but rather a component due to our culture. It can be included in a description, but not a definition, of science. It seems like a subtle distinction, but considering we're dealing with pedantic jerks in this thread I think it's important to be precise here.
If you look at all the mundane things scientists do you might even convince yourself they have very little time to commit fraud because most of their opinions are just that, opinions!!! It is only when they pass their opinions as fact that it becomes an issue when they could easily have passed it off as science fiction where it would belong legally and technically. It is this oversight that is troubling...when scientists fail to separate facts from fiction and publish their unsolicited opinions.
 
justintime said:
What that proves is scientists are rather inept at detecting fraud...
And yet no one does it better. Funny how that works.

or that scientists protect their profession by downplaying how common science fraud is in the scientific community.
There's no evidence supporting that interpretation.

It also points to why the role of the press and the public in exposing scientific and medical fraud in becoming increasingly critical in the interest of public safety and to reign in scientific fraud.
There's no evidence supporting that interpretation.

It was naive to believe science is self-correcting
Yet science is doing all the correcting. You can't present ONE example of a scientific fraud discovered by a non-scientist.

now that the evidence to the contrary is shedding light on just how common science fraud is.
Right--it's less than 1% of 1% in the medical field, as was demonstrated up-thread.

Your other post has no bearing on what I'm talking about, and falls into the trap of confusing mere opinion and professional opinion--two very different concepts. It's akin to confusing a skateboard with a Saturn V rocket; after all, both are modes of transportation, right?
 
Here is a link to the top 10 science hoaxes. You will also find top 10 science mistakes and top 10 science feuds.
Top 10 Science Hoaxes
http://science.discovery.com/strange-science/10-science-hoaxes.htm

<snip>
So, the top 10 science hoaxes. I was sort of expecting these to be modern examples of fraud, perpetrated by scientists - and fooling other scientists. Some of them aren't very modern. Few of them involve scientists.

1. An amateur archaeologist fooled a paleontologist 100 years ago. The hoax was discovered by scientists 60 years ago.
2. From 1999, so this one is at least recent. A magazine was fooled (by a farmer cementing bits of fossil together), and scientists demonstrated that the 'discovery' was a fake. By February 2000, the magazine had begun an investigation and in 2002 there were papers published that identified the true origin of parts of the fossil.
3. El Chupacabra. Wait, what? How is this a science hoax?
4. Someone apparently convinced 18th century doctors they'd given birth to rabbits. I'm not sure that the credulity of quacks in the 1700s has much relevance to modern science.
5. Barnum's mermaid. A 19th century showman attracted customers by means of a hoax. Not really "science fraud" is it?
6. The fake chess-playing machine from the 18th century, The Turk. More a magician's trick than a science fraud, imho.
7. 1990s. A cameraman pretended to have footage of an alien autopsy and Fox decided to broadcast some of the faked footage. Again - how is this "science fraud"?
8. 1995. A comedy show successfully trolls an MP. Science fraud? Er, no. Satire from comedians and gullibility from politicians.
9. Someone fooled the media into thinking there was a study that predicted blondes would 'become extinct'. 2002-2006
10. 1956. "...actually a satire of everyday American life" Not a hoax. Satire. There is a difference.
 
What that proves is scientists are rather inept at detecting fraud

And yet no one does it better. Funny how that works.
I dunno. At least in some cases, I think we have to give a nod to stage magicians like our own host here, Mr. James Randi. But scientists are clearly among the best, and in many cases, will unquestionably be the best. And in no cases will crackpots and promoters of woo ever do better, since they checked their critical thinking at the door! :)
 
xtifr said:
At least in some cases, I think we have to give a nod to stage magicians like our own host here, Mr. James Randi.
They're good at detecting fraud in general, yes. However, they have not, to my knowledge, uncovered any frauds in science, as defined in the thread. I may be wrong, but the burden is on the person making the claim (ie, justintime) to demonstrate it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom