science fraud is common place

To those who push this idea of fraud being commonplace in science: what is the end game here?

Suppose you utterly win this argument. What is it that you would desire us all to declare with you in solidarity?

Do you want us to join with you, declare science a fraud and ask for it to be defunded by all parties?

Do you want to make science illegal?

I mean I just want to know what your goal might be.

The objective/goal is to expose science for what it is not and and to see through it without rose-colored glasses for what it is.
Even distinguished physicists like Steven Hawking struggle with the basic concepts/principles of physics....
"Stephen said that when a bit of information falls into a black hole it is permanently lost to the outside.
But that violated the basic principles of physics.

The problem that upset me is that the most basic principle of physics—the principle that underpins everything including classical physics, thermodynamics, quantum mechanics, energy conservation, that physicists have believed for hundreds of years—is that information is never truly lost. It can be scrambled beyond recognition, but it is never completely erased."
http://old.richarddawkins.net/artic...shes-hawking-in-quarrel-over-quantum-quandary

That scientific research is used mainly for the self promotion of individuals and career advancements and not for the advancement of science.
The Economist weighs in on what’s wrong with science
http://thefinchandpea.com/2013/10/18/the-economist-weighs-in-on-whats-wrong-with-science/

The kind of scientists committing fraud are as the author discovers. "So contrary to my initial thoughts, the higher a person’s scientific position, the more likely he or she is to commit fraud!"

In short the higher the science maturity the more likely the person will commit fraud which explains why the majority of scientific fraud goes undetected because they are committed by mature professional scientists or seasoned criminally minded scientists.
http://blog.drwile.com/?p=10426

What about those scientists who have yet to achieve any relative success who have not committed fraud? It would be hasty to conclude underachievers in the scientific community lack the incentive to commit fraud or could that be the the reason they are unable to advance their careers?
 
The objective/goal is to expose science for what it is not and and to see through it without rose-colored glasses for what it is.

We have a method for exposing science when it gets stuff wrong.

We call it science.

The problem is when good science disproves bad science people can't fit their Woo in there. To do that you have to smear science as a concept.
 
We have a method for exposing science when it gets stuff wrong.

We call it science.

The problem is when good science disproves bad science people can't fit their Woo in there. To do that you have to smear science as a concept.


This depends on accepting the concept that "science" is not an entity, but rather is a method. Barring that, justintime and the others are playing silly word games and making content-free arguments.
 
And this is true. Certain elements in this discussion are falsely creating the image the science is.... well this thing that is doing stuff.

It isn't.
 
This Ganymede pun refers to me and is a misquote. I said people on Ganymede are also humanoid due to the fact that life is created by the supernova and is being dispersed by the supernova explosion.

Maybe misquoted but no less nonsensical, unless you're joking.
 
This Ganymede pun refers to me and is a misquote. I said people on Ganymede are also humanoid due to the fact that life is created by the supernova and is being dispersed by the supernova explosion.

So it's still a bunch of nonsense without merit? Alright then.
 
This Ganymede pun refers to me and is a misquote. I said people on Ganymede are also humanoid due to the fact that life is created by the supernova and is being dispersed by the supernova explosion.

I don't mean to be thick, but might you be so kind as to identify the "pun" in the statement, "And humans are form Ganymede"? Thanks.
 
We have a method for exposing science when it gets stuff wrong.

We call it science.

The problem is when good science disproves bad science people can't fit their Woo in there. To do that you have to smear science as a concept.

There are several studies that exposes the "The Myth of the Self-Correcting Nature of Science."

It will therefore not come as a major surprise that peer reviewers are also not very successful in uncovering scientific fraud. Even the most reputable journals appear to accept articles that contain glaring inconsistencies overlooked by reviewers.

And just how unscientific are scientists in their approach to fellow scientists. Shockingly, science is based on trust not scientific method as the following paragraph will reveal.

So how can we explain the failure of the self-correcting processes of science? One major reason is that science is based on trust. As already mentioned, scientists do not expect their colleagues to falsify their data and therefore do not look for signs of fraud when reading manuscripts or articles. This is probably the reason why hardly any fraud cases are discovered by the peer review process. It is only in extreme cases of data patterns that are simply too good to be true that fraud is considered as a possibility.
http://pps.sagepub.com/content/7/6/670.full

The brightest minds are recruited by financial institution and engineering conglomerates where there are tangible results and rewards for the individual careers. Only third and fourth tier candidates apply for science. Even here they have to compete for research grants and have to produce results quickly or lose funding and public interest. Scientists are forced to pander to the public's imagination by producing science fiction literally or embellishing their research along similar lines with sensational announcements of breakthrough discoveries or inventions. The stuff that science fiction is make of.

Unfortunately the public are able to separate facts from fiction and do not see the justification for millions of dollars spent on research that struggles to produce the same results as those of a creative science fiction writer and ruining a titillating experience at the end.

It doesn't help when skeptics are defending such fraudulent behavior and are as much in denial as the scientific community is over how common fraud is the sciences. The same scientific methodology is now used to systematically promote fraud and once again the methodology is being proven ineffective because it only perpetuates fraud like it did in past research or we would not be questioning it today.
 
We still have no working definition of what "science fraud" is. That would be a starting point before discussing it.
 
justintime said:
There are several studies that exposes the "The Myth of the Self-Correcting Nature of Science."
Funny how you can't present any. At best, you've shown that science self-corrects slowly.

And just how unscientific are scientists in their approach to fellow scientists.
Speaking as a scientist, it depends on the scientist. I trust people based on their knowledge and ability to apply it. However, in a group that includes a few tens of thosuands of people, there's obviously going to be all sorts of variation. The general rule of thumb, however, is "Trust but verify."

The brightest minds are recruited by financial institution and engineering conglomerates where there are tangible results and rewards for the individual careers. Only third and fourth tier candidates apply for science.
There is no way this can possibly be demonstrated.

Scientists are forced to pander to the public's imagination by producing science fiction literally or embellishing their research along similar lines with sensational announcements of breakthrough discoveries or inventions. The
That's funny. I've never been preasured to do any of that. Could it be you're not really talking about scientists here?

It doesn't help when skeptics are defending such fraudulent behavior and are as much in denial as the scientific community is over how common fraud is the sciences.
I'm not in denial. I've given due consideration to your sources. They are worthless. Since you've been unable to present any rigorous data to support your conclusion, I can rationally dismiss it--and cannot rationally accept it.

The fact that you find such a thought process incomprehensible demonstrates that you are not qualified to identify fraud in science.

Perpetual Student said:
Welcome to my ignore list.
Probably a wise move. Trakar is one of the better examples of why one can't merely use the specific words to determine of someone is being polite or not.
 
We still have no working definition of what "science fraud" is. That would be a starting point before discussing it.

You can just as easily say we don't have a working definition of scientific method because all that does is perpetuate fraud.
 
OK, I give up! If an auto mechanic is a scientist, then science fraud is commonplace.
While that was funny, it also was insightful.

If you define something as "doing science", or say somebody is "using science", and they are engaged in a fraud, is that "scientific fraud"? It's not a flippant question.

If not, then what is "scientific fraud"? How can you even know how common "something" is, if you can't define what "it" is?
 
You can just as easily say we don't have a working definition of scientific method because all that does is perpetuate fraud.

Funny how you've yet to present a single example of a fraud committed in science that wasn't discovered by non-scientists.

Also funny how you referenced Creation.com without irony. If you can do that, you have no business talking about fraud. You've demonstrated that you are incapable of identifying it.
 
We have a method for exposing science when it gets stuff wrong.

We call it science.

That assumes that it is "science" that is "getting stuff wrong". Isn't fraud a completely different thing than scientific error? And fraud by definition means the intent is to fool people, or to get ahead, it is done for a reason. It is not the same as a mistake, an error, or doing science poorly.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom