science fraud is common place

:rolleyes: Whatever...

You were the one who snarkily initiated this exchange with the suggestion that my post was not in context. I demonstrated the context (which you acknowledged) but then still attempted to float the impression that it was my wrong rather than acknowledge your own error. Now, you misattribute my post to Travis and continue the snark while rolling your eyes like a spoiled prepubescent school girl?
 
Do you think that, when an auto mechanic must discover that some exhaust valve is not operating, he is doing science?

He may well use scientific method for that...nearly all diagnosis is thesis, test, confirm thesis or discard and try again.

Will he make a ground breaking discovery??
Unlikely tho there is an off chance something might be revealed about % of combustion of fuel that would warrant further analysis by an appropriate arm of science...it's a bloody important field.
 
He may well use scientific method for that...nearly all diagnosis is thesis, test, confirm thesis or discard and try again.

Will he make a ground breaking discovery??
Unlikely tho there is an off chance something might be revealed about % of combustion of fuel that would warrant further analysis by an appropriate arm of science...it's a bloody important field.

OK, I give up! If an auto mechanic is a scientist, then science fraud is commonplace.
 
OK, I give up! If an auto mechanic is a scientist, then science fraud is commonplace.

black and white, either/or extremism, if this is your preferential filter for categorizing and understanding the world, it explains why you seem to exhibit so many inaccurate and confused conceptualizations of reality.
 
black and white, either/or extremism, if this is your preferential filter for categorizing and understanding the world, it explains why you seem to exhibit so many inaccurate and confused conceptualizations of reality.

Welcome to my ignore list.
 
Are you totally humorless?
That does seem to be a shortcoming of many.

I thought the mechanic thing was brilliant. I can think of a dozen more scenarios where it it's science involved, and fraud involved, then it's scientific fraud.
 
Of course rather than distrust the science of fixing a car, people tend to distrust mechanics after they find out they got ripped off.

Which is what the OP is talking about. It's not distrust of science, it's what certain scientists, their employers, and reporters are trying to sell us, that is what is distrusted.
 
To yet again re-reiterate a concept that Woo Slingers need to have pounded into them... science is a methodology, not a position.

Science is not an organization or a group or a political party or a secret society. It's not out to get your Woo in the way you think it is. It is simply a framework of rules and standards that is trying to give up the most accurate representation of how the world we live in operates, a world in which your Woo doesn't exist.
 
To those who push this idea of fraud being commonplace in science: what is the end game here?

Suppose you utterly win this argument. What is it that you would desire us all to declare with you in solidarity?

Do you want us to join with you, declare science a fraud and ask for it to be defunded by all parties?

Do you want to make science illegal?

I mean I just want to know what your goal might be.
 
OK, I give up! If an auto mechanic is a scientist, then science fraud is commonplace.

Talk about illogical extrapolation. Any such fraud isn't in the science, but in the business model.

Why don't you go after the "maximize profits" business model, and blame the right source of the problem for once?
 
I thought the mechanic thing was brilliant. I can think of a dozen more scenarios where it it's science involved, and fraud involved, then it's scientific fraud.

It's terribly illogical.

The sun causes skin cancer, right? Where should we make that lead, according to your unwarranted extrapolation.

Some human, somewhere, engages in fraud, so all humans are fraudsters? Where does your sliding down the razor blade of logic stop here?
 
Talk about illogical extrapolation. Any such fraud isn't in the science, but in the business model.

Why don't you go after the "maximize profits" business model, and blame the right source of the problem for once?
Follow the thread; it was sarcasm -- a gag! Good grief!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom