science fraud is common place

So in response to rigorous analysis, we have a blog. We're supposed to assume it is rigorous because it's Scientific American, but it's a blog none the less.

Assuming the data are valid--and that's a HUGE assumption--it's for one country and one field. I can't speak to the country, but that field has enormous financial incentives for fraud. This is very different from fields such as chemistry, physics, astronomy, and portions of biology, where no such incentives exist. This is the opposite of such fields as materials science, geology, paleontology, and archaeology, where scientific fraud would actually cost you money. This means that we should expect the fraud rates to be AT LEAST proportionally lower.

The "study" also misrepresents fraud. Any researcher can tell you that when looking at data, the raw data needs to be cleaned up for analysis. When I write my reports about fossil finds, I don't include all the data. That's not fraud--it's an acknowledgement of the fact that not all the data are worth reporting. In my field, fragmentary remains with no diagnostic traits are irrelevant. I'll leave medicine to our local medical people, but I assume that, like every field, you can generally tell when the data are good--clear outliers indicate that there's a problem. What we are expected to accept, in fact, is that exercise of expertise and the formulation of expert opinions is fraud.

I'd also like to point out that the graphs as presented here are misleading. We don't know what the percentages are percentages OF, for one thing. Nor do we know the methods of these self-described surveys. Simply taking them at face value is, by itself, poor practice that no scientist should ever engage in--and justintime expects us to not only uncritically accept them, but to assume that these graphs represent vastly different fields based on nothing but his desire to believe.

justintime said:
You are entitled to your opinions but not to the facts.
The worst part of this statement is that you don't actually believe it.
 
Please note the above graphs only represents a survey on scientific frauds in medical faculties in the Flanders region of Belgium. Add to it the scientific fraud from all the advanced countries (US, EU, China, India etc.etc.) and across the scientific disciplines and the numbers can only be described as staggering.

Hilarious. Even when you have concrete data, you beg us to "please note" that you ALSO have totally-made-up non-data that's just STAGGERING.
 
Even though the link below list predatory publishers that researchers, scientists and academics should avoid dealing with. It will also be useful to the general public to know just how many publishers are involved in the business of scientific fraud. If you don't find the publisher you are looking for, they might be found in another list of Predatory Publishers.

Beall’s List of Predatory Publishers 2013

In both cases, we recommend that researchers, scientists, and academics avoid doing business with these publishers and journals. Scholars should avoid sending article submissions to them, serving on their editorial boards or reviewing papers for them, or advertising in them. Also, tenure and promotion committees should give extra scrutiny to articles published in these journals, for many of them include instances of author misconduct.
http://scholarlyoa.com/2012/12/06/bealls-list-of-predatory-publishers-2013/
 
Is our faith in the High Priests of Science misplaced?
http://www.ted.com/conversations/18887/is_our_faith_in_the_high_pries.html


Read Epistemology
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epistemology


UN Climate Scientists Plead for Immunity from Criminal Prosecution
http://johnosullivan.wordpress.com/...plead-for-immunity-from-criminal-prosecution/

Scientific fraud: Is prosecution the answer?
http://www.the-scientist.com/?artic...Scientific-fraud--Is-prosecution-the-answer-/



Fraud is found across all the scientific disciplines. Because they are reported independently, it will be difficult to show a single study listing all the scientific frauds in all the disciplines. But when you add them all up, the numbers are described as alarming, shocking, skyrocketing, epidemic etc. etc.

Here are a few cases from different branches of science.
High-profile cases and modern technology are putting scientific deceit under the microscope.
http://www.theguardian.com/science/2012/sep/13/scientific-research-fraud-bad-practice

Here is another study which attempts to identify scientific fraud across the disciplines.
Scientific Fraud: Driven by the Culture of a Discipline?
http://news.ncbs.res.in/story/scientific-fraud-driven-culture-discipline

And here is fraud in another scientific discipline.
Paleontology Fraud & Hoaxes Wiki
http://paleontologyfraudhoaxes.wikia.com/wiki/Paleontology_Fraud_&_Hoaxes_Wiki

In other words, no citations, no data, no evidence, some references to general materials.

Nothing substantial, please try a little harder.

Show soem actual hard data, if you can, please avoid editorials and fluff pieces.

the piltdown man has what relevance to current science fraud?

Hmmm?
 
I don't think it's the people, but the system, wich makes them corrupt.
The hard competition, the need for publication in journals every month, the reputation of the university, the money, coming from companies or politicians with their own intrests, they want to keep their title, keep their job, keep their reputation, make careers etc.

Knowledge must only be 'because of wanting to know'. And that's it. No conflict with other intrests: just the enterprise of science, because of the beauty of this interprise.
No pressure, no deadlines, no conlfict of intrests only: silent thinking and studying and testing, and maybe, when we are lucky: discovering something new. But that's about 'having luck'.


Diederick Stapel, a scientist, said it: the system in universities is not good for scientists: the pressure is too high and people make mistakes: they invent data, to make it look nice for publication. They don't like critical thinkers (against current scientific hypothesis)
That's not good for society and not good at all for science.

The big problem is: scientists are sometimes only long goal driven. And it's the only goal they have. So they don't want to hear: it's wrong. Mr. Stapel states that this is a problem.
 
Last edited:
Now we have the ever weak argument by youtube video.

How about data and actual citations?


Strange underlying assumption: you cannot provide true conclusions based on data in a documentary where scientists are witnessing fraud in science, because the documentary is posted on Youtube?

That's a fallacy, Dancing David.

I think the documentary is convincing enough for people who also like to be critical of "science'' and scientists and not only of ideas of ordinary people.
And a lot of youtubevideos provide accurate data, evidence and information: NASA video's, educational youtubevideos from professors giving a lecture, tutorial video's etc. So, it's not because "it's a youtubevideo' that it is not informative.
 
Last edited:
Diederick Stapel, a scientist, said it: the system in universities is not good for scientists: the pressure is too high and people make mistakes: they invent data, to make it look nice for publication. They don't like critical thinkers (against current scientific hypothesis)
That's not good for society and not good at all for science.

I guess big fraud didi was talking about himself.

The big problem is: scientists are sometimes only long goal driven. And it's the only goal they have. So they don't want to hear: it's wrong. Mr. Stapel states that this His a problem.

just corrected this for you
 
Last edited:
A smaller percentage of fraud in a small community like the scientific community versus the same percentage applied to the general public, the order of magnitude of fraud is proportionally higher in the scientific community.

The proportion of damage cause by scientific fraud is also much higher relative to the general public.

OMG, you are fraudulent here yourself!
You just threw away any believability that you might have thought you had.
 
OMG, you are fraudulent here yourself!
You just threw away any believability that you might have thought you had.

You don't have to believe you just have to accept scientific fraud in rampant, more common place than expected of a discipline that prides itself for self-correcting.

It it more than a few bad apples. People don't realize how corrupt science is. Scientific fraud is prevalent across all scientific disciplines. To deny it is a public disservice.
 
I don't think it's the people, but the system, wich makes them corrupt.
The hard competition, the need for publication in journals every month, the reputation of the university, the money, coming from companies or politicians with their own intrests, they want to keep their title, keep their job, keep their reputation, make careers etc.

Knowledge must only be 'because of wanting to know'. And that's it. No conflict with other intrests: just the enterprise of science, because of the beauty of this interprise.
No pressure, no deadlines, no conlfict of intrests only: silent thinking and studying and testing, and maybe, when we are lucky: discovering something new. But that's about 'having luck'...

So conspiracy, delusion and sour grapes all rolled up into one?!

Sounds like you tried to save money buying the "party favors."
 
And a lot of youtubevideos provide accurate data, evidence and information: NASA video's, educational youtubevideos from professors giving a lecture, tutorial video's etc. So, it's not because "it's a youtubevideo' that it is not informative.
YouTube videos from NASA aren't suspect because they are from a reputable source and they are factual. YouTube videos coming from non-reputable sources with no facts are suspect.
 
Some nice graphs that is easy on the eyes even if they are troubling for science/scientists.

Spring (and Scientific Fraud) Is Busting Out All Over(Spring (May 2, 2013)

http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/talking-back/files/2013/05/graphic2-for-blog3.jpg
Summaries of a survey on scientific fraud in medical faculties in the Flanders region of Belgium


Image Sources: from an English-language version of “Science Fraud: The Hard Figures” published in EOS‘s April issue.

http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/talking-back/files/2013/05/graphic-8.jpg

http://blogs.scientificamerican.com...and-scientific-fraud-is-busting-out-all-over/


The response rate for this survey was 12.6% (or less), which makes the results unscientific and uninterpretable. Furthermore, a survey of medical researchers in Flanders is hardly generalizable to the population of scientists in all fields worldwide.
 
Last edited:
Please note the above graphs only represents a survey on scientific frauds in medical faculties in the Flanders region of Belgium. Add to it the scientific fraud from all the advanced countries (US, EU, China, India etc.etc.) and across the scientific disciplines and the numbers can only be described as staggering.


What is staggering is your innumeracy.
 
Still the practitioners and institutions of science are accused of going beyond mere ambition in the eternal quest for knowledge. Our researchers pressured by the need to produce are venturing beyond the boundaries of honest science into the forbidden territory of science fraud.

Worst cases are evolutionism and the idea of anthropogenic "global warming(TM)".

Particularly in the United States, when something is absolutely resistant to being figured logically, you follow the money, thus in the case of Algor seeking to become a billionaire with that Chicago carbon exchange.

The opposite example and the main hero of this sleazy story is Vladimir Putin who, apparently got a number of Russia's best hackers together in a room and ordered them to blast their way into that East Anglia email database and spread to the four winds whatever they might find there.

Боже храни Владимирa Путина!
 
Worst cases are evolutionism and the idea of anthropogenic "global warming(TM)".

Particularly in the United States, when something is absolutely resistant to being figured logically, you follow the money, thus in the case of Algor seeking to become a billionaire with that Chicago carbon exchange.

The opposite example and the main hero of this sleazy story is Vladimir Putin who, apparently got a number of Russia's best hackers together in a room and ordered them to blast their way into that East Anglia email database and spread to the four winds whatever they might find there.

Боже храни Владимирa Путина!

And here would be an appropriate place to mention the sad state of education in many parts of the world.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom