science fraud is common place

wrs said:
Where do you find me angry?
Your refusal to actually address any of the myriad of issues raised concerning your arguments. It appears to be entirely emotionally driven. It can't be driven by logic or data, as your arguments have neither.

You quoted and addressed my original hypothesis here here by rejecting it on the basis of the redacted paper data.

Are you now no longer rejecting it on this basis but on some other?
Please re-read my arguments. Also, please understand that it is perfectly possible--and in my opinion advisable--to arive at a conclusion via multiple chains of reasoning. The fact that all of hte data thus far provided in this thread regarding the actual topic are against you is one line of reasoning by which we can arive at the conclusion that you don't have a leg to stand on. The fact that your arguments, taken by themselves, amount to nothing more than unsubstantiated hypotheses is another. The fact that you so regularly err on basic information on the topics you discuss is another. Accepting any of these in no way necessitates a rejection of any of the rest.
 
Your refusal to actually address any of the myriad of issues raised concerning your arguments. It appears to be entirely emotionally driven. It can't be driven by logic or data, as your arguments have neither.

I am amazed at your seeming ability to draw conclusions such as this without merit and then write stuff like this:



Please re-read my arguments. Also, please understand that it is perfectly possible--and in my opinion advisable--to arive at a conclusion via multiple chains of reasoning. The fact that all of hte data thus far provided in this thread regarding the actual topic are against you is one line of reasoning by which we can arive at the conclusion that you don't have a leg to stand on. The fact that your arguments, taken by themselves, amount to nothing more than unsubstantiated hypotheses is another. The fact that you so regularly err on basic information on the topics you discuss is another. Accepting any of these in no way necessitates a rejection of any of the rest.

Your spelling is in general, not very good. I am very willing to concede to errors in my thinking and my writing. The fact that I make errors doesn't invalidate my thought process nor do I think does it for you.

What data have been provided in this thread which supports your position other than the redacted paper data?

Then as to the facts that I have provided in support of my hypothesis, I guess you haven't read any of the linked articles because they suggest my position is far more tenable than yours.
 
I am thinking of using a fake ID to get drinks underage. I am also thinking of selling a fake as the real thing. Both of those types of fraud would be ongoing until detected.
.

And that has what bearing in context, committing fraud in a scientific publication will get you fired from your employer and likely never employed again as a researcher. How does that compare to your example.

Don't try drinking on a false ID in my town, they bust quite a few who try, hundreds.
 
Scientists have positioned themselves as the modern day high priest and therefore immune from any prosecution.
Nice ********, and your source for this is what?
They also promoted their discipline as the only reliable way to arrive at the facts..ie the scientific method.
You have another method that works, please do tell us about it and its success.
Having raised the bar they are now complicit in scientific amnesty for the profession when the appearance of fraud is becoming evermore prevalent in the scientific community.
More *******, when did this happens , exactly, please do tell us about the alleged amnesty. Or did you make it up?
It hasn't risen to the level of organized crime but as a unified body the viability must be quite appealing to the scientists. It is quite obvious from the attempts made here by members of the scientific community to absolve themselves semantically, statistically, offensively or through denial that fraud plagues their profession.
If you can't show actual data then ******** does not suffice.

What is this incidence of fraud?
That science fraud is common place is not a misnomer and the poorly mounted defense of their profession stems from an arrogance or naivety that they were immune from public scrutiny or criticism because they successfully hid behind 'science' with their esoteric high flung dung until it hit the ceiling and now has caught everyone's attention. :crowded:

More ******** , when you lack data you just extemporize some nonsense.

So your data is what exactly?
 
Then as to the facts that I have provided in support of my hypothesis, I guess you haven't read any of the linked articles because they suggest my position is far more tenable than yours.

Hi, why don't you just spell out what they say, I usually can quote my sources. make it easy for us to see your actual data and share it.

I don't think you mean to hand wave, but what is the data?
 
Hi, why don't you just spell out what they say, I usually can quote my sources. make it easy for us to see your actual data and share it.

I don't think you mean to hand wave, but what is the data?

I read the OP and it allows for a lot more than just academic papers. That is where I started coming at this from. Now what happens here is that Dinwar appears to be coming at it here from the pile of redacted papers and is satisfied to stay in that small domain of reality. I was not.

Perpetual Student is allowing that corporate fraud is fairly rampant. He doesn't consider that scientific fraud. I do as long as it involves scientific methods and scientists are involved. I first tried to provide support for the notion that fraud is common place in humanity and I think that is accepted by most but I don't have anyone agreeing to what commonplace is.

I didn't start the thread and so I didn't make up the title. I think that dishonesty would better serve the discussion than fraud.

I will leave it there. I am off this thread.
 
wrs said:
Your spelling is in general, not very good.
Errors in spelling have no demonstrable correlation with errors in reasoning.

I know my spelling sucks. I work on it. This has nothing to do with the topic at hand, and is in fact yet another attempt by you to avoid the actual conversation.

What data have been provided in this thread which supports your position other than the redacted paper data?
That alone is far more data than you've provided. I also have your inability to actually demonstrate any levels of fraud whatever. Then there's your constant re-defining of fraud (which now includes child molestation and the discovery of rare side effects in medical trials) and what counts as scientific fraud (now including corporate fraud to some--as always with you--unknown degree). All of these support my conclusion that your argument is not substantiated and can therefore be dismissed.

Then as to the facts that I have provided in support of my hypothesis, I guess you haven't read any of the linked articles because they suggest my position is far more tenable than yours.
Should be no trouble to quote those parts with actual data in them, then, eh?
 
I read the OP and it allows for a lot more than just academic papers. That is where I started coming at this from. Now what happens here is that Dinwar appears to be coming at it here from the pile of redacted papers and is satisfied to stay in that small domain of reality. I was not.

Perpetual Student is allowing that corporate fraud is fairly rampant. He doesn't consider that scientific fraud. I do as long as it involves scientific methods and scientists are involved. I first tried to provide support for the notion that fraud is common place in humanity and I think that is accepted by most but I don't have anyone agreeing to what commonplace is.

I didn't start the thread and so I didn't make up the title. I think that dishonesty would better serve the discussion than fraud.

I will leave it there. I am off this thread.


Hmm, so your claim that there were papers talking about levels of fraud in science were specious and now you leave. Okay dokay.

I has hoped it was more than arm waving.
 
A smaller percentage of fraud in a small community like the scientific community versus the same percentage applied to the general public, the order of magnitude of fraud is proportionally higher in the scientific community.

Words fail me. Don't we learn about proportions in high school ?
 
Originally Posted by justintime View Post
Scientists have positioned themselves as the modern day high priest and therefore immune from any prosecution.

Dancing David wrote: Nice ********, and your source for this is what?
Is our faith in the High Priests of Science misplaced?
http://www.ted.com/conversations/18887/is_our_faith_in_the_high_pries.html

You have another method that works, please do tell us about it and its success.
Read Epistemology
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epistemology

Dancing David wrote: More *******, when did this happens , exactly, please do tell us about the alleged amnesty. Or did you make it up?
UN Climate Scientists Plead for Immunity from Criminal Prosecution
http://johnosullivan.wordpress.com/...plead-for-immunity-from-criminal-prosecution/

Scientific fraud: Is prosecution the answer?
http://www.the-scientist.com/?artic...Scientific-fraud--Is-prosecution-the-answer-/

Dancing David wrote: If you can't show actual data then ******** does not suffice.
What is this incidence of fraud?
More ******** , when you lack data you just extemporize some nonsense.
So your data is what exactly?

Fraud is found across all the scientific disciplines. Because they are reported independently, it will be difficult to show a single study listing all the scientific frauds in all the disciplines. But when you add them all up, the numbers are described as alarming, shocking, skyrocketing, epidemic etc. etc.

Here are a few cases from different branches of science.
High-profile cases and modern technology are putting scientific deceit under the microscope.
http://www.theguardian.com/science/2012/sep/13/scientific-research-fraud-bad-practice

Here is another study which attempts to identify scientific fraud across the disciplines.
Scientific Fraud: Driven by the Culture of a Discipline?
http://news.ncbs.res.in/story/scientific-fraud-driven-culture-discipline

And here is fraud in another scientific discipline.
Paleontology Fraud & Hoaxes Wiki
http://paleontologyfraudhoaxes.wikia.com/wiki/Paleontology_Fraud_&_Hoaxes_Wiki
 
Last edited:
I see a bunch of alleged incidents, appeals to a variety of questionable sources, some extractions from context, and no justification at all for the claim of "common place".

Showing one person misbehaved does not demonstrate misconduct. Ditto for 2 or 3. "Common place" means most scientists are frauds, and I see no evidence for that. For instance, my cell phone works despite claims from audiophiles that the sampling theorem is flawed, my car starts despite claims that magnetic fields don't work the way the are, the earth stays in its orbit despite electric universe theories, and planet x is still missing.

N.B. Please not which way "science" voted on each of those.
 
UN Climate Scientists Plead for Immunity from Criminal Prosecution
http://johnosullivan.wordpress.com/...plead-for-immunity-from-criminal-prosecution/

That link leads to a right-wing global-warming-denialist complaining about totally routine UN treaty boilerplate. It's normal for diplomats to have this sort of immunity---that's so, if Robert Mugabe gets mad at an anti-AIDS initiative, or the Greeks get mad at the World Bank, or Myanmar decides UNICEF is exploiting them, they can't start by filing a civil lawsuit against any random UNAIDS/WB/UNICEF employee. A tiny detail of treaty-wording left UNFCCC employees open to this sort of risk, so it's being fixed.

Nothing to do with science, justintime.

This is not a promising way to start your anti-science "evidence"---by falling for an attempted right-wing-noise-machine non-scandal meme. What's next? Was Benghazi a science-fraud coverup? Was Whitewater actually a cold-fusion-fraud coverup?

Fraud is found across all the scientific disciplines. Because they are reported independently, it will be difficult to show a single study listing all the scientific frauds in all the disciplines. But when you add them all up, the numbers are described as alarming, shocking, skyrocketing, epidemic etc. etc.

You didn't add them all up, did you?

And here is fraud in another scientific discipline.
Paleontology Fraud & Hoaxes Wiki
http://paleontologyfraudhoaxes.wikia.com/wiki/Paleontology_Fraud_&_Hoaxes_Wiki

That is a two-year-old abandoned Wiki consisting of a single page, filled with a single cut-and-paste operation performed by someone who doesn't know Wiki syntax. Not promising.

Most of the text-dump on that page, insofar as it's readable, appears to be discussion of mistakes and uncertainty---not frauds---in paleontology and/or anthropology and/or archaeology. Geez.

Maybe you should go back to refusing to present evidence for your claims, justintime. This attempt to present evidence is embarrassingly bad.
 
That link leads to a right-wing global-warming-denialist complaining about totally routine UN treaty boilerplate. It's normal for diplomats to have this sort of immunity---that's so, if Robert Mugabe gets mad at an anti-AIDS initiative, or the Greeks get mad at the World Bank, or Myanmar decides UNICEF is exploiting them, they can't start by filing a civil lawsuit against any random UNAIDS/WB/UNICEF employee. A tiny detail of treaty-wording left UNFCCC employees open to this sort of risk, so it's being fixed.

Nothing to do with science, justintime.

This is not a promising way to start your anti-science "evidence"---by falling for an attempted right-wing-noise-machine non-scandal meme. What's next? Was Benghazi a science-fraud coverup? Was Whitewater actually a cold-fusion-fraud coverup?



You didn't add them all up, did you?



That is a two-year-old abandoned Wiki consisting of a single page, filled with a single cut-and-paste operation performed by someone who doesn't know Wiki syntax. Not promising.

Most of the text-dump on that page, insofar as it's readable, appears to be discussion of mistakes and uncertainty---not frauds---in paleontology and/or anthropology and/or archaeology. Geez.

Maybe you should go back to refusing to present evidence for your claims, justintime. This attempt to present evidence is embarrassingly bad.
I have presented a lot more than verbal arguments against the status quo. These are published articles in the public domain not personal unsupported positions for arguments sake and labels such as left wing right wing have little to do with the facts.
You are entitled to your opinions but not to the facts.
 
Last edited:
I have presented a lot more than verbal arguments against the status quo. These are published articles in the public domain not personal unsupported positions for arguments sake and labels such as left wing right wing have little to do with the facts.
You are entitled to your opinions but not to the facts.


The irony in your claiming to use facts to defend virtually any of your positions in this forum is palpable.

Actual facts have never stopped you from spouting BS.
 
Some nice graphs that is easy on the eyes even if they are troubling for science/scientists.

Spring (and Scientific Fraud) Is Busting Out All Over(Spring (May 2, 2013)

http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/talking-back/files/2013/05/graphic2-for-blog3.jpg
Summaries of a survey on scientific fraud in medical faculties in the Flanders region of Belgium


Image Sources: from an English-language version of “Science Fraud: The Hard Figures” published in EOS‘s April issue.

http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/talking-back/files/2013/05/graphic-8.jpg

http://blogs.scientificamerican.com...and-scientific-fraud-is-busting-out-all-over/
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Please note the above graphs only represents a survey on scientific frauds in medical faculties in the Flanders region of Belgium. Add to it the scientific fraud from all the advanced countries (US, EU, China, India etc.etc.) and across the scientific disciplines and the numbers can only be described as staggering.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom