Belz...
Fiend God
Since the general public are left out of the review process scientists should be held to a higher standard because they are reviewed by their peers.
Isn't that the whole point of the review process itself ?
Since the general public are left out of the review process scientists should be held to a higher standard because they are reviewed by their peers.
That is the percentage that got caught. What about those that escaped discovery such as the tons of paleontologist mentioned in the link I provided and those from other disciplines yet to be mentioned?
This is a test for scientists not a layman.
Actually the penalties are often simply being moved to a different church. That's a big reason why so many people are mad at the Catholic Church.1.) Priests are trained for 8 years in seminary that homosexuality and child abuse are sins that will send you to hell. The penalties in the current life are often career ending and in the child abuse case can mean jail time. Priests believe in the after life and respect the consequences in the current life as well.
Nope. Detection depends on the child victim being brave enough to come forward (something many adult victims have trouble doing), AND on the person they tell believing them (which may not happen if the confidant firmly believes that the priest can do no wrong).2.)Returns for the behavior are low and the chance of detection is fairly high.
That is probably a good idea, what would you consider it to be? Obviously it's something that would be noticed regularly since it's against the law. I would say around 1-2% would be commonplace but I would allow for as high as 6%. What would you think?
Erm. We have 'data' but it's not useful data for this case. Fraud detection is not even a proxy for fraud. Your methodology (!) is completely inappropriate.
Unless you have good cause to claim that researchers are not normal humans, then using normal human honesty as a baseline is reasonable. Please, do, make a case that it is not.
Actually the penalties are often simply being moved to a different church. That's a big reason why so many people are mad at the Catholic Church.
You've obviously never had to deal with a lawyer. Courtrooms aren't about truth or falsehood, or about effective communication of ideas. They're about lawyers. I've met a number of scientists called as special witnesses, and the lawyers intentionally tried to trick them. You can be the most effective communicator in the world and look stupid under such conditions. PLus, it's a Catch-22: if the scientist uses laymans terms they're accused of not understanding their field, while if they use jargon the lawyers play on the jury's unwillingness to learn what the terms mean. It's a flaw in the legal system, NOT in science.justintime said:It is not the lawyers presenting the forensic evidence. They are the expert witnesses, experts and specialists in their field trained in forensic science and methods.
Which amounts to no punishment at all. The Roman Catholic Church shuffles priests around as a general practice, regardless fo wrongdoing. A priest who was a very good friend of my family told a cardinal who wanted to move him that he'd leave the priesthood if that happened--the man was in his late 80s and had done nothing wrong, the cardinal simply thought he was needed elsewhere.
When something is a part of your job, it does not count as a penalty. So a priest could do whatever they wanted, behind completely closed doors, intimidate the child they did it to, and suffer no penalties for it. In contrast, scientists are required to present their work openly, their biggest competators are encouraged both by journals (who like controversy, because it sells) and by the culture of the field to find any flaws they can, and the penalty for discovered fraud is the destruction of one's career.
I think it's safe to say that these are different situations.
Originally Posted by justintime
It is not the lawyers presenting the forensic evidence. They are the expert witnesses, experts and specialists in their field trained in forensic science and methods.
You've obviously never had to deal with a lawyer. Courtrooms aren't about truth or falsehood, or about effective communication of ideas. They're about lawyers. I've met a number of scientists called as special witnesses, and the lawyers intentionally tried to trick them. You can be the most effective communicator in the world and look stupid under such conditions. PLus, it's a Catch-22: if the scientist uses laymans terms they're accused of not understanding their field, while if they use jargon the lawyers play on the jury's unwillingness to learn what the terms mean. It's a flaw in the legal system, NOT in science..

You are correct in that the situations are different, which I touched on a bit, but either way it still supports the central argument I made...
Actually, no, you're supporting my argument, but you don't realize it.
Your argument has been that the rate of "normal people" for some trait should be the same as the rate of a selected sub-group.
So, is the rate of child molestation in the general population the same as it is within the priesthood? Or is the rate among priests different? You haven't presented any data to show that comparison, so you STILL have not given any reason for us to assume your reasoning has any validity.
And even if that were true in this specific instance, that is a specific instance. You would then have to go on to argue the general case.
Your argument, logically extended, is that the rate of any given trait (fraud and pedophilia are the two examples so far) for any given subgroup of humanity, selected by occupation, is identical. You have not shown any data to lead us to believe that this holds true in the speciifc cases for scientists or priests, nor have you given any reason to assume the general case is true.
Rather, what is much more likely, is that some fields will have more fraud, some less, and simply assuming some rate (which, by the way, you still haven't given what the rate is for the general population) applies across the board is niave.
Self-selection simply means that the people in a subgroup choose to be in that subgroup, for one reason or another. In specaking of professions, this means that people in a certain profession will have a statistical tendency for various traits, that is NOT reflective of the population as a whole.
Professinal football players are more fit, on avergae, than the average person.
Surgeons have steadier hands and higher manual dexterity. People who dislike details and prefer physical activity to mental activity are unlikely to become scientists. People who don't believe in God don't become priests. These differences mean that teh subgroup is NOT representative of the group as a whole, and that's the fallacious argument you've been making from the get-go. YOu are assuming, based on no reason whatsoever, that scientists perfectly reflect humanity in general.
Actually the penalties are often simply being moved to a different church. That's a big reason why so many people are mad at the Catholic Church.
Nope. Detection depends on the child victim being brave enough to come forward (something many adult victims have trouble doing), AND on the person they tell believing them (which may not happen if the confidant firmly believes that the priest can do no wrong).
The OP has certainly put the people of science on notice and the scientists on defense. The general public have finally caught on to their esoteric high flung dung and raised the ceiling a bit higher. Scientists no longer have a free ride and are under public scrutiny. Call that progress. Even ordinary people are endowed with innate intelligence and natural selection conferred on them an evolutionary advantage by giving them a reproductive advantage.What I see on this thread is that there are a lot of people reacting to the suggestion that science is subject to the same human frailty that bankers, priests, salespeople, and many other humans are. In particular, we are supposed to believe that science has somehow been able to immunize itself against fraud and that these silly numbers about redacted papers are proof.
Sorry, color me not convinced.
Wouldn't it be better if the priests simply had their positions terminated, rather than being moved to a backwater church? Shouldn't abusers be denied working with people, period?What church you are at is very much part of your priestly career. So yes, moving to a backwater church is career ending and it's what I had in mind.
********. There's no statistics indicating that "most" sexual abuse survivors themselves become abusive. It's a myth, plain and simple.Most abused become abusers and thus, the priests victims go on to the population at large and become part of the more detectable group of abusers, assuming it's any more detectable in the general population for the same reasons.
I don't think so.
Yes if it's a large enough group that should be true.
No, I am not suggesting for the general case. I am suggesting for the fraud case. I use the priest example to demonstrate that priests are supposed to hold themselves to a higher standard whether or not detection led to punishment or not. Just as is the case for scientists that it's bad for the profession to commit fraud and that their entire work is predicated on the absence of fraud, so it is for priests and child molestation (maybe not homosexuality so much today). It should be unthinkable but obviously it isn't.
I am demonstrating that just because a person is expected to adhere to high standards and it's been drilled into them, doesn't mean that they aren't just as susceptible to that behavior and that in fact, it's commonplace.
You are correct that we would need to measure child molestation in the general population and in the priest population to know if it's occurrence is at the same level.
No, that isn't what I intend to do. What I am suggesting is that propensity to commit fraud is a commonplace trait in all of humanity and that it's not a function of profession. That is in opposition what is being argued by the No True Scotsman rationale that you and Dinwar and others are continuing to advance.
You are making an unjustified conclusion based on your opinion here. I would also consider child molestation by priests to fall into the category of fraud.
I agree with this but I wouldn't put propensity for fraud in that group of traits NOT reflective of the whole. I would put interest in problem solving as a trait I would find to be more prevalent in scientists than the population as a whole. I can easily agree with that and I am not ignorant of statistics.
Only while they are playing. Have many ex football players do you know? I find that those guys usually have really serious eating problems and that they are really more often overweight after they quit playing than the general population. They trained themselves to burn lot's of calories and so they consume them. Problem is, once they quit the training, they don't quit the consuming. That part is the harder habit to break. Training is an easy habit to break, overeating, not so much.
As a specific trait that you might dispute, let me ask you about sociopathy because it was mentioned by you up the thread. I have read that by some estimates, sociopaths amount to about 6% of the population. In that case, would you argue that science does not attract sociopaths in proportion and if so, why not?
Secondly, let's consider the motivation for fraud. I believe you are suggesting that the motivation for fraud is lower than normal in science.
You have suggested that there are factors mitigating fraud in science but how can you prove that those outweigh any factors that confer benefit? I think it has been claimed that money was a big factor for fraud in other fields (maybe not by you). I think we could agree that scientists are not excessively attracted by money unless it is in support of their work and to a degree, what they need for a comfortable lifestyle. So maybe with regard to getting money for grants, there would be a motivation for fraud among scientists at the same level as the general population. I don't see how you can argue against that. It's also a motivation given in the OP.
Another motivation given in the OP is public recognition. What scientist doesn't want this? Why do they publish if not at least in part for public recognition? What is the meaning of the saying, publish or perish? Is this not in itself a strong force motivating fraud?
I think it's up to you to prove that the mitigating factors outweigh the benefits of undiscovered fraud. To me, you haven't done so.
I realize that I started out with the premise that fraud is commonplace and I gave my percentages for what I thought that meant based on notice. As low as 1-2% and as high as 6% to be noticed.
What I see on this thread is that there are a lot of people reacting to the suggestion that science is subject to the same human frailty that bankers, priests, salespeople, and many other humans are. In particular, we are supposed to believe that science has somehow been able to immunize itself against fraud and that these silly numbers about redacted papers are proof.
Sorry, color me not convinced.
First of all, I hope you will agree that there are a large number of traits that scientists (because they are a large enough group) will statistically share with the human population at large. Let's see if I can name some you will agree with. How about, height, weight, hair color, eye color, shoe size, food preference, rate of alcoholism, rate of drug abuse, rate of infidelity to spouse for the married subset. How am I doing so far?
Only in your dreams, my friend. I assure you, scientists care nothing for what goes on on these forums, outside of the handful of members.justintime said:The OP has certainly put the people of science on notice and the scientists on defense.
Than you obviously aren't reading what has been written. You have presented a SPECIFIC hypothesis, and have been asked to support it. Your opponents have even gone so far as to tell you precisely how. You then got angry.wrs said:What I see on this thread is that there are a lot of people reacting to the suggestion that science is subject to the same human frailty that bankers, priests, salespeople, and many other humans are.
There's a quote from "The Princess Bride" that springs to mind...."Fraud" has a specific meaning, and you need to limit your analysis to that meaning. If you wish to discuss misconduct in general, that's entirely different. And usually irrelevant; I know of a few stratigraphers and paleontologists with police records due to wild parties at conferences, but who are also respected members of the scientific community--because in science, it's the publications and research that matter, not personal indescressions. Hell, my advisor was guilty of adultry and was still a damn fine researcher, respected all over the world.I would also consider child molestation by priests to fall into the category of fraud.
Precisely. I'm willing to entertain the idea that rates of fraud are much higher than rates of detected fraud--however, in science this means that I'm willing to consider what would be required to see if it's true, not that I'm going to act as if it's true. An unsubstantiated hypothesis is a potentially interesting area of research, not a conclusion of any sort.Hellbound said:No one is arguing against the possibility. But the possibility and the actuality are two very differnt things.
I never said anything about being moved to a backwater church. Additionally when we say that fraud ends a scientist's career we don't mean that they get stuck with a bad job, we mean they do not work as a scientist any more. At all. Their career isn't merely harmed, it's ended.What church you are at is very much part of your priestly career. So yes, moving to a backwater church is career ending and it's what I had in mind.
Abusers aren't easily detectable at all, in any subset of the population. There's very little ways for abuse to be detected aside from the victim coming forward, which is difficult to do because they've often been scared into silence by their abuser. There isn't any kind of regular oversight of the people who regularly interact with children (parents, for instance) that can catch when abuse is taking place.Most abused become abusers and thus, the priests victims go on to the population at large and become part of the more detectable group of abusers, assuming it's any more detectable in the general population for the same reasons.
Yep.Wouldn't it be better if the priests simply had their positions terminated, rather than being moved to a backwater church? Shouldn't abusers be denied working with people, period?
********. There's no statistics indicating that "most" sexual abuse survivors themselves become abusive. It's a myth, plain and simple.
Than you obviously aren't reading what has been written. You have presented a SPECIFIC hypothesis, and have been asked to support it. Your opponents have even gone so far as to tell you precisely how. You then got angry.
AT BEST you have an untested hypothesis, and now a repeated refusal to actually perform the test. In terms of a scientific discussion, the first bit renders your stance irrelevant and the latter renders it dishonest. Science has rules, and you don't get to refuse to play by them simply because you don't feel like it. Trust me, gathering data like I proposed is not unusual in science. It's actually a fairly easy job; nothing is activelly trying to kill you and you won't die simply from the environmetn you're working in, which puts it better than half the data-gathering I've done.
ETA: also, as someone else mentioned, most abuse victims do not become abusers (however it may be true that most abusers were themselves abused).