science fraud is common place

Furthermore, a self-selected and therefore biased survey of medical researchers in Flanders is hardly generalizable to the population of scientists in all fields worldwide.

A minor edit to highlight the irrationality.

Maartenn100 said:
The hard competition,
...which drastically increases the cost of fraud if discovered ,as well as the odds of it being discovered.

the need for publication in journals every month,
...which exists nowhere but your own mind.

the reputation of the university,
...which hinges on the integrity of the research staff, thus giving the administration a vested interest in ensuring integrity of its research staff.

the money,
....which doesn't exist. Seriously, look at how grant money is spent sometime--a huge chunk, often the majority, of the grant money goes to administrative costs. A lot of the rest goes towards paying grunts (aka grad students) to do the legwork. The researchers only get a small percentage of it--in the form of a line-item for their salary. And before you ask, this line-item is picked over pretty carefully, and often the agency granting the grant flat-out tells you what it'll be. So it's more or less impossible to give yourself a huge salary.

coming from companies or politicians with their own intrests,
...the implications of which you have yet to support. I'm a scientist working for a multinational corporation. Prove that my research is therefore fraudulent, or drop this line of nonsense. SOME fraud occurs, yes, but it's not as wide-spread as you imply.

they want to keep their title, keep their job, keep their reputation, make careers
...all of which gets completely destroyed at the merest hint of fraud.
 
....which doesn't exist. Seriously, look at how grant money is spent sometime--a huge chunk, often the majority, of the grant money goes to administrative costs. A lot of the rest goes towards paying grunts (aka grad students) to do the legwork. The researchers only get a small percentage of it--in the form of a line-item for their salary. And before you ask, this line-item is picked over pretty carefully, and often the agency granting the grant flat-out tells you what it'll be. So it's more or less impossible to give yourself a huge salary.

Yes, grant overhead (which doesn't even include salary overhead) is usually around 40%. Professors can generally only get "summer money", so at most 1/3 of their regular 9 month salary. Postdocs may be payed at most starting professor salary, and full time university researchers may be payed similarly to professors with the same level of experience - there aren't many of those, but I am one.
 
You don't have to believe you just have to accept scientific fraud in rampant, more common place than expected of a discipline that prides itself for self-correcting.

"You don't have to believe me, you just have to accept that what I postulate without evidence is totally true."
 
Which equivocation does not, of course, address the issue, or answer the question I have politely asked, that you have been ignoring.

You have been called on equivocating vocabulary before [...].

In which area of science does your expertise lie, that that is not patent to you?


JustinTime has been called on misrepresentation many times too, to put it charitably.
 
Many are. In paleontology in particular ametures can become quite important to the scientific process, both as formal reviewers and as researchers (that second, informal review process I keep mentioning).

What I've always found amusiing is that the people objecting to science have never found, to my knowledge, a single case of fraud. Every fraud they trot out as proof of science's failure was discovered by scientists.

[...].

Exactly. Like Piltdown Man, Lysenkoism and polywater (though polywater might better be described as error rather than misconduct).
 
Originally Posted by Dinwar View Post
Many are. In paleontology in particular ametures can become quite important to the scientific process, both as formal reviewers and as researchers (that second, informal review process I keep mentioning).

What I've always found amusiing is that the people objecting to science have never found, to my knowledge, a single case of fraud. Every fraud they trot out as proof of science's failure was discovered by scientists.

[...].
Public awareness of rampant scientific fraud is changing all that. That is why we see such a growing skepticism of science by the general public and why scientists today are held in such low esteem.

Even the US congress has declared science is nothing but quackery and science has no one to blame but the scientists engaging is fraud and quackery. The shine wore out decades ago.
 
justintime said:
Public awareness of rampant scientific fraud is changing all that.
In precisely the same manner that "public awareness" of the dangers of vaccination is changing vaccine rates.

Can you name one single example of scientific fraud that was discovered first by non-scientists? In every case you've presented thus far--every single one, bar none--the people who figured it out were scientists.

Never let the facts get in the way of a good story, though, eh? Why bother with actual research, investigation, and data analysis when mere assertion can carry the day, am I right?
 
John Jones said:
Exactly. Like Piltdown Man, Lysenkoism and polywater (though polywater might better be described as error rather than misconduct).

Not sure what you're driving at here. Piltdown Man was questioned from the very beginning, with many paleontologists rejecting it as a fraud. Lysenkoism was a political, not a scientific, issue, and was based on ideas that were even at the time outdated (Lamarckianism). I'm not very familiar with polywater, but from the Wiki page it sounds like a relatively minor issue that got blown completely out of proportion. The "scientific furor" sounds like pretty much SOP in science: someone proposes a radical new idea, it gets analyzed by a bunch of people, the results show what really is going on. In this case, it was contamination. In all three cases, scientists detected the error.
 
Public awareness of rampant scientific fraud is changing all that. That is why we see such a growing skepticism of science by the general public and why scientists today are held in such low esteem.

Even the US congress has declared science is nothing but quackery and science has no one to blame but the scientists engaging is fraud and quackery. The shine wore out decades ago.


To anyone who isn't already familiar with justintime's perfidy: Note the highlighted statement above, and ask him for links.
 
Not sure what you're driving at here. Piltdown Man was questioned from the very beginning, with many paleontologists rejecting it as a fraud. Lysenkoism was a political, not a scientific, issue, and was based on ideas that were even at the time outdated (Lamarckianism). I'm not very familiar with polywater, but from the Wiki page it sounds like a relatively minor issue that got blown completely out of proportion. The "scientific furor" sounds like pretty much SOP in science: someone proposes a radical new idea, it gets analyzed by a bunch of people, the results show what really is going on. In this case, it was contamination. In all three cases, scientists detected the error.


Piltdown Man is often held-up as a failure of the discipline of science. It wasn't until the 'fossils' were re-examined by scientists decades later that it was determined to be a fraud.

Lysenkoism was indeed a political issue. Politics in the Soviet Union declared it to be the most scientific theory. Soviet biological science fell behind the west because of this.

Polywater was exactly as you described it. Cold fusion looks like another example.

In all three cases I mentioned, the discipline of science demonstrated its self-correcting nature.

Perfect? No.

Better than any other known discipline for discovering the laws of the physical universe? Yes.
 
ETA About polywater: The burning question at the time was: If polywater exists, why isn't all water polywater?

I suspect this was the basis of Kurt Vonnegut's novel Cat's Cradle.
 
John Jones said:
In all three cases I mentioned, the discipline of science demonstrated its self-correcting nature.

Perfect? No.

Better than any other known discipline for discovering the laws of the physical universe? Yes.
Ah, okay. It almost seemed like you were presenting them as hoaxes/frauds that science didn't detect, so I was a bit confused.
 
Public awareness of rampant scientific fraud is changing all that. That is why we see such a growing skepticism of science by the general public and why scientists today are held in such low esteem.

Even the US congress has declared science is nothing but quackery and science has no one to blame but the scientists engaging is fraud and quackery. The shine wore out decades ago.

Without evidence, this is simply another lie.
 
The self-correcting nature of science was designed to give sloppy science a pass and that is how science/scientists have managed to avoid public scrutiny. Once the quackery of science was exposed. There was no cover for the absent minded professor or eccentric scientist. Scientists who commit fraud are like any common criminal who expect to profit from their deception.
 
I have no doubt that fraud exists in science as it does in all aspects of human activity.
However, for clarification, is the author of the OP and those supporting his/her position claiming that fraud in science is more prevalent than fraud in other professional activities like, politics, finance, big corporations, law, accounting, medicine, engineering, retail stores, banking, etc.?
 
The self-correcting nature of science was designed to give sloppy science a pass and that is how science/scientists have managed to avoid public scrutiny. Once the quackery of science was exposed. There was no cover for the absent minded professor or eccentric scientist. Scientists who commit fraud are like any common criminal who expect to profit from their deception.




Designed when? Designed by whom? What quackery of science has been exposed?

Do you have any non-lies to support that claim?

Please understand that when I accuse you of presenting lies, I'm not just saying you don't know what you're talking about. The casual observer can tell you don't know what you're talking about.

When I accuse you of presenting lies, I mean that you are intentionally presenting falsehoods as fact in an effort to deceive people, and convince them you are right.

I can quote any number of dictionaries if you continue to be obtuse.
:D
 
Last edited:
I have no doubt that fraud exists in science as it does in all aspects of human activity.
However, for clarification, is the author of the OP and those supporting his/her position claiming that fraud in science is more prevalent than fraud in other professional activities like, politics, finance, big corporations, law, accounting, medicine, engineering, retail stores, banking, etc.?

I think their implied claim is that the discipline of science should be held to a higher standard than most of those disciplines you mentioned.

Medicine is a science, BTW, and engineering is applied science.
 
Public awareness of rampant scientific fraud is changing all that. That is why we see such a growing skepticism of science by the general public and why scientists today are held in such low esteem.

1Even the US congress has declared science is nothing but quackery and science has no one to blame but the scientists engaging is fraud and quackery. The shine wore out decades ago.

The self-correcting nature of science was designed to give sloppy science a pass and that is how science/scientists have managed to avoid public scrutiny. 2Once the quackery of science was exposed. There was no cover for the absent minded professor or eccentric scientist. Scientists who commit fraud are like any common criminal who expect to profit from their deception.

1. Without evidence, this is a lie. You often do this. I would like you to support this claim, so that I may read and see if it has any merit at all, or is like so many other bogus claims you have made.

2. When do you think this happened, and under what circumstances? Without evidence, this is a lie. You often do this. I would like you to support this claim, so that I may read and see if it has any merit at all, or is like so many other bogus claims you have made.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom