science fraud is common place

Finally science fraud explained in a documentary for the unsuspecting public. It explains the hows, whys and just how common place scientific fraud is. The future trends in scientific fraud are not so encouraging because it is trending up.

Science Fraud​

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=lKbdzGTM5cM
Thank god for science is all I can say. It works and progress is made every-single-day. You see, there is generally no point in being dishonest in science, because the results will fins you out, eventually. Example: Andrew Wakefield.

If science has so much fraud, the world wouldnt look the same way it does now. Most scientific fraud is espoused by non scientific snake oil salesmen. Like magnetic bracelets and crystal healing and all the gumpf.

Ask your self where we would be without it (science). Think about the huge advances over the last 10 years in say:

1. Cancer Research. People survive much longer now. This is directly due to scientific research in a very complicated field.
2. HIV. Its now possible to live with the disease. Its not the death scentence it once was.
3. Computing and electronics. Your 100 Meg hard drive is now 1 Terra byte which is one small example. What some people dont realise is the huge amount of technology innovation that is required to mass produce electronic products. Take a Smart Phone, the technology required to build these in enormous numbers if probably more impressive than the phone itself.

See google:


2001 – The first draft of the human genome is completed.
2003 - Grigori Perelman presents proof of the Poincaré Conjecture.
2006 - Shinya Yamanaka generates first induced pluripotent stem cells
2010 – J. Craig Venter Institute creates the first synthetic genome for a bacterial cell.[5]
2010 - The Neanderthal Genome Project presented preliminary genetic evidence that interbreeding did likely take place and that a small but significant portion of Neanderthal admixture is present in modern non-African populations.[citation needed]
2012 - Higgs boson is discovered at CERN (confirmed to 99.999% certainty)
2012 - Photonic molecules are discovered at MIT

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_scientific_discoveries#21st_century

There will be direct consequences for these scientific discoveries. Fraud is not an option, simple as.

SCIENCE WORKS
 
Last edited:
"Public awareness of rampant scientific fraud ....]

HAHAHAHA! ^^^Look what justingtime wrote,^^^ with no supporting evidence.
 
Last edited:
Public awareness of rampant scientific fraud is changing all that. That is why we see such a growing skepticism of science by the general public and why scientists today are held in such low esteem.

Even the US congress has declared science is nothing but quackery and science has no one to blame but the scientists engaging is fraud and quackery. The shine wore out decades ago.
:jaw-dropp
You must be living on another planet. How delusional can you get. I'm not sure what is sadder, a troll who seems to get a some kind of affirmation of their intellect by playing silly games on forums (which any idiot could do), or to be so totally deluded and to so easily lie to themselves.

I mean, we are living in one of the most enlighted times in the history of the human race (subjectively speaking I guess). We are truly living in a time of real scientific wonder. Maybe every generation thinks that. But we know so much more than we did, and understand so much more about what we dont yet understand. Instead of lazily trying to pick a silly and boring argument which is completely wasting your time, why not get on and get excited about all the amazing stuff that keeps happening in science, almost every week. You will just get left behind to pontificate with yourself.
 
Last edited:
The opposite example and the main hero of this sleazy story is Vladimir Putin who, apparently got a number of Russia's best hackers together in a room and ordered them to blast their way into that East Anglia email database and spread to the four winds whatever they might find there.

Боже храни Владимирa Путина!
Blessing Putin explains a lot about you.

The self-correcting nature of science was designed to give sloppy science a pass and that is how science/scientists have managed to avoid public scrutiny.

Um, no. Science is "self correcting" because of the scientific method. Only irrational dogmatic beliefs such as religion ignore new evidence and research.
 
The saddest thing is when people respond.

I know, I know. Sometimes I just cant help myself. Sometimes its more for the people who read but never post who may start to believe all that rubbish.
Here's a conspiracy. Sometimes the trolling is so crass I wonder if jref plant trolls just to keep us entertained. ;)
 
Last edited:
I have no doubt that fraud exists in science as it does in all aspects of human activity.
However, for clarification, is the author of the OP and those supporting his/her position claiming that fraud in science is more prevalent than fraud in other professional activities like, politics, finance, big corporations, law, accounting, medicine, engineering, retail stores, banking, etc.?

Apparently yes, and because the percentage of fraudulent people in science is basically the same as that in "normal" people, therefore it is more prevalent in science, because the number of scientists is smaller than the number of "normal" people, at least according to the wonderful reasoning of justintime.
 
The self-correcting nature of science was designed to give sloppy science a pass and that is how science/scientists have managed to avoid public scrutiny. Once the quackery of science was exposed. There was no cover for the absent minded professor or eccentric scientist. Scientists who commit fraud are like any common criminal who expect to profit from their deception.

This is a false description. The practices of science or science culture has been developed over a long period of time by mostly trial and error. You find slowly evolving attitudes about science in the 1600s, 1700s, 1800s, and on to the present.

So, you had the Salem Witch Trials in 1692. On the Lewis and Clark Expedition in 1804, bloodletting was still being used to treat illness. As late as 1847, Puerperal Fever was the leading cause of death in childbirth. In 1898, the War Department gave money to Samuel Langley to build a man-carrying aerodrome which led to Langley's spectacular failure in 1903. In 1940, the Tacoma Narrows Bridge collapsed because of wind induced oscillation. In 1943, Liberty Ships were breaking in two because the steel was brittle in cold water and the welded hulls did not stop cracks as riveted hulls tended to do.
 
I just skimmed through the thread. Did I miss any argument of substance that isn't "Science fraud is common, therefore Woo?"
 
I just skimmed through the thread. Did I miss any argument of substance that isn't "Science fraud is common, therefore Woo?"

There was a bit of a diversion where we discussed actually examining the question of rates of scientific fraud in a serious manner, but the "Fraud is Rampant" crew rather ignobly shut that conversation down rather than run the risk of being proven wrong.

Other than that, no, your understanding of that side's arguments is accurate.
 
I think their implied claim is that the discipline of science should be held to a higher standard than most of those disciplines you mentioned.
Perhaps so. Then why the comment that fraud is "commonplace"?

Medicine is a science, BTW, and engineering is applied science.

This may be part of the confusion here. A practicing physician and an engineer are no more doing science than an electrician or a plumber. Of course, many professions rely on scientific principles, but unless they are doing research, they are merely using scientific laws and theories discovered by actual scientists. Only rarely, when involved in research, might a physician or an engineer be justifiably called a scientist.
 
Perhaps so. Then why the comment that fraud is "commonplace"?



This may be part of the confusion here. A practicing physician and an engineer are no more doing science than an electrician or a plumber. Of course, many professions rely on scientific principles, but unless they are doing research, they are merely using scientific laws and theories discovered by actual scientists. Only rarely, when involved in research, might a physician or an engineer be justifiably called a scientist.

How rare is medical research?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom