science fraud is common place

wrs said:
Obviously not, a good fraud is never detected.
Not true. A good fraud only needs to go undetected long enough for the person to get away with it.

Regardless, if that's not what you meant what DID you mean by that statement? I'm asking honestly here--I genuinely don't understand what you're getting at.

I was thinking 6% was a good top end number but was willing to go with as low as 1-2%.
Given the context of the discussion--that fraud invalidates the scientific process (no, I'm not saying you're arguing that, but the OP and others certainly are, explicitely)--I feel quite comfortable demanding in the 25% to 50% range. But that's to support the argument made by the OP and his ilk. If you merely want to show that it's common, we need to ensure that the frauds represent at least a statistically significant portion of the total number of papers published. That's typically left to the researcher doing the work; you'll know better than anyone else, once you delve into the data, how to determine significance (sometimes one case is hugely important, while other times a thousand cases are irrelevant; and a discussion of exactly those types of issues is not unwarranted).

MCH said:
Normally, we have quality controls in place to try and mitigate these ordinary human faults, but academia is (mostly, not all) bad at having these.
Prove it. Step 1: Provide a mechanism for detecting undetected incidents of fraud. Until then, the technical term for what you're doing is "mere speculation".
 
How good do the numbers need to be, and for what kinds of fraud? I know I keep banging on about Dan Airely, but then he has done a lot of work on the subject, and he comes up with about 0.1% of proper frauds in college students (I think) and about two thirds are minor frauds. Is that good enough?

What does comparing it to the fraud found give us? That conflates with detection rates, which we also don't know.

A smaller percentage of fraud in a small community like the scientific community versus the same percentage applied to the general public, the order of magnitude of fraud is proportionally higher in the scientific community.

The proportion of damage cause by scientific fraud is also much higher relative to the general public.
 
My comments apply to so called "pure" scientific research, usually done in a university setting, which I believe is quite rare and difficult to pull off.
In contrast, it seems corporate fraud is quite plentiful. For example, insecticides have been developed over the years using scientific methods. So, if some manufacturer fudges on data in order to label some stuff "safe" that actually does have some toxicity for humans, is that scientific fraud or just plain old corporate fraud?
If you are labeling that kind of activity "scientific fraud," we are not talking about the same thing.

Was the person doing the work a "scientist" with a science degree from one of these hallowed halls that actually do the science you refer to?
 
Was the person doing the work a "scientist" with a science degree from one of these hallowed halls that actually do the science you refer to?

Gods below, that's a loaded question! As a scientist working in the private sector, I can assure you that it gets quite complicated. I've taken my name off reports because engineers and managers have tried to change the data on me. My work was good--but theirs, not so much.

Finding out that data is going to be really, really complicated. There's a LOT of internal politics involved.

justintime said:
A smaller percentage of fraud in a small community like the scientific community
We aren't that small a community. GSA regularly pulls in thousands of people, and that's just geology/paleontology.

The proportion of damage cause by scientific fraud is also much higher relative to the general public.
Not really. Most of the frauds don't impact the general public.
 
Dinwar are you going to respond to my post #160 brought forward here.


Originally Posted by Dinwar View Post
It also deals with how the perpetuation of juvenile traits into adulthood can occur. If you know anything about human and chimp morphology and ontogeny, this sounds all sorts of bells.

The author was an ichthyologist. Yes the terms may be common but the specifics are there even in the title which you failed to pickup. You can thank me later.

Read the title again:
Quote:
"Saltatory Processes and Altricial to Precocial Forms in the Ontogeny of Fishes"
Abstract

SYNOPSIS. Development is not a gradual but a saltatory process. A combination of qualitative changes in form and function—thresholds—creates boundaries between a succession of quantitative intervals—steps. Thresholds can be modified by an altered time of appearance of structures and functions (heterochrony), especially during early ontogeny, to form an operational basis for the prolongation of juvenile characters and adaptability into later ontogeny. Whereas such prolongation enables juvenilization in phylogeny, analogous principles may operate on a much shorter time scale to produce the r-selection-like altricial and the K-selection-like precocial trends in ontogeny. The inherited capacity to adjust constantly to the environment (heterochrony) selects for structural, biochemical and behavioral improvements. The tendency is toward the precocial but the way back to altricial forms is left open. The heterochronous adaptations in early ontogeny can “reverse” the vulnerable specialization, should the environment become less stable and/or the community less competitive. Juvenilization, capable of turning gerontomorphosis into paedomorphosis in evolution, and heterochronous shifts of character anlagen, capable of turning a precocial trend into an altricial trend in ontogeny are both part of the same biological process which operates during early ontogeny.
 
Then why ask me to quantify it? I guess you aren't interested in actually discussing the proposition. Your position is more along the religious lines of simply dismissing it out of hand since it's obviously not possible. Kind of like infallibility of the pope or inerrancy of the bible.


Yes, I'm interested in discussing it. That's why I asked you to quantify "commonplace," a word that you, not I, used to support a claim. If it's not possible to quantify commonplace, then I suggest you try another tack. If you think it's 1-2%, I would ask:

a) Got research to back up that number? The finger-in-the-wind method won't cut it.

b) What range of human activity are you supposing this applies to? Is it 1-2% of transactions at the grocery store? Is it 1-2% of men on a first date who are actually married? 1-2% of parachute packing procedures?

c) How does it relate to scientific papers?
 
Last edited:
Not true. A good fraud only needs to go undetected long enough for the person to get away with it.

Regardless, if that's not what you meant what DID you mean by that statement? I'm asking honestly here--I genuinely don't understand what you're getting at.

I am thinking of using a fake ID to get drinks underage. I am also thinking of selling a fake as the real thing. Both of those types of fraud would be ongoing until detected.

Given the context of the discussion--that fraud invalidates the scientific process (no, I'm not saying you're arguing that, but the OP and others certainly are, explicitely)

I am not saying that the presence of fraud invalidates science or the scientific process. I am saying that given the incidence of fraud in the general population, we should be skeptical of the high regard in which we hold the scientific process. If it's not foolproof, then we have to be very careful about our acceptance of the results.


--I feel quite comfortable demanding in the 25% to 50% range. But that's to support the argument made by the OP and his ilk. If you merely want to show that it's common, we need to ensure that the frauds represent at least a statistically significant portion of the total number of papers published. That's typically left to the researcher doing the work; you'll know better than anyone else, once you delve into the data, how to determine significance (sometimes one case is hugely important, while other times a thousand cases are irrelevant; and a discussion of exactly those types of issues is not unwarranted).

Prove it. Step 1: Provide a mechanism for detecting undetected incidents of fraud. Until then, the technical term for what you're doing is "mere speculation".

I hardly think so.
 
Actually, no. Fraud detection is not DIRECTLY a good proxy for fraud rates, but I'd love to see any data you can offer that refutes the idea that fraud can be treated as a population and sampled in a similar manner. I'm saying that you and wrs need to look at fraud detection over time, as samples of total fraud committed, for discrete chunks of time. I see no reason to assume, without evidence, that this methodology will fail in this case, when it works in so many other areas.
I'd like to see some evidence, or reasoning, that it will work. You've given no reason, so far, that fraud detection as a sampling measure has any relationship with fraud committed.

But hey, if you can propose a better method for detecting cases of fraud, I'm all ears.
Oh I have methods for detecting fraud in research if not in publications; they are the methods used everywhere else for detecting any kind of mismatch, by mistake or deliberate. They're called quality controls. And you need them at all stages, not just at output, and they need to be demonstrated, not just claimed, and they need to be part of the work, not part of the publication process.

Thus far, all you've done is dismissed the numbers provided in this thread, petulantly declare that we can't know what we don't know, and demand that we accept that you can (which is what wrs is doing when he states that fraud is commonplace). If you have a method of determining rates of undetected fraud, let's hear it! If you can't provided one (and I don't think it unfare to request this within the next few posts), the rest of your arguments fall apart because even if I accept that I can't know rates of fraud, your own argument demonstrates that neither can you.
Indeed let's start with: Neither can I.

Let's go on to: what can we use to estimate likely fraud rates?

No, it's not. For several reasons. First and foremost: I'm going to attack EVERY datum on fraud that you provide with the argument "That's just based on the known stuff." Your data set is not and cannot be superior to what is available for science--not without a mechanism for detecting undetectable frauds. Second, you are asking us to dismiss data directly related to the topic at hand in favor of data only tangentially related--I shouldn't have to explain why that's dishonest to someone who's been published. It introduces a host of issues. Finally, I do not feel it overly demanding to expect two researchers (and one crackpot--I won't lump you in with justintime here) to present data that's actually from the field in question when they wish us to draw conclusions about that field. You ASSUME that the fraud rates will be the same--an assumption that I see no evidence for. Others have recently presented very good reasons why science is unique.
Quite a lot of wrong things here. Datasets on fraud rates in business is a datasets available for science - but I think you use 'science' very loosely here. I'm not dismissing data about detected fraud, I'm simply saying that it's not related to actual fraud. And again you're making claims about what's been presented that are not relevant or are not true: no-one's made any claim upstream as to why scientists would be less fraudulant than most people.

So, so far, the idea that research fraud rates will be similar to normal people's scientifically tested fraud rates is likely a closer dataset (because scientists are normal people) than detected fraud rates (because detection is only a lower limit but otherwise unconnected).

Also, humans don't notice things below 5%. 15% in sediment analysis, but 5% and below is considered sufficient to appear identical when working with metal. Just an FYI.
Bollocks. I mean, really? I'd notice a 5% change in my body temperature.
 
A smaller percentage of fraud in a small community like the scientific community versus the same percentage applied to the general public, the order of magnitude of fraud is proportionally higher in the scientific community.

Huh? If 1% of the total population engages in fraud, and 1% of the scientific community engages in fraud, it's proportionally higher in the scientific community because it's smaller? I think that you need to go somewhere quiet and think about what "proportional" means.

The proportion of damage cause by scientific fraud is also much higher relative to the general public.

Hardly. I think that if I had fudged half of my thesis work, people still wouldn't have noticed, because my work wasn't that important. Work that has the capacity to be damaging gets much more tightly scrutinized.
 
Gods below, that's a loaded question! As a scientist working in the private sector, I can assure you that it gets quite complicated. I've taken my name off reports because engineers and managers have tried to change the data on me. My work was good--but theirs, not so much.

Glad to know we live in the same world. I started my own company for very similar reasons.


Finding out that data is going to be really, really complicated. There's a LOT of internal politics involved.

Did you ever do bids and proposals in order to get grant money?



Not really. Most of the frauds don't impact the general public.

Not ones in papers but stuff that actually got implemented and lied about, all the time. I keep thinking about medicines here. All it takes is one fraud to harm a huge number of people.
 
And replicated by other scientists!

wow, this sounds so wonderful. Let's all join hands and sing how wonderful scientists are because they are always replicating each others work and making sure they are all holy and pure.......
 
Work that has the capacity to be damaging gets much more tightly scrutinized.
It's true that some fields - medicine for example - are more tightly scrutinised, but I think that normally it's work that is surprising that gets more scrutiny - and replication.
 
Not ones in papers but stuff that actually got implemented and lied about, all the time. I keep thinking about medicines here. All it takes is one fraud to harm a huge number of people.


I wonder about that. Has there ever been a case where an FDA-approved drug caused widespread harm due to the fraud of a single person?
 
wow, this sounds so wonderful. Let's all join hands and sing how wonderful scientists are because they are always replicating each others work and making sure they are all holy and pure.......

Try to follow the thread of the conversation. That replication comment applied to Maldach's reference to research that has the capacity to be damaging, and not all research -- the vast majority of which is inconsequential.
 
Scientists have positioned themselves as the modern day high priest and therefore immune from any prosecution. They also promoted their discipline as the only reliable way to arrive at the facts..ie the scientific method. Having raised the bar they are now complicit in scientific amnesty for the profession when the appearance of fraud is becoming evermore prevalent in the scientific community.

It hasn't risen to the level of organized crime but as a unified body the viability must be quite appealing to the scientists. It is quite obvious from the attempts made here by members of the scientific community to absolve themselves semantically, statistically, offensively or through denial that fraud plagues their profession.

That science fraud is common place is not a misnomer and the poorly mounted defense of their profession stems from an arrogance or naivety that they were immune from public scrutiny or criticism because they successfully hid behind 'science' with their esoteric high flung dung until it hit the ceiling and now has caught everyone's attention. :crowded:

Couldn't make it through the sample, eh? Oh, well.

Why is it that you never figured out just how many papers are involved, in just how many fields of science, in your claim that fraud is common place [sic]? Is it because less than 1% OF 1% is not a very impressive number?

And why is it that you will not explain in which field of science your expertise lies, "mate"?
 
Last edited:
I can think of the depression caused by ulcer-calming tablets. It's not fraud as such, but the hold that the small number of 'stress-cause-of-ulcers' people had over the research community was not 'scientific'
 
I wonder about that. Has there ever been a case where an FDA-approved drug caused widespread harm due to the fraud of a single person?

Why does it need to be one person? How about a conspiracy? I think the answer is absolutely. Any drug the FDA is forced to withdraw would count as highly probable and I think there are plenty of those.
 
MCH said:
I'd like to see some evidence, or reasoning, that it will work.
It's a standard technique used in biology. Well, more accurately, it's the underlying premise for several such techniques. I'm sorry, but if you aren't familiar with these statistical methods I can't take your claims about the validity of anything seriously. It's basic, freshman stuff. Look up tag and release sampling sometime; it's an example of the application of these principles.

Oh I have methods for detecting fraud in research if not in publications; they are the methods used everywhere else for detecting any kind of mismatch, by mistake or deliberate.
So no, you in fact DO NOT have any method for determining undetected frauds in scientific publications. We can therefore dismiss the notion that you have any better sense of this data than has been presented in this thread.

This means that you have nothing upon which to base your arguments.

Thank you for refuting yourself.

Let's go on to: what can we use to estimate likely fraud rates?
I have answered that repeatedly. You have ignored it repeatedly--and you have demonstrated that you're ignorant of standard methods for estimating this sort of unknown data. You really should think about that a bit.

Datasets on fraud rates in business is a datasets available for science
No, they're not. They're datasets for business. By definition. If you play this fast and loose with terminology, prepare to have your accedemic career cut very short.

When I say you need data for science, I mean that if you wish to discuss rates of fraud in scientific publications you are obliged to provide data on rates of fraud in scientific publications. Providing rates of fraud for other things is irrelevant. It's off topic. We actually have data for rates of fraud in science--not, perhaps, the best data, but sufficient to draw conclusions (again, the sampling methods will help provide estimates for what we're missing). Ignoring that data in favor of datasets less related to the topic at hand is dishonest. If you want to discuss undetected frauds in scientific publications, you must provided date on the rate of undetected frauds in scientific publications.

I'm not sure why this is so difficult: If you wish to discuss X, you need data on X. This is basic stuff.

I'm not dismissing data about detected fraud, I'm simply saying that it's not related to actual fraud.
That's absurd on the face of it. Obviously they are related--detected frauds are a subset of committed frauds. The issue you and I are having is that you presume that undetected rates are much higher than detected rates, and I'm demanding you actually provide some justification for that belief.

And again you're making claims about what's been presented that are not relevant or are not true: no-one's made any claim upstream as to why scientists would be less fraudulant than most people.
This is a lie.

Here's proof.

Perpetual Student said:
Science is a unique human endeavor in that its purpose is to expand knowledge and understanding. By its very nature, its end result is both public and open. Those who dare commit fraud in science risk a high probability of exposure because thousands of scientists throughout the world are motivated to scrutinize new results and expand on new findings. Simply put, other than intellectual curiosity, a major motive behind discovering something new is to have the world acknowledge one’s success in having done so. It’s very difficult for fraud to be successful.
In most other areas, fraud is secretive and not subject to universal scrutiny and the reward is almost always financial. Without any supporting data, it stands to reason that fraud is much less prevalent in the pursuit of science when compared to other professional activities.
Hired hacks of corporations who spew stuff like anti-global warming babble, the safety of tobacco use, the benefits of herbal remedies, etc. are just ordinary frauds pretending to be scientific -- even though they actually may have some credentials. There are incompetent hacks in every field.

So, so far, the idea that research fraud rates will be similar to normal people's scientifically tested fraud rates is likely a closer dataset than detected fraud rates. [snipped parantheticals]
Nothing more than baseless assertions which ignore all available data in favor of supporting a pet hypothesis. The paranetheticals were nothing more than self-serving justifications for ignoring data and facts you don't like.

Bollocks. I mean, really? I'd notice a 5% change in my body temperature.
Is your body temperature metal? If no, than your statement is irrelevant. I was giving a few numbers I happened to know off the top of my head regarding human perception, to illustrate what range "commonplace" and "detectable" should fall into.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom