science fraud is common place

Dinwar are you going to respond to my post #160 brought forward here.

The author was an ichthyologist. Yes the terms may be common but the specifics are there even in the title which you failed to pickup. You can thank me later.

That's twice, now...surely you mean, "is" an ichthyologist...

Did you ever read anny further than the title?

How is your rewrite going?

Justintime, are you going to respond to my question, repeated multiple times? In what area of science does your expertise lie?
 
wow, this sounds so wonderful. Let's all join hands and sing how wonderful scientists are because they are always replicating each others work and making sure they are all holy and pure.......
It's not a question of checking each other's work to make sure they are holy and pure. It's more of a matter of wanting to use each other's work in our own fields.

When I was a wee graduate student, one of my tasks was to make a particular compound that had been previously made in our research group, and follow up on its chemical properties (a previous grad student had made &(CO)3(CH3) and investigated all of its properties, one such property being that it reacted with HCCPh to give &(CO)3(CCPh). My job was to do a similar study with &(CO)3(CCPh). I'm using "&" to represent the rest of the complicated molecule). Now, his way of making it was a pain in the arsenic, because it involved a number of low-yield steps and expensive reactants. Hitting the literature showed me that another researcher had made a similar molecule (&(CO)2(Cl)(CCPh)) through a completely different procedure. So I tried his procedure, thinking that I'd easily be able to turn his molecule into mine. I was rather surprised to find out that his procedure actually gave my molecule- he hadn't characterized his product carefully enough, and his suggested structure was incorrect. I wasn't repeating his results because I wanted to make sure he was behaving, but because I wanted to apply it to my own research.
 
wrs said:
Did you ever do bids and proposals in order to get grant money?
Not much, but I do bids and proposals for environmental monitoring.

Not ones in papers but stuff that actually got implemented and lied about, all the time.
We're working with different datasets, then. The thread has been, thus far, about publication.

MCH said:
This is an ad-hom isn't it.
It's a request for information. justintime is pretending to have more knowledge about how science works than three or four scientists combined. It's not unreasonable to ask what sort of background in science he has in such situations.
 
I can think of the depression caused by ulcer-calming tablets. It's not fraud as such, but the hold that the small number of 'stress-cause-of-ulcers' people had over the research community was not 'scientific'

How does that help understand how common place [sic] fraud is, in scientific research?
 
Why does it need to be one person? How about a conspiracy? I think the answer is absolutely. Any drug the FDA is forced to withdraw would count as highly probable and I think there are plenty of those.

When you said "[a]ll it takes is one fraud to harm a huge number of people," were you referring to one person committing fraud?

You say any drug that the FDA is forced to withdraw, it's highly probable ... that it's fraud? Again, you are launching suppositions as argument. I have no reason to think that it's highly probable that these events are caused by fraud. Of course you can bring evidence... or not.
 
Dinwar are you going to respond to my post #160 brought forward here.

The author was an ichthyologist. Yes the terms may be common but the specifics are there even in the title which you failed to pickup. You can thank me later.

I have ignored nothing. The paper deals with genetics, and it's perfectly acceptable to ask "Do similar mechanisms play a role in similar evolutionary trends in other classes of the same phylum?" I've failed to pick up nothing. In fact, I've picked up more than you.

And I'm not going to simplify it. My argument continues to be that it's perfectly simple to understand, once one understands the jargon. YOU want to demonstrate that it's all for the purpose of obfuscation; YOU demonstrate that you can actually comprehend what's stated. That's Step 1 in demonstrating that it's all to hide something.
 
Huh? If 1% of the total population engages in fraud, and 1% of the scientific community engages in fraud, it's proportionally higher in the scientific community because it's smaller? I think that you need to go somewhere quiet and think about what "proportional" means.



Hardly. I think that if I had fudged half of my thesis work, people still wouldn't have noticed, because my work wasn't that important. Work that has the capacity to be damaging gets much more tightly scrutinized.

1 percent of the general population engaging in fraud versus 1% of the so called elite scientific community. Qualitatively speaking scientific fraud stick out like sore thumbs and gets splashed all over the media.

Just the after effects of Andrew Wakefield's MMR vaccine debacle is causing major problems for social healthcare. How does ordinary fraud even begin to compare with the damage cause by scientists in influential positions?
 
Last edited:
It's a standard technique used in biology. Well, more accurately, it's the underlying premise for several such techniques. I'm sorry, but if you aren't familiar with these statistical methods I can't take your claims about the validity of anything seriously. It's basic, freshman stuff. Look up tag and release sampling sometime; it's an example of the application of these principles.
No it's not. Using detection rates as a sample for actual rates, without understanding what the detection rates against actual rates are in the first place, are pointless. As you say, that's basic, 'freshman' stuff.

So no, you in fact DO NOT have any method for determining undetected frauds in scientific publications. We can therefore dismiss the notion that you have any better sense of this data than has been presented in this thread.
I never said I did. You're arguing against a ghost you have constructed, not anything I've said.

My point is (again) that if you don't know what the fraud rates are, you can't make claims about general scientific validity of research.


No, they're not. They're datasets for business. By definition. If you play this fast and loose with terminology, prepare to have your accedemic career cut very short.
Ha ha. The loose terminology here is yours. The datasets I have referred to are from academic studies. The datasets for business people are still scientific datasets available to 'scientists'. I see no reason so far to think that scientists are any more honest than businessmen. That's not to say they are or are not, but it would be extraordinary to claim that they are very different. Do you?

When I say you need data for science, I mean that if you wish to discuss rates of fraud in scientific publications you are obliged to provide data on rates of fraud in scientific publications. Providing rates of fraud for other things is irrelevant. It's off topic. We actually have data for rates of fraud in science--not, perhaps, the best data, but sufficient to draw conclusions (again, the sampling methods will help provide estimates for what we're missing). Ignoring that data in favor of datasets less related to the topic at hand is dishonest. If you want to discuss undetected frauds in scientific publications, you must provided date on the rate of undetected frauds in scientific publications.
Good grief. If we don't have data for something directly we can still estimate it from other similar data - for various explicit assumptions of 'similar'. You don't have any data for fraud in science. Not just 'not the best data', but no data. You only have data for fraud detection. That is *not* data (other than a minimum) for fraud.

That's absurd on the face of it. Obviously they are related--detected frauds are a subset of committed frauds. The issue you and I are having is that you presume that undetected rates are much higher than detected rates, and I'm demanding you actually provide some justification for that belief.
No they're not related - other than as a minimum, and it's so small as makes very little odds. The number of actual frauds has no known relationship with the detected frauds.

(re no-one has claimed that scientists are different to ordinary people) This is a lie. Here's proof.
I beg your pardon. I was thinking on a thread like this we would be talking about evidence-based claims, not just wild opinionated rants.

Nothing more than baseless assertions which ignore all available data in favor of supporting a pet hypothesis. The paranetheticals were nothing more than self-serving justifications for ignoring data and facts you don't like.
Er. yes, the parentheticals were justifications. It would be all sciency if you answered them rather than make silly statements like this.

Is your body temperature metal? If no, than your statement is irrelevant. I was giving a few numbers I happened to know off the top of my head regarding human perception, to illustrate what range "commonplace" and "detectable" should fall into.
You said people wouldn't detect changes under 5% and gave some examples. I gave a counter example to show it's not true. The point of this is what anyway?
 
MCH said:
No it's not.
~shrug~ You want to criticize science as being full of fraud without even understanding basic sampling techniques, have fun. I'm sorry, but at this point I can no longer take you seriously. You're a crackpot.

I never said I did.
Nope. However, having one is absolutely necessary to support any of the arguments you are making. Therefore you can't make any argument beyond "Maybe fraud is higher than the detected rates", which isn't any sort of argument at all. You've got NOTHING to say, period--and cannot have anything to say until you have established some way to detect undetected frauds.

I'm not going to continue to humor you by pretending your arguments have any validity until you provide such a mechanism and learn rudamentary sampling techniques. Until you've done that you have no potential--NONE--of having anything with which to support your opinions. And this is a science forum--mere opinions have no validity.
 
When I was a wee graduate student, one of my tasks was to make a particular compound that had been previously made in our research group, and follow up on its chemical properties (a previous grad student had made &(CO)3(CH3) and investigated all of its properties, one such property being that it reacted with HCCPh to give &(CO)3(CCPh). My job was to do a similar study with &(CO)3(CCPh). I'm using "&" to represent the rest of the complicated molecule). Now, his way of making it was a pain in the arsenic, because it involved a number of low-yield steps and expensive reactants. Hitting the literature showed me that another researcher had made a similar molecule (&(CO)2(Cl)(CCPh)) through a completely different procedure. So I tried his procedure, thinking that I'd easily be able to turn his molecule into mine. I was rather surprised to find out that his procedure actually gave my molecule- he hadn't characterized his product carefully enough, and his suggested structure was incorrect. I wasn't repeating his results because I wanted to make sure he was behaving, but because I wanted to apply it to my own research.
Examples like this are a breath of fresh air, but ....

... it's a single case. When generalising to the whole of academic research (or 'science' if you like...) the question becomes: how often does this happen without being detected, and for how long? It's all very well saying that 'eventually' someone will/might find out, but 'eventually' can be a long time, and in the meantime.... what happens?
 
When you said "[a]ll it takes is one fraud to harm a huge number of people," were you referring to one person committing fraud?

One successful instance.


You say any drug that the FDA is forced to withdraw, it's highly probable ... that it's fraud? Again, you are launching suppositions as argument. I have no reason to think that it's highly probable that these events are caused by fraud. Of course you can bring evidence... or not.

As we have discussed, fraud is best if undetected. The best frauds will go undetected. Let me quote from the OP:

Most of what occurs in the practice of science goes on behind closed doors, beyond the prying eye of the public.

Very true in corporate laboratories and in govt labs as well (particularly there).


Against this backdrop however, science is increasingly accused of fraud in the pursuit of useful research findings, applications and profits.

This latter is where I am very concerned. In my experience, fraud is rampant inside corporations and govt. When I see an agency like the FDA forced to withdraw a drug, I can only conclude there was fraud involved in the process of release. If not, then the FDA is incompetent and it's highly likely that there are a lot of drugs causing a lot more harm that the FDA hasn't found. If the FDA is in fact highly competent and the drug release process is as well, then it stands to reason that the only way a drug could get approved and subsequently withdrawn, is via fraud.
 
Last edited:
wrs said:
Very true in corporate laboratories and in govt labs as well (particularly there).
Laboratories aren't the only place science is conducted. Science is more than physics and chemistry. Furthermore, the methods will be included in any report--at least enough of them to reproduce the experiment. They have to be, or the paper will be rejected (this was discussed earlier, and is one of the main purposes of peer review, as stated by someone who's reviewed papers).

As we have discussed, fraud is best if undetected.
We did not discuss it. You asserted it, and that's about as far as it went.

In my experience, fraud is rampant inside corporations and govt.
My experience is quite different. Actual cases of fraud have been very few and far between, isolated to a handful of individuals, and I have always been supported when I fought back against them.

When I see an agency like the FDA forced to withdraw a drug, I can only conclude there was fraud involved in the process of release.
Than you have a poor understanding of why drugs are withdrawn. Many are withdrawn because while no severe side effects were detected in clinical trials, general use reveals such side effects (due to the longer period from which to gather data and the larger amount of data one can gather). This counts as a slightly more formal version of what I've been calling informal review. Fraud is not the only--and I would say probably not the major--cause for drugs being withdrawn. At the very least, given that additional mechanisms are possible we certainly are warranted in asking for evidence that such fraud is the main cause of withdraw of FDA approval.

If not, then the FDA is incompetent and it's highly likely that there are a lot of drugs causing a lot more harm that the FDA hasn't found.
It's not a question of competance; it's a question of limitations of clinical trials.

If the FDA is in fact highly competent and the drug release process is as well, then it only stands to reason that the only way a drug could get approved and subsequently withdrawn, is via fraud.
No. Just....no.
 
~shrug~ You want to criticize science as being full of fraud without even understanding basic sampling techniques, have fun. I'm sorry, but at this point I can no longer take you seriously. You're a crackpot.
Oh joy. I've made no such criticism - and you've admitted I haven't, yet still keep saying it. This is a lie thing isn't it? You're very quick to make that statement about other people.

You also make up a completely inappropriate sampling 'method' as if it's supposed to prove something, and then resort to more namecalling. I suppose it's that kind of debate. All sciency/

Nope. However, having one is absolutely necessary to support any of the arguments you are making. Therefore you can't make any argument beyond "Maybe fraud is higher than the detected rates", which isn't any sort of argument at all. You've got NOTHING to say, period--and cannot have anything to say until you have established some way to detect undetected frauds.
You have been very quick to make up your own cartoons of any arguments I have been making, without actually addressing any of the ones I have been. Maybe you're a little over sensitive about criticism of science practice - yet I vaguely recall scientists are supposed to be all open and honest and welcoming criticism.

Oh well.
 
The 0.0096% was in 2007 from a low of (0.00097%) in 1976. But as of 2012 "(PNAS), found that more than two-thirds of the biomedical and life sciences papers that have been retracted from the scientific record are due to misconduct by researchers, rather than error."
It only takes a small percentage of fraud to create havoc.
Sorry, justintime, but it looks like you still need to learn to understand what you read and even basic mathematics :rolleyes:!
1) In 2007 0.0096% of papers were retracted due to misconduct.
2) In 2012 "(PNAS), found that more than two-thirds of the biomedical and life sciences papers that have been retracted from the scientific record are due to misconduct by researchers, rather than error."

0.0096% is a tiny percentage of every paper published in 2007.
67.4% is a high percentage of 2,047 retracted papers up to 2012.
As of 3 October 2013, PubMed has over 23 million records going back to 1966.

That is 0.0059986% (but is a bit low since I do not have the 2012 total).
 
This latter is where I am very concerned. In my experience, fraud is rampant inside corporations and govt. When I see an agency like the FDA forced to withdraw a drug, I can only conclude there was fraud involved in the process of release. If not, then the FDA is incompetent and it's highly likely that there are a lot of drugs causing a lot more harm that the FDA hasn't found. If the FDA is in fact highly competent and the drug release process is as well, then it stands to reason that the only way a drug could get approved and subsequently withdrawn, is via fraud.

I don't think that's the only explanation, although it is one explanation, and there have been incidents of fraud.

In the scenario where FDA approves a drug and later announces its withdrawl, there are several root causes:
  • Research submitted for approval by manufacturer is incomplete or fabricated or both, harm levels are detected through post-marketing research.
  • Research submitted for approval by manufacturer did not have enough power to detect rare but serious harm, detected through post-marketing research.
  • Product does not require pre-marketing research, harm levels detected through post-marketing research (eg: dietary supplements)
  • FDA withdrawing a product approved previously for a particular use now replaced by newer drugs, and now predominantly unsupported off-label use with demonstrated serious harmful effects
 
Laboratories aren't the only place science is conducted. Science is more than physics and chemistry. Furthermore, the methods will be included in any report--at least enough of them to reproduce the experiment. They have to be, or the paper will be rejected (this was discussed earlier, and is one of the main purposes of peer review, as stated by someone who's reviewed papers).

This was not some kind of limitation on the examples of where science is practiced or applied. It was an affirmation of the opening statement in the OP.



It's not a question of competance; it's a question of limitations of clinical trials.

Are these trials scientific?

No. Just....no.

Clearly a well supported response.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom