science fraud is common place

Science is a unique human endeavor in that its purpose is to expand knowledge and understanding. By its very nature, its end result is both public and open. Those who dare commit fraud in science risk a high probability of exposure because thousands of scientists throughout the world are motivated to scrutinize new results and expand on new findings. Simply put, other than intellectual curiosity, a major motive behind discovering something new is to have the world acknowledge one’s success in having done so. It’s very difficult for fraud to be successful.
In most other areas, fraud is secretive and not subject to universal scrutiny and the reward is almost always financial. Without any supporting data, it stands to reason that fraud is much less prevalent in the pursuit of science when compared to other professional activities.
Hired hacks of corporations who spew stuff like anti-global warming babble, the safety of tobacco use, the benefits of herbal remedies, etc. are just ordinary frauds pretending to be scientific -- even though they actually may have some credentials. There are incompetent hacks in every field.
 
It says nothing about it - that's my point. Denwar for some reason seems to be saying (frequently) that because there's data for fraud detection then we have answered the question about fraud rates.

Actually, no. I'm saying that we have data and therefore it is incumbant upon you, justintime, and wrh--who wish to refute that data--to actually address it. Playing games with data from other fields isn't sufficient.

I've also told you exactly what such research would look like. Basically, at this point all you need to do is follow that methodology. It won't be easy, but in the end you'll arive at the actual facts of the matter--as opposed to the current line of reasoning, which amounts to "We don't know what the rate of fraud in science is, so let's pretend it's identical to other areas."

It's hard to say that I'm the unreasonable one in the discussion when I've basically handed you everything but the answer.
 
Scientists have positioned themselves as the modern day high priest and therefore immune from any prosecution. They also promoted their discipline as the only reliable way to arrive at the facts..ie the scientific method. Having raised the bar they are now complicit in scientific amnesty for the profession when the appearance of fraud is becoming evermore prevalent in the scientific community.
I think that's a bit strong. Lots of people - experts particularly - think they are right for very good reasons, and 'scientists' are usually experts. And of course, people who think they are right will defend their rightness, and that's ordinary too.

And, luckily, most people can spot unsupported rubbish from far away, so although most of us 'trust' scientists, we are often skeptical about individual 'scientific conclusions' that turn up in public discussion. Sometimes rightly, sometimes not!

In the meantime what bothers me is the tremendous inertia in academia (and elsewhere!) where it's very hard to do the kind of introspection and major reorganisation that tends to be forced upon commerce from time to time. And in particular, the confusion of academic research as being 'science' and - worse - being the only science. Luckily the rest of us involved in producing reliable knowledge (ie, science) can manage alongside academia, but it's annoying.

It's really really annoying because there are some great academics, but they are squashed or warped by the culture and incentives, and you know it could be so much better.
 
Please quantify "commonplace."

That is probably a good idea, what would you consider it to be? Obviously it's something that would be noticed regularly since it's against the law. I would say around 1-2% would be commonplace but I would allow for as high as 6%. What would you think?
 
Actually, no. I'm saying that we have data and therefore it is incumbant upon you, justintime, and wrh--who wish to refute that data--to actually address it. Playing games with data from other fields isn't sufficient.
Erm. We have 'data' but it's not useful data for this case. Fraud detection is not even a proxy for fraud. Your methodology (!) is completely inappropriate.

Unless you have good cause to claim that researchers are not normal humans, then using normal human honesty as a baseline is reasonable. Please, do, make a case that it is not.
 
My premise is that fraud is commonplace in humanity. It is your job to either refute that or prove that scientists are somehow different than the rest of humanity.

Well, how commonplace is it in general populations? Commonplace just means it happens enough to not be surprised, it really doesn't illuminate how often it actually happens. Once you come up with some good numbers for the common population you can then compare them to how much fraud is found in the scientific community...

You've said a whole lot of nothing with your statement, in other words.
 
You want me to take these unknown frauds seriously? Quantify them.
Ha ha ha etc. This is how you understand 'doing science'? Really?

Provide an estimate for the frequency of their occurance. Until you do you have nothing. There is no data upon which you could hang ANY conclusion. You are left with "Maybe there are some frauds we don't know about."
Really? You make stuff up and then you have data?!

Yes. Maybe there are some frauds we don't know about. Is this a common starting point?

No. My writing is actually put forward to the entire state of California to review. It's called the "Public Comments Period". This is in addition to internal review, legal review, client review, and regulator review.
Tell me where the rigour turns up. Or the scrutiny.

I have not failed to answer anything. I have failed to do your work for you. Your questions were answered up-thread. If you are too lazy to read the thread, that's your problem, not mine.
I've read the thread and there is no evidence of you answering any of these issues with any kind of reasoned argument. That is, I have looked and found none (evidence of lack), not just ignored it and hope it goes away (lack of evidence that academic research produces science)
 
Had I directed such an argument towards you, you'd currently be screaming about how known fraud rates have nothing to do with actual fraud rates. The only thing extraordinary about this conversation is that you, justintime, and wrs expect to be taken seriously.

You want me to take these unknown frauds seriously? Quantify them. Provide an estimate for the frequency of their occurance. Until you do you have nothing. There is no data upon which you could hang ANY conclusion. You are left with "Maybe there are some frauds we don't know about."

Isn't the best fraud one that is undetected?


And the premise that we can determine the rate of unknown scientific frauds by looking at known frauds from other areas is absurd.

Really? So scientists are different than other people? I have asked you this and you have dodged it so far.


There's actual data on rates of fraud in science.

You provided information about paper submissions. There are many more frauds that are currently being perpetuated but that science refuses to acknowledge as such. Medicines that produce side effects more grave than the condition they seek to ameliorate come to mind as obvious frauds.
 
No, unless you choose to broaden the definition to include all applied fields like engineering.

I am asking here. Keep in mind, I didn't start the thread and it's rather poorly defined to begin with. Common place hasn't been quantified as has been pointed out already. I gave my guess at that. I was just trying to further the discussion here by clarifying what is meant by science.
 
Well, how commonplace is it in general populations? Commonplace just means it happens enough to not be surprised, it really doesn't illuminate how often it actually happens. Once you come up with some good numbers for the common population you can then compare them to how much fraud is found in the scientific community...

You've said a whole lot of nothing with your statement, in other words.

Well is it commonplace for preachers to tell their congregation that God helps those that help themselves? Is it commonplace for preachers to tell their congregation that god loves a cheerful giver? Is it commonplace for preachers to tell their congregations that god will bless them for their tithe?

Are those examples of fraud?
 
Well, how commonplace is it in general populations? Commonplace just means it happens enough to not be surprised, it really doesn't illuminate how often it actually happens. Once you come up with some good numbers for the common population you can then compare them to how much fraud is found in the scientific community...

You've said a whole lot of nothing with your statement, in other words.
How good do the numbers need to be, and for what kinds of fraud? I know I keep banging on about Dan Airely, but then he has done a lot of work on the subject, and he comes up with about 0.1% of proper frauds in college students (I think) and about two thirds are minor frauds. Is that good enough?

What does comparing it to the fraud found give us? That conflates with detection rates, which we also don't know.
 
MCH said:
Erm. We have 'data' but it's not useful data for this case. Fraud detection is not even a proxy for fraud. Your methodology (!) is completely inappropriate.
Actually, no. Fraud detection is not DIRECTLY a good proxy for fraud rates, but I'd love to see any data you can offer that refutes the idea that fraud can be treated as a population and sampled in a similar manner. I'm saying that you and wrs need to look at fraud detection over time, as samples of total fraud committed, for discrete chunks of time. I see no reason to assume, without evidence, that this methodology will fail in this case, when it works in so many other areas.

But hey, if you can propose a better method for detecting cases of fraud, I'm all ears. Thus far, all you've done is dismissed the numbers provided in this thread, petulantly declare that we can't know what we don't know, and demand that we accept that you can (which is what wrs is doing when he states that fraud is commonplace). If you have a method of determining rates of undetected fraud, let's hear it! If you can't provided one (and I don't think it unfare to request this within the next few posts), the rest of your arguments fall apart because even if I accept that I can't know rates of fraud, your own argument demonstrates that neither can you.

Unless you have good cause to claim that researchers are not normal humans, then using normal human honesty as a baseline is reasonable
No, it's not. For several reasons. First and foremost: I'm going to attack EVERY datum on fraud that you provide with the argument "That's just based on the known stuff." Your data set is not and cannot be superior to what is available for science--not without a mechanism for detecting undetectable frauds. Second, you are asking us to dismiss data directly related to the topic at hand in favor of data only tangentially related--I shouldn't have to explain why that's dishonest to someone who's been published. It introduces a host of issues. Finally, I do not feel it overly demanding to expect two researchers (and one crackpot--I won't lump you in with justintime here) to present data that's actually from the field in question when they wish us to draw conclusions about that field. You ASSUME that the fraud rates will be the same--an assumption that I see no evidence for. Others have recently presented very good reasons why science is unique.

Nothing you can possibly say about identified rates of fraud in any other field is inapplicable to science, therefore any statements about identified rates of fraud in other fields merely support the conclusion that the rates of fraud presented in this thread for science are valid. You need to discuss UNDETECTED fraud rates for your statements to have any validity. Otherwise, you're saying that we should discard the data available for the topic and replace it with data on another topic entirely--which is irrational. I'd reject any paper that tried such dishonest trickery.

wrs said:
Obviously it's something that would be noticed regularly since it's against the law.
Are you saying that fraud should be noticed when it occurs? If that's true, the rates of fraud in science (which are often against the law, and certainly against policy of various companies and organizations) should be as well.

Also, humans don't notice things below 5%. 15% in sediment analysis, but 5% and below is considered sufficient to appear identical when working with metal. Just an FYI.
 
How good do the numbers need to be, and for what kinds of fraud? I know I keep banging on about Dan Airely, but then he has done a lot of work on the subject, and he comes up with about 0.1% of proper frauds in college students (I think) and about two thirds are minor frauds. Is that good enough?

What does comparing it to the fraud found give us? That conflates with detection rates, which we also don't know.

Is any underage kid using a fake ID engaging in fraud?
 
Is any underage kid using a fake ID engaging in fraud?

Obviously. However, scientists aren't underage kids, and publication isn't using a fake ID. Apples need to be compared to apples, not black holes.
 
That is probably a good idea, what would you consider it to be? Obviously it's something that would be noticed regularly since it's against the law. I would say around 1-2% would be commonplace but I would allow for as high as 6%. What would you think?


Sorry, but you're the one using that word to support your claim. As for myself, I don't go putting numbers to things willy-nilly.
 
Are you saying that fraud should be noticed when it occurs? If that's true, the rates of fraud in science (which are often against the law, and certainly against policy of various companies and organizations) should be as well.

Obviously not, a good fraud is never detected.


Also, humans don't notice things below 5%. 15% in sediment analysis, but 5% and below is considered sufficient to appear identical when working with metal. Just an FYI.

I was thinking 6% was a good top end number but was willing to go with as low as 1-2%.
 
Is any underage kid using a fake ID engaging in fraud?
I think the extent of fraud is important to the OP's question.

That is, small frauds - such as removing 'difficult' data points, or only looking for problems with unexpected results, or abandoning an experiment that appears to be 'going wrong' - can all be rationally justified, but will all affect the results and the body of research.

Normally, we have quality controls in place to try and mitigate these ordinary human faults, but academia is (mostly, not all) bad at having these.
 
Sorry, but you're the one using that word to support your claim. As for myself, I don't go putting numbers to things willy-nilly.

Then why ask me to quantify it? I guess you aren't interested in actually discussing the proposition. Your position is more along the religious lines of simply dismissing it out of hand since it's obviously not possible. Kind of like infallibility of the pope or inerrancy of the bible.
 
I am asking here. Keep in mind, I didn't start the thread and it's rather poorly defined to begin with. Common place hasn't been quantified as has been pointed out already. I gave my guess at that. I was just trying to further the discussion here by clarifying what is meant by science.
My comments apply to so called "pure" scientific research, usually done in a university setting, which I believe is quite rare and difficult to pull off.
In contrast, it seems corporate fraud is quite plentiful. For example, insecticides have been developed over the years using scientific methods. So, if some manufacturer fudges on data in order to label some stuff "safe" that actually does have some toxicity for humans, is that scientific fraud or just plain old corporate fraud?
If you are labeling that kind of activity "scientific fraud," we are not talking about the same thing.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom