science fraud is common place

I have to concede it was a noble profession before the fraudsters got in. Dinwar is trying to defend his profession and maybe expects a little respect and recognition. But he is unwittingly defending the fraudsters in the process and there is very little justification for that.
 
Akri, do you really think that a scientist is going to admit here on a forum that he doesn't like the current peerreview process?
Sorry, Maartenn100, but no scientist "likes" the peer review process. :D
It delays publication. It is a lot of hassle revising papers to meet review comments. As for being a peer reviewer :eek:!

Peer review is a necessary part of the scientific process though and so scientists tolerate it. They know its strengths and weaknesses.
 
Fact is that sometimes very good submitted manuscripts were first rejected by some high profile journals and, later on, these manuscripts were accepted by another journal.
That fact is correct, Maartenn100.

That tells us enough about the acceptance criteria of various journals and tells us what anyone should know - the abilities of people (e.g. peer reviewers) vary!
 
wrs said:
This was not some kind of limitation on the examples of where science is practiced or applied. It was an affirmation of the opening statement in the OP.
And my statement is a refutation of it. At best, you're talking about a subset of science. Precision is necessary in these discussions.

Are these trials scientific?
Yes, but there are still limitations. "Scientific" doesn't mean "omniscient", or even "gathers all the data possible". Very rare but very serious side effects can be caused by the drug, but at rates low enough to be completely missed by the clinical trial. It's the Law of Large Numbers--a one in a million event may not occur in a 1,000 person trial, but it'll certainly occur when the drug becomes used by 10 million people. Or, there could be factors that the researchers were not aware of or did not realize could impact the drug. The human body is incredibly complex, after all, and the researchers can't account for every possible permutation of human activities. None of this invalidates the scientific nature of the clinical trials, but it also means that we have to allow for a certain failure rate.

Clearly a well supported response.
You removed the bits where I discussed possible mechanisms that you hadn't considered. And you've provided precisely NO support for your assertion that all incidents of withdraw of FDA approval are frauds.
 
I don't think that's the only explanation, although it is one explanation, and there have been incidents of fraud.

In the scenario where FDA approves a drug and later announces its withdrawl, there are several root causes:
  • Fraud
  • incompetence of process
  • incompetence of process and possible fraud
  • FDA withdrawing a product approved previously for a particular use now replaced by newer drugs, and now predominantly unsupported off-label use with demonstrated serious harmful effects -- Yes, this is a good example of neither, thanks. I do see doctors doing exactly this but not always to the detriment of the patient although it could be risky.
 
I have to concede it was a noble profession before the fraudsters got in. Dinwar is trying to defend his profession and maybe expects a little respect and recognition. But he is unwittingly defending the fraudsters in the process and there is very little justification for that.

I think that's rather generous. If I read the background to Newton right, for example, research has always been a fairly 'fraught' and highly personaly political activity just like many other human activities, but without the common purpose of either money or an enemy to force people to work cooperatively.

But yes, Dinwar has I think a rather enthusiastic defence of his profession. Ideally of course, scientists should self-criticise rather than justify (to be all properly Popper and all that), and there are quite a lot of people struggling with the problems of generating reliable research, and it would be nice to have a discussion about that, and ways to reduce fraud rather than pretend it's not there.

Research is a particularly difficult one because, by definition, much less is known about what is being found out than most fields.
 
Dinwar is trying to defend his profession and maybe expects a little respect and recognition.

You've yet to demonstrate the prevelance of fraud in science. And I don't give the furry crack of a rat's butt what you think of me. I'm arguing against you because you're wrong and you're dishonest.

Reality Check said:
That tells us enough about the acceptance criteria of various journals and tells us what anyone should know - the abilities of people (e.g. peer reviewers) vary!
Not necessarily. A paper can be rejected for a variety of reasons not having to do with quality. It may be outside the journal's are of interest, or the journal may shift its focus, for example. Extremely high-quality work gets rejected by high-IF journals all the time, and the acceptence of those papers by lower-IF journals in no way deminishes the quality of the report.
 
Dinwar said:
I've taken my name off reports because engineers and managers have tried to change the data on me.

Good that we had Dinwar. But the reports exist.
 
Last edited:
blutoski said:
Research submitted for approval by manufacturer did not have enough power to detect rare but serious harm, detected through post-marketing research.
wrs said:
incompetence of process
This is a gross mischaracterization of the process, one that anyone familiar with statistics and sampling methods cannot honestly perpetrate.

blutoski said:
FDA withdrawing a product approved previously for a particular use now replaced by newer drugs, and now predominantly unsupported off-label use with demonstrated serious harmful effects
wrs said:
Yes, this is a good example of neither, thanks.
Okay. Now please present evidence to support the idea that fraud--legitimately defined!--is the main cause of withdraw of FDA approval. Failure to do so means that we can only conclude that your statements are mere opinions, and therefore should be dismissed.
 
Any profession that starts out with a guess(hypothesis) on critical research and puts it to the standard process (scientific method):...
A bit incoherent, justintime, but you do have a bit of the scientific review process there. It is more like: Bob notices some interesting data and creates a hypothesis to explain it. Then
* Bob looks for problems in the hypothesis.
* Bob's colleague Alice looks for problems in the hypothesis.
* Bob presents the hypothesis at a symposium to his colleagues.
* Bob puts a poster up at a conference.
* Bob presents the hypothesis at another conference.
* After dozens of scientists have had a look for problems with the hypothesis, Bob writes it up and submits a paper to a journal.
* Now the peer review process starts!
* The paper is published.
* Hundreds of scientists look for problems in the paper.
* Every time that the paper is cited, it is implicitly reviewed again by the authors of the new paper.
 
I'm trying to find a picture of an iron knee.

Can anyone help?

I have not made a dishonest statement in this thread. I have disagreed with you, and presented my reasons for doing so. If you cannot comprehend the idea of someone disagreeing with you without being dishonest, that's your problem.

Care to explain your method for determining the rates of undetected frauds in scientific research? Because your entire position in this discussion hangs on that, and you've thus far been unable to provide anything other than "But these other people over there are frauds" (and actually wrs provided that--all YOU have provided is "Detection rates aren't rates of committed frauds").

Maartenn100 said:
But the reports exist.
No they don't. Things generally get a bit hairy, but the reports usually die.
 
justintime: Shrink the abstract down to one or more sentences

Here is a sample of scientific high flung dung (esoteric mambo jumbo) which a layman can shrink down to one or two sentences.
What is missing is the actual shrinking down to one or more sentences.
That makes your assertion a complete fantasy until you demonstrate it is possible.
justintime,
Please shrink the following down to one or two sentences without losing any meaning:
Saltatory Processes and Altricial to Precocial Forms in the Ontogeny of Fishes

Abstract

SYNOPSIS. Development is not a gradual but a saltatory process. A combination of qualitative changes in form and function—thresholds—creates boundaries between a succession of quantitative intervals—steps. Thresholds can be modified by an altered time of appearance of structures and functions (heterochrony), especially during early ontogeny, to form an operational basis for the prolongation of juvenile characters and adaptability into later ontogeny. Whereas such prolongation enables juvenilization in phylogeny, analogous principles may operate on a much shorter time scale to produce the r-selection-like altricial and the K-selection-like precocial trends in ontogeny. The inherited capacity to adjust constantly to the environment (heterochrony) selects for structural, biochemical and behavioral improvements. The tendency is toward the precocial but the way back to altricial forms is left open. The heterochronous adaptations in early ontogeny can “reverse” the vulnerable specialization, should the environment become less stable and/or the community less competitive. Juvenilization, capable of turning gerontomorphosis into paedomorphosis in evolution, and heterochronous shifts of character anlagen, capable of turning a precocial trend into an altricial trend in ontogeny are both part of the same biological process which operates during early ontogeny.

Remember, justintime, that you made the assertion that a layman (i.e. you) can do this. It is up to you to provide evidence for your assertion.
 
Last edited:
I have not made a dishonest statement in this thread. I have disagreed with you, and presented my reasons for doing so. If you cannot comprehend the idea of someone disagreeing with you without being dishonest, that's your problem.

Care to explain your method for determining the rates of undetected frauds in scientific research? Because your entire position in this discussion hangs on that, and you've thus far been unable to provide anything other than "But these other people over there are frauds" (and actually wrs provided that--all YOU have provided is "Detection rates aren't rates of committed frauds").
I'll try and take this seriously for a moment, though there's a derail risk.

You again have some weird concept of my 'entire position' which has nothing to do with anything I've claimed. Now I understand we often make mistakes, but this is a common thread with your posts. It's not a genuine attempt to understand and then discuss, it's a continuous fabrication and then handwaving 'refutation'.

That's dishonest.

Oh, and wrong.
 
Okay. Now please present evidence to support the idea that fraud--legitimately defined!--is the main cause of withdraw of FDA approval. Failure to do so means that we can only conclude that your statements are mere opinions, and therefore should be dismissed.

Hardly so. This is not what I claimed either. Go back and read what I said. Blutoski admitted to fraud being the cause in some cases. QED
 
MCH said:
You again have some weird concept of my 'entire position' which has nothing to do with anything I've claimed.
Are you, or are you not, claiming that we do not have sufficient data presented in this thread to discuss rates of fraud in science?

Have you, or have you not, presented the evidence best paraphrased as "Detection rates are only lower limits to actual rates of fraud"?

Have you, or have you not, defending the notion that scientists commit fraud at the same rates as other people?
 
This is a gross mischaracterization of the process, one that anyone familiar with statistics and sampling methods cannot honestly perpetrate.

To recap, that was regarding my point "Research submitted for approval by manufacturer did not have enough power to detect rare but serious harm, detected through post-marketing research." and wrs categorized this as "incompetence of process"

I agree with you Dinwar... I think wrs has an unreasonable fallacious black and white expectation that either the FDA must detect all side effects or that it is incompetent and should not exist. We live in a real world of probabilities, and the FDA's role is to define and demand due diligence for a specific product segment.

Either way, it's not fraud.Alas: it's just the age old acknowledgement that sampling is not perfect, but it's the best we have and absolutely better than nothing.



wrs responded to another point from the same post: "Product does not require pre-marketing research, harm levels detected through post-marketing research (eg: dietary supplements)" with "incompetence of process and possible fraud"

I disagree with part of this one as well - the FDA is prohibited by law from requiring DSHEA products to demonstrate efficacy and safety prior to marketing. wrs' beef is with the political climate of deregulation that continues to re-elect a Congress that defines the FDA's scope in this way. To put this in another way: it's not legal for them to police this, so failure to do so is not incompetence.

OTOH, I think we can all agree that there are fishy claims, but the problem is that since it's legal to market dietary supplements without testing for efficacy or safety, discovering seriously harmful effects post-market does not imply any fraud. Just indifference and disinterest on the manufacturer's part as to whether the product is effective or safe.
 
Hardly so. This is not what I claimed either. Go back and read what I said. Blutoski admitted to fraud being the cause in some cases. QED
Here's what you said.

wrs said:
When I see an agency like the FDA forced to withdraw a drug, I can only conclude there was fraud involved in the process of release.
There is nothing in this sentence that can, to a reasonable person speaking the English language, be taken to mean that you are only talking about some cases of fraud. This sentence, read by a reasonable speaker of the English language, appears to argue that ALL cases of withdrawn FDA approval are due to fraud. The highlighted word in particular supports this assertion, but the complete lack of anything resembling discussions of any other options, and the lack of any caveats, equivocation, or proposed alternatives is sufficient to lead a reasonable speaker of the English language to that conclusion.

No one, least of all me, has ever argued that NO fraud occurs. I have merely argued that you have over-stated your case and that your understanding of the clinical trial system is flawed. The fact that you consider the appearance of previously-undetected detrimental side effects upon generael use as evidence of flaws in the reaserch further supports this conclusion.
 
OTOH, I think we can all agree that there are fishy claims, but the problem is that since it's legal to market dietary supplements without testing for efficacy or safety, discovering seriously harmful effects post-market does not imply any fraud. Just indifference and disinterest on the manufacturer's part as to whether the product is effective or safe.

I'd also like to point out that such supplements DO get tested. Anyone can do a search of threads in this forum to see such tests. These supplements are being analyzed scientifically, and all the issues with them have been discovered by scientists, not the likes of justintime or Maartenn100. What these arguments boil down to is, essentially, that the scientific process is too slow for the tastes of some people. It works, but eventually, and these people don't like that last phrase.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom