An interesting argumentation technique. Avoid answering the question, then claim you have answered it. OK...We've already addressed this, with data. Feel free to ignore it, though.
EIR/EIS is your offering for 'rigorous review' and 'zealous scrutingy'? Or the fact that sometimes a paper refutes another paper?
Really, no. That's not the amazing scrutiny you seem to think it is. It's laughable, and believe me, it gets laughed at.
No, really, no again. There was no [second] "therefore", and putting it in quotes as if I had is a poor mark of your credibility. Very close to fraud, no? My point was just that you don't know, and if you don't know, you can't claim it's low, and you can't claim to be scientific, and you certainly can't claim to have the data and have a precise picture.Neither, by the way, does the argument "You only look at discovered frauds, therefore you don't know how much fraud is occurring, therefore it's extremely high." A bit of a sensationalized, yes, but not too far off the mark in terms of the implications of your post.
Do these somehow go together? I am arguing that the academic processes currently in place are akin to gossip, and are therefore not scientific, and not science. Please do, do, show me what makes it better. Even gossipers sometimes uncover lies, even gossipers sometimes produce reliable knowledge (usually about old, well discussed facts).This demonstrates that you have no bloody idea what you're talking about. You are arguing that science is gossip--just about the stupidest statement about science that I can imagine. It also deminishes your credibility.
But please, feel free to point to a single example of fraud that was discovered by someone attacking science, rather than scientists. I look forward to it.
Last edited:
