science fraud is common place

We've already addressed this, with data. Feel free to ignore it, though.
An interesting argumentation technique. Avoid answering the question, then claim you have answered it. OK...

EIR/EIS is your offering for 'rigorous review' and 'zealous scrutingy'? Or the fact that sometimes a paper refutes another paper?

Really, no. That's not the amazing scrutiny you seem to think it is. It's laughable, and believe me, it gets laughed at.

Neither, by the way, does the argument "You only look at discovered frauds, therefore you don't know how much fraud is occurring, therefore it's extremely high." A bit of a sensationalized, yes, but not too far off the mark in terms of the implications of your post.
No, really, no again. There was no [second] "therefore", and putting it in quotes as if I had is a poor mark of your credibility. Very close to fraud, no? My point was just that you don't know, and if you don't know, you can't claim it's low, and you can't claim to be scientific, and you certainly can't claim to have the data and have a precise picture.

This demonstrates that you have no bloody idea what you're talking about. You are arguing that science is gossip--just about the stupidest statement about science that I can imagine. It also deminishes your credibility.

But please, feel free to point to a single example of fraud that was discovered by someone attacking science, rather than scientists. I look forward to it.
Do these somehow go together? I am arguing that the academic processes currently in place are akin to gossip, and are therefore not scientific, and not science. Please do, do, show me what makes it better. Even gossipers sometimes uncover lies, even gossipers sometimes produce reliable knowledge (usually about old, well discussed facts).
 
Last edited:
We've already addressed this, with data. Feel free to ignore it, though.

Actually not. The title of the thread is scientific fraud is common place. My argument is that scientific fraud cannot be any lower than the incidence of fraud in the general population unless you have specific data to the contrary.

I think fraud is common place in human life and thus, it's common place in science. You can feel free to prove me wrong but unless you can prove scientists are different than other people, I can't help but conclude you guys are looking at science with rose colored glasses.

http://www.kroll.com/media/pdfs/KRL_FraudReport2011-12_US.pdf

Obviously in business circles fraud is quite common and a fairly significant concern.
 
But business men are capitalist and greedy and evil, whereas scientists need to be honest and objective and self-critical in order to do science, and so therefore they are.
 
The author was an ichthyologist. Yes the terms may be common but the specifics are there even in the title which you failed to pickup. You can thank me later.

Read the title again:

I didn't fail to pick up anything. The paper presents a genetic mechanism for a specific type of evolutionary pattern. Humans follow that pattern. The research potential is obvious.

This is a major difference between scientists and people like you: scientists are able to figure out implications of research and expand upon them. You are demonstrably incapable of doing so (you demonstrate your lack of capacity in this quote).

MCH said:
EIR/EIS is your offering for 'rigorous review' and 'zealous scrutingy'? Or the fact that sometimes a paper refutes another paper?
Do you know what an EIR/EIS is? It IS an example of rigorous review and zealous scrutiny--often overly zealous, to be honest. When was the last time YOUR work was put in front of an entire state for review? For me, it was in the spring. And I'm currently working on a paper that's going to go through that process all over again.

Also, papers refuting one another are examples of the type of informal review scientists are subject to. This can continue essentially indefinitely--something utterly unique to science. Even when it's not, there's always the potential for any paper to be refuted by any researcher after it's published. That potential represents a more rigorous review process than anything anyone else goes through. It's entirely open-ended, and invites the entire field to criticize it.

All of this has been discussed up-thread. I'm not avoiding anything, I'm merely refusing to re-itterate what's already been stated. The thread's not that long. Go back and read it.

There was no therefore, and putting it in quotes as if I had is a poor mark of your credibility.
If you didn't intend the "therefore...." you should have wrote your post differently. It was a logical conclusion to be drawn. Your entire argument is that science sucks, and your only evidence is that we don't know how common fraud is! The concept is laughable.

My point was just that you don't know, and if you don't know, you can't claim it's low, and you can't claim to be scientific, and you certainly can't claim to have the data and have a precise picture.
Okay, here you're claiming that science isn't scientific. This is impossible and irrational. Science DEFINES scientific.

By the way, have you read the book on fraudulant science I referenced up-thread? If not, I recommend you do so. You'll find that most of your criticisms are utterly baseless.

I am arguing that the academic processes currently in place are akin to gossip, and are therefore not scientific, and not science. Please do, do, show me what makes it better.
This has been done extensively throughout this thread. I'm not waisting any more time on this. Go back and re-read the thread if you want to see the data. If you refuse to do so, you don't get to pretend that I treat your questions as honest.
 
The author was an ichthyologist. Yes the terms may be common but the specifics are there even in the title which you failed to pickup. You can thank me later.

Read the title again:

Did you mean, "...'is' an ichthyologist..."?

What does the rest of the paragraph say, in "layman's terms' (without leaving out any detail)?
 
wrs said:
Actually not. The title of the thread is scientific fraud is common place. My argument is that scientific fraud cannot be any lower than the incidence of fraud in the general population unless you have specific data to the contrary.
Specific data to the contrary has been provided. Multiple times. And I mean specific--as in, numbers of papers retracted due to fraud. Your argument was refuted yesterday (check the time-stamps on the relevant posts--I leave it as an exercise for you to determine which are relevant). I feel no obligation to repeat the data merely because you do not wish to look for it.
 
Dinwar, the number of papers redacted for fraud is not the same as the number of fraudulant papers. Lots of people have said this.
 
Dinwar, the number of papers redacted for fraud is not the same as the number of fraudulant papers. Lots of people have said this.

True, on both counts. But you've yet to provide ANY data AT ALL about the actual numbers of fraudulant papers. Thus literally anything you say after the above statement is unsubstantiated and can be dismissed without further consideration. In fact, to say anything at all other than "We don't know", given the data you've provided, is to overstep the data by a huge margine.

But I haven't done so. I've presented a specific reference that addresses, among other things, that exact point. Here's a hint as to how: Fraudulant work remains fraudulant in perpetuity. And we are very good at figuring out population sizes from samples of the population.

None of this supports the moronic notion that scientific publication is nothing more than gossip, by the way.
 
Dinwar, the number of papers redacted for fraud is not the same as the number of fraudulant papers. Lots of people have said this.

Indeed but he isn't going to acknowledge this or my premise which doesn't have anything to do with what has already been discussed.
 
Specific data to the contrary has been provided. Multiple times. And I mean specific--as in, numbers of papers retracted due to fraud. Your argument was refuted yesterday (check the time-stamps on the relevant posts--I leave it as an exercise for you to determine which are relevant). I feel no obligation to repeat the data merely because you do not wish to look for it.

My premise is that fraud is commonplace in humanity. It is your job to either refute that or prove that scientists are somehow different than the rest of humanity.
 
But business men are capitalist and greedy and evil, whereas scientists need to be honest and objective and self-critical in order to do science, and so therefore they are.

Scientists have positioned themselves as the modern day high priest and therefore immune from any prosecution. They also promoted their discipline as the only reliable way to arrive at the facts..ie the scientific method. Having raised the bar they are now complicit in scientific amnesty for the profession when the appearance of fraud is becoming evermore prevalent in the scientific community.

It hasn't risen to the level of organized crime but as a unified body the viability must be quite appealing to the scientists. It is quite obvious from the attempts made here by members of the scientific community to absolve themselves semantically, statistically, offensively or through denial that fraud plagues their profession.

That science fraud is common place is not a misnomer and the poorly mounted defense of their profession stems from an arrogance or naivety that they were immune from public scrutiny or criticism because they successfully hid behind 'science' with their esoteric high flung dung until it hit the ceiling and now has caught everyone's attention. :crowded:
 
Indeed but he isn't going to acknowledge this or my premise which doesn't have anything to do with what has already been discussed.

Provide data to support your claim that fraud rates are higher than those presented thus far in this thread. I've gone so far as to give you a methodology. If you can't figure it out, I'm saying to look at fraud as a population, and analyze how our knowledge of fraudulant works for specific time periods has changed through time; that will tell you the prevelance of fraud in that time period, including a fairly good estimate of the number of frauds you haven't found. We use such statistical methods constantly in biology, and they can be remarkably accurate. Certainly they'll put you within the correct order of magnitude, which is FAR more data than you have currently. Once you've done this for a time period or two we can discuss the rates of fraud--including estimates of undiscovered frauds--through time.

Until then, you've got nothing more than "Maybe you're wrong." Provide the data or admit you are making an unsubtstantiated--and therefore unscientific--assertion.
 
Do you know what an EIR/EIS is? It IS an example of rigorous review and zealous scrutiny--often overly zealous, to be honest. When was the last time YOUR work was put in front of an entire state for review? For me, it was in the spring. And I'm currently working on a paper that's going to go through that process all over again.
Let me put this to you as actual rigour and scrutiny: You run your experiment with two people overlooking you and your measurements. Copies are taken of all the logs, all the code, all the data collection and held separately while you work on them. All versions of the code and data are also held so we know which version was run on what. The code is reviewed by people outside your department. An approval board sits to decide which method - implemented in which code version - is to be used. The final results are checked, data point by data point. And that's just the collection.

Your work was not put in front of an entire state; some of your writing was reviewed by a board.

The difference in scrutiny, and rigour, is mahuuuusive.

Also, papers refuting one another are examples of the type of informal review scientists are subject to.
They are examples of the occasional review that researchers are subject to. It's not rigour. And what on earth makes you think that continuing indefinitely is unique to science?! Have you ever worked outside academia?!

If you didn't intend the "therefore...." you should have wrote your post differently. It was a logical conclusion to be drawn. Your entire argument is that science sucks, and your only evidence is that we don't know how common fraud is! The concept is laughable.
No, that's not my argument; I am amused that you think that your need to bolt on your prejudices are my fault in writing.

Okay, here you're claiming that science isn't scientific. This is impossible and irrational. Science DEFINES scientific.
OK I think you're confusing academic research with science. Academic research is research - it might be scientific, it might produce science. Just because you label it science doesn't make it scientific.

By the way, have you read the book on fraudulant science I referenced up-thread? If not, I recommend you do so. You'll find that most of your criticisms are utterly baseless.

This has been done extensively throughout this thread. I'm not waisting any more time on this. Go back and re-read the thread if you want to see the data. If you refuse to do so, you don't get to pretend that I treat your questions as honest.
So, again, you fail to answer the actual question and then claim that you have.

FWIW, since I think this is important to you, I work both in and around academic research - as a customer, as a producer (some conference papers, hopefully a journal one coming up), once upon a time in support, and in several disciplines. So I have the advantage in knowing what it's like inside and out.
 
Provide data to support your claim that fraud rates are higher than those presented thus far in this thread. I've gone so far as to give you a methodology. If you can't figure it out, I'm saying to look at fraud as a population, and analyze how our knowledge of fraudulant works for specific time periods has changed through time; that will tell you the prevelance of fraud in that time period, including a fairly good estimate of the number of frauds you haven't found. We use such statistical methods constantly in biology, and they can be remarkably accurate. Certainly they'll put you within the correct order of magnitude, which is FAR more data than you have currently. Once you've done this for a time period or two we can discuss the rates of fraud--including estimates of undiscovered frauds--through time.

Until then, you've got nothing more than "Maybe you're wrong." Provide the data or admit you are making an unsubtstantiated--and therefore unscientific--assertion.

Is pharmacology science? Is medicine science?
 
My premise is that fraud is commonplace in humanity. It is your job to either refute that or prove that scientists are somehow different than the rest of humanity.

Please quantify "commonplace."
 
Provide data to support your claim that fraud rates are higher than those presented thus far in this thread.
That's really quite extraordinary. He's done so - he's pointed at 'normal' dishonesty rates in 'normal' populations, and reasonably conjectured that scientists will follow similar rates.

And you have admitted that the fraud rates given are not fraud rates, but fraud detection rates.
 
Dinwar, the number of papers redacted for fraud is not the same as the number of fraudulant papers. Lots of people have said this.

And that says what about the actual level of fraud?

(Now as an a side as a former psych major and community outreach worker I am aware of the huge amount of mistaken research, not fraudulent but just research that fails in replication. Large and diverse samples sizes are essential.)
 
And that says what about the actual level of fraud?

(Now as an a side as a former psych major and community outreach worker I am aware of the huge amount of mistaken research, not fraudulent but just research that fails in replication. Large and diverse samples sizes are essential.)
It says nothing about it - that's my point. Denwar for some reason seems to be saying (frequently) that because there's data for fraud detection then we have answered the question about fraud rates.

And, yes, well there is also the seperate question of what research can be reliably used in any way :-) which is an even smaller subset than the research that is not fraudulant!
 
That's really quite extraordinary. He's done so - he's pointed at 'normal' dishonesty rates in 'normal' populations, and reasonably conjectured that scientists will follow similar rates.

Had I directed such an argument towards you, you'd currently be screaming about how known fraud rates have nothing to do with actual fraud rates. The only thing extraordinary about this conversation is that you, justintime, and wrs expect to be taken seriously.

You want me to take these unknown frauds seriously? Quantify them. Provide an estimate for the frequency of their occurance. Until you do you have nothing. There is no data upon which you could hang ANY conclusion. You are left with "Maybe there are some frauds we don't know about."

And the premise that we can determine the rate of unknown scientific frauds by looking at known frauds from other areas is absurd. There's actual data on rates of fraud in science. The only excuse for ignoring those in favor of datasets that have nothing to do with science is that the data for science doesn't support your pet hypothesis.

wrs said:
Is pharmacology science? Is medicine science?
I will leave that to you to determine. I don't care. But you said SCIENCE, so the only result of this determination will be to include those in the dataset or not. If that's your entire dataset, we can dismiss it as necessarily incomplete.

MCH said:
Your work was not put in front of an entire state; some of your writing was reviewed by a board.
No. My writing is actually put forward to the entire state of California to review. It's called the "Public Comments Period". This is in addition to internal review, legal review, client review, and regulator review.

They are examples of the occasional review that researchers are subject to. It's not rigour. And what on earth makes you think that continuing indefinitely is unique to science?! Have you ever worked outside academia?!
Thanks for that--I needed some humor in this thread! :D I'm in a private firm.

No, that's not my argument;
Then you have obviously failed to convey your argument effectively. Please do so.

OK I think you're confusing academic research with science. Academic research is research - it might be scientific, it might produce science. Just because you label it science doesn't make it scientific.
No. I'm strictly limiting myself to science. I'm not confused in the slightest.

But okay, define science.

So, again, you fail to answer the actual question and then claim that you have.
I have not failed to answer anything. I have failed to do your work for you. Your questions were answered up-thread. If you are too lazy to read the thread, that's your problem, not mine.

FWIW, since I think this is important to you, I work both in and around academic research - as a customer, as a producer (some conference papers, hopefully a journal one coming up), once upon a time in support, and in several disciplines. So I have the advantage in knowing what it's like inside and out.
So do I. And it depresses me that someone can go through those processes and still come out as ignroant and misinformed as you.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom