Sarkozy says burqas are 'not welcome' in France

Rationalist International Bulletin 181 had an article on this issue.
ETA, I can't seem to get a link to work.
 
Last edited:
its more important to protect and help woman that are forced to wear a Burka while she does not want to, instead of outlawing all burkas.
 
The excuses the pro-burqa side gives are self-contradictory. One argument is that the burqua should not be banned since if it is banned, those women forced to wear it will be hidden from view altogether by their families. The other is that the burqa should not be banned since women choose to wear it of their own free will.

No. It's not that everyone who disagrees with you is "pro-burqa". No one on this thread has demanded that women wear a burqa or any other form of garb. We are not necessarily enthusiastic about burqas either.

At the same time, we are not enthusiastic about people telling women what they can't wear. Trying to control what women wear does not free them from someone's idea of slavery.
 
???

... But I have never seen a person led about with a dog collar and leash.

Come to think of it, that would be far preferable to what actually happens in Berkeley sometimes.

Maybe you haven't lived in Berkeley long enough. Have seen it happen specifically on Telegraph and Shattuck avenues. Also, I noticed you didn't mention the Castro. All you need to do there is attend one Gay Pride parade to see what I mean. Great costumes in general, by the way.
 
Hey, why stop there? I'm required (by law now, not just by some family, religious, or social pressure) to wear clothes that cover my genitals while in public. Clearly, France needs to enforce my human rights by coming over here, taking over, and banning the pants, shorts, and underpants. The fact that I actually prefer to keep my genitals covered is beside the point - the state of Michigan would punish me for exposing them, so if I "choose" to cover them, it's a false choice, like a black person "choosing" to sell himself into slavery.

Word. Why not compare the involuntary physical abuse and murder of Black people to a free person's choice to wear a piece of cloth of their choice.

Was it Dr. King or Gandhi who said "A covered-up wiener anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere"?

:)
 
Oh, but that sounds hard! Let's just ban the burqa, and use the time we save to paint our avatars green.

Well, in Sarkozy's defense, targeting the abuse behind the Burqa directly is not just hard, but damned near impossible. Prosecuting or even discovering abuse without charges pressed by the abused is vanishingly difficult.

How would the police know which women are being abused? Pull aside everyone with a Burqa or beard for close questioning? Breaking into all Muslim Homes?

The laws are already on the books against domestic violence, against enslaving women. This move is a response to the difficulty there is in enforcing those laws.

I think it's something of the "Broken Windows" approach that New York used a few years back, based on the idea that environment and visual cues contribute to behavior. Broken windows, graffitti, urine in the street made people feel like they were in a lawless area. Getting rid of them seems to have had a real effect on crime.

Sarkozy's idea could be that by minimizing the visual cues and environmental reminders of this particularly oppressive strain of Islam, people will act more like they're living in France and not Afghanistan.

After all the Burqa itself relies on this same principle, it reinforces behaviors against women with strong visual and environmental cues.

What I'd like to see is the research to suggest that this specific tactic (which is a loss of freedoms) will be worth the negative consequences likely.
 
The laws are already on the books against domestic violence, against enslaving women. This move is a response to the difficulty there is in enforcing those laws.

Because this way you get to prosecute or fine the women. Good feminist plan.

I think it's something of the "Broken Windows" approach that New York used a few years back, based on the idea that environment and visual cues contribute to behavior.

Bad analogy. Broken windows are generally an act of vandalism. Graffiti is too. A woman choosing to purchase and wear some clothes that she - maybe not you - finds personally meaningful, is not.
 
Oh, but that sounds hard! Let's just ban the burqa, and use the time we save to paint our avatars green.

Oh, I'm sure there are tons of women property who wear this that do it out of their own free will.

(The strikeout is appropriate -- the whole point of the burqa, just like that of slaves' chains, is to declare that the wearer is not a person, but somebody's property.)
 
Last edited:
By the way, have you heard of Nosuchplacinstan?

In that country, slavery for blacks still exists. Black are property, must leave home only while wearing chains, cannot vote, drive, or engage in politics. All such things are White-only.

Community leaders of the immigrants to France from Nosuchplacinstan -- all Whites, of course -- declare that this is their tradition, and, by gum, their Blacks are going to continue to wear chains when the dare to leave the house where they serve their White master, even in France. It's a choice, you see -- some Blacks from Nosuchplacintan want to do it out of their own free will, and who are we to stop them? Say the Nosuchplacinstan community leaders in France.

True, back home, they give slightly different reasons for why Blacks must walk around in chains -- to wit, Gallah, the one true God, having declared to their prophet that Blacks are inferiors, indeed property -- but one must use what weapons one's got in the fight to keep the Blacks in chains.

Sarkozy declared, inexplicably, that he actually sees Blacks walking around in chains as an insult to human dignity and freedom, and wants to ban this. He was immediatelly attacked as a narrow-minded Nosuchplaceinstanphobe by all the right-thinking, sophisiticated intellectuals.

Meanwhile, the community leaders of Nosuchplacinstan immigrants warned of dire consequences to the health and safety of French who dare to try to release their Blacks from their chains, since trying to do so is "an insult to Nosuchplacinstan" and will "lead to violence".
 
Oh, I'm sure there are tons of women property who wear this that do it out of their own free will.
However many it is, it's enough that it still makes sense to punish the people who force them to wear them, rather than the women who are their victims.

(The strikeout is appropriate -- the whole point of the burqa, just like that of slaves' chains, is to declare that the wearer is not a person, but somebody's property.)
[citation needed]
 
Oh, I'm sure there are tons of women property who wear this that do it out of their own free will.

(The strikeout is appropriate -- the whole point of the burqa, just like that of slaves' chains, is to declare that the wearer is not a person, but somebody's property.)

The numbers are not the issue. Women, however many, who choose to wear a burka should not be punished. Women, however many, who choose to not wear a burka should not be punished.
I think wearing a burka is a stupid choice but I do not think it is the state's business to legislate for stupidity.
 
By the way, have you heard of Nosuchplacinstan? ...

I know you think you're doing women a favor by taking away their choice to wear a garment whose symbolism you don't like ... but some of them like it, and that's all there is to it, in a basically free country like France.

You probably feel the same way when you see a burqa as I do when I see someone wearing the Confederate flag pattern on a vest or hat. But I will fight for these ppl's rights to display those offensive items because otherwise I am infringing on their rights to express themselves.
 
Just to clarify: I didn't mean to suggest there's an exact analogy between the burqa and the confederate flag/garb. Just speaking to the need NOT to stifle ppl's individual freedom of expression when there are some negative reactions to a particular object on public display.
 
I know you think you're doing women a favor by taking away their choice to wear a garment whose symbolism you don't like ...

I also think I'm doing Black people a favor by banning slavery, despite the fact that some of them want it.

Yes, I just lack the deep sophistication that allows one to see instruments of opression and ownership, such as chains and burqas, as symbols of pride, freedom, and individual choice.

Why do I get the feeling that, if my "Nosuchplacinstan" actually existed, you'd be in favor of the White slave-owners' desire to keep, at least, the dress code of slavery alive?
 
Last edited:
I also think I'm doing Black people a favor by banning slavery, despite the fact that some of them want it.

Yes, I just lack the deep sophistication that allows one to see instruments of opression and ownership, such as chains and burqas, as symbols of pride, freedom, and individual choice.

Why do I get the feeling that, if my "Nosuchplacinstan" actually existed, you'd be in favor of the White slave-owners' desire to keep, at least, the dress code of slavery alive?

Can you truly not see the difference between someone imposing their wishes on someone else (slavery or burqas) and allowing people freedom of choice?
You really think allowing someone (colour irrelevant) to hold someone else(colour again irrelevant) in slavery is comparable to someone choosing to be a 'slave'? One cannot choose to be a slave. The very meaning of slavery is the holding of someone against their will. If a person chooses to work for nothing but has the freedom to leave, that person is not a slave.
So that analogy is totally useless and foolish.

Do you wish to have women who choose to wear a burqa punished? Does that sum it up?
 
Why do I get the feeling that, if my "Nosuchplacinstan" actually existed, you'd be in favor of the White slave-owners' desire to keep, at least, the dress code of slavery alive?

Why do you get that feeling? Because you don't understand the arguments to which you're responding. Or you're pretending not to.
 
I also think I'm doing Black people a favor by banning slavery, despite the fact that some of them want it.

Why do you keep trying to (unsuccessfully) compare the act of slavery to a woman's choice to wear what she wants? And don't bother answering this. I'm being rhetorical.

Yes, I just lack the deep sophistication that allows one to see instruments of opression and ownership, such as chains and burqas, as symbols of pride, freedom, and individual choice.

I'll ask this again: girls and women in slave trade environments are often forced to wear high-heeled shoes. Should we fine or prosecute them for it? And should be outlaw the "instrument of slavery" that is high-heeled shoes?

Why do I get the feeling that, if my "Nosuchplacinstan" actually existed, you'd be in favor of the White slave-owners' desire to keep, at least, the dress code of slavery alive?

... Because you lack a basic understanding of my argument, including the need to allow women to wear what they wish to wear in a basically free country.
 
Why do you keep trying to (unsuccessfully) compare the act of slavery to a woman's choice to wear what she wants? And don't bother answering this. I'm being rhetorical.

58burkamuelligfmj
burkamuelligfm.jpg

In the name of Richard Dawkins, may peace be upon him (because education can't be easy).

Step 1: Take an average 10 year old. Oh, any will do.

Step 2: Place his or her hand over a jet lighter flame for a minute, producing an open, cauterized scar. It will, if you are caught, also produce mainstream news coverage and an array of experts speculating about mental illness, which you surely must have.

Step 3: The yelling should stop after an hour, at which point they are ready to understand spirituality, primarily that if they don't dress as ghosts or refuse to follow orders, this is what they deserve for an eternity. Pork, cultivating a human identity, absence at rituals also increase that likelihood by the way. The devil is in the details, they quickly learn.

Currently, to over a billion people this is a lifestyle, which they also understand must eventually be yours.



 
Do you wish to have women who choose to wear a burqa punished? Does that sum it up?
Put humorously France which understands fashion statements is at the forefront against it's antithesis the Burqa. It's nature is socially obnoxious and degrading regardless of culture, as no sane human naturally dresses that way unless forced, as it is neither practical nor presentable. The argument "If you are so devoted, live in a devoted community", is valid. All modern societies have restrictions on what is defined as socially obnoxious. The burqa is bizarre, sad and socially obnoxious just about everywhere but Islamic societies.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom