Sarkozy says burqas are 'not welcome' in France

I'm not having any trouble. I simply have a different point of view about where to draw the line.

We are not 'free' to yell fire in a crowded theater. So Let's start by agreeing there is a line.

Women willingly stay with abusing partners, society doesn't approve. Again there is a line.

In many states abusing partners go to jail even when the abused person refuses to testify. Another line.

All these "freedoms" you think are so clear cut are not. Different societies draw the lines in different places.

But I think these examples miss the point, because wearing a piece of cloth around the head called a "burqa" is not intrinsically an abusive act. Also, it puts no one in clear and present danger.

... However I draw a definite line when someone tries to legally enforce what a woman should or shouldn't wear, as a general rule. This includes the burqa.
 
But I think these examples miss the point, because wearing a piece of cloth around the head called a "burqa" is not intrinsically an abusive act. Also, it puts no one in clear and present danger.

... However I draw a definite line when someone tries to legally enforce what a woman should or shouldn't wear, as a general rule. This includes the burqa.
I do believe this was clarified earlier in the thread, a burqa is the extreme form of a covering from head to toe, not a piece of cloth around one's head.
 
I don't agree with this.

If I decide to make a burqua today and wear it when I go to town, where is the abuse? If I decide to dress as a fairy, where is the abuse.
A burqua is not intrinsically abusive. That's a fact, whether you agree or not. A burqua is made from fabric, as are most clothes. If a burqua is intrinsically abusive, so are all clothes.
It is the compulsion which is abusive.
 
I'm not having any trouble. I simply have a different point of view about where to draw the line.

We are not 'free' to yell fire in a crowded theater. So Let's start by agreeing there is a line.

Women willingly stay with abusing partners, society doesn't approve. Again there is a line.

In many states abusing partners go to jail even when the abused person refuses to testify. Another line.


All these "freedoms" you think are so clear cut are not. Different societies draw the lines in different places.

I'm just not drawing the line in the same place you are.

But I think these examples miss the point, because wearing a piece of cloth around called a "burqa" is not intrinsically an abusive act. Also, it puts no one in clear and present danger.

... However I draw a definite line when someone tries to legally enforce what a woman should or shouldn't wear, as a general rule. This includes the burqa. And your response?
 
when a woman believes that Allah wants her to wear such a Burka, is this then her free will when she wears one?

Of course it is. Not a single human being has told or ordered her to wear it. Family, community and the place of worship and the place of worship's leaders might play a role, as they almost always do in one's personal religiosity, but she believes in Allah, she chooses to follow Allah, chooses the degree to which she worships and she chooses to wear the clothing.
 
In Berkeley and in the Castro (San Francisco), you see a couples and one of them is wearing a dog collar and leash, being led around by the other.

And to think they say Berkeley is nuts.

Still, I agree. Wearing the Burqa has the same purpose -- domination -- as the leash. But hey, it's a choice, as you say: I'm sure those who wear the burqa to be dominated do it out of their free will.

Apparently, though nobody would have guessed it, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Afghanistan under the Taliban, etc. are (or were) in reality a heaven for kinky domination sexual fetishists.
 
e
And to think they say Berkeley is nuts.

Still, I agree. Wearing the Burqa has the same purpose -- domination -- as the leash. But hey, it's a choice, as you say: I'm sure those who wear the burqa to be dominated do it out of their free will.

Not the best analogy. Not everyone wears a burqa for the same purpose. It's already been noted here that some women prefer to wear it in more liberal countries so they don't get ogled all the time by random men. That makes them smart but not necessarily repressed in such a situation.

Apparently, though nobody would have guessed it, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Afghanistan under the Taliban, etc. are (or were) in reality a heaven for kinky domination sexual fetishists.
Yes, women are oft forced to do wear or not wear certain things in the countries you mentioned. ... And also, women sold into slavery in various countries are often forced to wear high heeled shoes. What's your point? Should we ban high heeled shoes in the US or France, as well as the burqa?
 
im against such Burkas, but if a woman wants to wear it, she should be free to do so.
to us it looks opressive and abusive and what not, but to someone that belives her god wants her to wear the Burka, it is not opressive or abusive. it is her faith.
Many religions do things that look strange to us.

whats next? will we force orthodox jewish man to shake womans hands? because not doing so is sexism?
 
Last edited:
Slavery is about domination and ownership of the slave by the master, often with some phoney-baloney theological excuse ("God wants this to save the African heathen's soul"). The burqa is about domination and ownership of the woman by the master, the man, often with some phoney-baloney theological excuse ("Allah wants this to save women and from sinful lust to each other"). Neither are intrinsically abusive, I suppose: some Blacks, especially those brainwashed from childhood, really wanted to be White people's property; and some women, especially those brainwashed from childhood, really want to be Muslim men's property. They believe God (or Allah) wants it so.

If the burqa shold not be banned, slavery should not be banned, either. We should reinstitute slavery -- not by force, mind you; we should only make it legal for Blacks to sell themselves into slavery. This way, those who want to do it, of course from their own free will (wink wink, nudge nudge) will be able to. Just like those who wear the burqa do it from their own free will in 99% of the case (wink wink, nudge nudge). But it should be banned, even if some women want it, for the same reason we banned slavery even if some Blacks wanted it: both are, symbolically and in practice, a tool of opression, ownership, and domination of one group (Blacks or women) by another (Whites or men).

P.S.

The excuses the pro-burqa side gives are self-contradictory. One argument is that the burqua should not be banned since if it is banned, those women forced to wear it will be hidden from view altogether by their families. The other is that the burqa should not be banned since women choose to wear it of their own free will.

P.P.S.

Why is it that the claim, "well, I should get special treatment and be allowed to do this because the diety told me so" --routinely and almost universally dismissed in this forum as ridiculous -- suddenly respected, and seen as the epitome of human rights, when it comes from Muslims?

"I think God would like a nativity scene on this lawn." -- "NO WAY!"
"I think God would like me to treat my women like owned chattle" -- "Be my guest! We appreaciate the different!"
 
Last edited:
P.S.

The excuses the pro-burqa side gives are self-contradictory. One argument is that the burqua should not be banned since if it is banned, those women forced to wear it will be hidden from view altogether by their families. The other is that the burqa should not be banned since women choose to wear it of their own free will.

It's only contradictory if you assume for some reason that each case is talking about all women.

Some women are in abusive, violent or guilt based relationships. Outlawing burquas may cause their families to hide them from the world, increasing their oppression. Those women will be harmed by this law.

Some women hide their bodies in public for the same reasons western women hide their breasts in public, or for whatever spiritual, cultural kick they get out of it. Those women will be harmed by this law.

What this law is counting on to be effective is that there is a large enough population of muslims who are on the fence enough to grudgingly allow the women in their families more freedom in respect for the new law. I'm skeptical that a Muslim family exists that forces it's women to cover their bodies through threats and violence but then turns around and lets these women, in their eyes, run around essentially naked. For this law to be beneficial, this group needs to outweigh the negatives of the others, especially the first group.
 
Fixed:
"I think God would like a nativity scene on this public property." -- "NO WAY!"

"I think God would like a nativity scene on this private property." -- "Be my guest! We appreaciate the different!"

"I think God would like me to wear this garment." -- "Be my guest! We appreaciate the different!"


"I think God would like me to force women to wear this garment." -- "No Way!"
 
In Berkeley and in the Castro (San Francisco), you see a couples and one of them is wearing a dog collar and leash, being led around by the other.

???

I live in Berkeley. I'll be the first to point out the high levels of weirdness here (much of which is neither quaint nor charming). I've seen naked middle aged hippies dancing around while playing the didgeridoo. I've seen Stalinist stooges marching under a hammer and sickle banner in a city parade. I've seen Code Pink activists urging high school kids to physically assault war veterans. But I have never seen a person led about with a dog collar and leash.

Come to think of it, that would be far preferable to what actually happens in Berkeley sometimes.
 
@Skeptic:

For the nth time:

Voluntary slavery (to the extent such a thing is not self-contradictory) not only should be legal, it is legal. It's called "employment." So to suggest that legalizing voluntary burqa-wearing requires that we legalize voluntary slavery is fine - it is not some kind of devastating argument against those who would allow women to wear what they will.

Also for the nth time: The issue that escapes you is consent.
 
Yes, women are oft forced to do wear or not wear certain things in the countries you mentioned. ... And also, women sold into slavery in various countries are often forced to wear high heeled shoes. What's your point? Should we ban high heeled shoes in the US or France, as well as the burqa?

Hey, why stop there? I'm required (by law now, not just by some family, religious, or social pressure) to wear clothes that cover my genitals while in public. Clearly, France needs to enforce my human rights by coming over here, taking over, and banning the pants, shorts, and underpants. The fact that I actually prefer to keep my genitals covered is beside the point - the state of Michigan would punish me for exposing them, so if I "choose" to cover them, it's a false choice, like a black person "choosing" to sell himself into slavery.

Was it Dr. King or Gandhi who said "A covered-up wiener anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere"?
 
If the burqa shold not be banned, slavery should not be banned, either.
That's a false analogy. Banning slavery is not like banning the burqa. The equivalent ban would be a ban against forcing someone to wear a burqa. That's already illegal of course, as it should be.

Banning the burqa is like banning gunshot wounds because we don't like people shooting each other. So if someone is seen with a gunshot wound, that person gets arrested. Not very sensible.

You do realise that to be effective, any law has to be enforced? And the enforcement of an anti-burqa law would in every case be to punish women. Do you really think these women deserve such punishment?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom