Sarkozy says burqas are 'not welcome' in France

In the one sentence you posit women being forced to wear one and being allowed to do so.
If someone is forced to do something, being 'allowed' doesn't come into it.
If someone chooses to do something, being 'forced' doesn't come into it.

There's no way around this point. Someone choosing to wear a garment in a free society is not a slave, nor can she be compared to a slave in that context alone.

Do you advocate punishing women who are forced to wear a burqa?
Do you advocate punishing women who choose to wear a burqa?
I doubt s/he will be brave enough to answer these questions directly. No one on this thread will be because these questions are the achilles heel of the "ban burqas" argument.

And I'm pretty sure we both know that ridiculous "99.9" percent claim will go unsupported as well.
 
Last edited:
There's no way around this point. Someone choosing to wear a garment in a free society is not a slave, nor can she be compared to a slave in that context alone.

I doubt s/he will be brave enough to answer these questions directly. No one on this thread will be because these questions are the achilles heel of the "ban burqas" argument.

And I'm pretty sure we both know that ridiculous "99.9" percent claim will go unsupported as well.

All true, but I live in hope. Sometimes I wonder why I am not religious...
 
All true, but I live in hope. Sometimes I wonder why I am not religious...

647258151_9c66ed5920.jpg


This miracle probably might take several hours.

Take a survey board to a large shopping mall. You will ask 100 people, excluding those belonging to Muslim, schools of Ninjutsu, and vampire subculture communities and irrespect of age, ethnicity, or country of origin, three mysterious questions. You'll also have several photographs on hand, like this.

The cheerful greeting goes as follows: "Hi, we are taking a women's rights poll to get Western opinions on the burqa. A lot of people think they are forced to wear it, but I know that's not true. It's gorgeous, like the fluttering of the night's wind caressing the human form in motion, the bottomless expanse of the cosmos wrapped around the light of the woman under it that beckons the stranger: "Get to know me better." Anyway, we want to find out what you think. This will only take 10 seconds of your time."

She's shown the photograph, then asked:

1)
Would you willingly wear this?
2) Is this something you think is attractive?
2) Why do you think a woman would?

You will notice several fascinating results, impossible before to understand but with the aid of statistics, now a reality:

"Like, no!"

"F(Beep)k no!"

"That's just sad.."

"If I had the option to dress like that for the rest of my life or jump off a bridge, I'd choose the bridge!"


"I'd rather wear a "Do Me. 1$." sign on my back."

Here is where you profit. If the result dips below 99.0%, I'll of course immediately apologize. There's just no excuse for throwing out loose percentages like this.
 
Last edited:
Quite a few wear the burqa in a free society on their own volition, many because they don't have to deal with their own extramarital sexual temptations as much, and don't have to put up with a lot of catcalls and lude remarks from men. That is their choice, not yours or mine. You are free to call it obnoxious, sick or whatever. That's your opinion. Your opinion shouldn't lead to a mandate on how a woman should dress herself.
A more interesting question, or perhaps a predictable one, is were you raised under Islam?
 
Do you advocate punishing women who are forced to wear a burqa? Do you advocate punishing women who choose to wear a burqa?
I certainly advocate women in burqas punishing men who force them to wear them. We can start with large amplifiers:

 
[Irrelevant attempt at proposing objective evidence for an unprovable claim]


Except 99.9% of cases the reason they "choose" to wear it is to maintain their livelihood, to not be psychologically or physically abused, rejected by their husbands and families, and as an added bonus, not mutilated and burned for eternity by God.
Above is your claim in full. The ridiculous poll you just attempted to propose included no direct questions that would prompt direct responses to your claim. Now, show me how you would set up a sensible study based on your claim. Hint: You would need to survey the women who actually wear burqas, as they are the ones you are attempting to mind read for.

Btw, interviewing a bunch of mallrats to the exclusion of the Muslim community and others who wear the burqa, then including frivolous fashion questions that seek to address the attractive a woman's style of dress ... that's more along the lines of superficial objectification of females.
 
Last edited:
A more interesting question, or perhaps a predictable one, is were you raised under Islam?

That's entirely none of your business. Stick to the contents of peoples' arguments. Anything else just leads to distracting, childish ad hominem attacks. Here is what I said. Maybe you can respond to the content of it this time ...

Quite a few wear the burqa in a free society on their own volition, many because they don't have to deal with their own extramarital sexual temptations as much, and don't have to put up with a lot of catcalls and lude remarks from men. That is their choice, not yours or mine. You are free to call it obnoxious, sick or whatever. That's your opinion. Your opinion shouldn't lead to a mandate on how a woman should dress herself.
 
I doubt s/he will be brave enough to answer these questions directly. No one on this thread will be because these questions are the achilles heel of the "ban burqas" argument.

And I'm pretty sure we both know that ridiculous "99.9" percent claim will go unsupported as well.

You were, of course, entirely right.
Just drivel about a silly poll that has nothing to do with the claims made.
And a complete failure to front up and say whether s/he wants to punish
a) Women who are forced to wear a burqa
b) Women who choose to wear a burqa.
 
Btw, interviewing a bunch of mallrats to the exclusion of the Muslim community and others who wear the burqa, then including frivolous fashion questions that seek to address the attractive a woman's style of dress ... that's more along the lines of superficial objectification of females.
Do you wear one? A fair question.
 
The poll illustrates what women not brought up in a cult naturally react to it: a grotesque, unnatural way to maintain livelihood, sanity and physical health. Banning it out of principle is far more constructive than not doing so. Put simply, who wants to look at it?
 
Last edited:
The poll illustrates what women not brought up in a cult naturally react to it: a grotesque, unnatural way to maintain livelihood, sanity and physical health. Banning it out of principle is far more constructive than not doing so. Put simply, who wants to look at it?

LOL First of all, a poll - even one as ludicrous as yours, that was never actually conducted, means absolutely nothing.

Secondly, your poll idea, as you've been notified, fails to address your original claim. This is a skeptics forum and if you can't present solid evidence behind a claim you made (like that ridiculous 99.9% mind-reading silliness), you've lost credibility and are making yourself appear quite foolish.
 
Why don't you respond to the post you are ignoring before moving on to new (and unimportant) personal questions?
Because it isn't a personal question. Furthermore, you are doing a very predictable job at lying. The constructive benefits of banning them on principle vastly outweigh the irritation 0.1% of converts (those that actually choose to without pressure) would "suffer" by being forced to wear a hijab.
 
You were, of course, entirely right.
Just drivel about a silly poll that has nothing to do with the claims made.
And a complete failure to front up and say whether s/he wants to punish
a) Women who are forced to wear a burqa
b) Women who choose to wear a burqa.

That sums it up quite well. The conclusion is the "ban burqa" argument is based on simple emotionality, unbacked by any sort of sound logic.

Another clue this argument is based in emotion is the presence of a poster who thinks it's relevant to pry into another poster's personal beliefs to try and support their argument. That's the kind of silly thing that happens when someone lacks objective evidence.
 
LOL First of all, a poll - even one as ludicrous as yours, that was never actually conducted, means absolutely nothing. Secondly, your poll idea, as you've been notified, fails to address your original claim.

This miracle probably might take several days. Take a survey board to a large mosque. You will ask 100 muslims, irrespect of age, ethnicity, or country of origin, three mysterious questions. You'll also have several photographs on hand, like this. You might also want to study this beforehand.

The cheerful greeting goes as follows: "In the name of Allah who has no partners and no clue about human nature, we are taking a women's rights poll to get fair opinions on the burqa. A lot of people think they are forced to wear it, but I know that's not true. It's gorgeous, like the fluttering of the night's wind caressing the wife's form in motion, the bottomless expanse of the cosmos wrapped around the light of the woman under it that beckons the stranger: "Get to know me better." Anyway, we want to find out what you think. This will only take 10 seconds of your time."

She's shown the photograph, then asked:

1)
Do you wear a burqa to please other people?
2) If you chose not to dress like this, would it be respected or would you be physically, psychologically or emotionally abused?
2) Does the need to wear anything else that you actually like override these repercussions?

You will notice several fascinating responses. Fascinating because they are all the same.

To the first question, "Yes"
To the second question, "Yes"
To the third question, "No, of course not"

Here is where you profit. If the result dips below 99.0%, I'll of course immediately apologize. There's just no excuse for throwing out loose percentages like this. Of course, in this case, few would actually answer these loaded, very personal questions.
 
Last edited:
The constructive benefits of banning them on principle vastly outweigh the irritation 0.1% of converts (those that actually choose to without pressure) would "suffer" by being forced to wear a hijab.

Where are you getting that 0.1% statistic? Whose mind are you reading this time?

If you can't back stats with facts, there's no perfectly good reason to take anything you're claiming seriously.
 
Where are you getting that 0.1% statistic? Whose mind are you reading this time? If you can't back stats with facts, there's no perfectly good reason to take anything you're claiming seriously.
Then I'll allow you to correct me. What percentage, out of 1.6 billion people wear burqas who are not raised in an Islamic environment or are not under any social pressure to do so. In other words, women converts who choose to walk around in public dressed as a ghost, instead of wearing a stylized hijab. To illustrate, here's an example in this documentary. Note the colorful hijab during the rituals.

My point is, obviously, nobody dresses like that in public every single day unless they have to.
 
This miracle probably might take several days. Take a survey board to a large mosque. You will ask 100 muslims, irrespect of age, ethnicity, or country of origin, three mysterious questions. You'll also have several photographs on hand, like this.

Oh my. You need to at least take a class in research psychology, as well as at least a beginner's course in psychological statistics. One of my majors was psychology and I recommend that you are embarrassing yourself here.

Aside from the fact that one survey is never is enough to satisfy a singular claim like yours ...

You would need to find a broader representative sample than a mosque (or a shopping mall). You would want a representative sample far larger than your 100 people. Your questions are leading and smack of bias and ten seconds is probably not long enough to allow people to ponder a set of questions with such heavy implications.

What is your highly specific - and I mean highly specific - reason for choosing that particular picture? It's unusual and problematic to show singular photos in opinion surveys anyway because they often unwittingly reveal a tester bias.

Now for your questions, which frankly are far too few and too general to receive nuanced answers to strongly support your sweeping claim.

1) Do you wear a burqa to please other people?
Many might answer "yes" and "no", and the answer could change for one person based on who is around them during the survey. But in your survey they are being forced to answer either "yes" or "no" (in ten seconds).

Some might point to that leading picture you held up and say she feels pressured to wear what that woman in the picture is wearing, just to fit it. In fact more than several women might say the burqa makes her feel less pressured than having to play "dress up" like that model you're presenting.

.. I'll finish my response in a moment ...
 
2) If you chose not to dress like this, would it be respected or would you be physically, psychologically or emotionally abused?

First you'd have to make sure there's a universally understood definition for "physical abuse", "psychological abuse" and "emotional abuse". For some women (or men) if their partner raises his voice they call it "abuse".

You notice how collecting subjective data requires some organized effort?

And when you say "respected", you'd have to ensure that your definition matched up with the subject's. But of course that too is very subjective, plus you only gave your subjects ten seconds to answer.

And that's just the start of your problems with Question #2.


3) Does the need to wear anything else that you actually like override these repercussions?
Are you sure wearing a particular type of clothes counts as a "need" for these women? Last time I checked needs includes air, water, food and shelter. What "repercussions" are they responding with (you didn't ask them about repercussions)? What would you understand "repercussions" to mean in evaluating their responses later? These are subjective matters and take investigative analysis.



... 99.0%, I'll of course immediately apologize. There's just no excuse for throwing out loose percentages like this.
I agree. You're forgiven ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom