Sarkozy says burqas are 'not welcome' in France

There's a big difference. If a woman's father, brothers, mother, other family members or community is so intent and so uncompromising on making her wear a burqa in public, they might be driven to keep her out of the public alltogether if they can't force her to wear a burqa.

In that case, they should be put in jail for THAT. Kidnapping and false arrest are felonies, you know. We should tolerate neither the burqa, nor families keeping their women virtual prisoners. Both are deeply opressive to women.
 
These arguments make total sense in a world where no one wears burqa voluntarily

There are also people who want to be slaves, voluntarily. Indeed, slavery -- whether sex- or color- or property-based -- is very comforting to certain type of submissive people, and had always been. But it still should not be legal.
 
snip for brevity

If a black man in the 50s said he didn't mind separate but equal, would that make it merely a different culture? One has to look a little beyond just the freedom of expression issue here.

I agree with your entire post on principle, I think it's rather bizarre, even disgusting, to see these women talk about "freedom of choice" when they are literally subjugating themselves to their husbands and their god, kind of like if a black slave in the 19th century had advocated his "freedom of choice" to keep his shackles (making the words "freedom" and "choice" lose all of their meaning), but is it the government's role to stop people from being stupid (unless their stupidity affects public safety)?

It looks like the most fundamentalist of Muslims don't understand what "freedom" is, they think "freedom" is a bad word, they do not want it because to them "freedom" is like being an animal. The fact that they are using it so wrongly here shows clearly that they are only using the word to keep being subservients to their god.

But then again, I guess they have the freedom to be stupid.

I'm kind of ambivalent about it.
 
Last edited:
I agree with your entire post on principle, I think it's rather bizarre, even disgusting, to see these women talk about "freedom of choice" when they are literally subjugating themselves to their husbands and their god, kind of like if a black slave in the 19th century had advocated his "freedom of choice" to keep his shackles (making the words "freedom" and "choice" lose all of their meaning), but is it the government's role to stop people from being stupid (unless their stupidity affects public safety)?

It looks like the most fundamentalist of Muslims don't understand what "freedom" is, they think "freedom" is a bad word, they do not want it because to them "freedom" is like being an animal. The fact that they are using it so wrongly here shows clearly that they are only using the word to keep being subservients to their god.

But then again, I guess they have the freedom to be stupid.

I'm kind of ambivalent about it.
Sometimes I like you, Pard. ;)

I agree there is a case for individualism. I'm trying to point out there is another way to look at it. You can't not be ambivalent to some degree. And I have no evidence this statement against oppression of women would be the least bit effective so I am ambivalent about that as well. But I do think I get Sarkozy's point.
 
Can you list some 'modern' countries where suicide is illegal (leaving aside the fact that it is impossible to punish suicide)
I disagree. One does not have to look beyond freedom, of expression or anything else. Freedom should be defended, not restricted so as to defend freedom.
Suicide is illegal in the US with the rare state that has a law allowing assisted suicide for people already dying of something.

Freedom to oppress or to be oppressed is not freedom. If it were then everything would be an example of freedom. Is a person free to own slaves?
 
Last edited:
I agree with your entire post on principle, I think it's rather bizarre, even disgusting, to see these women talk about "freedom of choice" when they are literally subjugating themselves to their husbands and their god, kind of like if a black slave in the 19th century had advocated his "freedom of choice" to keep his shackles

Well, some black slaved DID that, didn't they?

Pro-slavery advocates often gave examples of the happy, loyal, meek slave who realized how slavery was great for them -- saving their soul from hell by making them christians, showing them the proper relationship between the races -- and therefore found it deeply insulting that the annoying busybodies from the north want to "free" them from this happy servitude.

Similarly, indeed almost exactly, pro-burqa advocates today give examples of the happy, loyal, meek woman who realized how wearing the burqa is good for them -- saving their soul from hell by making sure they are modest, teaching them the proper relatinship between the sexes -- and therefore find it deeply insulting that the annoying busybodies from the west want to "free" them from this happy servitude.

You know something? I think those black slaves, like those burqa-supporting women, were or are honest. With enough brainwashing -- especially since childhood -- you can teach people to love anything, including their shackles... or their burqa.

Bring back slavery is what *I* say. No fair limiting freedom of choice, right?
 
Voluntary slavery does continue to happen. Google BDSM and you will find people who do love their shackles.
 
Er, no. BDSM is a sexual game. It is not actually being owned or controlled by someone else.

That aside, let me accept your point that, whether or not BDSM is in fact slavery (it isn't, I believe), there are indeed people who wish to be slaves, as I said. Would that be a reason to legalize slavery?

Wouldn't it be perfectly obvious that whatever "right to be a slave" is violated by the tiny minority of people who really do want to be slaves, it is nothing compared to the horrific abuse of coerced slavery than will become widespread if slavery is legalized?

Same with the burka. Perhaps there is a small number of submissive doormats who really want to wear it of their own free will. But they are surely only a tiny minority compared to those who are opressed, silenced, and made into moving black objects by the burka against their will.

Besides, isn't it ironic that these submissive doormats now say -- or rather, have others say in their place -- that they DEMAND the RIGHT to wear the burka? Since when do they have any will other people should respect? They should just shut up and take off the burka, like their betters command them to. After all, shutting up and doing as they're told is what they claim they WANT to do all their lives anyway.
 
Last edited:
Someone in this thread claimed that my arguments about banning the burka -- that it is a symbol and tool of opressing and dehumanization of women -- would only be relevant in a world where no woman wants to wear a burka of her own free will.

But, using the same logic, enslavement of blacks should only be illegal tout court if no black person wants to be a slave of their own free will. Since some blacks want to be slaves -- even if very few -- I suggest that we should allow blacks to sell themselves into slavery.
 
I get all the "this is about freedom" comments. One can easily see that side of the argument.

You appear to be having some trouble with this.

This is about taking a stand against repression of women and stating the obvious, the burqa is a symbol of repression of women, regardless of all the women who feel they are choosing to wear them.
Not always. Women don't all think alike and the women who choose to where a burqa in a (relatively) free country do so by their own free will, whether or not you think they are repressing themselves. You cannot easily minimize this point or set it aside for the sake of looking at the other "side of the argument".

Let's look at a different example where it is more clear society has a right to define and intervene in brainwashing. Take the Heaven's Gate cult.
Wearing a burqa doesn't satisfy the definition of dangerous cultish behavior. This is hyperbole.

So every case where someone willingly does something is not necessarily purely about freedom.
I'm speaking about burqas.
As for a history of willingness of women to let men abuse them, there are many examples of women who willingly stay in abusive situations.
Wearing a burqa doesn't mean a women is necessarily in an abusive situation.

If a black man in the 50s said he didn't mind separate but equal, would that make it merely a different culture? One has to look a little beyond just the freedom of expression issue here.
Society didn't give Blacks a choice. Today, in a free country like the US (or France, etc.) a woman can choose to "be equal" or not, to a large extent. She can also choose to wear a burqa or not, regardless of how much her chosen action offends you.
 
Last edited:
H'm -- wait a minute, don't we have a solution staring us in the face?

1). Ban the burqa. Make sure, however, that only men make this specific law that bans it.

Now:

2). If you are a woman with any self-respect, you'd not want to wear the burqa anyway, and will be relieved it is banned. That only men made the law, in this case, would be of no relevance.

3). If you're one of those who wants to be a burqa, then you should shut up and accept your betters' decision that you are not allowed to do it. Since the whole point of wearing a burqa in the first place is to show one's submissiveness and inferiority to men, always deferring to their superior judgement and intelligence, what's the problem?
 
Last edited:
Society didn't give Blacks a choice. Today, in a free country like the US (or France, etc.) a woman can choose to "be equal" or not, to a large extent.

In the past, society didn't give black people much choice. Today, in a free country like the USA, a Black person can choose to "be equal" or not, to a large extent, so why limit their choice to sell themselves into slavery if they really want to?

I'll buy one.
 
Last edited:
Wearing a burqa doesn't mean a women is necessarily in an abusive situation.

Well, except for having no peripheral vision, no freedom of movement, no face, no body, no ability to speak to anyone except perhaps chose family, and a few other minor inconveniences.

But hey, it's "freely chosen" -- by those women whose view of their sex's place is the same as that of the average male Beduin in 8th-century Arabia.

Boy, you should meet Sambo, my slave. He just freely chose to live like that, having freely decided that Blacks' role in society really should be the same as the average 1820s plantation owner believed. Who are you to say he's in an abusive situation? He LIKES it that way.

Hey, Sambo, another round of drinks! There's a good boy.
 
Last edited:
You appear to be having some trouble with this..
I'm not having any trouble. I simply have a different point of view about where to draw the line.

We are not 'free' to yell fire in a crowded theater. So Let's start by agreeing there is a line.

Women willingly stay with abusing partners, society doesn't approve. Again there is a line.

In many states abusing partners go to jail even when the abused person refuses to testify. Another line.


All these "freedoms" you think are so clear cut are not. Different societies draw the lines in different places.

I'm just not drawing the line in the same place you are.
 
http://www.breitbart.com/article.php?id=D98VP85G1&show_article=1

I'm personally a little torn on this one.

I think burqas/niqabs/etc. are ridiculous - literally, worthy of ridicule. It's absurd to tell women to cover themselves up so that they don't "shame themselves" or incite a man's lust. (If a man looks at a woman and has "lustful thoughts," that's his problem to deal with, not hers.)

The idea that women who don't shave their legs and armpits are disgusting, that they have to alter their bodies constantly as to not cause visual offense or disgust in others is ridiculous too. ESPECIALLY when legs aren't a gendered part, a hairy guy leg looks more or less the same as a hairy womans leg but you won't catch anyone going "EEW" at a man wearing some shorts. it is an expectation of the fundamental altering of a body feature that is totally normal and harmless. things like high heeled shoes, which are obviously disabling at the cost of trying to fit beauty norms are as well. I could go on and on. plastic surgery. The amount of cultural snobbery I have seen expressed over this issue is pretty awful. (note: before anyone says it, there isn't anything wrong with shaving as an act by itself just like there isn't anything wrong with a burqa in the absence of social context, and i am not saying that our fashion mandates for women are any better or worse than theirs I am simply pointing out that they exist in our culture as well).

the burqa rule will do nothing but make the oppression of women less visible, and people will probably assume it is less of a problem because of that.
 
Last edited:
Surely you're not suggesting the social pressure on a woman to shave her armpits in the west, and the social pressure on a woman to wear a burqa in the Muslim world, are equivalent? You might as well argue that the exclusion of Blacks from certain country clubs today, and the exclusion of Blacks from the voting booth half a century ago are equivalent.
 
when a woman belives that Allah wants her to wear such a Burka, is this then her free will when she wears one?
 
There are also people who want to be slaves, voluntarily. Indeed, slavery -- whether sex- or color- or property-based -- is very comforting to certain type of submissive people, and had always been. But it still should not be legal.

This is ridiculous. Slavery is involuntary. If you want to be a slave, you're not a slave. You're a volunteer, or an intern. Once again, the issue that escapes you is consent. What would "voluntary slavery" look like? Working for free? That's not illegal, and nobody thinks it should be. Involuntary slavery (i.e., slavery) should be illegal.

Someone in this thread claimed that my arguments about banning the burka -- that it is a symbol and tool of opressing and dehumanization of women -- would only be relevant in a world where no woman wants to wear a burka of her own free will.
That's a dishonest paraphrase, but let's not worry about it...
But, using the same logic, enslavement of blacks should only be illegal tout court if no black person wants to be a slave of their own free will. Since some blacks want to be slaves -- even if very few -- I suggest that we should allow blacks to sell themselves into slavery.
No, that doesn't make sense. Like I said, slavery is involuntary by definition. The very phrase "wants to be a slave of their own free will" is nonsensical. Blacks (along with everyone else) should be and are allowed to "sell themselves into slavery." Of course, we don't call it slavery, because slavery is involuntary.

Now, I agree with you that it should be illegal to force someone else to wear burqa. But there's nothing magical about a burqa that makes it impossible to wear voluntarily. I repeat: the only way your arguments make sense is if no one wears a burqa voluntarily.

So you've tried the inapt wife-beating analogy, and the inapt slavery analogy. Do you have anything else?

There are decent arguments for your position, but these are not among them.


ETA:
In the past, society didn't give black people much choice. Today, in a free country like the USA, a Black person can choose to "be equal" or not, to a large extent, so why limit their choice to sell themselves into slavery if they really want to?

I'll buy one.

The word you're looking for is "hire," and yes, you can do that, if you find someone willing. This argument is nonsensical.
 
Last edited:
Well, except for having no peripheral vision, no freedom of movement, no face, no body, no ability to speak to anyone except perhaps chose family, and a few other minor inconveniences.

But hey, it's "freely chosen" -- by those women whose view of their sex's place is the same as that of the average male Beduin in 8th-century Arabia.

In Berkeley and in the Castro (San Francisco), you see a couples and one of them is wearing a dog collar and leash, being led around by the other. This goes for women and men, gay and straight couples. I may not understand it, but they're doing it by choice, in a relatively free country.

Boy, you should meet Sambo, my slave. He just freely chose to live like that, having freely decided that Blacks' role in society really should be the same as the average 1820s plantation owner believed. Who are you to say he's in an abusive situation? He LIKES it that way.

Hey, Sambo, another round of drinks! There's a good boy.

... And some of those people being led around in "bondage" I speak of are Black. It's a choice.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom