There are also people who want to be slaves, voluntarily. Indeed, slavery -- whether sex- or color- or property-based -- is very comforting to certain type of submissive people, and had always been. But it still should not be legal.
This is ridiculous. Slavery is
involuntary. If you want to be a slave, you're not a slave. You're a volunteer, or an intern. Once again, the issue that escapes you is
consent. What would "voluntary slavery" look like? Working for free? That's not illegal, and nobody thinks it should be. Involuntary slavery (i.e.,
slavery)
should be illegal.
Someone in this thread claimed that my arguments about banning the burka -- that it is a symbol and tool of opressing and dehumanization of women -- would only be relevant in a world where no woman wants to wear a burka of her own free will.
That's a dishonest paraphrase, but let's not worry about it...
But, using the same logic, enslavement of blacks should only be illegal tout court if no black person wants to be a slave of their own free will. Since some blacks want to be slaves -- even if very few -- I suggest that we should allow blacks to sell themselves into slavery.
No, that doesn't make sense. Like I said, slavery is involuntary by definition. The very phrase "wants to be a slave of their own free will" is nonsensical. Blacks (along with everyone else) should be
and are allowed to "sell themselves into slavery." Of course, we don't call it slavery, because slavery is involuntary.
Now, I agree with you that it should be illegal to force someone else to wear burqa. But there's nothing magical about a burqa that makes it impossible to wear voluntarily. I repeat: the only way your arguments make sense is if no one wears a burqa voluntarily.
So you've tried the inapt wife-beating analogy, and the inapt slavery analogy. Do you have anything else?
There are decent arguments for your position, but these are not among them.
ETA:
In the past, society didn't give black people much choice. Today, in a free country like the USA, a Black person can choose to "be equal" or not, to a large extent, so why limit their choice to sell themselves into slavery if they really want to?
I'll buy one.
The word you're looking for is "hire," and yes, you can do that, if you find someone willing. This argument is nonsensical.