Sarkozy says burqas are 'not welcome' in France

Because this way you get to prosecute or fine the women. Good feminist plan.

Every freedom to come at the cost of a freedom from, and vice versa.

The principle behind this move is to exchange one facet of freedom of dress (which already is limited in several ways) for the increased freedom from the oppression behind that garment.

If it looked like it would work, I'd say it was a fair exchange. I just haven't seen a strong case that this move will effectively achieve that exchange.
 
The issue that escapes you is consent.
Are you legally permitted to walk naked through a shopping mall because mother nature says so? You aren't because it is offensive or disruptive to everyone else. That's not the case in Kenya. In France, or anywhere else really, a burqa and the reasoning underlying it is not socially acceptable.
 
The burqa is bizarre, sad and socially obnoxious just about everywhere but Islamic societies.

Yep, and "socially obnoxious" (according to some people) does not automatically equate with a state of slavery. "Socially obnoxious" is not a good enough reason to punish women for being socially/fashionably "obnoxious" in some peoples' eyes by wearing a certain garment.
 
Are you legally permitted to walk naked through a shopping mall because mother nature says so? You aren't because it is offensive or disruptive to everyone else. That's not the case in Kenya. In France, or anywhere else really, a burqa and the reasoning underlying it is not socially acceptable.

Actually, there are quite a few Muslims in France and other "free" nations who are not offended by a woman wearing the burqa. In fact, there are plenty of non-Muslims too who find it legally important for women to be able to CHOOSE to wear burqas in free nations. However much you try, you can't get around the fact that adult women are often choosing to wear this style of clothing.

... Take that choice away and it is chauvenism, ironically.
 
Every freedom to come at the cost of a freedom from, and vice versa.

The principle behind this move is to exchange one facet of freedom of dress (which already is limited in several ways) for the increased freedom from the oppression behind that garment.

If it looked like it would work, I'd say it was a fair exchange. I just haven't seen a strong case that this move will effectively achieve that exchange.

The "principle", as you've spinned it here, is not what I'm addressing. I'm addressing how masogynistic[sic] it is to take away a woman's right to wear a simple garment that she desires to wear in observing what she deems valuable to her culture or religion.
 
Yep, and "socially obnoxious" (according to some people) does not automatically equate with a state of slavery. "Socially obnoxious" is not a good enough reason to punish women for being socially/fashionably "obnoxious" in some peoples' eyes by wearing a certain garment.
Sick more than obnoxious, the issue is why not what. But it is not a choice on their part whatsoever. They are rejected by their relatives and community, some outright murdered if they do not.
 
Actually, there are quite a few Muslims in France and other "free" nations who are not offended by a woman wearing the burqa. In fact, there are plenty of non-Muslims too who find it legally important for women to be able to CHOOSE to wear burqas in free nations. However much you try, you can't get around the fact that adult women are often choosing to wear this style of clothing. ... Take that choice away and it is chauvenism, ironically.
Except 99.9% of cases the reason they "choose" to wear it is to maintain their livelihood, to not be psychologically or physically abused, rejected by their husbands and families, and as an added bonus, not mutilated and burned for eternity by God. It is liberating, undeniably, not to have to worry about these facts of life. To take off a burqa is to take on living hell, and to wear it is to promote it. Or do you think otherwise?
 
So are a lot of clothes from the catwalks.
Do you want to punish women who choose to wear a burqa?
They are required to wear it, they cannot furthermore leave Islam. The act of banning it as socially unacceptable (as it should be in any modern society), if anything allows them a rare excuse to enjoy, if only in secret, basic human dignity. The entire purpose of the burqa was that the female form is "repulsive" to Allah - it provokes heterosexual thoughts and behavior in men and turns it away from a fictional dictator. You have a situation then, unlike nuns, where the least a woman provokes anything naturally attractive to the opposite sex, the better. This also results in acute violence if a woman from a Muslim community does outright provoke it.

That is why it is so reprehensible. Plenty of people walk around Europe looking like the living dead. Obviously the issue is not fashion.
 
They are required to wear it, they cannot furthermore leave Islam. .
What does ' they cannot furthermore leave Islam' mean? I don't understand that.

And women who choose to wear the burqa are not
required to wear it. That is what 'choose' means.

Do you want to punish women who choose to wear the burqa?

Do you want to punish women who are forced to wear the burqa?

Neither position makes any sense to me.
 
Neither position makes any sense to me.
That's because you don't understand or accept the function the burqa actually serves: to degrade. The question is exactly like asking why women who are forced by their communities to wear dog leashes in public should not be allowed to do so.
 
Except 99.9% of cases the reason they "choose" to wear it is to maintain their livelihood, to not be psychologically or physically abused, rejected by their husbands and families, and as an added bonus, not mutilated and burned for eternity by God. It is liberating, undeniably, not to have to worry about these facts of life. To take off a burqa is to take on living hell, and to wear it is to promote it. Or do you think otherwise?

source?
 
They are rejected by their relatives and community, some outright murdered if they do not.

Careful with the word "they"; there are plenty of women in "free" countries who are wearing the burqa because it is their desire to do so ... not out of a sense of coercion. You and I don't have to totally understand it.

Quite a few wear the burqa in a free society on their own volition, many because they don't have to deal with their own extramarital sexual temptations as much, and don't have to put up with a lot of catcalls and lude remarks from men. That is their choice, not yours or mine. You are free to call it obnoxious, sick or whatever. That's your opinion. Your opinion shouldn't lead to a mandate on how a woman should dress herself.
 
Except 99.9% of cases the reason they "choose" to wear it is to maintain their livelihood, to not be psychologically or physically abused, rejected by their husbands and families, and as an added bonus, not mutilated and burned for eternity by God. It is liberating, undeniably, not to have to worry about these facts of life. To take off a burqa is to take on living hell, and to wear it is to promote it. Or do you think otherwise?

LOL ... Where are you getting that statistic from?

Anyhow, what you are horrified by is radical Islam, not a piece of cloth. In a relatively free society people wear different types of clothing for different reasons. We enjoy something called "freedom of expression", which extends to shirts, pants, burqas, snowpants, etc. So yes, "I think otherwise".

You can't prove everyone who wears a burqa in a liberated society like France is being subjugated so really you have no solid argument against the burqa - a piece of cloth - itself. Come on.
 
That's because you don't understand or accept the function the burqa actually serves: to degrade. The question is exactly like asking why women who are forced by their communities to wear dog leashes in public should not be allowed to do so.

Can you not see the incongruencies in your "argument"? The burqa serves different functions based on who is wearing it and where. I've already listed situations where women CHOOSE to wear it to stave off unwanted male attention. But apparently you're not intellectually honest enough to admit the burqa means different things to different people.

Did you know ski masks are often purchased in order to rob banks? I'm sure we should ban ski masks too :rolleyes:
 
That's because you don't understand or accept the function the burqa actually serves: to degrade. The question is exactly like asking why women who are forced by their communities to wear dog leashes in public should not be allowed to do so.

Nonsense. I fully understand that wearing the burqa is degrading. I consider that true whether the woman is forced to wear it or chooses to wear it.
Your analogy to the dog leash is ludicrous. In the one sentence you posit women being forced to wear one and being allowed to do so.
If someone is forced to do something, being 'allowed' doesn't come into it.
If someone chooses to do something, being 'forced' doesn't come into it.

Do you advocate punishing women who are forced to wear a burqa?
Do you advocate punishing women who choose to wear a burqa?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom