Sarkozy says burqas are 'not welcome' in France

Although less dishonest, SirPhilip ... ]

Fixed that for you.

To refresh your memory, first I made the following statement:

Until someone can objectively prove the burqa is intrinsically harmful, it shouldn't be banned in the context of a relatively free society like France.

Your reply? A contradicting statement with alleged "evidence" in the form of this ...



You have failed to explain how the links above offer evidence that objectively proves the burqa is intrinsically harmful. I fully expect you to keep fearfully avoiding a reasonable request to offer a direct, clear explanation as to how your items #1,#2 and #3 above objectively prove that (your claim) "the burqa is intrinsically harmful" is fact.

This is a skeptics' forum SP, and no one need take your "intrinsic" claim seriously unless or until you back it with facts. Especially because you're already lacking credibility, given your earlier abuse of statistics as "fact", plus your embarrasing hack polling ideas that failed to boost your argument.
 
Which 99.9% of the time, they haven't and have no comprehension of what rights or a free choice actually is..

Speaking of (more) dishonesty, where, SP, specifically, did you get this statistic?
 
What part were you having trouble with, though?

Let's see:
. the utter incoherence of some of your posts
. the made up statistics
. the claim that Turkey is predominantly Arab
. the failure to say which countries ban the burqa (if you can make such an egregious error as the above regarding Turkey's ethnic composition, it is not unreasonable to politely ask that you name a few countries which ban the burqa)
. the insistence that no woman would choose to wear a burqa, despite the fact that some women do
. the belief that two groups of women should be punished: one which is comprised of women forced to wear a burqa and the other comprised of women who choose to wear a burqa
. the reference to child abuse when we are talking about adults
. the use of insults when you cannot rationally back up your position
. the denial that people should have the right to make choices you find offensive

Is that enough to be going on with?
 
This extract still makes no sense, despite being edited more than once:

Do they not publicly shame themselves in the purely fake and contemptible manner they pretend it is something you invented, and pitiful of all, challenge you to figure it out step by step for them?
 
Let's see:
. the utter incoherence of some of your posts
. the made up statistics
. the claim that Turkey is predominantly Arab
. the failure to say which countries ban the burqa (if you can make such an egregious error as the above regarding Turkey's ethnic composition, it is not unreasonable to politely ask that you name a few countries which ban the burqa)
. the insistence that no woman would choose to wear a burqa, despite the fact that some women do
. the belief that two groups of women should be punished: one which is comprised of women forced to wear a burqa and the other comprised of women who choose to wear a burqa
. the reference to child abuse when we are talking about adults
. the use of insults when you cannot rationally back up your position
. the denial that people should have the right to make choices you find offensive

Is that enough to be going on with?

Bingo.
 
I know - it's really about 99.0%, but I get so tired of saying the most likely right thing all the time.

and what is the source for those 99%?

you dont realise it he?
your made up statistics and lies dont help your argument, it makes you look like a loonatic freak.

its ok for me when you belive its a good thing to ban the burqa. thats your oppinion, but you keep making stuff up and spread lies just because you cannot accept that other people have a diffrent oppinion in that regard.

it is getting quite laughable.
 
You have failed to explain how the links above offer evidence that objectively proves the burqa is intrinsically harmful.
It isn't a real question though. What you are doing, at your own shame, is declaring that child abuse doesn't exist and my statements have no context. Which of course is why it is being banned in yet another country, right?

Self-evident is used where cause and effect are so clearly defined on an issue no reasonable cause for debate is merited. We already know why it is worn, what it's effect on an individual and social level are, and what it's effect on children are. If I simply wanted however, to go along with your game - labor to get you to agree with me (an art form after thoroughly and rightfully insulting someone, always), I would first have to satisfy three rules:

1) Prove beyond a reasonable doubt the Burqas' function is amoral, inhumane and abusive.

2) Outline and explain why it is unacceptable in any society, why banning it does not conflict with rights as it is a symbol of none for a gender, and furthermore because by extension of it not being banned and acceptable to wear, child abuse is also acceptable.

3) Outline why these social factors astronomically outweigh the petty irritation a few people would have about not being able to walk around in public in disguise that you, Keri and Cheney consider me insensitive for neglecting.


If done, much like one would do in a court where issues are weighed (although I've already done this to a large extent), would you acknowledge that I am right? I draw the reader to the fact nobody here actually challenged any statement I made - simply declaring the entire context doesn't exist for debate and challenging me to prove otherwise.
 
Last edited:
I draw the reader to the fact nobody here actually challenged any statement I made - simply declaring the entire context doesn't exist for debate and challenging me to prove otherwise.

Challenges:
where do your statistics come from?
which countries ban the burqa?
why do you say Turkey is predominantly Arab?
on what do you base your insistence that no woman chooses to wear a burqa, when it is a fact that some women have articulated that choice quite eloquently

Who declared
the entire context doesn't exist for debate?

That is a nonsensical statement and nobody has said it.
 
Last edited:
It isn't a real question though. ...

Yes it is. My question is and was: how is it that those three links of yours back up your assertion that "the burqa is intrinsically harmful"?

It is you who chose to post those links as evidence to back up the above assertion. ... Therefore it is your responsibility to directly explain yourself. Anything else is just one more cowardly distraction and believe it or not SP, people around here aren't fooled by your obvious avoidance.
 
As I've already pointed out, nobody does [choose freely] in the case of the burqa: It's intentionally, specifically, officially intended to be degrading.

I haven't read the whole thread I'm afraid, but could you direct me to the post where you explained how you demonstrated that nobody chooses freely what to wear in the case of the burqa, and your sources for this assertion?

Also, where and by whom is it "officially" announced that the burqa is "intended to be degrading"?

Thanks.
 
I haven't read the whole thread I'm afraid, but could you direct me to the post where you explained how you demonstrated that nobody chooses freely what to wear in the case of the burqa, and your sources for this assertion?
I stated that virtually nobody wears a Burqa willingly for the rest of their life unless under enormous passive aggressive pressure to do so by their communities. I also stated that if you asked 1000 people under no pressure, probably 0.1% out of 1000 people polled might consider it. This provoked a series of very silly questions as to my 'source' for this when it should be obvious what I meant.

Also, where and by whom is it "officially" announced that the burqa is "intended to be degrading"?
The Qu'ran and Hadith (s) certainly affirm it's status beyond any reasonable doubt. It is degrading in the context of affirming the repulsiveness of females to the very point where, often, not even their eyes should be seen as a convenience. I have to point out what is degrading about this?
 
The Qu'ran and Hadith (s) certainly affirm it's status beyond any reasonable doubt. It is degrading in the context of affirming the repulsiveness of females to the very point where, often, not even their eyes should be seen as a convenience. I have to point out what is degrading about this?

You could point out which part of the koran says that burqas should be worn.
You could also point out which part said that it should be worn because females are repulsive.
Or you could just carry on with your ignorance and continue making things up to suit yourself.
 
Last edited:
You are completely wrong in saying nobody chooses a burqa. Repeating a falsehood, or deliberate lie, does not make it true.
Then I'll hijack your own position. We'll assume I'm completely wrong now, that is:

1) People in Europe and elsewhere routinely convert to Islam, and choose to wear it every day of their life despite it not being a requirement.

2) There is no aggressive pressure to do so, it is a choice they've made and carries no immediate repercussions such as in theocratic Islamic states.

2) There is no passive aggressive pressure to do so, it carries no repercussions about what people close to them think of them if they do not. They are still "loved".

And..

3) 50% or higher of those who wear burqas aren't in fact forced or mandated to, despite the almost universal, natural need women have to look attractive.

Is there anything you can offer to suggest this, although totally unlikely, is the case?
 
Last edited:
Some posts moved to AAH.

Keep it civil from now on please. Attack the argument, not the arguer.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Gaspode
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom