But France is not one of those countries, and if a woman so chooses, she gets to behave as if she's "oppressed", in your words, provided it is her preference to wear the garment.
That is not relevant. I posted what Sarkozy gave as the reason he wanted to make this particular statement. I agree with his message.
I get all the "this is about freedom" comments. One can easily see that side of the argument.
I am trying to put a little focus on the other side of the argument. This is not about bigotry against Muslims nor is it about suppressing anyone's religious freedom. This is about taking a stand against repression of women and stating the obvious, the burqa is a symbol of repression of women, regardless of all the women who feel they are choosing to wear them.
Let's look at a different example where it is more clear society has a right to define and intervene in brainwashing. Take the
Heaven's Gate cult. Suicide is against the law in modern countries with perhaps exceptions for people nearing death naturally. Yet one could argue the followers of Marshall Applewhite were willing participants. But most people would say they were brainwashed and had anyone known what was up the law might have intervened.
So every case where someone willingly does something is not necessarily purely about freedom.
We are so used to religious views being about freedom that when it is not quite as abnormal appearing as a cult, then it must be a case of religious freedom. Yet there is plenty of evidence the Koran does not include instructions to wear burqas. So
you could make the case wearing burqas is only practiced by certain cults within the Muslim religion.
There is at least a case to be made the issue is cults oppressing female members. You may not agree with the case, but the case can be made.
As for a history of willingness of women to let men abuse them, there are many examples of women who willingly stay in abusive situations.
Whether that is the equivalent here is very hard to determine. I have struggled with this given I've always been a supporter of tolerating, even enjoying other cultures. But in seeing the damage done by cultures oppressing women, including the fact cultures where women do not have equal rights often do poorly compared to cultures where women do have equal rights, I have come to the conclusion this particular cultural practice does not deserve tolerance regardless of the willingness of women in those cultures to drink the koolaid.
If a black man in the 50s said he didn't mind separate but equal, would that make it merely a different culture? One has to look a little beyond just the freedom of expression issue here.