Sarkozy says burqas are 'not welcome' in France

I'm afraid to ask how you found that web page.
I've noticed that the nicest of intentions can result in landing in some extremely "different" sites on the 'net.
It can take hours and hours to get out of them, the way they link to each other!

Basically as Mr Ratant says. When there was a fuss about hijab/niqabs/burqas a few years ago I googled to find out which was which - I am basically inquisitive - and that site (or a previous incarnation) was one that came up. It has enough, how can I put this, interesting features to find again by googling. Honest! ;)
 
By this logic, slapping women around in public should be legal -- after all, as long as it's done publicly, at least people watching will make sure it doesn't cross the line. Much better than having the wife-beater beat her up at home where nobody can see how hard he hits her, don't you think?
What a terrible analogy. Is "slapping women around in public" meant to be analogous to men forcing women to wear burqa in public, or analogous to women wearing burqa in public?
 
And now Al Qaeda is threatening France over the alleged "injustice".

http://www.cnn.com/2009/WORLD/europe/06/30/france.burkas.al.qaeda/index.html

"We will not tolerate such provocations and injustices."
Is there anything they do tolerate?

I guess killing thousands of innocent people, including children, and cutting people's faces off with piano wires is not "injustice". :rolleyes:

I was originally against France's decision, but now I think I'll support it, just to piss these guys off.

 
Last edited:
Martin Jarvis (an actor) played a blinder on this yesterday. On a discussion programme (the One Show), they did an item about niqab/hijab/burka, presenting all angles, after which they went back to the studio. There was a woman in niqab, I think, who defended it quite vehemently, explaining all the wonderful reasons she wants to wear it and why it's right to wear it, and how liberated it made her feel. After this, Martin Jarvis expressed a respectful admiration of the views presented, and then said something along the lines of "...and can I just say, you have the most beautiful eyes", which rather missed the point. She immediately began pulling the top of the eyeslit down and the bottom of it up and was most discomfited. I think he meant it quite innocently, but the way it came across had me in stitches.
 
This is a comment made by one of the posters in the discussion linked by Rat above. I think it nails the point on the head.

"Ultimately this is about freedom of choice.

If women have the choice to uncover as much as they like surely they have the choice to cover as much as they want?

Society should not dictate to individuals how they dress and the choices they make."
 
I can understand feeling liberated by a burqa or a nun's habit.

No need to spend hundreds of dollars on clothes, no need to spend hours on your hair, no need to wear makeup and high heels. No women judging you on your appearance, no men judging you on your appearance. No horny idiots bothering you, no lunatic trying to look up your skirt on the escalator or trying to peer down your shirt, no wolf whistling as you walk down the street, no disgusting boss trying to get a date with you, little chance of sexual harassment.
 
No need to spend hundreds of dollars on clothes, no need to spend hours on your hair, no need to wear makeup and high heels. No women judging you on your appearance, no men judging you on your appearance. No horny idiots bothering you, no lunatic trying to look up your skirt on the escalator or trying to peer down your shirt, no wolf whistling as you walk down the street, no disgusting boss trying to get a date with you, little chance of sexual harassment.

The 'need' to buy fashionable clothes and spend 'hours' on hair and wear makeup and fashionable shoes exists independently of burquas. I, for one, have no 'need' to do any of those things. And I don't need a burqua to resist those 'needs'. Neither does a burqua eliminate the offensive behaviours of others. It may elicit other offensive behaviours.
But for all that I should have the choice of wearing or not wearing a burqua and should not be either required to wear it or required to not wear it.
 
While the Burqa may be worn voluntarily by some women, even by many women, and perhaps in and of itself it is not oppressing a woman, but no one can deny women are oppressed in many countries and the requirement they wear these coverings when out in public is one tool of that oppression.

But France is not one of those countries, and if a woman so chooses, she gets to behave as if she's "oppressed", in your words, provided it is her preference to wear the garment.
 
I can understand feeling liberated by a burqa or a nun's habit.

No need to spend hundreds of dollars on clothes, no need to spend hours on your hair, no need to wear makeup and high heels. No women judging you on your appearance, no men judging you on your appearance. No horny idiots bothering you, no lunatic trying to look up your skirt on the escalator or trying to peer down your shirt, no wolf whistling as you walk down the street, no disgusting boss trying to get a date with you, little chance of sexual harassment.
Do you wear your burqa often, or just when you're not feeling 'dressy'?
 
By this logic, slapping women around in public should be legal -- after all, as long as it's done publicly, at least people watching will make sure it doesn't cross the line. Much better than having the wife-beater beat her up at home where nobody can see how hard he hits her, don't you think?

Don't be so ridiculous.
You claimed that if burqas are made illegal then it liberates the women who are forced to wear them by their dominant male family members. It doesn't, because it doesn't magically change the attitude of those males. They will still believe that they have the right to deny having 'their women' seen by other males, and therefore the steps to enforce that change. Their minds do not.

It has nothing to do with whether the public see it and allow it or not. It is to do with what dominant male members will permit to happen to 'their women'. Good grief, what a bizarre twisted logic that was to apply to my response.
 
By this logic, slapping women around in public should be legal -- after all, as long as it's done publicly, at least people watching will make sure it doesn't cross the line.

I'm quite sure that it's already illegal to force someone to wear a burqa against their will. It's hard to prove though, given that the threat applied is not a gun to their head, but rather the threat of not being provided for, of being thrown out of the family, etc.

Exactly how would oppressed women be helped by a law that criminalizes them - not their husbands, fathers, brothers etc?


Here in Sweden we had a case not too long ago where one burqa-wearing woman was thrown out of some education. If I recall correctly, the motivation was that she would not be able to work in that profession wearing a burqa anyway.

Now, this strikes me as extremely stupid if you're serious about fighting sexual oppression. What if this woman wasn't intending to wear the burqa at all, once she completed the education? Isn't it pretty obvious that if she was coerced by her family to wear it, she'd figure that before she tried to stand up to them, it would be good to have a chance at providing for herself?

The same argument goes for wearing burqas in public really. If we want to give oppressed burqa-wearing women a fighting chance, isn't it obviously bad to deny them the chance to interact with people outside their families?
 
Don't be so ridiculous.
You claimed that if burqas are made illegal then it liberates the women who are forced to wear them by their dominant male family members. It doesn't, because it doesn't magically change the attitude of those males.

True, true.

So why make wife-beating illegal? Merely making it illegal doesn't change the attitude of the wife-beater, does it? He still WANTS to beat his wife and considers it his right.

How about segregation? Making it illegal didn't stop White racists' attitudes of not wanting to be next to Blacks, did it (e.g., "White flight" and the rest of that).

See? Pointless political grandstanding, both making wife-beating illegal and ending segregation.

Just like banning the burqa.
 
No need to spend hundreds of dollars on clothes, no need to spend hours on your hair, no need to wear makeup and high heels. No women judging you on your appearance, no men judging you on your appearance. No horny idiots bothering you, no lunatic trying to look up your skirt on the escalator or trying to peer down your shirt, no wolf whistling as you walk down the street, no disgusting boss trying to get a date with you, little chance of sexual harassment.

Indeed so. All for the small, small price of seeing the world through a letterbox for the rest of your life as your husband owns you.

I can see why slavery is liberating, too. No need to worry about a home, clothes, food, etc. -- it's all your master's problem; no annoying people asking how you're getting on in your career; your children are guaranteed to follow your line of work; no need to deal with haughty white people since you only use the servant's quarters anyway... all for the small, small price of being property.
 
Last edited:
But France is not one of those countries, and if a woman so chooses, she gets to behave as if she's "oppressed", in your words, provided it is her preference to wear the garment.
That is not relevant. I posted what Sarkozy gave as the reason he wanted to make this particular statement. I agree with his message.

I get all the "this is about freedom" comments. One can easily see that side of the argument.

I am trying to put a little focus on the other side of the argument. This is not about bigotry against Muslims nor is it about suppressing anyone's religious freedom. This is about taking a stand against repression of women and stating the obvious, the burqa is a symbol of repression of women, regardless of all the women who feel they are choosing to wear them.


Let's look at a different example where it is more clear society has a right to define and intervene in brainwashing. Take the Heaven's Gate cult. Suicide is against the law in modern countries with perhaps exceptions for people nearing death naturally. Yet one could argue the followers of Marshall Applewhite were willing participants. But most people would say they were brainwashed and had anyone known what was up the law might have intervened.

So every case where someone willingly does something is not necessarily purely about freedom.

We are so used to religious views being about freedom that when it is not quite as abnormal appearing as a cult, then it must be a case of religious freedom. Yet there is plenty of evidence the Koran does not include instructions to wear burqas. So you could make the case wearing burqas is only practiced by certain cults within the Muslim religion.

There is at least a case to be made the issue is cults oppressing female members. You may not agree with the case, but the case can be made.


As for a history of willingness of women to let men abuse them, there are many examples of women who willingly stay in abusive situations.

Whether that is the equivalent here is very hard to determine. I have struggled with this given I've always been a supporter of tolerating, even enjoying other cultures. But in seeing the damage done by cultures oppressing women, including the fact cultures where women do not have equal rights often do poorly compared to cultures where women do have equal rights, I have come to the conclusion this particular cultural practice does not deserve tolerance regardless of the willingness of women in those cultures to drink the koolaid.

If a black man in the 50s said he didn't mind separate but equal, would that make it merely a different culture? One has to look a little beyond just the freedom of expression issue here.
 
Last edited:
...

See? Pointless political grandstanding, both making wife-beating illegal and ending segregation.

Just like banning the burqa.

There's a big difference. If a woman's father, brothers, mother, other family members or community is so intent and so uncompromising on making her wear a burqa in public, they might be driven to keep her out of the public alltogether if they can't force her to wear a burqa.

This was one of the arguments against the public schools banning the hijab in France- a family that would make a girl wear that would be equally willing to withdraw her from public high school and from mainstream society rather than let her "run around uncovered". Whereas going to public school, having a job, going to the mall once in a while if you promise to behave, interacting with Christians, Jews, Buddhists, secularists, having a life, etc. is an opportunity for them to slowly Westernize.

The only way your analogy would be in any way valid was if white supremacists were ready and willing to murder every black person in America rather than let them vote and go to white schools.
 
Last edited:
Suicide is against the law in modern countries with perhaps exceptions for people nearing death naturally.

... One has to look a little beyond just the freedom of expression issue here.
Can you list some 'modern' countries where suicide is illegal (leaving aside the fact that it is impossible to punish suicide)
I disagree. One does not have to look beyond freedom, of expression or anything else. Freedom should be defended, not restricted so as to defend freedom.
 
True, true.

So why make wife-beating illegal? Merely making it illegal doesn't change the attitude of the wife-beater, does it? He still WANTS to beat his wife and considers it his right.

How about segregation? Making it illegal didn't stop White racists' attitudes of not wanting to be next to Blacks, did it (e.g., "White flight" and the rest of that).

See? Pointless political grandstanding, both making wife-beating illegal and ending segregation.

Just like banning the burqa.

Indeed so. All for the small, small price of seeing the world through a letterbox for the rest of your life as your husband owns you.

I can see why slavery is liberating, too. No need to worry about a home, clothes, food, etc. -- it's all your master's problem; no annoying people asking how you're getting on in your career; your children are guaranteed to follow your line of work; no need to deal with haughty white people since you only use the servant's quarters anyway... all for the small, small price of being property.

These arguments make total sense in a world where no one wears burqa voluntarily. In this world... not so much.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom