Sarkozy says burqas are 'not welcome' in France

This is a really random observation but has anyone else noticed that some Muslim women actually look gorgeous with the hijab on? :o
Yes. Especially along with those super-tight jeans a lot of the hijab-wearing girls have around where I live.
 
The burqa, unlike the common headcloth (hijab), is a tool for oppression of women. It prevents the wearer from interacting normally with other people. It should be discouraged, including by governments. That should be done through public discussion, through ordering police to prioritize cases of domestic abuse, through providing safe-houses and new identities for women who want to leave their husbands or relatives, and in many other ways.

But look at this proposed law. So, burqa-wearing women are often oppressed. Oftentimes, their husbands/fathers/brothers prevent them from having normal social interaction with other people. Sometimes they are themselves indoctrinated into believing that this is normal or good for them.

And now you claim that you want to counter this by criminalizing these women on those occasions that they are allowed to leave their homes?

That justification cannot be taken seriously. The proposal is obviously intended to court anti-muslim opinions, not to help oppressed women.
 
In France laws typically reflect the right of a woman to be a man's equal.

Therefore it is a woman's choice to either wear a burqa or not. If she wishes to observe what some might consider sexist customs while living in a relatively free country, that should be allowed. Why? Because she can always appeal to the court of that free nation (France), if she feels her husband is forcing her to wear the burqa or to do anything else.

It is her choice to act or appear subservient in whatever way she wishes, unless of course it entails breaking an established law or if it presents a danger to someone else.

Leave the choice to the woman in the context of a free nation.
 
While the Burqa may be worn voluntarily by some women, even by many women, and perhaps in and of itself it is not oppressing a woman, but no one can deny women are oppressed in many countries and the requirement they wear these coverings when out in public is one tool of that oppression.
 
While the Burqa may be worn voluntarily by some women, even by many women, and perhaps in and of itself it is not oppressing a woman, but no one can deny women are oppressed in many countries and the requirement they wear these coverings when out in public is one tool of that oppression.

Certainly. But can oppression be alleviated in those countries by imposing another oppression in other countries?
Removing choice is oppressive.
 
Yes. Especially along with those super-tight jeans a lot of the hijab-wearing girls have around where I live.

That is so true. Somalian immigrant women wear a hijab along with skin tight jeans.

Doesn't one not go with the other?
 
Let us suppose that all of sudden in Country X a paternalistic leadership decides that women should properly wear stonewashed jeans. Many women are beaten, and some die, if they are caught out in public not wearing stonewashed jeans. Does anyone really think the proper way to address the situation is that in Country Y, where the violent oppression isn't happening, they ban stonewashed jeans?

A burqa is an implement, a tool, of oppression in some places. You don't ban the tools, you try to change the environment that led to it becoming a tool, otherwise they'll just find a new tool to achieve the same end.
 
Some people here seem to be confusing the burqa with the hijab.

There is an enormous difference between the hijab, or headscarf, which some Muslim women wear (as well as women in many other societies), and the burqa, which covers the face and makes the woman into a "moving black object".

Consider the difference between the two first images of "burqa" and "hijab" that came up on google: these women and this woman.

The woman wearing the hijab is a person. (I have no idea who she is, but you get my point). The women in the burkas are objects. They have no face or body, and might as well be robots.

I believe all the claims that the burqa is "actually feminist" and expresses "choice" to about the same degree I believe the claims that stirppers and hookers are "expressing a choice" and are "actually feminist" -- which is to say, not at all.

If Sarkozy had wanted to ban the hijab from France, that would certainly be religious discrimination. But not the burka, which conflicts so strongly with France's ideals. Religious freedom does not include the right to violate the law. Human sacrifice, headhunting, and polygamy are (or were) practices in some religions, but they, too, are illegal in France.
 
A burqa is an implement, a tool, of oppression in some places. You don't ban the tools, you try to change the environment that led to it becoming a tool, otherwise they'll just find a new tool to achieve the same end.

I can just imagine a bunch of rightwing Islamic fundamentalists having the scales suddenly fall from their eyes when Sarko (the Zionist Imperialist Crusader Jew) rams a ban on burqas through the parliament.

"Gee, guys, maybe we have been mistreating women. Let's not set her on fire."

P.S. Who else thins hijabs are kinda sessy? Forbidden fruit and all that...
 
Last edited:
Some people here seem to be confusing the burqa with the hijab.

There is an enormous difference between the hijab, or headscarf, which some Muslim women wear (as well as women in many other societies), and the burqa, which covers the face and makes the woman into a "moving black object".

Consider the difference between the two first images of "burqa" and "hijab" that came up on google: these women and this woman.

<snip>

I am happy that someone is stressing the difference between a burqa and a hijab. Minor nitpick : I think your first link show niqabs, burqas include a small grid to hide the eyes.

However I am not totally convinced that a law would achieve anything.
 
Certainly. But can oppression be alleviated in those countries by imposing another oppression in other countries?
Removing choice is oppressive.
I'm not sure I agree. I think taking a stand against something like the Burqa has an effect.

Some people here are only looking at this from the point of view of individual freedom. I think there is another view that one should consider.
 
...

A burqa is an implement, a tool, of oppression in some places. You don't ban the tools, you try to change the environment that led to it becoming a tool, otherwise they'll just find a new tool to achieve the same end.
There is some truth in this. One, legislating social change is not very effective and 2 the idea some of these women will opt to stay home is worse.

But there is still some value here in making a public statement that the burqa is not a religious dress, it is a dress used specifically to oppress women. That's what Sarkozy was saying. And despite all the cries it is religion, no it isn't. It is cultural. The women have been told it is in the Koran and it is not.
 
Maybe someone should introduce M. Sarkozy to this woman - that might change (blow?) his mind. :eye-poppi

ETA: Probably NSFW.
 
Last edited:
1. It's unclear to me if women wearing the burqa in France are doing so willingly (i.e. if they are pressured into doing so by their pious, and violent, male family members). A ban would ensure this practice wouldn't continue.
Excuse me, but if a woman is being forced to wear a burqa by male family members, she is forced to wear it on occasions that she is permitted to be out in public where any number of non-family males may happen to see her. Therefore, outlaw the buraq and these women simply disappear, and are not permitted to be seen in public at all. Big lose.

I don't believe that governments should be legislating this - apart from under the same circumstances where other people are forbidden to wear balaclavas and full face helmets.
 
Excuse me, but if a woman is being forced to wear a burqa by male family members, she is forced to wear it on occasions that she is permitted to be out in public where any number of non-family males may happen to see her. Therefore, outlaw the buraq and these women simply disappear, and are not permitted to be seen in public at all. Big lose.

By this logic, slapping women around in public should be legal -- after all, as long as it's done publicly, at least people watching will make sure it doesn't cross the line. Much better than having the wife-beater beat her up at home where nobody can see how hard he hits her, don't you think?
 
Maybe someone should introduce M. Sarkozy to this woman - that might change (blow?) his mind. :eye-poppi
That certainly does put a different slant on the argument - here's one of the comments:
I agree, the sight of a niqabi or even a woman in a burqa is very common in the West nowadays. We recently had to transit rhough Atlanta. I was in abaya, hijab & niqab with a burqa over them. To make it easy at security I removed my burqa ahead of time & just lowered my niqab at the checkpoints. We had a 4 hour wait at the gate for our next flight & husband/Master had me kneel (back in my burqa) by his seat with my head lowered for the whole wait. He said no-one even gave us a second glance! For my part it felt good to be able to show the world what a good, modest wife I was. Once on board the plane I went into the toilet & gagged myself for the flight home.
Makes you wonder how her French counterparts would react if the law were passed.
 
I always imagine that women wearing burqas have absolutely perfect bodies, ad that they are completely naked underneath the burqa, except perhaps for some jewelry.

I wonder whether Muslim men would still make their women wear them if they knew all the other men are thinking of them as being naked underneath a sheet?

I know this is going to sound shocking, but most people are actually naked underneath their clothes :p
 
I'm afraid to ask how you found that web page.
.
I've noticed that the nicest of intentions can result in landing in some extremely "different" sites on the 'net.
It can take hours and hours to get out of them, the way they link to each other!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom