Sarkozy says burqas are 'not welcome' in France

Burqas are bad, but Traditional Nun's Habits are OK.
Sort of confusing, isn't it?
.
Mother Teresa should have worn one.
The wimpel is the same as the hajib.
I buy candy in a store at the Mall from a young lady wearing the hajib.
Cute gal.
 
This is a really random observation but has anyone else noticed that some Muslim women actually look gorgeous with the hijab on? :o
Headscarves were worn by Christian women during the early medieval period. Members of my reenactment group wear this kind of garb voluntarily, and I have to say, they look quite attractive when they do.

jennyandamanda.jpg


The difference is, they are wearing garb by choice, not by tradition or by rule.
 
The difference is, they are wearing garb by choice, not by tradition or by rule.

Their wearing of that particular garb is a matter of their own tradition, which just doesn't happen to be shared by most others. They are able to make the choice to follow the tradition.

Choice is the key. Talk of murder and acid is dramatic but essentially irrelevant.
Women should be allowed to wear whatever demeaning garments they choose.
Women should not be forced to wear whatever demeaning garments someone else chooses.
The perception of what is demeaning for an individual woman is that woman's.
It is easy to find examples of women who wear varying degrees of veiling and are adamant that it is their choice.
If a woman says she likes to be hidden from view and not be judged by her appearance or be harrassed to any degree (and kid yourselves not: it is not just a hobby of muslim men) then she is entitled to make that choice.
 
First, many countries have dress code laws. So that is not new.

Second, one needs to look at the reason Sarkozy suggested the ban. In his own words from the OP link:
"In our country, we cannot accept that women be prisoners behind a screen, cut off from all social life, deprived of all identity," Sarkozy said to extended applause in a speech at the Chateau of Versailles southwest of Paris.

"The burqa is not a religious sign, it's a sign of subservience, a sign of debasement..."
I can understand some women feel it is a sign of respect for their beliefs. But then how do you ascertain which women are being pressured by men to wear these veils and which aren't?

As for it being religious, that's not supported by the facts. Cultural, yes, but if one thinks this is a religious requirement they are ascribing to a version of the Koran that does not exist. I wonder how many of them know that?

Times OnLine
The Koran does not call for burqas to be worn In the wake of the controversy, Taj Hargey, chairman of the Muslim Educational Centre of Oxford, raised the wider issue of whether burqas were worn for cultural or religious reasons. In his opinion “the mullahs fail to tell their flocks that nowhere in Islam’s transcendent text is there any mention of the word burqa or niqab”. The only mention of a face-covering is in the hadith, a secondary, and sometimes disputed, collection of sayings attributed to the prophet Muhammad. Usma Hasan, a reformist imam in London, points out that the Koran advocates that “Muslims should respect local customs”.


From that same link:
France’s secretary of state for urban policies, herself a Muslim, spoke out in support of the president’s view. She said she was alarmed by the number of women “who are being put in this kind of tomb”, and she urged: “We must do everything to stop burqas from spreading.”


I also found it interesting, again from the same link,
Turkey, also a secular state, does not allow the headscarf in schools and universities even though its population is overwhelmingly Muslim.
I hadn't known that.


After weighing the pros and cons briefly, free speech vs potential oppression of women, my conclusion is I support Sarkozy's position. (I don't think any law has yet been passed but I could be wrong.)
 
Last edited:
The burqa is a religious matter, and the state should avoid getting involved in religious matters as much as possible.

now if a woman is punished by violence or abuse because she refuses to wear a burqa, then the state can get involved. but other then that, it really isn't the state's business.

otherwise they need to inform immigrants that french society will not tolerate cultural customs that make them uncomfortable.
 
I always imagine that women wearing burqas have absolutely perfect bodies, ad that they are completely naked underneath the burqa, except perhaps for some jewelry.

I wonder whether Muslim men would still make their women wear them if they knew all the other men are thinking of them as being naked underneath a sheet?
 
See, this is exactly what I was saying in the OP. I think burqas are oppressive and demeaning, and are a tool for keeping women under control. If you have no public identity, no face, you are not a person. They rob women of their dignity and individuality.
Yes, but... in practice you are saying that the government should rob women of their ability to leave the house, so that non-Muslims don't have to feel uncomfortable when they see a woman in a burqa. You haven't eliminated the religious restriction, or given women any more freedom. You've only made non-Muslims feel better about how helpful they are being, and making things harder for Muslims.
 
I find it odd that we have jumped to the conclusion that all women who wear burqa's are forced to do so. Is it so impossible that a woman might be, on her own, religiously inclined to do so?
 
I find it odd that we have jumped to the conclusion that all women who wear burqa's are forced to do so. Is it so impossible that a woman might be, on her own, religiously inclined to do so?

Every Muslim woman I've ever known has worn the hijab or burqa because she was a life long devout Muslim and wanted to wear it.

..but that's an unreliable anecdote. After all, if a woman didn't want to wear one, she wouldn't have complained to Christian acquaintances at school or work.

She wouldn't have Christian acquaintances and she probably wouldn't be going to work or public school.
 
I find it odd that we have jumped to the conclusion that all women who wear burqa's are forced to do so. Is it so impossible that a woman might be, on her own, religiously inclined to do so?

Well... to hear Christians tell the tale, everyone is really a Christian, and knows that Jesus is real. The rest of us are just denying it for various reasons.Therefore, every non-Christian would secretly prefer to be Christian (and Caucasian, since one seems to go with the other.) Muslim women would prefer to give up their savage brown-people culture, and be good Europeans... or, at least good European servants and wait-staff. Let's not get crazy here.
 
Therefore, every non-Christian would secretly prefer to be Christian (and Caucasian, since one seems to go with the other.)

There are Caucasian Muslims. European Caucasian Muslims too- the Albanians and Bosnians.

Granted, they are olive skinned whites. And most Caucasian Muslims are probably converts to Islam.

Still, it's an important point to make.
 
Last edited:
There are Caucasian Muslims. European Muslims too- the Albanians and Bosnians.

Just saying...

Oh, I know... I'm talking about the stereotype, not the reality. Hell, most Americans I've talked to in real life think that all the people in Iraq and Iran live in caves and mud huts without indoor plumbing or electricity.
 
Yeah, it's amazing how most Americans seem to think the Middle East is a Stone Age civilization.

Iraq may not be wealthy, may not have the buildings and malls America does, may have shootings on the streets in broad daylight- but it's not paleolithic!

It may be a poor country but they are up to date with the 20th century. The image people have of them is that they aren't even up to date with the Middle Ages...!
 
Yeah, it's amazing how most Americans seem to think the Middle East is a Stone Age civilization.

Iraq may not be wealthy, may not have the buildings and malls America does, may have shootings on the streets in broad daylight- but it's not paleolithic!

It may be a poor country but they are up to date with the 20th century. The image people have of them is that they aren't even up to date with the Middle Ages...!

Yeah... and by the same token, while Western people accept Christian monks, nuns, and priests dressing in ancient traditional garb, when Muslims do it they see something wrong with it, that must be stopped by law.
 
I always imagine that women wearing burqas have absolutely perfect bodies, ad that they are completely naked underneath the burqa, except perhaps for some jewelry.

I wonder whether Muslim men would still make their women wear them if they knew all the other men are thinking of them as being naked underneath a sheet?
I'm told that Muslim women are a very large market for sexy lingerie.
 
Yeah... and by the same token, while Western people accept Christian monks, nuns, and priests dressing in ancient traditional garb, when Muslims do it they see something wrong with it, that must be stopped by law.

See, this is what I have a problem with. We are projecting onto this the idea that women wearing practically nothing is somehow evidence of their liberation and empowering. That is wrong, them being practically naked is not empowering or evidence of their liberation, having the choice to do so is. Of course that very same free exercise might also lead them to wear Amish garb, a burqa, a velvet power suit or a really awful looking spandex outfit. I mean I have seen women wearing truly horrendous things entirely through choice.
 
Yeah... and by the same token, while Western people accept Christian monks, nuns, and priests dressing in ancient traditional garb, when Muslims do it they see something wrong with it, that must be stopped by law.

There's a difference, though. A nun chooses to be a nun. She chooses to abide by the rules of her convent, however harsh. She chooses to have her head shaved upon entrance (from what I know, a fairly common practise in convents), to be forever cut off from her family (once a common practise, don't know about nowadays), to pray and work all day, to have no profession besides maybe a teacher or a nurse and to never marry.

Of course, there used to be many cases of women forced to be nuns. Usually unmarriageable women who were burdens on their families or unwanted widows. And political, social and religious pressure and various financial reasons.

Same story for monks and priests- no one forced them to be monks or priests.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom