Sarkozy says burqas are 'not welcome' in France

mmhhh maybe one needs more than just 2 braincells for this complicated case?
Making little coherent sense and third grade English literacy are also your rights outside third world countries. Manners are always optional.

No one can read every woman/person's mind to make this claim, about women in a free country like France, choosing to wear a burqa. But if you insist on sliding back into your unverifiable fit of mind-reading, so be it.
Um, a burqa and niqab aren't in fact worn outside the reasons outlined, as evidenced by asking individuals not brought up inside strict communities (raised under theocratic law or subgroup residing in a foreign country) would clearly, obviously demonstrate. Common sense to almost everybody who sees a Burqa for the first time, and silently asks why someone would do that day in day out - as it is an alarmingly sad sight, and nothing else.

You chose to publicly shame yourself defending something profoundly inhumane, completely outside the purpose it serves and context: what no mentally healthy person wears on a daily basis, as evidenced by a point you will ignore as the focus shifts to you personally: You would never wear one, Cheney would never ask a girlfriend (probably retarded, but nevertheless) to potentially wear one, and Keri would not for precisely the same reasons. You type these objections against common sense with a petty indigance not staring through a slit; if asked to for a month, you would not. If forced, it would be a ridiculous very odd ritual even as you became acclimated even over a year, as an understanding of personal repulsiveness first must be appreciated to then appreciate the boundless benefits of subjecting as few people to yourself as possible.
 
Last edited:
Making little coherent sense and third grade English literacy are also your rights outside third world countries. Manners are always optional.

my lousy english skills is still alot better than your swissgerman skills

how come some woman are forced to wear the burka on your pictures while a woman next to her isnt forced to. how come?
 
"If Ataturk can ban it in Turkey..."

Indeed and that led to millions of women in Turkey becoming miserable, objectified sex slaves, right?

Ataturk, who is considered a national hero among Turks for the changes he brought upon their society, didn't only change their attire. He also changed the written form of Turkish (from arabic to latin) and also forced the turkish state to be as independent from religion as it could be.

I think a lot of posters confuse personal opinion/right of expression with tradition and good ol' peer pressure. While the latter is not a problem in France (since afaik Muslims are an accepted part of society and not congregated in any specific place), the first is quite true. I tend to dislike any tradition that is actually impractical and in the case of french burkas it would be because wearing a burka would actually serve as to objectify the wearer (since it is so dissimilar to the usual form of attire).

In effect should burka be banned, in a few years it will not even be considered a clothing option, apart from those who would actually feel like wearing one (like the quite interesting submissive lady mentioned early on).

Sidenote: excuse any horrendous grammatical errors that may have escaped me as english is not my native language
 
As for "One": nah. Depends on a person's diet and metabolism, and how much sun s/he is exposed to at home. And even the amount of melanin (pigment) in the skin. Once again, there's nothing intrinsically harmful about the piece of cloth itself, rather the behavior around it.

"Scientists had previously found high rates of vitamin D deficiency in Arab and East Indian women living in the United Arab Emirates. A follow up study investigated the effect of vitamin D supplements on 178 UAE women, many of whom covered themselves entirely, faces and hands included, when outside their homes. Only two of the women did not have vitamin D deficiency prior to receiving supplements. The results were published by a team of scientists in the June issue of the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition.
"

The study was conducted for a reason. Anybody can read it, I don't know why you bother.

I'm required to explain again what I shouldn't have to. Free clue: the study suggests obviously if you have a darker pigment, live in a high climate desert environment and subsist on a simple diet, you are likely to have a high (unhealthy) deficiency in, as evidenced by the study of people living even in second world conditions, Vitamin D. The study also suggests that in third world regions (like Afghanistan) this is probably far worse. So if you are among 2% (5% perhaps?) of those who wear a Burqa that are caucasian, maintain a balanced healthy diet, live in a climate close to the equator as a bonus and ensure you stand outside for longer periods of time than usual congratulations, being covered head to toe over a lifetime has no significant health concerns.

When you make the lifestyle choice, as so many do without the least bit of coercion, to become a walking obelisk for the rest of your life have a bottle nearby to compliment your newfound psychological and emotional health, just to be on the safe side. In other news, black absorbs heat and heat rises. Walking around during a hot summer with the slit for your eyes as a vent is probably not a great idea, even with a multivitamin supplement.
 
Last edited:
my lousy english skills is still alot better than your swissgerman skills
Well he's got me there. Given the natural beauty of Norwegian women and how cheerfully they greet you nude without a shred of apprehension, I really should get my priorities straight. Alas, instead of interacting with the likes of them tonight I'm stuck with you, Probe and Keri dug into a trench at the Internet's ground zero for the clash of logos and ethos with everything else. Isn't that always the way?

..how come some woman are forced to wear the burka on your pictures while a woman next to her isnt forced to. how come?
(Philip leans forward to confide, a climbing and somber array of violin fades in heightening the building suspense, he whispers..)

"Why everything sucks for some people is a mystery, but why everything sucks period is the greatest mystery of all.."
 
Last edited:
I think a lot of posters confuse personal opinion/right of expression with tradition and good ol' peer pressure. While the latter is not a problem in France (since afaik Muslims are an accepted part of society and not congregated in any specific place), the first is quite true. I tend to dislike any tradition that is actually impractical and in the case of french burkas it would be because wearing a burka would actually serve as to objectify the wearer (since it is so dissimilar to the usual form of attire).

Having women wearing the burqa (and even the veil) is a relatively new phenomenon in France, that has no roots in traditions coming from the Mahgreb or the muslim former French colonies, where most French muslims come from. Those who promote it, men and women alike, are actually playing a political game and are looking forward to an over-reaction from the French authorities so they can play martyrs (and hopefully advance their communautarist goals).


In effect should burka be banned, in a few years it will not even be considered a clothing option, apart from those who would actually feel like wearing one (like the quite interesting submissive lady mentioned early on).

I tend to agree. For a few years, though, we will hear a lot of complaints of anti-muslim discrimination and of threats against French interests, blah, blah, blah ...
 

"Scientists had previously found high rates of vitamin D deficiency in Arab and East Indian women living in the United Arab Emirates. ... "
A woman in a free society like France, the country we're discussing here, can choose a diet and dietary supplements that easily compensate for any vitamin D deficiency she is at risk for (as can Indian women, among others).

... Or she can choose to wear the piece of cloth all the time and risk the deficiency. She can choose to sit in a sunny area of her house for a while while she's at home each day. These will allow her to wear the burqa w/out developing a vitamin D problem.

As for your links above, called "Two" and "Three", you need to explain how any of the contents in either link clearly stands as evidence that the burqa, specifically, is intrinsically harmful. That is going to be a challenge.

Chop chop.
 
Making little coherent sense and third grade English literacy are also your rights outside third world countries. Manners are always optional.

LOL ... this is coming from a poster who launches personal attacks when he can't back a set of made up statistics, can't construct a single, half-way intelligent hypothetical poll, or argue from anything other than raw emotion.

Um, a burqa and niqab aren't in fact worn outside the reasons outlined ...
First, this argument has nothing to do with the niqab, just the burqa. And you can't guarantee that every woman in a free country like France chooses to wear the burqa in the strictest of traditional ways ... but you're free to make up more statistics to back up your emotions if you'd like.

You chose to publicly shame yourself defending something profoundly inhumane, completely outside the purpose it serves and context: what no mentally healthy person wears on a daily basis, as evidenced by a point you will ignore as the focus shifts to you personally: You would never wear one, Cheney would never ask a girlfriend (probably retarded, but nevertheless) to potentially wear one, and Keri would not for precisely the same reasons.
This is a skeptics' forum. Attempts at mind-reading aren't held in high esteem. Attempts at personalizing arguments, rather than focusing on objective reasoning, will not validate a stance on whether or not a burqa should or shouldn't be banned in a relatively free country like France.

[More attempts at mind-reading]
 
This is a skeptics' forum. Attempts at mind-reading aren't held in high esteem. Attempts at personalizing arguments, rather than focusing on objective reasoning, will not validate a stance on whether or not a burqa should or shouldn't be banned in a relatively free country like France.
You challenge it shouldn't be based on a delusional opinion the issue is three things which it in fact is not:

1) A choice of dress and a cultural tradition that should be protected
2) Neutral as an ethics problem
3) The benefits of accepting it in society outweigh any short or long term social impact of banning it

All three ridiculously idiotic as you've (but should not have to) required me to point out to you. The burqa is not mandated by Islam, represents mental illness, is a socially obnoxious utterly antisocial statement set against modern cultural standards of decency. That is exactly, irrefutably, precisely what it is. You cannot, on any sane ethical grounds endorse what it represents and expect a positive result, which is why Turkey banned it, a country fast becoming a model of secular cultural progressiveness. It is banned successfully elsewhere. Few things, I shouldn't have to mention either, are more ominous to secular humanists than the burqa. A central theme in Dawkins public educational efforts is his disgust at socially acceptable, religious child abuse. The importance of that cannot be overstated.

Pointed Comments:

"That some women have fallen for the ongoing propaganda that it is somehow their free choice to don the burka and perhaps even more preposterously have also fallen for the nonsense that the wearing of an item with the almost express purpose of eliminating individual expression is in any way a form of self expression is simply tragic..." - rumbelow

"I find your views completely shameful.A woman being forced to wear a burka will NOT be able to freely access the legal system and risks physical and emotional sanction from her community if she refuses. The only way to improve women's rights and hence freedom is to ban the practise of erasing women's identitys - regardless of whether some women claim it is what they want - I'm sure you could have found some slaves in the nineteenth century who claimed being a slave was ok. If you don't do this you allow this practise to be normalised in society. My neighbours pre-teen daughter has now started sporting a black robe and face mask in public. I find it hard to believe this isn't due to brain washing and sanctions if she doesn't and there simply isn't an I'd rather not wear it choice having weighed up all the pro and cons choice. It is SLAVERY and treating women as faceless property without identity in all but name. Anyone who supports this garment deserves only contempt."

And..

"The whole point of a law banning the burka is that you can't then secretly put pressure on someone to wear it. The sacrifice we have to make is that those who of their own genuine free will who wish to wear it can't. How do we know pressure is likely to occur ? You need to measure the volume of 'honour' killings/beatings/domestic violence/forced marriages/young girls disappear aboard in burka wearing communities compared to the general population. Banning the Burka is a critical measure that adds rather than subtracts from freedom and IS appropriate in a western country like France if only the British government was as forward thinking.
" - CarlPierce

What pray tell, are you contesting here?
 
Last edited:
I think the Bura is a sick peace of cloth. And i think woman should not wear it and rise up against their husband and relatives that think she must wear one.
and i would be very happy to see my taxfranks beeing spend to help woman that do rise up and no longer take it. we should protect those woman against people that want to harm them becuse they refuse to wear it.

but i dont want to see my taxfranks beeing spend on enforcing a ban of that sick peace of cloth and even end up punishing exactly those opressed woman.
and making their live even more ******.

No, i want those woman to know that when they do refuse to wear the burka and someone wants to harm her that they will get the protection for her and her kids that she needs and also the assistance she needs to build up her own life, independent from her husband.

But by simply banning it she will get punished anyway. When she wears it, we punish her and when she is not wearing it her husband may punish her.

how is that suposed to help those woman?
 
Last edited:
I think the Bura is a sick peace of cloth. And i think woman should not wear it and rise up against their husband and relatives that think she must wear one.

That's the hindsight of banning it, they won't.

..and i would be very happy to see my taxfranks beeing spend to help woman that do rise up and no longer take it. we should protect those woman against people that want to harm them becuse they refuse to wear it.
No disagreement. Extensive laws should be additionally put in place to accomodate domestic violence as a result of inhumane religious extremism, which is exactly what the burqa falls under.

..but i dont want to see my taxfranks beeing spend on enforcing a ban of that sick peace of cloth and even end up punishing exactly those opressed woman.
The problem is, if not outright banned, you are essentially making a statement that it is acceptable. Banning is a simple solution that covers all these bases, shifts the blame away from the women themselves, far reducing conflict than if they were to resist if it were acceptable to wear.

No, i want those woman to know that when they do refuse to wear the burka and someone wants to harm her that they will get the protection for her and her kids that she needs and also the assistance she needs to build up her own life, independent from her husband.
Without a doubt, it shouldn't be banned until these options exist either. Although it was accomplished as a flat out ban without any newsworthy events in Turkey.

But by simply banning it she will get punished anyway. When she wears it, we punish her and when she is not wearing it her husband may punish her.
No, the primary benefit is effectively the blame is shifted completely off her to the government and secular society. If religious domestic violence laws just exist, she will be met with far more psychological (and perhaps potential physical) retribution. If accepted by society yet (utterly unlikely) not wearing it becomes a trend, you've created a rift in Islamic communities focused entirely on these apostates. You want to take the responsibility off them completely. Few, if any would ever willingly have the courage to step out of that lifestyle (deathstyle?) without an excuse. A secular society can provide that in the form of a very appropriate indecency measure.

how is that suposed to help those woman?
If you want to kill something off effectively, go for the root.
 
You challenge it shouldn't be based on a delusional opinion the issue is three things which it in fact is not:

1) A choice of dress and a cultural tradition that should be protected ...

Just more fact-free opinions.

Pointed Comments: ...
More emotionally-laden opinions, plus someone's further attempts at mind-reading.

Meanwhile, it hasn't gone unnoticed that you've twice failed to explain how any of the contents in your link "One" and link "Two" clearly stands as evidence that the burqa, specifically, is intrinsically harmful.

You're obviously scared to admit your links - like your cooked up stats and failed poll ideas - don't bolster the stance you've taken on the OP.
 
Last edited:
Btw there are parts in France, where the police dears not to go to, the police is scared there, how are the woman there suposed to feel save when rising up against her husband?
 
Ban Humans or only Husbands?
Unfortunately, the root is not in fact the burqa, but human evolution and sociobiology. Humans are naturally hard wired with few exceptions to follow dominant figures of their respective community - regardless how unnatural or ridiculous what those dictates are. In absolute dictatorships, with absolute laws, and absolute mandated lifestyles such as Islam, no diplomacy or integration is possible with an open society.
 
Just more fact-free opinions.
If something represents an utter absence of personal rights, the product of which is wearing a disguise the rest of your life, tolerating it due to respecting rights of choice is a clear, obvious contradiction. You contest this?
 
If something represents an utter absence of personal rights, the product of which is wearing a disguise the rest of your life, tolerating it due to respecting rights of choice is a clear, obvious contradiction. You contest this?

I certainly do contest it. There is no contradiction between allowing someone to choose to do something, and not allowing someone to force another person to do something.
Unless you have you own definition of 'contradiction'.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom