Sarkozy says burqas are 'not welcome' in France

ProbeX,
I've provided all the info, I've answered all your points.

If you can't, or refuse to see that at this point, nothing is going to get through to you.

Have a nice day.
 
Let's review. Below was my question, which you (Cavemonster) claimed you answered in "post 333 and 347":

Let's stick to this particular issue: what study/s are you proposing for this burqa "problem" ... since you seem to think studies would help?
Nowhere, in either of your posts, did you answer this question, specifically. If you had any confidence you had offered a specific study idea of yours that satisfied this request, you'd have no problem reiterating it, or even just paraphrasing it.

I challenge you or anyone else here in internet world to find your alleged answer in either of those two posts of yours.
 
A free society should not tell another human that they cannot underake a voluntary action (with themselves or another adult) that harms no one else.
 
A free society should not tell another human that they cannot underake a voluntary action (with themselves or another adult) that harms no one else.
This, obviously, idiotically assumes the action of forcing women to wear them in the first place is not wrong, abusive, a form of tyranny. Which is a self-evident fallacy. A virtual minority wear them without being conditioned to do so, and their irritation is irrelevant in contrast to human rights issues.
 
You still haven't provided a study, or any reason to believe studies of the burqa (recall the topic here?) will help in resolving the burqa "problem" in France.
A far better idea is ensuring you posess two brain cells to rub together and a moral compass first before voicing your opinion as something else. Intellectual dishonesty is irritating, but publicly making an exhibition of ethical dishonesty is shameful. Now you have to labor to pretend, as so many petty people here do until both sides give up, somehow that common sense and the obvious are something otherwise, therefore you aren't flat out wrong and unapologetically out of touch.
 
This, obviously, idiotically assumes the action of forcing women to wear them in the first place is not wrong, abusive, a form of tyranny. Which is a self-evident fallacy. A virtual minority wear them without being conditioned to do so, and their irritation is irrelevant in contrast to human rights issues.
Nobody has suggested that force is acceptable, so it is fallacious to bring it up when responding to a post which speaks of 'free' and 'voluntary' actions. You have most inappropriately suggested that someone has idiotically assumed something which is the complete opposite of what was said.
It has been made abundantly clear that those of us who oppose a ban on the wearing of the burqa do not think anyone should be forced to wear one, so please stop repeating that ludicous canard.
What in the name of Peppermint Patty is a 'virtual minority'? A minority is a minority. Nothing virtual about it.
Minority rights are just as worthy of protection as majority rights.
I don't care if out of 1000 burqa wearers, 999 are wearing under duress and only 1 through choice.
That 1 should have the right to make that choice.
 
A far better idea is ensuring you posess two brain cells to rub together and a moral compass first before voicing your opinion as something else. Intellectual dishonesty is irritating, but publicly making an exhibition of ethical dishonesty is shameful. Now you have to labor to pretend, as so many petty people here do until both sides give up, somehow that common sense and the obvious are something otherwise, therefore you aren't flat out wrong and unapologetically out of touch.

The use of insults does nothing to bolster your argument. If anything it makes it even weaker.
Your emotional reactions appear to be affecting the clarity of what you post.
 
That 1 should have the right to make that choice.
Unlike Probe who is simply dishonest, this is a profound mystery to you, isn't it. A far better idea, in your case, is just having two brain cells to rub together. You could however wear one for a month, not taking it off except in the presence of a designated significant other, then explain what you think makes somebody choose to do that without their livelihood leveraged against them or a literal gun to their head, or lessening the likelihood of being tortured and mutilated for eternity in the afterlife.
 
Last edited:
The use of insults does nothing to bolster your argument. If anything it makes it even weaker.
 
This, obviously, idiotically assumes the action of forcing women to wear them in the first place is not wrong, abusive, a form of tyranny. Which is a self-evident fallacy. A virtual minority wear them without being conditioned to do so, and their irritation is irrelevant in contrast to human rights issues.


That's cute. Your statement that I've highlighted is the equivalent of saying, "Their rights are irrelevant to their rights."

What exactly are you rubbing together as a substitute for brain cells?

Have you contemplated thinking as an alternative to rubbing things?
 
Last edited:
A far better idea is ensuring you %$#U$& G*&G opiur poaoo9jt yjoi yp2 (@ (Jt w.

Translation: Wahhhhhhhh!

You're right. This is a clear example of SP choosing emotion over logic; a personal attack versus sound reasoning. And when you can't attack the argument, attack the person posing it, right? Weak indeed.

Her/his personal attack might have been acceptable (by me) if it was accompanied by facts to back up those statistical claims earlier or those shoddy ideas for polls to back his claim, etc. ... Or evidence that I'm lying about something (another fact-free claim of hers/his made a couple posts later).

Meanwhile, I'm still hoping another poster can help me find the specific answer to my question that Cavemonster claims s/he made in posts # 333 and 347, about studies posed re: the burqa. Want to know if I'm overlooking his/her answer, as s/he claims. Cavemonster is unwilling or unable to highlight it. Somehow I don't think anyone else will see the clear connection either. But I'll be waiting.
 
A free society should not tell another human that they cannot underake a voluntary action (with themselves or another adult) that harms no one else.

Agreed, although I support the idea of "mental hygiene arrests" for suicidal individuals. Until someone can objectively prove the burqa is intrinsically harmful, it shouldn't be banned in the context of a relatively free society like France.
 
Last edited:
You could however wear one for a month, not taking it off except in the presence of a designated significant other, then explain what you think makes somebody choose to do that ...

At least you are using the word "choose" in the context of the burqa. It's a fine start.

Personal experiments and mind-reading efforts are no substitute for the fact that you can't know what every person's motivation is for choosing to wear a burqa (or anything else) in a free society like France ... another reason not to ban a piece of cloth.
 
Learning You Are Grotesque From Birth

niqab.jpg

​


"I am a Muslim woman and believe the burqa should be banned. Islam says to cover yourself modestly, which can be done with loose-fitted clothes and a headscarf."
- Hannah Khan

"If Ataturk can ban it in Turkey, we should also. It is a chain which needs undoing. Banning the burqa will not end the suppression of women, but it is a beginning. There are countries where women are not allowed to step out of the house without a burqa."
- Sharif Lone

"In the country, to pass somebody without making eye contact at least, and exchanging a pleasantry or two, would be unthinkable. The unspoken message from a burqa-clad person would unmistakeably state that, “I do not wish to know you, and I most certainly do not wish for you to know me”. To a villager, such as myself, that would be deeply disturbing and repugnant."
-
Hugh Ferguson

"I've seen many women in burkas during my military travels and it breaks my heart knowing the stigma that goes with it in my mind. Having to watch them hide while eating (lifting the front just to bring the food to their mouths), walking behind the men... it's very stifling for the women. I'm all for a woman's choice to wear something like this, but not forced. I do recall an Air Force officer telling her male superiors "NO" to having to wear Islamic clothing if she was to leave base. I didn't blame her then and don't now because it's not just a society thing.. .it's a religious statement and for me to have to wear the hajib or some other form of Islamic clothing, to my heart, it would be saying I agree with that religion and I most certainly do not. I wear head coverings to Mass and have a much more conservative clothing style. I wish more women would respect their bodies more and not showcase their sexual *ahem* assets. But our society has reduced women to nothing more than that. But it's my choice to dress in that fashion and it makes me feel more like a woman. Especially knowing that men that are speaking to me are actually speaking *to me* not my T&A. Sorry for the long post... but I do NOT like the burka and I'm with Sarkozy on this one. Because so much can be hidden under the burka, I'm not comfortable with it either. How many of our soldiers have been killed by terrorists wearing a burka and because we respect them enough to NOT search them unless a female soldier is there to do the searching, there is no way to really ascertain immediately if that burka wearing terrorist is really a female in the first place!!! It's naturally built into our soldiers heads that when they see a female, they tend to not feel too threatened, so how many terrorists play off that sentimentality?" - Meliss

"Whether one tries to mingle with people while naked or hermetically covered from head to toe, the absurd contrast to what everyone else is wearing screams out loud at the crucial subtleties we commonly take for granted in the spectrum of human relations."
- Kejda Gjermani
​

Sources: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5


 
Agreed, although I support the idea of "mental hygiene arrests" for suicidal individuals. Until someone can objectively prove the burqa is intrinsically harmful, it shouldn't be banned in the context of a relatively free society like France.
One. Two. Three.

Except the purpose of the burqa is to avoid harm, which is the only reason why it is in fact worn, as evidenced by asking anyone who does: "Safety". Cue Google and refute yourself.
 
Last edited:
What is your point in this latest post Sir Philip?
My point is, Keri, I have every right to declare to my offspring from the time they walk by divine mandate they are disgusting to look at, then offer them a solution to this absolute reality: a physically unhealthy, grotesque garment, a barrier to any form of social or interpersonal intimacy, set about in public to achieve it's opposite goal: to demoralize, disturb and draw attention, and you don't have any right whatsoever to say that's coming off right now, especially as they tell you wholeheartedly that they feel better with it on. And the sense of safety, you cannot describe, you are let on in.

Surely, it's just something somebody chooses to wear, I know now. Well, I'm glad we found common ground at least.
 

As for "One": nah. Depends on a person's diet and metabolism, and how much sun s/he is exposed to at home. And even the amount of melanin (pigment) in the skin. Once again, there's nothing intrinsically harmful about the piece of cloth itself, rather the behavior around it. To explain:

A woman in a free society like France can choose a diet and dietary supplements that easily compensate for any vitamin D deficiency she is at risk for. ... Or she can choose to wear the piece of cloth all the time and risk the deficiency. She can choose to sit in a sunny area of her house for a while while she's at home each day. These will allow her to wear the burqa w/out developing a vitamin D problem.

As for "Two" and "Three", you need to explain how any of the contents in either link clearly stands as evidence that the burqa, specifically, is intrinsically harmful. That is going to be a challenge.

Except the purpose of the burqa is to avoid harm, which is the only reason why it is in fact worn, as evidenced by asking anyone who does: "Safety". Cue Google and refute yourself.
No one can read every woman/person's mind to make this claim, about women in a free country like France, choosing to wear a burqa. But if you insist on sliding back into your unverifiable fit of mind-reading, so be it.
 
Surely, it's just something somebody chooses to wear, I know now. Well, I'm glad we found common ground at least.

Finally you admit it. Yes, in a relatively free country like France, women - that's grown adults - have the right to wear what they'd like, including the burqa, even if you personally feel angry, sad, hurt, or self-righteous about watching these women wear it.
 
Funny, SirPhilip posts pictures of woman, some wear a Burka, others dont, how come?
why is nobody forcing those other woman to wear a Burka? and when nobody forces them to wear one, how come the one wearing it is wearing it when nobody forces her?

mmhhh maybe one needs more than just 2 braincells for this complicated case?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom