Sarkozy says burqas are 'not welcome' in France

The Idiots Guide To Right & Wrong

I certainly do contest it. There is no contradiction between allowing someone to choose to do something, and not allowing someone to force another person to do something. Unless you have you own definition of 'contradiction'.

Let's try this again.

Nobody chooses to view the world through a slit, placing food into their mouth over a cover, being unable to be identified in public, wearing an identical black shroud with the stated purpose of appearing repulsive for the rest of their life outside psychologically abusive, extremist sects of Islam. It is utterly unnatural, and were you challenged to live this way for a year it would be humiliating (although satisfying) to watch you live out what you pretend here is a lifestyle choice, likely giving up after two months and refusing to admit why.

Pretending likely the most widespread and (along with genital mutilation, a practice intimately (pun intended) related to the burqa) reprehensible crimes against humanity, as real as radioactive fallout and several orders of magnitude as dangerous to public health - doesn't exist, is something anybody should be genuinely ashamed of.
 
Last edited:
Let's try this again.

Nobody chooses to view the world through a slit, placing food into their mouth over a cover, being unable to be identified in public, wearing an identical black shroud with the stated purpose of appearing repulsive for the rest of their life outside psychologically abusive, extremist sects of Islam. It is utterly unnatural, and were you challenged to live this way for a year it would be humiliating (although satisfying) to watch you live out what you pretend here is a lifestyle choice, likely giving up after two months and refusing to admit why.

Pretending likely the most widespread and (along with genital mutilation, a practice intimately (pun intended) related to the burqa) reprehensible crimes against humanity, as real as radioactive fallout and several orders of magnitude as dangerous to public health - doesn't exist, is something anybody should be genuinely ashamed of.

Let's try again.
Yes some women do choose to wear a burqa. You are entirely wrong when you insist they do not. They should be free to make that choice, much as you and I may dislike it. I have already made it clear that it is not a choice I would make so stop your silly little challenges.
No woman should be forced to wear a burqa.

Genital mutilation and the burqa are both 'several orders of magnitude as dangerous' (that doesn't make any sense at all) to public health as radioactive fallout? What a truly bizarre concept.
 
If something represents an utter absence of personal rights, the product of which is wearing a disguise the rest of your life, tolerating it due to respecting rights of choice is a clear, obvious contradiction. You contest this?

Meanwhile, it hasn't gone unnoticed that you've twice failed to explain how any of the contents in your link "One" and link "Two" clearly stands as evidence that the burqa, specifically, is intrinsically harmful.

You're obviously scared to admit your links - like your cooked up stats and failed poll ideas - don't bolster the stance you've taken on the OP.
 
Teach You How To Sing The Burqa Blues

Meanwhile, it hasn't gone unnoticed that you've twice failed to explain how any of the contents in your link "One" and link "Two" clearly stands as evidence that the burqa, specifically, is intrinsically harmful. You're obviously scared to admit your links - like your cooked up stats and failed poll ideas - don't bolster the stance you've taken on the OP.
Oh fine, you got me. I admit it, walking around the city in a death shroud is completely safe (with some exceptions). I had them almost convinced too, until you brought out the: "No studies have ever proven cotton and wool are structurally related to asbestos, and your argument that metal face veils are constructed from salvaged depleted uranium lacks evidence", and "Show me one shred of proof that a match accidentally dropped onto a burqa results in a 40% higher chance of being set ablaze than bell bottoms" hard balls.
 
Last edited:
Oh fine, you got me. ... [ ... And another fact-free rant]

True. You continue to fearfully dodge accountability for your claims.
Once again you've gone on an emotional rant rather than explaining how any of the contents in your link "One" and link "Two" clearly stands as evidence that the burqa, specifically, is intrinsically harmful (your claim).
 
I'm full of it, clearly.

Why ... yes! None of the off-tempo banter or links you've offered up serve as a statement to show how, specifically, your examples "One" and "Two" offer evidence that the burqa is intrinsically harmful, as you've suggested.
 
I am beginning to wonder if SirPhilip actually knows what 'intrinsically' means.

Yes, I am too. Seems a person should understand what s/he's saying in a claim though, before making that claim.

That reminds me: Sir Philip, what did you mean when you said (your) examples "One" and "Two" offer evidence that the burqa is intrinsically harmful?
 
Yes, I am too. Seems a person should understand what s/he's saying in a claim though, before making that claim. That reminds me: Sir Philip, what did you mean when you said (your) examples "One" and "Two" offer evidence that the burqa is intrinsically harmful?
No. You have to guess this time, what possibly "burqa" could have to do with the definition of the word "harm". This requires at minimum, at least several hundred thousand braincells but alas..

Tip: The more successfully you visualize actually suddenly having to wear one for the rest of your life, the more you'll understand why everyone who does is directly or indirectly forced from an early age and the more a quality people call common sense is developed, and to your astonishment, the more sense (increasingly pristine) I appear to make. If you can't read minds like I can however, just take my word for it: they really do, objectively suck and nobody outside socially imposed mental illness wants to wear them. So much so they should not be tolerated as an acceptable standard of human decency in first world countries.
 
Last edited:
I am beginning to wonder if SirPhilip actually knows what 'intrinsically' means.
I am beginning to wonder in all fairness, if you actually could go three months instead of two until the burqa's intrinsic lack of form and function, comfort and least important of all intrinsic lack of human dignity eventually got to you, overriding the need to prove otherwise and further save face (pun intended), and with a certainty and firmness usually unheard of in the science of human behavior, my point proved exactly.
 
Last edited:
To refresh your memory: pages ago I'd made the following statement.

Until someone can objectively prove the burqa is intrinsically harmful, it shouldn't be banned in the context of a relatively free society like France.

Your reply? ...


You have failed to explain how the links above offer evidence that objectively proves the burqa is intrinsically harmful. Number three was the most useless, and you continue to avoid showing how numbers one and two can be taken seriously at all.

Given your reckless track record of cooking up statistics and pretending they're factual, plus creating fake, useless polls, it's not helping your credibility any to continue avoiding responsibility for your very own claim above. All the pictures, links and rants you keep throwing up won't overshadow your obvious unwillingness to back your claims. ... But by all means, keep it up if you think you're actually fooling anyone.
 
I am beginning to wonder in all fairness, if you actually could go three months instead of two until the burqa's intrinsic lack of form and funct ...

Nope. Your hunch was right. He definitely doesn't understand what "intrinsic" means LOL
 
But by all means, keep it up if you think you're actually fooling anyone.
My points again, beyond a reasonable doubt true:

- Burqas are virtually not worn outside extremist religious communities or theocracies where rights are nonexistent.
- Burqas are products of extremism and mental illness, not religious devotion, in the same class as racist or anti-semitic symbols are and publicly restricted as the primary purpose is degrading a group of people. In this case, the humanity of a gender.
- Burqas are uncomfortable, are proven to limit intake of sunlight, veils significantly reduce visibility while crossing streets and cannot be worn while driving, pose clear security risks, their acceptance encourages barbaric, profound child abuse along with genital mutilation. By all sane standards, they are harmful. But to those who wear them, the assurance of safety from harm, physical and psychological.


There were no errors in anything I wrote. You and Keri's responses, as I'm rightfully being rude due to shamefully condoning and contesting something undeniably sick, are cheap defensive tactics very commonplace here.
 
Last edited:
their acceptance [the burka] encourages barbaric, profound child abuse along with genital mutilation.

oh i didnt know that, can you show me how that knowledge came into existance, I hope you didnt pull it out of a bodypart of yours.
 
The traditional cultural practice of FGC predates both Islam and Christianity. A Greek papyrus from 163 B.C. mentions girls in Egypt undergoing circumcision and it is widely accepted to have originated in Egypt and the Nile valley at the time of the Pharaohs. Evidence from mummies have shown both Type I and Type III FGC present.[40]

and all just because those Egypt 163 BC forced their wifes to wear a Burka.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom