Sarkozy says burqas are 'not welcome' in France

So, your position is that any human behavior that people might lie about can't be studied and we shouldn't bother?

So all those studies of the gay community that helped track down and understand the AIDS virus were actually worthless since gays in the 80s had every reason to want to keep their sex lives private.

And studies among heroin users that helped understand use in the community and develop needle exchange and methadone programs that worked better and saved lives, they couldn't get any real data there.

Is that really your position?

And why do you assume that any study can only be used as an excuse to punish women? I listed several situations in other countries where pressure on the women comes from outside the home, and could be addressed by confronting those sources of pressure.
 
Let's stick to this particular issue: what study/s are you proposing for this burqa "problem" ... since you seem to think studies would help?

Be specific. It was your idea.

(And then I'd be more than happy to address all those questions and assumptions you just rattled off.)
 
The Burqa Blues

The problem is no viable solution exists except the secular world standing it's ground. Adapting Sharia law to a first world country is very dangerous, if the U.K does this, what will occur is infringement on everyday life by these standards, as both are opposed ways of life as they are again, "divinely inspired". It is sad I have to point this out on a forum like this..
 
Last edited:
The problem is no viable solution exists except the secular world standing it's ground. Adapting Sharia law to a first world country is very dangerous, if the U.K does this, what will occur is infringement on everyday life by these standards, as both are opposed ways of life as they are again, "divinely inspired". It is sad I have to point this out on a forum like this..

If it were a CHRISTIAN religious practice, you wouldn't have had to do so. But since it's Islamic, it's impolite to point out that it is a tool of oppression and possession of women -- that's not politically correct, "Islamophobic", blah blah blah.
 
If it were a CHRISTIAN religious practice, you wouldn't have had to do so. But since it's Islamic, it's impolite to point out that it is a tool of oppression and possession of women -- that's not politically correct, "Islamophobic", blah blah blah.
People associate it with Bush administration talking points - an atrocious administration, however fundamentally right: the ends really do justify the means to protect the civilized world. You do not give rights to those who recognize none for themselves or others, nor do you have the option to be diplomatic.
 
Let's stick to this particular issue: what study/s are you proposing for this burqa "problem" ... since you seem to think studies would help?

Be specific. It was your idea.

(And then I'd be more than happy to address all those questions and assumptions you just rattled off.)

Please read the article. It isn't my idea, it is the idea of the french legislature backed by the President.

And I've already posted the questions that such a survey is meant to investigate.

In France specifically, how does the burqa effect quality of life for the women wearing it? Obviously if they can't be outside the house without it, these women are excluded from any activity that can't be done while wearing a huge sack. How else does this effect their lives?

How do they generally feel about the burqa? How prevalent are women who are more motivated by choice and general culture vs those who wish they had more freedom, starting with what they wear?

Is there policing of dress code in the community as there is in many Islamic countries? Who polices, family, religious authorities, self appointed moral guardians?

How are dress codes enforced (to the extent that they are)? Is there peer pressure? Shaming, religious guilt, direct threats, indirect threats (In afganistan a woman's husband/father may be punished is she fails to follow the dress code) Is there actual violence?

And so on.

Are you looking for the specific tactics to be used in gathering this information? I'm not a sociologist or an anthropologist, that's a bit like asking exactly where to buy the concrete and rent the backhoes before you'll agree that building a bridge is a good idea. Go and read some studies on spousal abuse, sexual abuse, narcotics, all published in the most respected peer reviewed journals.

If you're claiming that no useful information can be gotten because there are reasons for secrecy you're claiming one of two things.

1) All those studies and all those journals are wrong and wasting their time, even though the results are held to the highest standards and accepted by the academic world.

2) The Islamic community in France is somehow especially impenetrable.

These are both strong claims that require backing up. Which one are you making?
 
These are both strong claims that require backing up. Which one are you making?
Basically, without in depth studies we can't possibly assume burqas suck like a proverbial black hole.

Then there's Pat Condell..

 
Last edited:
If it were a CHRISTIAN religious practice, you wouldn't have had to do so. But since it's Islamic, it's impolite to point out that it is a tool of oppression and possession of women -- that's not politically correct, "Islamophobic", blah blah blah.

Who here has said anything remotely approaching that?
 
The problem is no viable solution exists except the secular world standing it's ground.

Solution to what problem? This thread is chiefly about whether or not it should be legal to ban the burqa (as Sarkozy proposes). The "solution" is it's isn't.

You just questioned why people are missing your point "in this forum". That's an amazing question in light of:

1. Your groundless, emotional statistical claims on this thread.
2. Your fearful avoidance of offering an explanation for why you'd punish women for wearing a piece of clothing.
3. Your pathetic multiple attempts at polls to support your stance when you clearly have no understanding of how polls are created and conducted.

And tell me - not that you necessarily know - how does the Youtube vid you posted specifically relate to my quote?
 
In France specifically, how does the burqa effect quality of life for the women wearing it? Obviously if they can't be outside the house without it, these women are excluded from any activity that can't be done while wearing a huge sack. How else does this effect their lives?

Regardless of how these questions about attitude are answered, as long as women are choosing to wear any given outfit in a free society, they are also choosing to go along with any restrictions in activities that might arise because of it. Adults are allowed to wear gigantunormous poorly fitting outfits in France.

We could also study women re: how many activities they can or can't do wearing mini-skirts, high heels and long, fake nails. It's still a choice, in a free country like France. If it isn't ... if the woman is being forced at gunpoint, w/in the context of a free society, then she has the choice to run away and report the culprit to the authorities. If she chooses to stay, it is her choice, in a free society like France.

In studies, you will get varying views on what the burqa means to a woman, and a range of answers on what restrictions, if any, each perceives she has as a result of the outfit she chooses to wear in a free country. Not sure how the answers should affect the choice of whether or not to ban a woman's outfit in France.

Ditto for the other questions you propose: varied answers, and some percentage of people lying always make these opinion studies questionable as objectively valid.

The problem with what you correctly label "sociological" studies, is that they are so subjective that they rarely can be used as a finite, singular body of factual information. They are based on varying and ever-changing attitudes, are often proven flawed, and many times similar studies will have contradictory outcomes.

Many times study outcomes based on opinion questions are created or administered with bias. Note SirPhilip's noticably biased attempt at a poll about the burqa in this thread. But even among professionals this happens.

If you're claiming that no useful information can be gotten because there are reasons for secrecy you're claiming one of two things.

1) All those studies and all those journals are wrong and wasting their time, even though the results are held to the highest standards and accepted by the academic world.

2) The Islamic community in France is somehow especially impenetrable.
"Useful information" needs to be qualified before I can answer your questions. Without you having to be a sociologist, what sort of "useful information" do you imagine might be discovered as a result of a study involving the burqa, to help decide whether or not the burqa should be legal in a country that enjoys relative freedom of speech/expression (like France)?
 
It was a CDC study that gathered statistics on, among other things, sexual activity and drug use in AIDS patients that helped spur researchers to look at transmissable viruses as possible causes of the epidemic.

I would call that useful.

As for your definition of choice...really? Someone being beaten, forbidden to obtain an education, who may come from a place where there is no possible way for a woman to support herself and who has been purposefully sheltered from finding out this isn't so.

That's a choice?
 
It was a CDC study that gathered statistics on, among other things, sexual activity and drug use in AIDS patients that helped spur researchers to look at transmissable viruses as possible causes of the epidemic.

I would call that useful.

Ultimately it took science/scientific research to make inroads with the issue above. Without it the rest of the data meant little. What science will be included in the study/s you would propose for finding out if the burqa should be banned in France?

As for your definition of choice...really? Someone being beaten, forbidden to obtain an education, who may come from a place where there is no possible way for a woman to support herself and who has been purposefully sheltered from finding out this isn't so.

That's a choice?
The "someone" we generally are describing here are adult women in a relatively free country like France, where women can choose to be beaten or can choose to walk away. At the very least, grown women in France are able to report abusive crimes to the authorities and seek them out for protection. And there is no global proof these women are absolutely shielded from this information or the basic understanding of it, in France.
 
Anyway, I'll ask you this again Cavemonster, in hopes of getting a direct answer:

Without you having to be a sociologist, what sort of "useful information" - as you call it - do you imagine might be discovered as a result of a study involving the burqa, to help decide whether or not the burqa should be legal in a country that enjoys relative freedom of speech/expression (like France)?
 
Last edited:
Ultimately it took science/scientific research to make inroads with the issue above. Without it the rest of the data meant little. What science will be included in the study/s you would propose for finding out if the burqa should be banned in France?

That's a pretty shifty goalpost you've got there mister.

The immediate question was whether a study could provide useful information on cultural practices that people would have reason to lie about. That's been satisfied.

The initial question of AIDS was a medical question, so many of the important steps were medical research. Studies of battered women have been used to optimize outreach from shelters and public programs. Studies of heroin users have been used to create needle exchange programs that would actually distribute needles effectively.

None of the required medical research.

This issue is not medical so it won't likely require it either.
 
Anyway, I'll ask you this again Cavemonster, in hopes of getting a direct answer:

Without you having to be a sociologist, what sort of "useful information" - as you call it - do you imagine might be discovered as a result of a study involving the burqa, to help decide whether or not the burqa should be legal in a country that enjoys relative freedom of speech/expression (like France)?

I've answered this in posts 333 and 347.
 
Solution to what problem? This thread is chiefly about whether or not it should be legal to ban the burqa (as Sarkozy proposes).
And the answer is yes, it should not be tolerated due not to what it is but represents, on very obvious grounds. If you cannot or refuse to understand this, the insult pretending it isn't is far worse instead of admitting you are carelessly opinionated and flat out wrong on a forum. :duel
 
And the answer is yes, it should not be tolerated due not to what it is but represents, on very obvious grounds. If you cannot or refuse to understand this, the insult pretending it isn't is far worse instead of admitting you are carelessly opinionated and flat out wrong on a forum. :duel

I, for one, understand entirely that you want to ban an item of clothing because of what it represents to you. Others insist that women (and men) should be free to make their own choices. Not that they should be forced, but that they should be free, including the freedom to make decisions you don't like.

I think the burqa is extremely offensive in what it says about women and what it says about men. But I insist that the state should not interfere in what free people do.

Understanding is not agreeing. Clearly we will never agree.
I do not understand your second sentence after the comma, so can't say whether or not I agree.
Perhaps you could edit it.

But seriously (well, almost) you really should be able to admit that you are flat out wrong.
I mean I admit I was wrong in saying I don't understand your second sentence after the comma. I understood bits of it.
 
That's a pretty shifty goalpost you've got there mister.

The immediate question was whether a study could provide useful information on cultural practices that people would have reason to lie about. That's been satisfied.
Goalshifting? I never made lying a centerpiece of an any argument, rather one of many problems in treating the outcome of a sociological study, in and of itself (that means w/out the aid of science) as factual.

A major concern/question was this, which I posed to you:

Let's stick to this particular issue: what study/s are you [meaning 'Cavemonster'] proposing for this burqa "problem" ... since you seem to think studies would help?

Be specific. It was your idea.
Next you told me you've already answered this question in former posts. I don't see it. If you sincerely feel I'm overlooking your answer, simply highlight or cut and paste your specific part of those posts that answer my specific question. Thank you.

The initial question of AIDS was a medical question, so many of the important steps were medical research. ...
Medical research is based on science. That made the use of your AIDS analogy to pure sociological studies incongruent. Sociological studies, in and of themselves (without the aid of science), is the example I asked you to find. You still haven't provided a study, or any reason to believe studies of the burqa (recall the topic here?) will help in resolving the burqa "problem" in France.

Chop chop.
 
I, for one, understand entirely that you want to ban an item of clothing because of what it represents to you. Others insist that women (and men) should be free to make their own choices. Not that they should be forced, but that they should be free, including the freedom to make decisions you don't like.

I think the burqa is extremely offensive in what it says about women and what it says about men. But I insist that the state should not interfere in what free people do.

Understanding is not agreeing. Clearly we will never agree.
I do not understand your second sentence after the comma, so can't say whether or not I agree.
Perhaps you could edit it.

But seriously (well, almost) you really should be able to admit that you are flat out wrong.
I mean I admit I was wrong in saying I don't understand your second sentence after the comma. I understood bits of it.

Seconded.

Also, this is - or should be - about arguing the facts. You can't build a reasonable argument on sentiment alone. That's part of why SP sometimes doesn't make sense. S/he's overly-emotional. I refuse to subjugate women by telling them they can't wear a particular piece of cloth in a free society. It's not required that I be happy about everything a woman wears.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom