Sarkozy says burqas are 'not welcome' in France

no its not the way to go as it will punish the woman that are already punished with a man that forces them to wear a burka. but you dont care about the woman.
Again, you are making absolutely no sense. When Turkey, a predominantly Arab country banned them, no epidemic of domestic violence was the result. Nor would there be in other countries, and what sense are you using to conclude that anything but a ban would be effective? Banning it solves the problem, the primary being it's role in psychological child abuse - which unlike Probe and Keri, you dignify yourself admitting it is. Excellent overview of the whole issue by the way:

 
This is a fair and sane question. SP reminds me of someone who doesn't grasp that he isn't fully grasping an issue. Of course some of it is also intellectual dishonesty: the made up statistics, the fantasy hack polls, the anti-Muslim rhetoric, all the subjective "God" talk that he thinks can support a reasonable argument. And then there is that matter of his links, which bear no association to his proof claim that "the burqa is intrinsically bad". Just continued, willful avoidance; him knowing full well he lacks competency in responding directly to a questioning of his crazy claim.
Competency is not something I lack, as I treat this as a discipline and it shows. You have an equal opportunity to challenge whatever I say, and if done so properly, I have the right to bow. You've stated several things that, and I mean this as respectfully as possible, qualify as: ridiculous, idiotic, morally oblivious, merit every justification for insult. Summarized here:

- Burqas are a choice of clothing people make. No, overwhelmingly they aren't. Virtually nobody chooses to wear them outside extremist religious sects or immigrants from theocracies, and wear it for the rest of their life. They are uncomfortable, ridiculous, plus dangerous in many situations that require driving, running, or climbing and limit sunlight intake.

- There is no harm in accepting the function burqas serve as decent, it is also not child abuse to mandate your children to wear them for the rest of their life by telling them God made them repulsive to look at. It is not a human rights issue. Yes it is, by every standard social and mental health are recognized.

Both of these are self-evidently right, what was I arguing?

 
Last edited:
Again, you are making absolutely no sense. When Turkey, a predominantly Arab country banned them, no epidemic of domestic violence was the result. Nor would there be in other countries, and what sense are you using to conclude that anything but a ban would be effective? Banning it solves the problem, the primary being it's role in psychological child abuse - which unlike Probe and Keri, you dignify yourself admitting it is. Excellent overview of the whole issue by the way:


You are, whether through deliberate dishonesty or stupidity, misrepresenting what I have said.
I have said that women who choose to wear a burqa should have the right to make that choice.
I have said that women should not be forced to wear a burqa.

As for the assertion that Turkey is predominantly Arab, you are absolutely wtrong. Such ignorance does nothing to bolster your position.
 
Competency is not something I lack, as I treat this as a discipline and it shows. You have an equal opportunity to challenge whatever I say, and if done so properly, I have the right to bow. You've stated several things that, and I mean this as respectfully as possible, qualify as: ridiculous, idiotic, morally oblivious, merit every justification for insult. Summarized here:

- Burqas are a choice of clothing people make. No, overwhelmingly they aren't. Virtually nobody chooses to wear them outside extremist religious sects or immigrants from theocracies, and wear it for the rest of their life. They are uncomfortable, ridiculous, plus dangerous in many situations that require driving, running, or climbing and limit sunlight intake.

- There is no harm in accepting the function burqas serve as decent, it is also not child abuse to mandate your children to wear them for the rest of their life by telling them God made them repulsive to look at. It is not a human rights issue. Yes it is, by every standard social and mental health are recognized.

Both of these are self-evidently right, what was I arguing?
Darn. I was kinda hoping you knew.

You might want to hold off on your posts 'til you do, they'll probably be more coherent.
 
Competency is not something I lack, as I yadayadayada ... what was I arguing?


You're presenting a fecund crop of silly, emotionally-driven "arguments". Meanwhile, for pages now, you've repeatedly failed to back a major claim with applicable facts.

To refresh your memory, first I made the following statement:

Until someone can objectively prove the burqa is intrinsically harmful, it shouldn't be banned in the context of a relatively free society like France.
Your reply? A contradicting statement with alleged "evidence" in the form of this ...

You have failed to explain how the links above offer evidence that objectively proves the burqa is intrinsically harmful. I fully expect you to keep fearfully avoiding a reasonable request to offer a direct, clear explanation as to how your items #1,#2 and #3 above objectively prove that (your claim) "the burqa is intrinsically harmful" is fact.

This is a skeptics' forum SP, and no one need take your "intrinsic" claim seriously unless or until you back it with facts. Especially because you're already lacking credibility, given your earlier abuse of statistics as "fact", plus your embarrasing hack polling ideas that failed to boost your argument.
 
I'll could try, but I still can't guarantee I'd make the least bit of sense.

There's nothing like an apt typo to illustrate a point. ;)


But as to the assertion that people who defend other people's rights to make bad choices should make the same choices: that is to miss the whole point.
People should be able to choose for themselves what they do and what they wear as long as their choices do not impinge on the rights of others.
They should be able to make stupid choices. They should be able to make choices we think are insane. We should not have the right to deny that right.


Oh, and have you brushed up on the ethnic makeup of Turkey?
 
:chores037:
This is a skeptics' forum SP, and no one need take your "intrinsic" claim seriously unless or until you back it with facts. Especially because you're already lacking credibility, given your earlier abuse of statistics as "fact", plus your embarrasing hack polling ideas that failed to boost your argument.
Begging the question (then asking an ever expanding series of fake, clueless questions in a challenging manner). Two penalties I count. If someone refuses to accept driving with alcohol in your system is harmful, when this is self-evident and common sense, are you going to take them seriously? If someone likewise does not recognize something as not only a self-evident symbol of lack of rights, but the definition of child abuse are you not going to want to simply mock them? Do they not publicly shame themselves in the purely fake and contemptible manner they pretend it is something you invented, and pitiful of all, challenge you to figure it out step by step for them?

Do I even need to point out every secular humanist, naturalist, public educator and the secular majority of this forum - are in profound disagreement with you, and consider these garments the definition of psychological abuse? And a question that really begs, would you agree to wear one for the rest of your life as a 'lifestyle choice'?
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by SirPhilip :
I'll could try, but I still can't guarantee I'd make the least bit of sense.
There's nothing like an apt typo to illustrate a point.


But as to the assertion that people who defend other people's rights to make bad choices should make the same choices: that is to miss the whole point.
People should be able to choose for themselves what they do and what they wear as long as their choices do not impinge on the rights of others.
They should be able to make stupid choices. They should be able to make choices we think are insane. We should not have the right to deny that right.


Oh, and have you brushed up on the ethnic makeup of Turkey?
 
Do I even need to point out every secular humanist, naturalist, public educator are in profound disagreement with you, and consider these garments the definition of psychological abuse?

Another made up fact from SirPhilip
 
Do they not publicly shame themselves in the purely fake and contemptible manner they pretend it is something your invention, and pitiful of all, challenge you to figure it out step by step for them?

A little more editing needed...
 
Would you and Probe like to wear one for a year? You can come back, convinced it is a lifestyle choice people freely make. It'll be loads of fun, I promise. I could also arrange escorts, a tall man dressed as an SS Officer and a cheerfully naked model, selected to look barely of legal age, to accompany us to the cafe every morning, and at brunch, to watch you master new things to eat.
 
Last edited:
A little more editing needed...
Ah! Yes, as opposed to none or two times, I have a habit of making ten revisions after the fact when snacking on habanero peppers. I recommend waiting about 5 minutes before quoting me in these situations.

Hey, everybody has their quirks. :)
 
Would you and Probe like to wear one for a year? You can come back, convinced it is a lifestyle choice people freely make. It'll be loads of fun, I promise. I could also arrange escorts, a tall man dressed as an SS Officer and a cheerfully naked model, selected to look barely of legal age, to accompany us to the cafe every morning, and at brunch, to watch you master new things to eat.

You don't actually read what I post, do you?
I have already said more than once that I would not choose to wear a burqa.
Yes, some women do make that choice. That is a fact, no matter how much you deny it.
I think it is a bad choice but I also think others have the right to make bad choices.
Your last sentence is stupid beyond belief.
 
Ah! Yes, as opposed to none or two times, I have a habit of making ten revisions after the fact when snacking on habanero peppers. I recommend waiting about 5 minutes before quoting me in these situations.

Hey, everybody has their quirks. :)

Actually I waited 17 minutes, and the post still makes absolutely no sense.
Would you like to try again?
 
People should be able to choose for themselves what they do and what they wear as long as their choices do not impinge on the rights of others. They should be able to make stupid choices. They should be able to make choices we think are insane. We should not have the right to deny that right.
So not being able to parade yourself around naked in public or wearing anything deeply demoralizing, does not make any sense to you. These laws exist in almost every country and in Saudi Arabia, carry death sentences however. The primary reason the Burqa is already banned in countries is, for all practical purposes they are disguises. The law makes sense in the same context nudity does on the opposite spectrum - it is not socially acceptable.

Oh, and have you brushed up on the ethnic makeup of Turkey?
Your um, point? According to the CIA World Factbook, Turkey is 99.5% Muslim.
 
Last edited:
So not being able to parade yourself around naked in public or wearing anything deeply demoralizing, does not make any sense to you. These laws exist in almost every country and in Saudi Arabia, carry death sentences however. The primary reason the Burqa is already banned in countries is, for all practical purposes they are disguises. The law makes sense in the same context nudity does on the opposite spectrum - it is not socially acceptable.

Your um, point? According to the CIA World Factbook, Turkey is 99.5% Muslim.

Do you not know that Arab is not a synonym for Muslim? Do you not know that the majority of the world's Muslims are not Arab and not even neighbours of Arabs?

Which countries is the burqa banned in?

I find the burqa quite acceptable if the wearer has made a free choice.
 
Do you not know that Arab is not a synonym for Muslim? Do you not know that the majority of the world's Muslims are not Arab and not even neighbours of Arabs?
I'm aware of that. Your point is?

Which countries is the burqa banned in?
bartgoogle.gif


I find the burqa quite acceptable if the wearer has made a free choice.
Which 99.9% of the time, they haven't and have no comprehension of what rights or a free choice actually is..
 
I'm aware of that. Your point is?

[qimg]http://img269.imageshack.us/img269/9721/bartgoogle.gif[/qimg]

Which 99.9% of the time, they haven't and have no comprehension of what rights or a free choice actually is..

My point is that you said Turkey was mostly Arab.

More made up statistics I see. Does that figure refer to women in free Western countries, particularly France, which this discussion has been about?

I would have thought if you make claims such as the burqa is banned in some countries you would be happy and able to say which countries
 
Actually I waited 17 minutes, and the post still makes absolutely no sense. Would you like to try again?
To agree it does is to accept every insult attached to everything I pointed out also - and I've done that precisely to make it very difficult for you and Probe. Although less dishonest, you are nevertheless forced by this yourself to react with cascades of shallow, oblivious, off-base questions, pretending my statements are incomprehensible to you. That little game is played by people here with post counts into the upper 30's, still they don't learn, and it looks exactly the same each time.

It was your choice to contest religiously motivated child abuse as something else. You are stuck along with Probe with somehow defending it, ridiculously, as a choice of clothing, or pretending that it's harmful nature isn't self-evident as even Cheney had enough human dignity to recognize.

howburqaswork.png



What part were you having trouble with, though?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom