Sarkozy says burqas are 'not welcome' in France

Because it should not be tolerated. If their husbands or family are responsible, it's within their self interest to state so to a judge.

Women choosing what to wear should not be tolerated.
If the women are forced to wear burqas now is it not in their interests to refuse now by seeking protection?
How does punishing the women make things better for them?
 
Because it should not be tolerated. If their husbands or family are responsible, it's within their self interest to state so to a judge.

To say someone should be punished because her behavior should not be tolerated is hardly a satisfying answer. In fact, it pretty much begs the question.

Murder should be punished because it should not be tolerated.
Fraud should be punished because it should not be tolerated.
Heroin possession should be punished because it should not be tolerated.
Cheeseburger possession should be punished because it should not be tolerated.
Karaoke should be punished because it should not be tolerated.
Curling up in bed with a good book should be punished because it should not be tolerated.

As arguments, these are all perfectly equivalent, yet some of them (between 1 and 4 of them, depending on your inclinations) are obviously absurd. So I repeat, to say x should be punished because it should not be tolerated is no real answer. You're leaving out a "why" - a real "why."
 

Liked the video. It didn't leave me with a desire to have the woman in it fined or jailed. Oh well.

I have given speeches wearing this, right? Now the thing is that, this forces the people to listen to what I have to say, it forces my character out - you're not judging me by my looks, you're not judging me by my clothes - and you're - you're definitely not judging me by the way I look, right? Cause, the way I'm covered, you're listening - it forces you to listen to what I have to say.

She left out "...unless you're SirPhilip, in which case what I have to say means nothing to you."
 
To try to bring this back to the topic. While Sarcozy's rhetoric was firey and divisive, calling for a "ban" and saying that the Burqa had no place in France, it's important to note that there is no specific law before legislature to punish women for wearing the garment.

Besides blustering about it, the only official action has been to endorse a study:
The French leader expressed support for a recent call by dozens of legislators to create a parliamentary commission to study a small but growing trend of wearing the full-body garment in France.

So addressing the only action France's legislature is actually close to taking, does anyone on either side have a problem with a parliamentary commission to study the garment?
 
Child abuse doesn't actually exist, you assure everyone reading this ...

More tangential unrelated grizzle.

... my name and avatar also suggest I'm not male.

Who would know what you are? Your avatar isn't any more proof of your gender that your claims to unconfirmed statistics are real.

But do you have anything else to add?

Why, yes:

Why do you wish to punish women for wearing something they have chosen to wear within a relatively free society?
 
So addressing the only action France's legislature is actually close to taking, does anyone on either side have a problem with a parliamentary commission to study the garment?

Maybe they should study yarmulkes, priests' collars, nuns' habits or five-inch stilettos next?
 
I applaud Sarkozy for this. Burqas are destructive tools of oppression and shouldn't be welcome anywhere in the civilized world.

This has nothing to do with choice since the women wearing burqas are either forced to wear them by physical violence or the threat thereof or because they've been brainwashed by women-loathing extremists who've convinced them that they'll burn in hell if anyone other than her husband sees her face. This kind of abuse, and that's what it is, should not be tolerated.

If Muslim nations want to remain in the dark ages, that's their business I suppose but countries that have gotten beyond such bizarre, discriminatory voodoo shouldn't backslide and allow it to occur in their society since doing so would be to extend their tacit approval of women being treated as inherently sinful and worthless chattel.
 
Because it should not be tolerated. If their husbands or family are responsible, it's within their self interest to state so to a judge.

If every woman who wore a burqa were a slave, as you wrongly assert, then she would likely never rat out her slave master, who is almost certainly making threats - possibly on her life - that she must wear a burqa.

But you'd be happy for the coerced woman to keep getting penalties under law (instead of her slave master) each time she was "forced" to wear the burqa, on behalf of her menacing slave master.

And how would you even hope to prosecute the person/s responsible for "making" someone wear the burqa in a free society? The culprit would simply deny the accusation each time, saying it was the woman's choice to wear it. It would be his word against hers: a wash. Then he might just beat the living piss out of her later (or worse) because she got caught and penalized for what he forced her to do.
 
This has nothing to do with choice since the women wearing burqas are either forced to wear them by physical violence or the threat thereof or because they've been brainwashed.

Please explain what you mean by "brainwashed".
 
Maybe they should study yarmulkes, priests' collars, nuns' habits or five-inch stilettos next?

As far as I know, being beaten for not wearing any of the above is a rarity, and while the stillettos can do some damage, they are also vanishingly unlikely to be anything but a pure choice and then worn quite rarely.

Surely you understand that even some women may wear a burqa willingly, many women do not, and in many cases it's a tool to isolate them socially and part of a larger pattern of dehumanization.

Do you know the approximate number of women in France who wear a burqa willingly vs unwillingly? Do you know the exact role the garment plays in the communities in France where it is worn?

Perhaps a study would go a good way toward finding that out.
 
So addressing the only action France's legislature is actually close to taking, does anyone on either side have a problem with a parliamentary commission to study the garment?

I would be surprised that it would take a parliamentary commission to study the garment. Basically it is just a big bag.
 
I would be surprised that it would take a parliamentary commission to study the garment. Basically it is just a big bag.

You're silly.
Of course you understand that this is a study of the cultural phenomenon. What kind of pressure is exerted on women who refuse to wear it, social, religious, physical violence. What sort of numbers in the french Muslim communities wear it for personal cultural reasons.

In what ways does it reinforce objectification and isolation, if any. In what ways does it add to the well being of the women, if any.

What is the stance of local clerics and sharia courts? Are there ways of encouraging families to or community leaders to allow women more choice in their dress and movement. Who enforces dress codes? In many of the countries these women come from, dress is policed by unofficial moral police (Taliban is just one well known example, there are many small, less formal groups). Do these communities have such people?

If a study uncovered that much of the dress code is enforced the way it is in Afghanistan, that men walked the streets looking for dress code violations and then confronted the family with threats, violence and religious guilt, would you be surprised? If women could be given more freedom by targeting these outside moral police, would you think their lives improved?

What if it were found, that like in many countries, it wasn't so much threat of violence but the threat of divorce and poverty was keeping women adopting unpleasant practices? What if an awareness campaign that allowed immigrants who have been isolated to know that there is actually a job market for women in France, and that they wouldn't need to be reduced to begging or prostitution (as there are no other options in the towns many of them may have come from) if they disobeyed their husbands.

Nobody in this thread has more than a gut feeling about this specific community of Muslims in France. There's a lot of debate about how the burqa effects life, and how willingly women there wear it, and not one person has presented a real source for the role of this garment in these women's lives.

I think there's an awful lot to study there.
 
Last edited:
As far as I know, being beaten for not wearing any of the above is a rarity ...

The problem is no one can say for certain how many women wearing burqas are so-called "forced" to do it, or choose to wear them on their own volition, in the context of a relatively free society like France.

Freedom of expression is a precious thing to be carefully guarded. Since a garment holds varying meanings for different people, the garment itself can't be universally deemed a "tool of isolation" or oppression.

Do you know the approximate number of women in France who wear a burqa willingly vs unwillingly?
No, that would probably require a ubiquitous invasion of privacy, if we assume coercion often takes place behind closed doors. But the point is there is a range of opinions, which means choice is involved in some cases. Women deserve to have a choice to wear the garment if they so wish, even if you or I don't necessarily understand it.

Do you know the exact role the garment plays in the communities in France where it is worn?
You'd get varied answers on this. Arguably, even the more broad religious and social customs are interpreted and expressed individually. That's why a dress code shouldn't be uniformly banned IMO.
 
You're silly.

Not so much. Kerikiwi is right. The thing really is just a glorified (and villified) bag.

Studies about cultural phenomenon can be interesting. But the fact still remains: garments are endowed with myriad meanings, at any given time, by the "wearer" as well as the observer.

Unless or until you can prove that a garment only holds a single, nefarious meaning in society, which creates a clear and present danger to society, there's little reason to discuss any possibility of legally punishing people for wearing that garment ... especially people that might be considered coerced into wearing that garment.
 
To say someone should be punished because her behavior should not be tolerated is hardly a satisfying answer. In fact, it pretty much begs the question.

Murder should be punished because it should not be tolerated.
Fraud should be punished because it should not be tolerated.
Heroin possession should be punished because it should not be tolerated.
Cheeseburger possession should be punished because it should not be tolerated.
Karaoke should be punished because it should not be tolerated.
Curling up in bed with a good book should be punished because it should not be tolerated.

As arguments, these are all perfectly equivalent, yet some of them (between 1 and 4 of them, depending on your inclinations) are obviously absurd. So I repeat, to say x should be punished because it should not be tolerated is no real answer. You're leaving out a "why" - a real "why."


I agree about the karaoke.
 
To try to bring this back to the topic. While Sarcozy's rhetoric was firey and divisive, calling for a "ban" and saying that the Burqa had no place in France, it's important to note that there is no specific law before legislature to punish women for wearing the garment.

Besides blustering about it, the only official action has been to endorse a study:


So addressing the only action France's legislature is actually close to taking, does anyone on either side have a problem with a parliamentary commission to study the garment?
Heck no. If that means the same thing in French as it does in American then other than a few tax dollars drifting into somebodies' pockets the whole thing will ultimately get less attention than we've been giving SirPhilip.
 
I applaud Sarkozy for this. Burqas are destructive tools of oppression and shouldn't be welcome anywhere in the civilized world.

This has nothing to do with choice since the women wearing burqas are either forced to wear them by physical violence or the threat thereof or because they've been brainwashed by women-loathing extremists who've convinced them that they'll burn in hell if anyone other than her husband sees her face. This kind of abuse, and that's what it is, should not be tolerated.

If Muslim nations want to remain in the dark ages, that's their business I suppose but countries that have gotten beyond such bizarre, discriminatory voodoo shouldn't backslide and allow it to occur in their society since doing so would be to extend their tacit approval of women being treated as inherently sinful and worthless chattel.
You realize of course that this is also a strong argument in favor of letting women go topless whenever they want to instead of being punished by law. Stronger, perhaps, since far more women in far more societies are constrained by such bizarre, discriminatory voodoo.

Viewed in that light I could find room for agreement.

In fact, why don't we work on that first, and get around to banning burqas afterward.
 
The problem is no one can say for certain how many women wearing burqas are so-called "forced" to do it, or choose to wear them on their own volition, in the context of a relatively free society like France.

If only we had some way to find out how many women are pressured and how... maybe we could study it somehow?

Unless or until you can prove that a garment only holds a single, nefarious meaning in society, which creates a clear and present danger to society, there's little reason to discuss any possibility of legally punishing people for wearing that garment ... especially people that might be considered coerced into wearing that garment.

So wait, until I can prove that the burqa is only harmful, there is no justification in studying the burqa. Did you miss the catch-22 you just did there?

No, that would probably require a ubiquitous invasion of privacy, if we assume coercion often takes place behind closed doors.

Really? Every civilized country has done many studies on spousal abuse which goes on behind closed doors. Did that require a ubiquitous invasion of privacy? Or is the culture behind the burqa so different that it can't be studied in a similar way? If it is, I'd say we're looking at more than a meaningless piece of cloth.
 
If only we had some way to find out how many women are pressured and how... maybe we could study it somehow?

No, that would probably require a ubiquitous invasion of privacy, if we assume coercion often takes place behind closed doors.

But I like your confidence in the idea of a study, so could you offer up one or more ideas you have for one? The more specific, the better. Thanks.

So wait, until I can prove that the burqa is only harmful, there is no justification in studying the burqa. Did you miss the catch-22 you just did there?
You can't prove the burqa, a piece of cloth, is harmful. It's certain peoples' behavior regarding a burqa (and the forced wearing of high heeled shoes, as in the traffic trade) that's harmful.


Really? Every civilized country has done many studies on spousal abuse which goes on behind closed doors. Did that require a ubiquitous invasion of privacy? Or is the culture behind the burqa so different that it can't be studied in a similar way? If it is, I'd say we're looking at more than a meaningless piece of cloth.
The studies you speak of are likely inaccurate to varying degrees because many woman (and men) who are abused, minimize their abuse when asked to describe of discuss it, while others exaggerate claims of abuse because have psychological issues. Also, many people (including men) who are abused are prone to deny they've been abused at all. To reveal more accurate data you'd have to secretly track the behavior of the women wearing the burqa, as well as the people around her, inside and outside of her home, for a time.

Again, if you think an actual piece of cloth is the cause of abuse in every case it's worn, and one or more studies can reveal the fact and help justify legally penalizing women for wearing it, you'll need to explain your study/s.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom