Sarkozy says burqas are 'not welcome' in France

I never promised to have a solution. You're off on an incoherent rant again. My main point is that there's no perfectly good reason to ban the piece of cloth called a burqa in a relatively free society. Especially when it just punishes women.
That is where we disagree. I consider it evil - as it profoundly is, you something people wear (deludedly, they prefer to wear), ignoring entirely what it stands for.


linusrichard said:
Anyway, we have all of SirPhilip's insistence that the burqa is bad and Islam is bad and the burqa symbolizes this and represents that and Islam is this and that and so on, and some of it I actually agree with, except that nowhere is made an argument why people who wear burqa should be punished...
My point is it is a lesser evil than accepting it in western society. Contest it, but do make sense. There is a difference between modesty as a choice and imposed self-hatred.
 
Last edited:
Would you wear one? Simple question.

Indeed it is a simple question, as is the two part question I have repeatedly asked you:
How do you propose to punish women who
a) are forced to wear a burqa
b) choose to wear a burqa
 
Indeed it is a simple question, as is the two part question I have repeatedly asked you:
How do you propose to punish women who
a) are forced to wear a burqa
b) choose to wear a burqa
Which I've answered the first time I was asked: The same manner in which public indecency is, and increasing fines for repeat offenses, if you choose to live in a country which considers it demoralizing. Conversely, theocracies like Saudi Arabia have brutal laws about doing the opposite in public, tit for tat and all that. What I've said is errorless on principle, in addition to this also: Islam does not recognize other cultures or societies as valid.

So would you wear one? Or is that too personal (one could only laugh at that as a tactic to save face) also.
 
Last edited:
Which I've answered the first time I was asked: The same manner in which public indecency is, and increasing fines for repeat offenses, if you choose to live in a country which considers it demoralizing which is just about everywhere. Conversely, theocracies like Saudi Arabia have brutal laws about doing the opposite in public, tit for tat and all that.

So would you wear one? Or is that too personal - one could only laugh at that as a tactic to save face - also.
No, you did not answer the first time you were asked, which is why the question had to be repeated.
How is public indecency punished?
You want to punish a woman who wears a burqa under duress? Do I understand you correctly?
And you want to punish her because in Saudi Arabia there are brutal laws?
I find your morality bizarre.
No, I would not wear a burqa but neither do I think I should be punished should I choose to wear one.
What do you mean about a tactic to save face?
What do you mean by 'is that too personal also'? I never said anything was too personal.
 
Ugly Is Ugly

How is public indecency punished?
Unless you have access to Google, you may never know.

You want to punish a woman who wears a burqa under duress? Do I understand you correctly?
Banning it is in fact a lesser evil than accepting it in modern countries - that is what you and others aren't understanding. What underlies it is abusive and a human rights issue. They are conditioned from an early age that they look repulsive, requiring them to wear it to minimize their effect on others. Do you want to somehow pretend this is not the case?

Would you like to wear one in public for a week?
 
Last edited:
Unless you have access to Google, you may never know.

Banning it is in fact a lesser evil than accepting it in modern countries - that is what you and others aren't understanding. What underlies it is abusive and a human rights issue. They are conditioned from an early age that they look repulsive, requiring them to wear it to minimize their effect on others. Do you want to somehow pretend this is not the case?

Would you like to wear one in public for a week?

Your unwillingness to state how you want to punish women is bemusing.
Your unwillingness to state whether you want to punish women who are forced to wear a burqa is also bemusing.
What does this mean :requiring them to wear it to minimize their effect on others?
Some of your points are a little hard to understand.
I have already said I would not choose to wear one. I also said I don't think I should be punished should I make that choice. Do you think I should be punished if I make that choice?
 
That is where we disagree. I consider it evil - as it profoundly is ...

You are welcome to "disagree" and "consider" things the way you wish. Opinion is not fact. I could care less that you "consider" a piece of cloth "evil". An opinion with no facts to back it isn't even worth a penny. Everyone has some or other varied opinion. Big deal. This is a skeptics forum. Put out (facts) or stop all the senseless whining.

... you something people wear (deludedly, they prefer to wear), ignoring entirely what it stands for.
Any piece of cloth stands for different things to different people. Your opinion on what a piece of cloth "stands for" is yet another opinion.

[Garbled horsecrap]
 
Would you wear one? Simple question.

Who cares whether or not I would wear a burqa? Even if I said "no", which I'm not saying, there are still people out there who would say "yes" and choose to wear a burqa in the context of a free society.

The point is, in a free society people have a choice whether or not to wear a burqa. And you would punish a woman who chooses to wear a burqa in a free society and call it "protecting her". That's just asinine; misogynistic.

And you pretending that women are too weak to make a choice about wearing the burqa in a free society, that it's all slavery, is misogynistic too, not to mention insulting and patronizing.
 
Your unwillingness to state how you want to punish women is bemusing.
Your unwillingness to state whether you want to punish women who are forced to wear a burqa is also bemusing.
What does this mean :requiring them to wear it to minimize their effect on others?
Some of your points are a little hard to understand.
I have already said I would not choose to wear one. I also said I don't think I should be punished should I make that choice. Do you think I should be punished if I make that choice?

SP lost any credibility pages back. S/he has no facts to back up any of her/his opinions. S/he's compulsively attached to subjective terminology like "evil", "indecency" and "immoralizing", as if we all don't have wildly varied ideas of what these things mean. S/he wants to legislate her opinion about what women should wear or not wear; wants laws of the land based on her personal definition of what society considers "immoral" or "indecent". Which is no better than what the Taliban does.

SP is never going to directly answer the questions you (rightly) keep pressing him/her to answer. That's because the answer is that yes, SirPhilip does want to punish women. SP had plenty of time to say no and back up her/his argument. ... Nor has s/he been able to back up any "statistics" that s/he pretended were true at the start of this discussion. Or that pathetic attempt at a poll?? That was embarrassing.

It's this kind of intellectual dishonesty and sloppy debate skills that are grounds for all of us to just start ignoring this poster and her/his fact-free nonarguments. Let her go on pretending s/he made some kind of sense at some point.
 
I am a bit of a pollyanna as evidenced by the fact that I teach 5 to 11 year olds: there's hope for everyone.
 
It's evil, sick and nobody chooses to wear one, people. Period. You should have the common sense and ability to tell right from wrong to come to that same conclusion, including the rudimentary insight to understand why they think they want to wear one, and understand why that should not be acceptable, regardless of whatever domestic instability it creates.
 
nobody chooses to wear one, people. Period.
You are wrong. Some women do choose to wear burqas.
You may not like burqas. Nor do I. But some women do choose to wear them.
Do you wish to punish women who make that choice?
Do you wish to punish women who are forced to wear burqas?
Try to give a direct answer rather than weasel around.
 
Last edited:
It's this kind of intellectual dishonesty and sloppy debate skills that are grounds for all of us to just start ignoring this poster and her/his fact-free nonarguments. Let her go on pretending s/he made some kind of sense at some point.
Child abuse doesn't actually exist, you assure everyone reading this, my name and avatar also suggest I'm not male. Michael Jackson also loved being African American, you know in your heart. But do you have anything else to add?
 
nobody chooses to wear one, people. Period.

You are wrong. Some women do choose to wear burqas.
You may not like burqas. Nor do I. But some women do choose to wear them.
Do you wish to punish women who make that choice?
Do you wish to punish women who are forced to wear burqas?
Try to give a direct answer rather than weasel around.

I'm satisfied with his answer about whether and how to punish. He has more or less said that he would punish women who would wear a burqa, and that he would give them the same punishment as a women who exposes herself in public. In my state, that's a "disorderly person," punishable by up to 90 days in jail or up to $500 fine, or both (although realistically, always much less). Which is disgusting of course, but there you go. And still no decent argument as to why.
 
You are wrong. Some women do choose to wear burqas
No. I'm not. Virtually nobody does outside a strict Islamic upbringing. That a virtual minority elects to does not mean what it represents is not sick, should be accepted by everyone else in the world, and not outright considered indecent. The central theme of Islam is slavery and submission, Islam and what we understand as human rights are in fact opposed. Furthermore nobody put a gun to your head, told you that you are repulsive and indecent to look at, and mandated you wear such a ridiculous thing every day of your life to not offend family, friends, and in the future, your husband.

Do you wish to punish women who make that choice?
Yes, and the second time, their husbands should be fined as well.

Do you wish to punish women who are forced to wear burqas?
Yes. It should not be acceptable, regardless of what domestic instability that causes. Furthermore, and most importantly, it should be considered child abuse to force someone to from an early age in any respectable country.

Try to give a direct answer rather than weasel around.
I can't get clearer than that, but whether you can be more clueless is another thing entirely.
 
Last edited:
No. I'm not. Virtually nobody does outside a strict Islamic upbringing. That a virtual minority elects to does not mean what it represents is not sick, should be accepted by everyone else in the world, and not outright considered indecent. The central theme of Islam is slavery and submission, Islam and what we understand as human rights are in fact opposed. Furthermore nobody put a gun to your head, told you that you are repulsive and indecent to look at, and mandated you wear such a ridiculous thing every day of your life to not offend family, friends, and in the future, your husband.

Yes, and the second time, their husbands should be fined as well.

Yes. It should not be acceptable, regardless of what domestic instability that causes. Furthermore, and most importantly, it should be considered child abuse to force someone to from an early age in any respectable country.

I can't get clearer than that, but whether you can be more clueless is another thing entirely.

You are being inconsistent. You say nobody chooses to wear a burqa and then that a 'virtual minority' ( whatever that means) does choose to.
So we agree. Some women choose to wear a burqa. And we also agree that they are a minority.
And you want to punish them. I find it obscene and offensive that you wish to mandate what women can and cannot wear.
Even worse is wanting to punish a woman for wearing a burqa because she is forced to. I can't see any difference , except in degree of the abuse, to punishing a woman because her husband raped her.
The sentence about a gun being put to my head is bizarre. Can you explain its relevance regarding whether I should be able to choose what to wear?
Perhaps you could explain your position better rather than resorting to name calling when you are challenged. If you can't get any clearer it could well be that the fault is yours. Something to consider.
 
First we rebranded their national cuisine as "Freedom Fries," and now they've retaliated by banning our burgas. When will this food fight end?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom