Sarkozy says burqas are 'not welcome' in France

Muslims consider anything outside Islam wrong, as their ritualistic lifestyle is prescribed by God and not man made. Everything that is must eventually be brought under Islam. In other words, they all think you should act likewise for your own good to avoid being tortured for eternity by a dictator that created the universe, similar to what neoconservatives believe. That is in fact what a Muslim is. That is why they dress, act, and behave that way: out of fear (submission).

it sound like it is pretty monolithic,

so you have ANY source for your claims? strangely enough i know an Imam, and he has no problem with me beeing an Atheist. he never tryed to behead me, not that i noticed atleast. he didnt even try to convince me that Islam is the right religion for me. and he said things like, first humans, then religion.

and sure they belive their religion is the right one, no diffrent to Christians or Jews.
hell even i belive my Atheism is the right thing. i think we dont need thos fantasy creatures anymore.
 
Last edited:
Muslims consider anything outside Islam wrong, as their ritualistic lifestyle is prescribed by God and not man made. Everything that is must eventually be brought under Islam. In other words, they all think you should act likewise for your own good to avoid being tortured for eternity by a dictator that created the universe, similar to what neoconservatives believe. That is in fact what a Muslim is. That is why they dress, act, and behave that way: out of fear (submission).
I have to think that your world is very monochromatic, when there is just this one kind of Muslim. I would have thought that like other major religious groups they would be more apt to come in different varieties and flavors.

Now of course, if you were referring to, say, Christians I could understand assuming that they were all baby-bombing Timothy McVeighs, or mass-murdering Jim Joneses.

We have, for example, the Southern Baptist rule that women should submit to their husbands' will. What sort of legislation do you propose to eradicate this particular travesty of human rights? How do you think the women who acquiesce to this rule should be punished?
 
SirPhilip is apparently unable to answer a simple question about how he wishes to punish burqa wearing women.
Possibly that is because it challenges some poor reasoning.
 
The problem with Sharia law is the same as with a malignant infection - the characteristic of growth. Sharia is divine law, man made law is therefore inferior, and efforts will be made to overthrow "man made" laws in the host country. There is no actual diplomacy possible as Islam is completely at odds in the first place with everything unislamic.

There seems to be a few voices of reason within Islam.



I hope there were more people like that guy, but somehow I doubt there actually are.
 
72 straight hours of American Idol's Worst Auditions.

More wimpy attempts at getting out of actually answering the questions. And not even funny.

Not only has SP miserably failed to back up her or his silly emotional claims, s/he dodges questions to avoid being held accountable for those silly emotional claims.
 
Muslims consider anything outside Islam wrong, as their ritualistic lifestyle is prescribed by God and not man made. Everything that is must eventually be brought under Islam. In other words, they all think you should act likewise for your own good to avoid being tortured for eternity by a dictator that created the universe, similar to what neoconservatives believe. That is in fact what a Muslim is. That is why they dress, act, and behave that way: out of fear (submission).

This piece of overly-generalized, under-educated paranoid vomit is the main reason people on this thread listen to you and only hear the banjo player in "The Deliverance" playing in the background.
 
And your solution, superior to mine in all regards, is what? I disagree the burqa is a choice except among a virtual minority of people who willfully adapt to that lifestyle, furthermore it is publicly demoralizing and what it actually represents is by definition, abuse by every measure that is defined.

It's as easy as asking you: "Would you wear it every single time you had to go out?"

Your answer is, like everyone elses, going to be a resounding no.

"Would you wear it if you were conditioned from a young age to accept it and what it represents as comforting?"


Yes, you would and you would resist adapting otherwise.
 
so you have ANY source for your claims?
Self-evident? If you disagree, I guess we could play the "Reduce Until Probability Of Being Right Approaches 1" game so popular on here.

strangely enough i know an Imam, and he has no problem with me beeing an Atheist. he never tryed to behead me, not that i noticed atleast. he didnt even try to convince me that Islam is the right religion for me. and he said things like, first humans, then religion.
Most moderate Muslims don't in fact understand their religion much the same way Neoconservatives don't. That he has humanist inclinations humanizes what he was brought up in, obviously not. The result of a literal, correct interpretation of the Qu'ran yields the mindset of hardliners.

i think we dont need thos fantasy creatures anymore.
Unfortunately, everybody else needs them and we have to deal with them - or face severe repercussions ourselves. The burqa deserves the apex of a roundhouse kick, followed by whoever forces anyone to wear it.
 
Last edited:
Sir Phillip, your opposition to burqa-wearing seems to amount to no more than "WAHHH!!! No like it! Take it away!" All your repeated assertions about burqua-wearing women being oppressed and unhappy are simply subjective assumptions - you've obviously never spoken to any and actually asked them.
I know women who literally never leave the house without full makeup, high heels and the rest of the 'slap'; I think they're pretty stupid, but it's their choice. These women admit that yes, it is pretty stupid, but they don't have the confidence to go out in public "naked" (their word, not mine). Yes, they're perhaps being forced to wear 'slap' by their menfolk, upbringing and society, but it's perfectly acceptable in the West. And, importantly, these women don't feel oppressed in the least.
I can easily imagine that most burqa-wearers actually feel much the same, and that for them going out in ordinary clothes feels like being naked.

BTW, not all burqa-wearers are women. It's strange that nobody seems to have put this forward as a reason for banning burqas, even though it's about the only sensible reason for a ban.
 
Last edited:
I have to think that your world is very monochromatic, when there is just this one kind of Muslim.
There however is one kind of Qu'ran and several Hadiths. Followed literally, that is the conditioning it produces and why other religious groups are not as fixated on world conquest.

What sort of legislation do you propose to eradicate this particular travesty of human rights?
You are essentially talking about a drama triangle involving a prosecutor, victim and rescuer. In this situation, a means of escape must be provided, the key being legislation that takes into consideration the dynamics of cults, which would be a noble cause for professional psychologists and sociologists to unite behind.

How do you think the women who acquiesce to this rule should be punished?
The same manner in which you would for public indecency. You are not in a Muslim country, and furthermore it poses a potential security problem in some situations. The government puts it's foot down first and foremost and does not raise Islam over their own laws or what the majority of people want.
 
Last edited:
I would not wear a burqa. Which, apparently has some relevance to the question of whether it should be banned that I don't see. Stay tuned to watch SirPhilip arguing for the banning of the dress, the skirt, the Oakley sunglasses, the brassiere, the Yankees cap, the studded collar, the cape, the pantyhose, the gold Rolex, the jeans, and the dashiki. Actually, I would wear a dashiki if I thought I could pull it off.

Anyway, we have all of SirPhilip's insistence that the burqa is bad and Islam is bad and the burqa symbolizes this and represents that and Islam is this and that and so on, and some of it I actually agree with, except that nowhere is made an argument why people who wear burqa should be punished, and nowhere does SirPhilip (seriously) say how he thinks they should be punished. Which make his contribution to the thread a whole lot of posts with pretty much nothing to say about the topic of the thread. Weak.
 
... nowhere is made [by SirPhilip] an argument why people who wear burqa should be punished, and nowhere does SirPhilip (seriously) say how he thinks they should be punished. Which make his contribution to the thread a whole lot of posts with pretty much nothing to say about the topic of the thread. Weak.

Right on point.
 
And your solution, superior to mine in all regards, is what? I disagree the burqa is a choice ...

I never promised to have a solution. You're off on an incoherent rant again. My main point is that there's no perfectly good reason to ban the piece of cloth called a burqa in a relatively free society. Especially when it just punishes women.

It's as easy as asking you: "Would you wear it every single time you had to go out?"

Your answer is, like everyone elses, going to be a resounding no.
Some women choose to wear a burqa every time they go out. That is enough not to label it an act of slavery. Some women choose to wear it out sometimes. That is not enough to label it an act of slavery either.

"Would you wear it if you were conditioned from a young age to accept it and what it represents as comforting?"
Everyone has a unique answer for this.

Yes, you would and you would resist adapting otherwise.
Everyone has a unique answer for this.
 
Last edited:
I completely understand now, thank you. So, do you wear one?

An answer to this personal question does nothing to change the fact that women choose to wear the burqa in a relatively free society like the US or France.

And I doubt the answer to this personal question will lead to a realization about why you support the punishment of women for their choice to wear burqas in a relatively free society.
 
Most moderate Muslims don't in fact understand their religion much the same way Neoconservatives don't.
<snip>

i think it is significant that you can make such a statement without even the least hint of irony. In trying to think of appropriate adjectives to describe the attitude this statement suggests, arrogant, conceited, and bombastic come to mind, but none of those are sufficient.

The result of a literal, correct interpretation of the Qu'ran yields the mindset of hardliners.
I have to smile at the use of "literal" and "correct" in conjunction with "interpretation". Is the irony of that lost on you as well?

It is the very attitude that those three words can even combine into a remotely coherent concept which permits "the mindset of hardliners." If something is correct or received literally then interpretation is not required. That would only be needful if the goal was to attribute meaning which was not thought to be apparent.

Your "hardliner" has to "interpret" because the meaning which they want to assert is neither "literal" nor "correct", but often convoluted and tortuously arrived at.

Your statement suggests that you feel the need to do the same.
 
There however is one kind of Qu'ran and several Hadiths. Followed literally, that is the conditioning it produces and why other religious groups are not as fixated on world conquest.

Yes. One Koran. Which, as has been pointed out any number of times in this thread, does not mandate the wearing of burqas.

I'm not sure what history of the world you follow, but the one I'm familiar with doesn't seem to give Islam any monopoly on proselytism or conquest. I'm not even sure they're running in the front of the pack.


You are essentially talking about a drama triangle involving a prosecutor, victim and rescuer. In this situation, a means of escape must be provided, the key being legislation that takes into consideration the dynamics of cults, which would be a noble cause for professional psychologists and sociologists to unite behind.
I'm not talking about anything of the sort. Apparently you are, but it must be with some invisible friend whose company you're not sharing.

The idea of legislation concerning cults first requires that the term "cult" be given a mutually agreeable definition. I've never seen that particular hurdle successfully negotiated, since it generally boils down to "people who believe things we don't."

This is exactly why the law is probably not an appropriate tool to use in this context in a free society, and that is the main point that I think people are trying to get across to you. (My apologies for speaking for others here.)

The same manner in which you would for public indecency. You are not in a Muslim country, and furthermore it poses a potential security problem in some situations. The government puts it's foot down first and foremost and does not raise Islam over their own laws or what the majority of people want.
Indecency is a moral (i.e. religious) concept. You seem to be suggesting here that the application of one set of religious standards to judge another set is appropriate in a free and open society. Is that what you meant to do?

We have managed to address any number of potential security problems without employing peculiarly selective or blanket prohibitions through legislation. If burqas are a potential security issue, then so are raincoats.
 
I note Sir Philip has still refused to specify how he would punish women who
a) are forced to wear the burqa
b) choose to wear the burqa
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom